e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from TONY'S NY STYLE PIZZA at 412 West Dickson Street in Fayetteville. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

TONY'S NY STYLE PIZZA 412 West Dickson Street - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to TONY'S NY STYLE PIZZA to pick up this order: 412 West Dickson Street

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

A classic pizza and you can make it your own with any toppings to make your mouth happy.

14" BYO Pizza

A classic pizza that you can make your own with any topping to make your mouth and tummy happy

18" BYO Pizza

Cheesy goodness is brushed with garlic butter and loaded with our herb cheese  makes a great starter or side to your pizza.   Served with marinara

Cheese Bread 

Fresh, fresh, fresh sliced tomatoes, basil and mozzarella . A classic

14" Classic Margherita

Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers and black olives

14" The Works

A luscious four cheese pizza made with mozzarella, feta, ricotta and parmesan. Creamy and delicious. 

14" The Gold Rush

2 crispy pastry shells dipped in chocolate & freshly filled with sweet cream ricotta & sprinkled with mini chocolate chips. 

Cannoli (2)

Wings

Pepperoni, ham, sausage, hamburger and bacon   A porker favorite

14" The Big Pigg

Fresh and simple. Romaine, tomatoes, croutons & parmesan in a large size

House Salad Large

Popular Items

Fresh baked bread topped with marinara, mozzarella and pepperoni. Served with house made ranch 

Cheesy Pizza Bread

Appetizers

Fresh and simple. Romaine, tomatoes, croutons & parmesan

House Salad Small

A small house salad made with your choice of protein. Romaine, tomatoes, croutons and parmesan

Pick Your Protein Small Salad

A large fresh house salad made with your choice of protein. Romaine, tomatoes, croutons & parmesan

Pick Your Protein Large Salad

Salads

Fresh spinach, grilled chicken, bacon and feta cheese on top of our fresh house made Alfredo base(cream base)

14" Fat Tony's Alfredo

A classic retro pie made with ham and pineapple

14" Hawaiian

Spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, green peppers and black olives

14" Vegetarian

Spicy buffalo style pizza sauce with fresh grilled chicken, fresh jalapenos, red onion and bacon topped with provolone, house blend ricotta & mozzarella. Served with house made ranch.

14" Spicy Buffalo Chicken

Hard to believe it's cauliflower(NOT VEGAN)   This is 10" personal size pizza
Just your basic pizza with sauce & cheese   Add any or all toppings to your hearts desire

10" BYO Cauliflower Crust

Hard to believe it's cauliflower(NOT VEGAN)   Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers & black olives on your own 10" cauliflower crust. 

10" Cauliflower The Works

Hard to believe it's cauliflower(NOT VEGAN)   This is a pork lovers' favorite with pepperoni, ham, sausage,  hamburger and bacon. YUM

10" Cauliflower Big Pigg

Fresh spinach, grilled chicken, bacon and feta cheese on top of our fresh house made Alfredo base(cream base) on your own personal cauliflower crust pizza

10" Cauliflower Fat Tony

Hard to believe it's cauliflower(NOT VEGAN)     A luscious four cheese pizza made with mozzarella, feta, ricotta and parmesan on your own person cauliflower crust. Creamy and delicious.   

10" Cauliflower Gold Rush

Hard to believe it's cauliflower(NOT VEGAN)    Our cauliflower crust is topped with fresh sliced tomatoes, basil and mozzarella. A classic treat. 

10" Cauliflower Margherita

Hard to believe it's cauliflower(NOT VEGAN)    Spinach, mushrooms, fresh tomatoes, onions, green peppers and olives

10" Cauliflower Vegetarian

Hard to believe it's cauliflower(NOT VEGAN)    Spicy buffalo pizza sauce with grilled chicken, fresh jalapenos,  red onion, and bacon  

10" Caul Spicy Buffalo Chicken

10" & 14" Pies

Our XL pizza has Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers and black olives

18" The Works

Our XL Pizza with Pepperoni, ham, sausage, hamburger and bacon   A porker favorite

18" The Big Pigg

Our XL pizza with fresh spinach, grilled chicken, bacon and feta cheese on top of our fresh house made Alfredo base(cream base)

18" Fat Tony's Alfredo

Our XL Pizza has is a  luscious four cheese pizza made with mozzarella, feta, ricotta and parmesan. Creamy and delicious. 

18" The Gold Rush

18" Classic Margherita

A classic retro pie made with ham and pineapple. Add any toppings to make it your own

18" Hawaiian

18" Vegetarian

18" Buffalo Chx

18" Pies

Ham & Cheese Half

Fresh sliced ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce,
 tomato and  onions with balsamic vinaigrette on fresh baked roll


Overloaded Italian Sub (Half)

Italian meatballs topped with our herb cheese blend, marinara and mozzarella & provolone on a fresh toasty roll   This is a Full size sub, large enough to share, approx 12 inches.  Serve with chips


Meatball Sub (Full)

Ham & Cheese Full

Fresh sliced ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce,
 tomato and onions with balsamic vinaigrette on fresh baked roll
This is a Full size sub. Big enough to share. Approx 12 inches


Overloaded Italian Sub(Full)

Hand folded perfection.  Over stuffed with our house blend of ricotta & mozzarella. Served with marinara. Customize with extra ingredients $1 each

Italian Calzone

Our signature over-stuffed calzone stuffed with pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon and ham mixed with our blend of creamy ricotta & mozzarella. Served with house made marinara. For the XL appetite

Bigg Pigg Calzone

Genoa salami, pepperoni  & fresh sliced ham mixed with our blend of creamy ricotta  and mozzarella   Served with fresh house made marinara

Spicy Italian Calzone

Spicy Buffalo style pizza sauce with grilled chicken, mixed with our creamy blend of ricotta and mozzarella, provolone, purple onions and  fresh jalapenos,   Served with  house made ranch 

Spicy Buffalo Chicken Calzone

Italian meatballs topped with our herb chees blend, marinara, melted mozzarella & provolone served on our toasty fresh hoagie roll

Meatball Half Sub 

Italian Hoagies & Calzones

A crispy pastry shells dipped in chocolate & freshly filled with sweet cream ricotta & sprinkled with mini chocolate chips. 

Cannoli (1)

Fresh made NY style cheesecake. Best west of the MIssissippi

New York Cheesecake

Dessert

Fresh house marinara 

House made ranch

Extra sauce and dressing 

All Day

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

Introducing Store Rewards

The buffalo chx was the best buffalo chicken pizza I've ever had, and their cannoli are to die for! Literally the best dessert I've ever tasted. I've had a lot of cannoli but Tony's cannoli is on it's own planet..so good!

I should have listened to the bad reviews. I'm not sure where people have gotten their NY style pizza before, but please know, this place is not it! This pizza is barely above a generic brand frozen pizza, and the salt level is ridiculous. A total waste of $20. Will not order again.

Tony has NEVER been to New York. No chewy hand-tossed crust here.  Clearly frozen crust pucks. Lackluster toppings. Salad from a bag with dressing straight out of a Ken's bottle. Nothing looked remotely like the pictures on Door Dash. Big disappointment. Never again.  Frozen Totinos is superior. 

Incredibly salty. Its also not New York style pizza. The crust is brittle and doesn't fold.  Flavor wasnt bad though, but I had to guzzle tons of water theoufhoutthe whole meal due to yhe amount of salt.  Didnt get the cheesecake that we ordered either 

hard to eat. extremely crunchy and tast really burn. only flavor their is, is a charcoal tast.

TONY'S NY STYLE PIZZA

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

Appetizers

Salads

10" & 14" Pies

18" Pies

Italian Hoagies & Calzones

Dessert

Extra sauce and dressing

TONY'S NY STYLE PIZZA (W Dickson St) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery