Barnegat Bay Ice Cream Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Barnegat Bay Ice Cream
515 N Main St, Barnegat, NJ 08005, USAOpens 1:15 PM
Order for later
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream
$4.25
#2 Most liked
Soft Serve
$3.95
Hard Ice Cream Sundae
$5.50
Milkshake
$6.95
Peanut Butter Topside
$8.95
#3 Most liked
Soft Serve Sundae
$5.25
Water Ice
$2.95
Hurricane
$6.75
Brownie Bay Volcano
$8.95
Gelati
$5.50
Starboard Strawberry Shortcake
$8.95
Need I Say S'more
$8.95
Ice Cream Sandwich 6-Pack
$9.95
Cookies & Cream Sundae
$8.95
Landlubber
$8.95
Dirt 'n Worms
$8.95
Full Menu
1:15 pm - 9:40 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Hard Ice Cream
#1 Most liked
$4.25•100% (91)
Soft Serve
#2 Most liked
$3.95•97% (81)
Soft Serve Sundae
#3 Most liked
$5.25•95% (44)
Hard Ice Cream Sundae
$5.50•100% (38)
Milkshake
Make with hand dipped for an additional charge.
$6.95•96% (25)
Water Ice
$2.95•100% (31)
Peanut Butter Topside
Peanut butter cups. Peanut butter sauce. Reese's pieces. All sit atop creamy vanilla ice cream. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry.
$8.95•100% (18)
Hurricane
Soft serve ice cream blended with you favorite candy.
$6.75•100% (9)
Brownie Bay Volcano
Our decadent brownie holds mountains of vanilla ice cream has hot fudge and walnuts stream down the sides. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry. The flavor will erupt!
$8.95•92% (14)
Gelati
Soft Serve Ice Cream Layered With Water Ice Served in a 12 oz cup.
$5.50•100% (13)
Ice Cream
All ice cream we be delivered in cups. Any cone selected will be on the side.
Soft Serve
#2 Most liked
$3.95•97% (81)
Hard Ice Cream
#1 Most liked
$4.25•100% (91)
Specialty Sundaes
Classic Banana Split
The classic sundae with vanilla, chocolate and strawberry hard ice cream. Topped with wet walnuts, strawberry and pineapple topping. Finished with whipped cream, a cherry, and sprinkles.
$10.95•100% (8)
Cookies & Cream Sundae
Cookies and cream ice cream topped with chocolate and marshmallow topping. Finished off with....you guessed it.....crushed chocolate cookies! Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry.
Take a left and make it "minty" if you want by switching to mint chocolate chip.
$8.95
Landlubber
Butter pecan ice cream topped with chocolate and caramel syrups and some snicker candy. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry.
$8.95
Starboard Strawberry Shortcake
A marriage of our soft pound cake and delicious strawberry ice cream. Accompanied with fresh strawberries and strawberry sauce. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry. It tastes so right!
$8.95
Brownie Bay Volcano
Our decadent brownie holds mountains of vanilla ice cream has hot fudge and walnuts stream down the sides. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry. The flavor will erupt!
$8.95•92% (14)
Nutella Sundae
Chocolate ice cream topped with Nutella and brownie bites. Finished with chopped hazelnuts, whipped cream and a cherry.
$8.95
Peanut Butter Topside
Peanut butter cups. Peanut butter sauce. Reese's pieces. All sit atop creamy vanilla ice cream. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry.
$8.95•100% (18)
Dirt 'n Worms
Chocolate ice cream topped with chocolate syrup, cake crunchies and of course gummi worms. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry.
$8.95
Need I Say S'more
Three scoops of vanilla chocolate chip ice cream , hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, and crushed graham crackers. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry.
$8.95•100% (10)
Death By Chocolate
Three scoops of classic chocolate ice cream topped with chocolate syrup, cake crunchies and mini chocolate chips. Finished off with whipped cream and a cherry.
$8.95
Sundaes
Up to two toppings incuded plus whipped cream and a cherry.
Soft Serve Sundae
#3 Most liked
$5.25•95% (44)
Hard Ice Cream Sundae
$5.50•100% (38)
Water Ice
Water Ice
$2.95•100% (31)
Milkshakes & Malts
Milkshake
Make with hand dipped for an additional charge.
$6.95•96% (25)
Malt
$7.75
Gelati
Gelati
Soft Serve Ice Cream Layered With Water Ice Served in a 12 oz cup.
$5.50•100% (13)
Hurricane
Hurricane
Soft serve ice cream blended with you favorite candy.
$6.75•100% (9)
Novelties
Choose from chocolate covered bananas, chocolate chip cookie sandwiches, and ice cream sandwiches.
Chipwich
$2.50
Ice Cream Sandwich
$2.00
Chocolate Covered Bananas
$2.00•100% (7)
Pup Cup
Vanilla soft serve topped with a milkbone.
$2.00•93% (16)
Chipwich 6-Pack
A six pack of your favorite chipwiches.
$12.95
Ice Cream Sandwich 6-Pack
A six pack of your favorite ice cream sanwiches.
$9.95•100% (10)
Chocolate Covered Banana 6-Pack
Six pack of Chocolate Covered Bananas.
$9.95
Side Toppings & Cones
Extra side order of toppings or cones.
Toppings
Cones
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash