e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Main Street Pizza at 159 East Center Street in Ithaca. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Main Street Pizza 159 East Center Street - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Main Street Pizza to pick up this order: 159 East Center Street

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

16" Large Pizza 

Mozzarella Street Sticks

Street Sticks 

Assorted sodas including cola, diet options, Sprite, Pepsi, and Mountain Dew. Available in 12 oz., 20 oz., and 2 liter sizes.

Beverages 

14" Medium Pizza

9"  Individual Pizza

12" Small Pizza

Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, olives, eggs, cheese. Choice of roast beef, turkey, ham, or chicken. Dressing options include buttermilk-ranch, thousand island, honey french, Italian, bleu cheese.

Chef Salad

Your choice of 3 items, sauce, mozzarella.

Pizza Submarine

Served with ham, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, green olives.

The Street Special-Large

Popular Items

Pizza

The Street Special-Individual

The Street Special-Small

The Street Special-Medium

The Street Special

Pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon & ground beef.

Individual  Meat Lovers Pizza 

Small Meat Lovers Pizza 

Medium Meat Lovers Pizza  

Large Meat Lovers Pizza 

Individual BLT Pizza 

Small BLT Pizza 

Medium BLT Pizza 

Large BLT Pizza 

Individual Hawaiian Pizza  

Small Hawaiian Pizza 

Medium Hawaiian Pizza 

Large Hawaiian Pizza 

  Individual Chicken Ranch Pizza

Small Chicken Ranch Pizza

Medium Chicken Ranch Pizza

Large Chicken Ranch Pizza

Individual Chicken BBQ Pizza

Small Chicken BBQ Pizza

Medium Chicken BBQ Pizza

Large Chicken BBQ Pizza

Individual Chicken Buffalo Pizza

Small Chicken Buffalo Pizza

Medium Chicken Buffalo Pizza

Large Chicken Buffalo Pizza

Specialty Pizzas

Extra Ranch on Pizza

Extra Buffalo on Pizza

Extra BBQ on Pizza

Pizza Add-Ons

Filled with meat sauce, cheese & noodles. Served with a dinner roll.

Lasagna

Lettuce, seasoned ground beef, onions, tomatoes, black olives chrushed chips & shredded cheese. Your choice of dressing.

Taco Salad*

Taco Salad 

Street or Dessert Sticks 

Cinnamon Sticks

Pizza Sauce

Ranch Packet

Garlic Dipping Sauce

Nacho Cheese 

Glaze

Extra Stick Sauces

Fresh greens, selection of dressings including buttermilk-ranch, thousand island, honey french, Italian, bleu cheese.

Dinner Salad

Salads

Chips, seasoned ground beef, onions, tomatoes, lettuce, black olives, sour cream, cheese.

Nachos Supreme*

Chips & Cheese

Nachos 

All subs served on a 10 " italian roll (cold, oven toasted or microwaved) with your choice of toppings: lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard, onion, pickles.

Chicken & Ranch Submarine

Buffalo Chicken Submarine

Chicken Submarine

Roast Beef & Cheese Submarine

BLT Submarine

Ham & Cheese Submarine

Salami, mild peppers, ham, mozzarella cheese, Italian dressing.

Italian Submarine

Shaved white turkey with American cheese.

Turkey & Cheese Submarine

BBQ Chicken Submarine

Submarine Alley

Beverages

Green Dragon-Small

Green Dragon-Large

Caramel Cashewlicious-Small

Caramel Cashewlicious-Large

Toffee Crunch-Small

Strawberry Lemonade-Small

Strawberry Lemonade-Large

Summertime S'more-Small

Summertime S'mores-Large

Key Lime Pie-Small

Key Lime Pie-Large

German's Chocolate Cake-Small

German's Chocolate Cake-Large

Fancy Pants Raspberry-Small

Fancy Pants Raspberry-Large

Ice Cream Bars-Michigan-Made Ice Box Brand

Original Potato Chips (2.75 oz.) 
Barbecue Potato Chips (2.75 oz.) 
Red Hot Potato Chips (2.75 oz.)
Sweet BBQ Potato Chips (2.75 oz.) 
Sour Cream & Onion Potato Chips (2.75 oz.)
Salt & Vinegar Potato Chips (2.75 oz.) 
Southern Style Sweet Heat BBQ (2.75 oz.)
Onion Rings 
Caramel Popcorn
Original Pork Rinds (2.5 oz.)
Barbecue Pork Rinds (2.5 oz)
Hot & Spicy Pork Rinds (2.5 oz.)
Salt & Vinegar Pork Rinds (2.5 oz.)
Cheese Puffs (3.25 oz.) 
Movie Theater Butter (2.5 oz.)
Cheddar Cheese Popcorn (2.75 oz.)
Hot Cheese Popcorn (2.75 oz.) 
White Cheddar Popcorn (2.75 oz.)
Potato Sticks
Pretzel Rods
Pretzel Super Thins


Better Made Choice 

Better Made Chips 

Paper Plates

Napkins

Plastic Forks

Serving Utensils

All Day

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

Introducing Store Rewards


Tried the BLT Submarine — it's a straightforward rendition of the classic sandwich. They do use bacon bits rather than strips of bacon, the lettuce and tomatoes were fresh, and the bread decently toasted. While it didn't boast exceptional flavors or stand out, it's a reliable, no-frills option for a quick bite. Fair portion size for the price and prompt service make it a decent choice for a simple, satisfying meal.

The pizza on the other hand is definitely one of my favorites around. Love the dough,  sauce is good, quality ingredients. Little pricy. $3/topping is a lot. So I don't get it often.  But it's good. 



Love the street sticks! The BLT pizza is always delish as well.but the pizza was cold this time unfortunately. I was also confused on the packets even though I ordered packets... Im used to the cups of ranch. The foods flavor is very good though. Not greasy. Delivioys   

The street sticks were very good! I think they were cooked wonderfully and prepared with care 

Ordered the street special, this time was extremely salty compared to their normal. 

There was no cheese on either order and I ordered a <<taggedItemId=7613612519>>Taco Salad*<</taggedItemId>> and <<taggedItemId=7613616322>>Nachos Supreme*<</taggedItemId>>  which we both served as salads which contained ONLY meat, chips and black olives, with a smattering of lettuce. Very confused. Which is the <<taggedItemId=7613616322>>Nachos Supreme*<</taggedItemId>> ? where's the tomatoes? Put my own cheese on this...

There was no cheese on either order and I ordered a Taco Salad* and Nachos Supreme*  which we both served as salads which contained ONLY meat, chips and black olives, with a smattering of lettuce. Very confused. Which is the Nachos Supreme* ? where's the tomatoes? Put my own cheese on this...

Ready by 11:50 AM

text/warning

Closed

Your address is not in this store's delivery area