e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Ally Cat Pizza and Subs at 340 Mount Vernon Road in Newark. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Ally Cat Pizza and Subs 340 Mount Vernon Road - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Ally Cat Pizza and Subs to pick up this order: 340 Mount Vernon Road

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

The Tom Cat

A delicious ''Park Pizza'' style thin crust pizza.

The Copycat

The Stray Cat

Salami, ham, pepperoni topped with lettuce, tomato, onions, banana peppers and our homemade Italian dressing.

The Italian Cat (Half)

Italian style bread topped with our homemade garlic butter and a provolone and mozzarella mix blend cheese 

Cheesy Garlic Bread

Tater tots topped with choice of chili, cheese, onions, tomatoes, and a variety of meats and vegetables.

Dumpster Tots

Creamy New York style cheesecake, sure to satisfy your sweet tooth 

New York style cheesecake 

Meat lovers with pepperoni, ground beef, bacon, sausage and ham.

The Fat Cat

Bread Stix (5 Pcs)

Jalapeño Poppers

Popular Items

Hand pressed graham cracker crust topped with graham cracker crumbles,chocolate chips, and mini marshmallows cooked in our oven until melted to perfection and then drizzled with chocolate syrup 

S'mores Pizza (10" Pie)

Desserts

Cheese Stix (5 Pcs)

Alley Cat Fries

Corn Nuggets

Crispy and juicy all white meat Tyson chicken strips served with your choice of dipping sauce 

Chicken Tenders (5 Pcs)

6 chicken wings with choice of sauce: Franks Red Hot, Carolina Tangy Gold, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Baby Rays Barbecue, Honey Hot, Garlic Buffalo.

Alley Cat Wings 6 pc

Lightly coated drums and flappers fried until crispy and delicious, finished with the sauce of your choice or plain amazing either way 

Alley Cat wings 

À La Carte Menu

Double the meat on any sub for an additional charge.

Hammy 

Lettuce, tomato, mushrooms and banana peppers, onion, with or without cheese.

The Skinny Cat (Half)

Philly cheesesteak grilled with onions mushrooms and peppers.

The Philly Cat (Half)

The Fancy Cat (Half)

Subs

Our handmade pizza crust with a red sauce topped with anchovies, sliced tomatoes and fresh garlic.

The Alley Cat

Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, green and black olives and banana peppers.

The Veggie Cat

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green and black olives, onions, banana peppers, green peppers, ground beef and bacon.

The Dumpster Cat

The Maui Cat

Marinated artichoke hearts, goat cheese, fresh spinach and caramelized red onions.

The Fancy Cat

Crushed tomato sauce topped with fresh basil and mozzarella drizzled with olive oil and oregano.

The Margherita Cat

A white sauce with olive oil, garlic and provolone cheese topped with chicken.

The White Cat

Alley Cat has partnered with the Salvation Army to feed the homeless this Holiday Season. Buy a pizza for a homeless person in Newark.
Receive a gift certificate in your name for purchase and the Salvation Army will feed the Newark Homeless community. "Everyone makes better decisions on a full belly " Can you help out.?

Homeless Cat 

Pizza

2-liter bottle with choice of Faygo flavors: cotton candy, moon mist, red, or orange.

2 Liter Bottle

12 oz canned sodas. Choose from Coca Cola, Dr Pepper, Sprite, or Mtn Dew.

12 Oz Cans

24oz bottled soda. Choice of Faygo Cotton Candy, Moon Mist, Red, or Orange.

24oz Bottle Pop

Drinks

Alley cat Menu 

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

Introducing Store Rewards

Best Italian I've ever had!! Perfect amount of fillings and dressing and bread was nicely toasted! Their ingredients are prepped fresh every day and all sauces and dressings are homemade! My sub held up quite well for leftovers, didn't get soggy or anything. Support your local pizza joint!!

very good lots of toppings and hot when it arrived

this was my first time ordering I got the <<taggedItemId=9913388964>>The Dumpster Cat<</taggedItemId>>  pizza and it was beyond delicious.  love the crust and loads of toppings.  can't wait to try some other of their products

this was my first time ordering I got the The Dumpster Cat  pizza and it was beyond delicious.  love the crust and loads of toppings.  can't wait to try some other of their products

Excellent pizza! Fast and delicious! Check em out!

Everything was great. Only complaint is the size of the <<taggedItemId=9913388932>> Dumpster Tot<</taggedItemId>>s. Very small. 

Everything was great. Only complaint is the size of the  Dumpster Tots. Very small. 

Ally Cat Pizza and Subs

Featured Items

Popular Items

Popular Items

Desserts

À La Carte Menu

Subs

Pizza

Drinks

Alley Cat Subs & Pizza (Mt Vernon Rd) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery