e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Mikey's Cream Pies at 775 Barton Street East in Hamilton. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Mikey's Cream Pies 775 Barton Street East - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Mikey's Cream Pies to pick up this order: 775 Barton Street East

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

8 oz Individual Pie Cups

Traditional custard coconut flavored filling with shredded coconut. Topped with real whipped cream and toasted coconut garnish, all on a buttery graham crust.

6" Coconut Cream Pie

Silky smooth chocolate custard filling, topped with real whipped cream and shaved chocolate garnish.

6" Chocolate Cream Pie

Banana Custard layered over a generous layer of fresh cut bananas.  Topped with real whipped cream all on top of a buttery graham crust.

6" Banana Cream Pie

Peanut butter, cream cheese and real whipped cream are blended together for just the right punch of peanut flavour. Topped with a chocolate ganache, toffee bits and candied peanuts. A peanut butter lover's dream.

6" Peanut Butter Pie

Cookies

Cream cheese and real whipped cream blended together for a light airy filling with chopped Oreos in an Oreo crust.. Topped with real whipped cream and Oreo garnish.

6" Cookies-N-Cream Pie

Cream cheese and real whipped cream blended together for a light airy filling with fresh strawberries folded in. Topped with real whipped cream and a fresh strawberry.

9" Strawberry Dream Pie

Butter cream base, topped with fresh bananas, pineapple, real whipped cream, pecans, maraschino cherries and finally a caramel and chocolate drizzle. A banana split all rolled up into a delicious pie.

6" Banana Split Pie

6 pack. Brown sugar, maple syrup and butter. Simply delicious.

Original Butter Tarts

Popular Items

A traditional Custard filling in all your favorite flavors.
Gluten free and sugar reduced options available by calling the restaurant between 11am and 6pm at 905-545-3777 at least one day prior.  Additional fee applies.

9" Coconut Cream Pie

9" Banana Cream Pie

9" Chocolate Cream Pie

CREAM PIES.  Please call 905-545-3777 for pick ups!!!

Cream cheese/whipped cream base with various delicious fillings.
Gluten free and sugar reduced options available by calling the restaurant between 11am and 6pm at 905-545-3777 at least one day prior.  Additional fee applies.

Cream cheese and real whipped cream blended together for a light airy filling with an amazing orange zing. Topped with real whipped cream.

6" Orange Dreamsicle  Pie

9" Orange Dreamsicle Pie

9" Cookies-N-Cream Pie

Dream Pies.  Please call 905-545-3777 for Pick Ups!

Special pies you will wish you've had your entire life.
Gluten free and sugar reduced options available by calling the restaurant between 11am and 6pm at 905-545-3777 at least one day prior.  Additional fee applies.

9" Banana Split Pie

9" Peanut Butter Pie

Specialty Pies.  Please call 905-545-3777 for pick ups!

Individual  8oz treats to tempt your taste buds.

Pie Cups.  Please call 905-545-3777 for pick ups!

Not too sweet, just the right treat made with all natural ingredients and  a light flaky crust.

The best thing you'll ever put in your mouth.  

Peanutbutter Butter Tarts

Ooey Gooey marshmallows and chocolate chips inside our original butter tart sauce with toasted marshmallows and chocolate chips on top.

Smores Butter Tarts

Butter Tarts.  Please call 905-545-3777for pick ups!!

Fresh, homemade treats are a welcome addition to any order. Choose between our traditional cookies or our new specialty cookies.

Cookies.  Please call 905-545-3777 for pick ups!!

All Day

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

We've been dying to try these pies and decided to take the plunge! Definitely a cream pie to remember lol!!
Honestly, best banana pie my partner and I have ever had.  The coconut one is fantastic too, but is wayyyy better the second day. Highly recommend this place! Can't wait to try more

I had the 6" Coconut Cream Pie, and it was amazing.  It was extremely creamy, and very satisfying.    It had a great subtlety, and depth of flavours, as well as textures, including the smooth sweetness  of the cream, and the rich meaty texture of the coconut, creating a pie that is in perfect balance.  I loved that it came in the 6" size, because it was the perfect size for two people, we were even able to have it for a couple days.  At the same time, the 6" is small enough for one person as well, it all depends on what you are looking for as a serving size.  I would suggest that you be aware of the actual size of the pies though, because it would be easy to mistakenly buy one too small, or too big.  I will definitely be trying many more of the different pies available from Mikey's Cream Pies, and I am looking forward to every one.  Oh, and I am aware that there are single pies available, but take my advice and get something bigger, because they are too good, and you will regret not having just that little bit more.

Absolutely amazing. Tried a few pies and tarts and all have been equally mouthwatering. A must try.

Everything was amazing - flakies, pecan butter tarts. <<taggedItemId=1141118226>>banana cream pie<</taggedItemId>> ... omg that whipped cream!!!

Everything was amazing - flakies, pecan butter tarts. banana cream pie ... omg that whipped cream!!!

The peanut butter cookies are always top notch. Cannot say the same about the peanut butter pie. 

Mikey's Cream Pies

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

CREAM PIES. Please call 905-545-3777 for pick ups!!!

Dream Pies. Please call 905-545-3777 for Pick Ups!

Specialty Pies. Please call 905-545-3777 for pick ups!

Pie Cups. Please call 905-545-3777 for pick ups!

Butter Tarts. Please call 905-545-3777for pick ups!!

Cookies. Please call 905-545-3777 for pick ups!!

Mikey's Cream Pies (Barton St) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery