e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Tiff's Love Butta Baked Seafood 💛 at 1021 North Pennsylvania Street in Indianapolis. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Tiff's Love Butta Baked Seafood 💛 1021 North Pennsylvania Street - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Tiff's Love Butta Baked Seafood 💛 to pick up this order: 1021 North Pennsylvania Street

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

2 Pieces of Catfish served on top of Buttery Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg.

Catfish Platter (2) pcs, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

1/2 lb Delicious Love Butta Baked Shrimp, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg.
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

1/2 lb Delicious Love Butta Baked Shrimp, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg.

1/2 lb Sausage

Comes with Potatoes. 1 Corn. 1 boiled Egg.
All Smothered with Love Butta

1 lb Love Butta Baked Snow Crab Clusters, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

1/2 lb Sausage, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg.
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

1/2 lb Sausage, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

2 Corns
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

2 Corns

2 Pieces of Tilapia served on top of Buttery Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg.

Tilapia Platter (2) pcs, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

Comes with Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 boiled Egg.
All Smothered with Love Butta

1/2 lb Love Butta Baked Snow Crab Clusters. Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

1 lb Love Butta Baked Snow Crab Clusters, 1/2 lb Shrimp, 1/2 lb Sausage, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

5 Big juicy Lamb chops, served on top of buttery potatoes, 1 corn on the cobb, 1 egg, ALL marinated in Tiff's love oil, Seasoned w/Tiff's Love rub, Smothered with Tiff's Love Butta. *lamb will be cooked medium unless requested otherwise.

(5) Lamb Chops, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

Popular Items

Transforms almost any Dish. Meats, Seafood, Eggs, Potatoes, Rice, Popcorn, Oatmeal, Steaks, Injector for turkeys baked & deep fried, VEGGIES!!! And much much more

16 oz Container of Tiff’s Love Butta

You can use on almost ANYTHING rice, eggs, meat, veggies, popcorn, etc.

8 oz Container of Tiff’s Love Butta

2 oz Tiff's Love Butta

Tiff’s Love Butta "Butta So Good It Will Make YOU Melt!"

1 Snow Crab Cluster, 1 Lobster Tail. 1/2 lb Shrimp. All smothered in Love Butta

Seafood Only!!! 1 lb TOTAL!! 

10-12 oz Lobster tail, 1/2 lb Shrimp, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 2 Eggs. 
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

10-12 oz Lobster Tail, 1/2 lb Shrimp, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 2 Eggs

8oz Lobster Tail , 1/2 lb Shrimp, Potatoes and 1 Corn.

7-8 oz Lobster Tail , 1/2 lb Shrimp, Potatoes , 1 Corn

4-6 oz Lobster Tail, 1/2 lb Shrimp, Potatoes, 1 Corn

Salmon, 1/2 lb Shrimp, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

Salmon, 1/2 lb Shrimp, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

Salmon, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 egg.
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

Salmon, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg

Seafood

2 Corn on the Cobb Smothered with Tiff's Love Butta, Tiff's Love OIl, Lemon pepper, and Parmesan cheese.

Smothered Corn on the Cobb

Potato & Egg Bowl w/ Smothered Corn on the Cobb

6 Boiled Eggs Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta

Smothered Egg Bowl (6)

12 Boiled Eggs Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta

Smothered Egg Bowl (12)

No Seafood

Tiff's Love Rub

Tiff's Spicy Love Rub

1/2 lb Snow Crab Cluster
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

1/2 lb Snow Crab Cluster

Salmon 
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

Salmon

1/2 lb Baked Shrimp
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

1/2 lb Baked Shrimp

4-6 oz Lobster Tail
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

4-6 oz Lobster Tail

7-8 oz Lobster Tail
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

7-8 oz Lobster Tail

10-12 oz Lobster Tail

Potatoes
All Smothered in Tiff's Love Butta.

Potatoes

 2 Boiled Eggs

Soft Drink/Bottled Water

Bib "To Catch the Love Butta & To Keep Your Clothes Clean"

Lemons

Ranch dressing (2oz)

Hot Sauce 2oz

BBQ sauce (2oz)

Extras

King Crab Cracker kit (Crab Scissors, Crab Cracker, Crab sheller, Crab fork, bib, gloves).

King Cracker Kit (Reusable)

Queen Cracker kit (Crab Cracker, Crab sheller, Crab fork, bib, gloves).

Queen Cracker Kit (Reusable)

Crab Cracker Kits (reusable)

5lbs Snow crab, 2lbs of Shrimp, 2lbs of Sausage, 10 corn on the cob, 5lbs potatoes, 10 boiled eggs.
1-16oz container Tiff's Love Butta.

Tiff's Love Butta 5lb Snow Crab Platters Feeds 5 people

Party Platters

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

This store is currently closed

My friend got the  <<taggedItemId=7702585665>>1/2 lb Snow Crab Cluster<</taggedItemId>>, and I made a <<taggedItemId=8742981138>>Build Your Own Platter!  (BYOP)<</taggedItemId>>. Both were absolutely incredible! The beef sausage is amazing, and the shrimp falls right out of the shell. 100% will be eating here again.

Do note that they prefer that you order delivery through their website. I didnt know this on my first order. 

My friend got the  1/2 lb Snow Crab Cluster, and I made a Build Your Own Platter!  (BYOP). Both were absolutely incredible! The beef sausage is amazing, and the shrimp falls right out of the shell. 100% will be eating here again.

Do note that they prefer that you order delivery through their website. I didnt know this on my first order. 

The food was cold and just ok. The corn was old and there was not enough sauce on the food. However the potatoes were very good! Overall I was highly disappointed

 Let's start with the good and go from there. First off order from here. The flavor in the butter sauce makes anything  taste amazing. It's buttery, savory, garlicky, and just really compliments the sweetness of the seafood really well. It was reasonably priced.  I cant give 5 stars only because the potatoes were just not fresh. There was an off putting flavor on the back end. But theyre human, and im sure that wasnt on purpose. But the butter alone would make me reorder again. 

This was worth it. Worth it. Worth it. I need to marry the person who made this. Everything was perfect. Even the egg and I don't like eggs. The prices were great and it was packaged with great care.

The food was delicious and less expensive. I stopped eating at juicy seafood because it was so expensive but this lady food is delicious for a good price I told my co worker about this place. 

Tiff's Love Butta Baked Seafood 💛

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

Tiff’s Love Butta "Butta So Good It Will Make YOU Melt!"

Seafood

No Seafood

Extras

Crab Cracker Kits (reusable)

Party Platters

Tiff's Love Butta Baked Seafood Near Me - Pickup and Delivery