e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Island Grill (Overseas Hwy) at 85501 Overseas Highway in Islamorada. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Island Grill (Overseas Hwy) 85501 Overseas Highway - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Island Grill (Overseas Hwy) to pick up this order: 85501 Overseas Highway

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

TEN JUMBO WINGS

Sour cream, pico de gallo, guacamole, Cheddar-Jack cheese

CHICKEN QUESADILLA

SLICE KEY LIME PIE

Fresh grilled Mahi-Mahi on sliced daily baked sourdough
bread with thousand island dressing, Swiss cheese and
coleslaw, French fries

MAHI-MAHI REUBEN

Crispy coconut shrimp, coconut butter, sweet chili sauce

COCONUT SHRIMP

FRENCH FRIES

Shredded cabbage, guacamole, chipotle sour cream, pico de gallo

MAHI MAHI TACOS

Fresh romaine lettuce, seasoned croûtons tossed in our classic Caesar dressing

CAESAR SALAD

SHRIMP TACOS

Fresh sushi grade tuna nestled on a bed of wakame seaweed
salad over crisp wontons topped with wasabi drizzle, sweet
teriyaki, sesame seeds, sriracha & scallions

THE ORIGINAL TUNA NACHOS

Popular Items

Kani, cucumber, avocado, topped with tobiko

CALIFORNIA ROLL 🍥

Cucumber, avocado, beets, & mango, with soy paper

VEGGIE ROLL 🍥

Crispy shrimp, kani salad, spicy tuna, mango, 
topped with avocado, eel sauce, spicy aioli, 
tempura flakes & tobiko

ISLAND GRILL ROLL 🍥

Salmon, cream cheese, avocado, with soy paper, 
topped with eel sauce, spicy aioli, and ikura

SANDBAR ROLL 🍥

Crispy shrimp, cream cheese, avocado, with
soy paper topped with fried plantain & eel sauce

ISLAMORADA ROLL 🍥

Tuna, salmon, yellowtail, avocado, topped with ikura &
truffle oil, served with spicy chili sauce & ponzu

SASHIMI ROLL 🍥

Tuna, yellowtail, avocado, mango, serrano & tempura
flakes, topped with tobiko, served with spicy mango 
chili sauce & ponzu

OVERSEAS ROLL 🍥

LARGE BOAT ⛴

SMALL BOAT ⛴

Sushi grade tuna, avocado, wrapped in seaweed, fried, topped with sriracha, wasabi mayo, teriyaki glaze.

SPICY TUNA ROLL 🍥

Yellowfin tuna, sushi rice, sesame seeds, cucumber, edamame, mango, avocado, wakame, scallions, kani salad, onion crisps, ponzu, eel sauce, spicy mayo

TUNA POKE BOWL 🥣

Fresh salmon, sushi rice, sesame seeds, guacamole, edamame, carrots, red cabbage, kani salad, wakame, tempura flakes, spicy yuzu, eel sauce, spicy mayo

SALMON POKE BOWL 🥣

Tempura shrimps, sushi rice, sesame seeds, carrots, red cabbage, avocado, onion crisp, wakame, edamame, scallions, ponzu, teriyaki glaze, spicy mayo, eel sauce

TEMPURA PARADISE POKE🥣

*Sushi & Poke

Traditional tomato based chowder made with fresh conch

BOWL CONCH CHOWDER

CUP CONCH CHOWDER

Soups

LOBSTER TOSTON

Fresh local fish, marinated, smoked and mixed with our Chef's spices served with assorted crackers

SMOKED FISH DIP

A Keys tradition, fresh ground conch served with
homemade chipotle sauce

CONCH FRITTERS

Sliced beef, sauteed onions, peppers, cheese, sweet Thai chili sauce.

PHILLY CHEESESTEAK ROLL

Fresh calamari cut by hand, dusted with graham cracker
crumbs, fried served with homemade chipotle sauce

FRIED CALAMARI

Shareables

Diced sushi grade tuna , chopped lettuce, rice, seaweed salad, avocado, Peruvian corn, tropical salsa

CORAL REEF SALAD

Grilled chicken breast, bacon, avocado, cherry tomatoes, hard boiled egg, crumbled blue cheese over mixed greens,
Italian vinaigrette

BIG BOB SALAD

Grilled shrimp skewers, black beans, rice, avocado, mixed greens, cucumber, pineapple chipotle salsa.

SHRIMP SKEWER SALAD

Salads

Cooked lobster meat, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing, sourdough bread, French fries

LOBSTER REUBEN

Crispy shrimp tossed in our Chef's buffalo sauce, blue
cheese dressing, hoagie bread, French fries

BUFFALO SHRIMP PO-BOY

Claw and knuckle Maine lobster tossed in our Chef's blend
of herbs spices, dressing served with lettuce, tomato,
scallions on a New England style roll and French fries

LOBSTER ROLL

Chicken breast, tomato, onions, lettuce, brioche bun, French fries

CHICKEN SANDWICH

Grilled steak, caramelized onions, pepper-jack cheese, hoagie bread, French fries

STEAK SANDWICH

Handhelds

Sautéed shrimp, scallops and mahi-mahi served over
linguine with garlic bread

SEAFOOD PASTA

Fettuccine pasta in a creamy Parmesan sauce

ALFREDO PASTA

Bok choy, green and red peppers, carrots, red cabbage, soy sauce, plum sauce and wine

LO MAIN

Pasta

Seasoned and broiled mahi-mahi topped with crab
cakes, shrimp served with Key Lime beurre blanc sauce

MAHI MAHI IMPERIAL

Pan seared Atlantic salmon served with passion fruit
coconut aminos sauce

ATLANTIC SALMON

Saffron rica calamari mussels, clame, shrimp.

SEA PAELLA

Crunchy, Grill or Blackened served with two sides of your choice.

CATCH OF THE DAY

Pan seared grouper, Asian vegetables, mashed potatoes, creamy chardonnay leek-mushroom sauce

PAN SEARED GROUPER

Macadamia crusted snapper, garlic broccoli, jasmine rice, brandy lobster sauce

MACADAMIA SNAPPER

Seafood

Fall-off-the-one tender baby back ribs with BBQ sauce "Locals favorite"

HALF BABY BACK RIBS

FULL BABY BACK RIBS

Crispy chicken cutlet, tomato sauce, melted Mozzarella
served with linguine and garlic bread

CHICKEN PARMIGIANA

14 Ounces of perfectly marbled and generously flavored cut

RIBEYE STEAK 12OZ

Grilled skirt steak, rice, beans, sweet plantains, chimichurri.

CHURRASCO

Land

AVOCADO

COLESLAW

GARLIC BROCCOLI

JASMINE RICE

MAC & CHEESE

VEGGIES

SIDE CAESAR SALAD

SWEET POTATO FRIES

GARLIC BREAD

RICE & BEANS

TOSTONES

SWEET PLANTAIN

Sides

FLAN

Five layer dark moist chocolate cake filled with silky smooth chocolate topped with elegant dark chocolate ganache.

CHOCOLATE LAYER CAKE

WHOLE KEY LIME PIE

Desserts

KID CHICKEN TENDERS

KID GRILLED CHICKEN

KID MAC & CHEESE

KID PASTA

KID MAHI MAHI FINGERS

KID MINI CORN NUGGETS

KID CHEESE QUESADILLA

Kid Menu