e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from On The Bay at 51034 Washington Street in New Baltimore. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

On The Bay 51034 Washington Street - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to On The Bay to pick up this order: 51034 Washington Street

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Our Lobster Rolls are the talk of the town! Served hot on Hawaiian rolls with a sauce of house made seasoned butter, and your choice of pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

Lobster Roll

Mozzarella cheese stuffed breadsticks, sprinkled with garlic and a blend of cheeses, and served with ranch or marinara sauce.

Bosco Sticks

Lobster in a rich blend of cream-based bisque. Served with a Hawaiian roll. Our bisque may just be the best you ever had!

Lobster Bisque

Cavatappi pasta tossed in a rich and creamy blend of white cheeses.

Side Mac 'n Cheese

24 ounce with your choice of salted or everything bagel seasoning, and served with queso dip.

Jumbo Pretzel

Lobster and cavatappi pasta tossed in a rich and creamy blend of white cheeses.

Lobster Mac N Cheese

Grilled chicken, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled of scallions.

Chicken Rice Bowl

Marinara sauce, topped with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, fresh basil, then drizzled with basil pesto olive oil.

Margherita Flatbread Pizza

Tart & Sweet - A delicious graham cracker crust filled to the brim with a creamy lime filling.

Key Lime Pie

Crispy all-white chicken served with our signature Key Lime BBQ sauce. Served with a choice of pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

Chicken Tenders

Popular Items

1 pound steamed then tossed in a light sauce of butter, garlic cloves and lime juice, served with toasted ciabatta bread.

Mussels

Crispy shrimp tossed in a sweet chili sauce, served over a bed of greens and finished with pineapple tid bits.

Sweet and Spicy Tempura Shrimp 

Topped with Parmesan and served with corn tortilla chips.

Spinach and Artichoke Dip

Roasted then drizzled with balsamic truffle glaze and feta.

Roasted Brussels Sprouts

Corn tortilla chips, served with mild queso cheese sauce and salsa.

Chips and Dips

Lightly blackened, served on a bed of spring mix with a side of creamy horseradish sauce.

Filet Tips

Corn Tortilla Chips, topped with chicken or pulled pork, jalapenos, tomatoes, red onions, and a blend of white and mild queso cheese sauces.

Loaded Nachos

Roasted seasoned redskin potatoes topped with shredded cheese, bacon, sour cream, and scallions.

Loaded Redskins

Appetizers

Garlic parmesan sauce, topped with lobster, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, then drizzled with our signature key lime, tangerine sweet sauce.

Lobster Flatbread

Lobster, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled with scallions. * For gluten free option please request gluten free glaze.

Lobster Rice Bowl

Lobster served hot in flour tortillas with a sauce of house made seasoned butter, atop pineapple coleslaw, pineapple mango salsa, drizzled with honey pineapple teriyaki glaze. Finished with scallions and fresh lime wedges.

Lobster Tacos

Lobster Dishes

Lobster Flatbread Pizza

Key lime BBQ sauce, topped with grilled chicken, bacon, mozzarella, and pineapple, then drizzled with our signature key lime BBQ and our signature key lime, tangerine sweet sauce.

Hawaiian Chicken Flatbread Pizza

Key lime BBQ sauce, topped with mozzarella, pepperoni, bacon, and queso fresco, then drizzled with our signature key lime tangerine sweet sauce.

Pepperoni and Bacon Lovers Fllatbread Pizza

Ranch, topped with grilled chicken, bacon, and dill pickle, then drizzled with ranch.

Dill Pickle Flatbread Pizza

Flatbread Pizza

Savory smoke house burnt ends, served with roasted Brussels sprouts, roasted red skin potatoes or sweet chili rice, and pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

Burnt Ends Dinner Platter

Lightly coated with blackening seasoning and grilled to perfection, served with roasted Brussels sprouts topped with Feta and balsamic truffle glaze, roasted redskin potatoes or sweet chili rice, and pineapple coleslaw or pasta salad.

Blackened Mahi Mahi Dinner

Grilled and served on a bed of veggie power blend, then drizzled with our signature key lime tangerine sweet sauce. Served with roasted Brussels sprouts, roasted redskins or sweet chili rice, and pasta salad or coleslaw.

Grilled Salmon Dinner

Dinner Platters

Savory smokehouse burnt ends, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled of scallions.

Burnt Ends Rice Bowl

Lobster, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled with scallions.

Grilled or blackened shrimp, long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, and carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled with scallions.

Shrimp Rice Bowl

Long grain white rice, celery, red cabbage, pineapples, and carrots, seared with a honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, sprinkled with scallions.

Tropical Rice Bowl

Rice Bowls

Slow-smoked pulled pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and yellow mustard served on a grilled Ciabatta roll. Served with chips.

Cuban Sandwich

Slow-smoked pulled pork marinated in key lime BBQ sauce, topped with pineapple and mozzarella, served on a grilled Ciabatta roll. Served with chips.

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Two 1/4lb. Angus beef patties and Swiss cheese topped with bacon and bacon-habanero jam served with lettuce and tomato on a Brioche bun. Served with chips.

Bacon Jam Burger

Two 1/4lb. Angus beef patties topped with American Cheese and our signature Key Lime BBQ sauce, served with lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun. Served with chips.

Bay Burger

Blackened Mahi Mahi, served on a brioche bun with lettuce and tomato. Served with chips.

Mahi Mahi Sandwich

Premium homemade chicken salad with celery, dried cranberries, and diced granny smith apples, served on a light, flakey golden croissant. Served with chips.

Chicken Salad Croissant Sandwich

Mahi Mahi lightly coated with blackening seasoning, grilled to perfection, topped with remoulade, Asian slaw, pineapple mango salsa, then finished with scallions and freshly sliced lime wedges.

Mahi Mahi Tacos

Slow-smoked burnt ends topped with pineapple coleslaw, pineapple mango salsa, queso fresco, drizzled with honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, then finished with scallions and freshly sliced lime wedges.

Burnt Ends Tacos

Pulled pork topped with pineapple coleslaw, pineapple mango salsa, queso fresco, drizzled with honey pineapple teriyaki glaze, then finished with scallions and freshly sliced lime wedges.

Pulled Pork Tacos

Lobster served ho in flour tortillas with a sauce of house made seasoned butter, atop pineapple coleslaw, pineapple mango salsa, drizzled with honey pineapple teriyaki glaze. Finished with scallions and fresh lime wedges.

Shrimp lightly coated with blackening seasoning, grilled to perfection, topped with remoulade, Asian slaw, pineapple mango salsa, then finished with scallions and fresh sliced lime wedges.

Shrimp Tacos

Grilled chicken served atop pineapple coleslaw, pineapple mango salsa, drizzled with honey pineapple teriyaki glaze. Finished with scallions and fresh lime wedges.

Chicken Tacos

Sandwiches • Burgers • Tacos 

Side of rice

Side Mac n Cheese

Side Pasta Salad

Side Pineapple Coleslaw

Soup of the Day

Soups • Salads • Sides 

Lobster Mac n Cheese

Savory, smokehouse burnt ends and Cavatappi pasta tossed in a rich and creamy blend of white cheeses.

Burnt Ends Mac 'n Cheese

Grilled chicken and cavatappi pasta tossed in a rich and creamy blend of white cheeses.

Chicken Mac 'n Cheese

Mac 'n Cheese

Blackened or grilled shrimp and Cavatappi pasta tossed in a rich and creamy blend of white cheeses.

Shrimp Mac 'n Cheese

All beef skinless frank served on 3 Hawaiian rolls. Served with chips.

1/4 Pound Hot Dog

All beef skinless frank served on 3 Hawaiian rolls then smothered in bacon and cheese. Served with a side of chips.

1/4 Pound Smothered Hot Dog

Hot Dogs • Chicken Tenders

Mixed greens, fresh basil, mozzarella, tomatoes, and avocado, drizzled with balsamic glaze.

Caprese Salad

Mixed greens, hard-boiled egg, bacon, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, feta, and kalamata olives, topped with pineapple mango salsa, served with southwest ranch.

9 Layer Cobb Salad

Veggie PowerBlend (brussells sprouts, , mixed nuts, feta, and dried cranberries, served with raspberry vinaigrette dressing.

Power Blend Salad

Salads

Layered chocolate genoise, rich & velvety peanut butter mousse, topped with brownie bits, and peanut butter chips, drizzled in fudge.

Peanut Butter Explosion Mini Cake

An elegant and rich layered Italian dessert made with delicate ladyfinger cookies, espresso, and mascarpone Italian custard.

Tiramisu

Desserts

Fresh Brewed Coffee

Rich and creamy topped with whipped cream.

Hot Cocoa

Unsweetened Iced Tea

Espresso

Espresso shot with equal parts steamed milk and foam.

Cappuccino

Coffee Slush and espresso shot topped with whipped cream.

Frappucino

A refreshing choice of blackberry, raspberry, strawberry, or peach flavor.

Fruit Infused Iced Tea

Espresso shot, steamed milk, and a very light layer of foam.

Latte

Frozen Cocoa

Hot Tea

Iced Coffee

Macchiato

From the coffee shop.

Fruit Slushies

Our malts are made with premium vanilla ice cream and malt powder.

Malts

Our shakes and malts are made with premium vanilla bean ice cream.

Shakes

Acai, bananas, pineapples, strawberries, and blueberries blended with wild berry puree.

Acai Smoothie

A premium blend of 4 seasonal berries, wild berries and strawberry puree. Fresh Berries on top are an extra charge.

Berry Fruit Smoothie

Dragon fruit, and pineapples, blended with strawberry puree.

Dragon Slayer Smoothie

Pineapples and bananas blended with pina colada puree.

I Love Pina Coladas Smoothie

Bananas, peanut butter, and chocolate sauce blended with vanilla bean ice cream.

Peanut Butter Buoy Smoothie

Strawberries and bananas blended with strawberry puree.

St. Clair Sunset Smoothie

Strawberries and pineapples blended with pina colada puree.

Strawberry Island Smoothie

Pineapples, peaches, and mangos blended with pina colada and mango fruit purees.

Sunny Day Smoothie

Strawberries and mangos blended with strawberry and mango purees.

Tropical Twister Smoothie

Smoothies • Slushies • Shakes • Malts

Diet Coke

Mountain Dew

Sprite

Vernors

Coke

Lemonade

Pop & Tea

CONTAINS ALCOHOL:  Kahlua, Baileys, Amaretto and Grand Marnier blended with coffee.

Bay Coffee

CONTAINS ALCOHOL: Baileys, Kahlua, Frangelico blended with coffee.

Nutty Buddy

CONTAINS ALCOHOL: Kahlua and vodka blended with cream.

Hot White Russian

CONTAINS ALCOHOL: Espresso, bourbon and simple syrup garnished with a lemon peel.

Old Fashion

Boozy Coffees

Citrus and Tropical notes of Pineapple, Mango, and Grapefruit come through in the huge, yet surprisingly delicate aroma.

Old Nation M43 IPA

Atwater Dirty Blonde

Bell's Two Hearted

Bud  Light

Landshark

Leinenkugel's Summer Shandy ON SPECIAL

Rich, toasty, malt aroma with a touch of caramel and a kiss of subtle floral hops.

Sam Adams Boston Lager

A wheat ale fermented with Bell's signature house ale yeast, mixing a spicy hop character with mildly fruity aromas.

Bell's Oberon

A wheat beer brewed with orange peel for a subtle sweetness and bright, citrus aroma.

On The Bay

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

Appetizers

Lobster Dishes

Flatbread Pizza

Dinner Platters

Rice Bowls

Sandwiches • Burgers • Tacos

Soups • Salads • Sides

Mac 'n Cheese

Hot Dogs • Chicken Tenders

Salads

Desserts

From the coffee shop.

Smoothies • Slushies • Shakes • Malts

Pop & Tea

Boozy Coffees

Beer

BAY COCKTAILS

Mixed Drinks

Boozy Smoothie TO GO

ON THE BAY Near Me - Pickup and Delivery