e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Custom Confections, LLC at 1187 West Chatham Street in Cary. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Custom Confections, LLC 1187 West Chatham Street - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Custom Confections, LLC to pick up this order: 1187 West Chatham Street

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Imagine an extra large peanut butter cup with a slight, cookie-like texture. (made w/natural peanut butter, egg-free) Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Peanut Butter Bar

Extra lemon-y! Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Lemon Bar 

A creamy peanut butter filling in our homemade chocolate cookie crust, topped with whipped cream. (made w/natural peanut butter) Limit 3 per order. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Peanut Butter Pie  (slice)

NY cheesecake with chocolate chips throughout, baked on a layer of our homemade cookie dough. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Cookie Dough (slice)

Chocolate cheesecake over a layer of our rich and fudgy, flourless chocolate torte. (gluten-free) Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Deadly Chocolate (slice)

NY cheesecake with chunks of Oreo cookies throughout baked on an Oreo crust. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Cookies & Cream (slice)

Puff pastry filled with white chocolate mousse, dipped in a chocolate glaze.  Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Crème Puff 

Our NY cheesecake served with 2 oz. of our homemade strawberry topping. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

NY w/strawberry topping (slice)

Rich and fudgy flourless chocolate cake, dusted with cocoa and garnished with chocolate buttercream.  (gluten-free) Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Chocolate Torte (slice)

Chocolate and peanut butter cheesecake over a layer of peanut butter cups baked on an Oreo and Nutter Butter crust. Limit 3 per order. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Peanut Butter Cup (slice)

Popular Items

Our classic rich and creamy NY cheesecake baked on a graham cracker crust.  Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

NY cheesecake (slice)

NY cheesecake flavored with Ghirardelli white chocolate with ripples of raspberry throughout, baked on an Oreo crust. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

White Chocolate Raspberry (slice)

CHEESECAKES BY THE SLICE

PLEASE DO NOT PREORDER FOR A FUTURE DATE! PRODUCTS LISTED HERE ARE SUBJECT TO CHANGE. 

Made with fresh juice and zest, baked on a graham cracker crust. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Key Lime Cheesecake (slice) 

NY cheesecake over our lemon bar recipe. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Lemon Drop (slice) 

NY cheesecake flavored with coffee and coffee liqueur over ladyfingers dipped in additional liqueur. The cake is topped with sweetened mascarpone then iced in whipped cream. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this product will automatically be cancelled.

Tiramisu (slice)

FEATURED CHEESECAKES

Crispy shell filled with sweetened ricotta cream and chocolate chips.  Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Cannoli 

Chocolate, cake-like cookies with vanilla buttercream in between. Limit 4 per order. Orders with more than 4 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Whoopie Pie

DESSERT BARS & PASTRIES

Creamy, coconut filling topped with whipped cream in a buttery, short dough crust. (egg-free) Limit 3 per order. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Coconut Cream Pie (slice)

Creamy coffee filling with chunks of Oreos throughout in our homemade chocolate cookie shell.  Limit 3 per order. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Mocha Cookies & Cream Pie (slice)

Creamy, chocolate pie filling made with Nutella hazelnut spread and served in our homemade chocolate cookie crust. Limit 3 per order. Limit 3 per order. Orders with more than 3 of this item will automatically be cancelled.

Nutella Cream Pie  (slice)

PIES & ADDITIONAL PRODUCTS

Cheesecakes

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

This store is currently closed

Vanilla cupcakes are perfect. Flavor, cake texture, icing- 10/10. Cheesecake is also great- we prefer the plain/NY. 

Love the desserts from here! Amazing taste and quality! Would recommend everything!!

Delicious as always. Cheesecake is great and the crème puffs are fantastic!

It was good taste like Cheesecake Factory 

I’m so sorry because I really wanted to love this place but the cheesecakes where not dense and creamy. They were light and fluffy resembling the taste of whipped jello cheesecake with a under taste of sour cream. Same went for the <<taggedItemId=148919913>>cannoli<</taggedItemId>>… but tasted more like whipping cream, very odd consistency. Expensive for cheesecake that really doesn't taste like cheesecake . But the <<taggedItemId=148920469>>peanut butter bar<</taggedItemId>> was amazing. 

I’m so sorry because I really wanted to love this place but the cheesecakes where not dense and creamy. They were light and fluffy resembling the taste of whipped jello cheesecake with a under taste of sour cream. Same went for the cannoli… but tasted more like whipping cream, very odd consistency. Expensive for cheesecake that really doesn't taste like cheesecake . But the peanut butter bar was amazing. 

Custom Confections, LLC

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

CHEESECAKES BY THE SLICE

FEATURED CHEESECAKES

DESSERT BARS & PASTRIES

PIES & ADDITIONAL PRODUCTS

Custom Confections (CHEESECAKES) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery