Bagels Your Way (NY-25A) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Bagels Your Way (NY-25A)

Bagels Your Way

331 NY-25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766, USA

Online ordering hours: Closed

Unavailable

Featured Items

#1 Most liked

Egg Sandwich

$8.00

#3 Most liked

Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter

$5.00

#2 Most liked

Egg Sandwich

$8.00

1 Dozen Assorted Bagels & 1 Half-Pound Spread

$25.00

Side of home fries

$5.50

Create Your Own Deli Sandwich

$11.00

Create Your Own Omelet (Choose up to 3 ingredients)

$10.00

Side of Home Fries

$5.50

Red Bull

$5.00

Full Menu

closed

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Egg Sandwich
Soon-To-Be; Almost World-Famous. Fresh Made To Order Egg Sandwiches. Always Made With Farm Fresh Eggs.
$8.00•Icon Loading96% (127)

Egg Sandwich 
Soon-to-be; almost world-famous. fresh made to order egg sandwiches. always made with farm fresh eggs.
$8.00•Icon Loading96% (127)

Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter
Bagel served with choice of butter, jelly, or plain cream cheese. Select from over 20 bread types including whole wheat, sesame, poppy, onion, garlic, everything, and cinnamon raisin options.
$5.00•Icon Loading93% (58)

Side of home fries
Our Soon-To-Be Famous Home Fries "CRISPY POTATO CUBES".
$5.50•Icon Loading87% (32)

1 Dozen Assorted Bagels & 1 Half-Pound Spread
12 bagels of your choice & 1/2 LB of cream cheese.                                                                             
 Choose from: Bialy, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Everything Bagel, Egg Onion Roll, Everything Bagel, Everything Flagel, Everything Twist, Garlic Bagel, HERO, Onion Bagel, Pain Roll, Plain Bagel, Plain Twist, Plain Wrap, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Roll, Pumpernickel Bagel, Rye Bagel, Rye Bread, Salt Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Sesame Flagel, Sesame Twist, Sunflower Bagel, Sunflower Flagel, White Bread, Whole Wheat Bagel, Whole Wheat Bread, Whole Wheat Roll, Whole Wheat Sunflower Bagel or Whole Wheat Wrap
$25.00•Icon Loading100% (7)

Create Your Own Deli Sandwich
Fresh sliced and made custom to order. :) let us know how you like it.
$11.00•Icon Loading100% (10)

Deli Iced Tea
Deli iced tea, choice of small or large.
$3.00•Icon Loading100% (12)

Hot Coffee
Drip coffee with size options: large, medium, small.
$3.00•Icon Loading93% (31)

Bottled Beverages
Choose your favorite beverage
$4.00•Icon Loading100% (21)

Iced Coffee
Choice of small or large, served chilled.
$4.00•Icon Loading100% (10)

Sandwiches

Create Your Own Deli Sandwich
Fresh sliced and made custom to order. :) let us know how you like it.
$11.00•Icon Loading100% (10)

BLT
Crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato on your choice of 25 breads, including whole wheat options, bagels, and rolls.
$8.00•Icon Loading87% (8)

Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Fresh breaded white meat, cooked crispy & golden brown ***For HERO we recommend at least 2 cutlets.
$11.00

Tuna Salad Sandwich
Tuna salad with crisp lettuce, tomatoes, served on your choice of bread, wraps, or bagels including whole wheat, rye, sesame, poppy, everything, and more.
$10.00•Icon Loading100% (7)

Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken salad with various bread options: from whole wheat variations to specialty bagels and wraps.
$10.00

Egg Salad Sandwich
Creamy egg salad on choice of whole wheat or white options, including wraps, bagels, twists, rolls, hero; various seeds and flavors like sesame, poppy, onion, garlic, everything.
$9.00

Bagels & Spreads

Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter
#3 Most liked
Bagel served with choice of butter, jelly, or plain cream cheese. Select from over 20 bread types including whole wheat, sesame, poppy, onion, garlic, everything, and cinnamon raisin options.
$5.00•Icon Loading93% (58)

Bagel with Jelly & Plain Cream Cheese
Bagel with jelly and plain cream cheese. Choices include whole wheat, white, rye, sesame, poppy, onion, garlic, everything, cinnamon raisin options, and more.
$5.25

Bagel with Premium Sliced Nova Scotia Lox (*Smoked)
Smoked sliced nova lox.
$15.00

1 Dozen Assorted Bagels
Please let us know your favorites, otherwise we will assort them for you. Choose from: Bialy, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Everything Bagel, Egg Onion Roll, Everything Bagel, Everything Flagel, Everything Twist, Garlic Bagel, HERO, Onion Bagel, Pain Roll, Plain Bagel, Plain Twist, Plain Wrap, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Roll, Pumpernickel Bagel, Rye Bagel, Rye Bread, Salt Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Sesame Flagel, Sesame Twist, Sunflower Bagel, Sunflower Flagel, White Bread, Whole Wheat Bagel, Whole Wheat Bread, Whole Wheat Roll, Whole Wheat Sunflower Bagel or Whole Wheat Wrap
$21.00•Icon Loading85% (7)

1 lb Large Tub Spread/Butter/Cream Cheese
1 lb of spread, butter, or cream cheese
$12.00

1/2 lb Tub Spread/Butter/Cream Cheese
1/2 lb of spread, butter, or cream cheese
$6.50

Breakfast Specials

Egg Sandwich
#1 Most liked
Soon-To-Be; Almost World-Famous. Fresh Made To Order Egg Sandwiches. Always Made With Farm Fresh Eggs.
$8.00•Icon Loading96% (127)

Create Your Own Omelet (Choose up to 3 ingredients)
Choose any 3 ingredients! Customize as you like :).
$10.00•Icon Loading90% (10)

Hot Fresh Sides

Side of home fries
Our Soon-To-Be Famous Home Fries "CRISPY POTATO CUBES".
$5.50•Icon Loading87% (32)

Side hash brown patty
Shredded potatoes, formed into a patty and fried to achieve a crispy exterior, typically served as a breakfast side.
$2.50•Icon Loading100% (11)

Side of bacon
Two Strips of our thick-sliced Fresh Farmhouse Bacon.
$3.00

Side sausage patty
Two specially blended sausage patties, seasoned and cooked to enhance their rich, meaty flavor.
$3.00

Side of turkey bacon
2 Slices of Premium Turkey Bacon.
$3.00

Side of turkey sausage
Lean turkey sausage, seasoned and encased, offering a lighter alternative to traditional sausage.
$3.00

Side of ham
Three slices of gently grilled Virginia ham, typically served as a hearty complement to breakfast dishes.
$1.50

Side of honey maple turkey
Sliced turkey, typically includes a glaze of honey and maple, offering a sweet and savory taste.
$3.00

Side of turkey
A side of tender, oven-roasted turkey, typically served sliced.
$3.00

Side of corned beef
Side of corned beef typically includes slices of cured beef, served as a hearty accompaniment.
$3.00

Homemade Salads

Fresh made daily

Chicken Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2 lb)
Fresh All White Meat.
$9.00

Tuna Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2 lb)
Fresh All White Meat.
$9.00

Egg Salad (Half Pound)( 1/2 lb)
Made From Whole Fresh Eggs.
$7.00

Catering & Large Groups

1/2 Gallon Tropicana Pure Premium OJ
Half gallon of Tropicana Pure Premium Orange Juice, offering 100% pure and natural orange juice.
$7.00

Coffee 2 GO
Box-Of-Coffee serves 10-15 includes Milk, Stirrers & Sweeteners.
$20.00

Half and Half
A pizza with one half featuring one set of toppings and the other half with a different set, catering to varied tastes in a breakfast setting.
$5.00

French Vanilla Creamer
French vanilla creamer typically includes a rich blend of cream and sweet vanilla flavor, designed to complement and enhance coffee for groups.
$7.00

Hazelnut Creamer
Hazelnut creamer typically includes a blend of cream infused with hazelnut flavor, designed to complement and enrich coffee for groups.
$7.00

Caramel Macchiato Creamer
Caramel macchiato creamer typically includes a blend of caramel flavor with a creamy texture, designed to complement and enhance the taste of coffee beverages.
$7.00

Half-Gallon of Whole Milk
A half-gallon of whole milk sourced to cater to large groups, providing a classic and essential beverage option.
$5.00

Bakery

Corn Muffin
Wholesome corn muffin, perfectly sweetened, with a delightfully crumbly texture.
$4.00

Chocolate Chip Muffin
Decadent muffin baked with rich chocolate chips for a delightful treat.
$4.00

Banana Chip Muffin
A freshly baked muffin incorporating ripe bananas and crunchy banana chips for a sweet and satisfying treat.
$4.00

Double Chocolate Muffin
A rich, chocolate batter muffin filled with generous amounts of chocolate chips, offering a double dose of chocolate in every bite.
$4.00

Apple Turnover
Crisp, flaky pastry filled with warm, spiced apples.
$4.00

Large Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie
A generously sized cookie adorned with vibrant rainbow sprinkles, offering a sweet and colorful treat.
$4.00

Black & White Cookie
Traditional black & white cookie
$4.00•Icon Loading100% (15)

Croissant
Flaky, Butter-rich French Pastry with a Golden, Crisp Exterior
$4.00

Large Hand Dipped Cookie
Hand-dipped butter cookie covered in rich chocolate.
$4.00

Large Milano Cookie
A sizable cookie, often featuring a delicate blend of chocolate and a hint of orange zest, baked to a golden perfection.
$4.00

Large Linzer Tart
A generously sized tart, traditionally filled with raspberry jam, encased in a nutty dough, and finished with a dusting of powdered sugar.
$4.00

Blueberry Crumb Muffin
Freshly baked muffin filled with blueberries and topped with a sweet crumb topping.
$4.00

Beverages

Bottled Beverages
Choose your favorite beverage
$4.00•Icon Loading100% (21)

Hot Coffee
Drip coffee with size options: large, medium, small.
$3.00•Icon Loading93% (31)

Hot Tea
Steaming hot tea, available in large, medium, or small.
$3.00

Iced Coffee
Choice of small or large, served chilled.
$4.00•Icon Loading100% (10)

Deli Iced Tea
Deli iced tea, choice of small or large.
$3.00•Icon Loading100% (12)

Pink Lemonade
Pink lemonade; available in small or large.
$3.00

Fresh Squeezed Lemonade
Fresh squeezed lemonade, available in small or large sizes.
$4.00

Red Bull
An energy drink with taurine, designed to vitalize body and mind. Contains 250 ml per can.
$5.00

Most Popular

Our most popular items all in one place!

Egg Sandwich 
#2 Most liked
Soon-to-be; almost world-famous. fresh made to order egg sandwiches. always made with farm fresh eggs.
$8.00•Icon Loading96% (127)

Hungry Dude Sandwich
3 eggs, bacon, ham, sausage, and cheese
$13.00

1 Dozen Assorted Bagels
Please let us know your favorites by using the box below, otherwise we will assort them for you :). Choose from: Bialy, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Everything Bagel, Egg Onion Roll, Everything Bagel, Everything Flagel, Everything Twist, Garlic Bagel, HERO, Onion Bagel, Pain Roll, Plain Bagel, Plain Twist, Plain Wrap, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Roll, Pumpernickel Bagel, Rye Bagel, Rye Bread, Salt Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Sesame Flagel, Sesame Twist, Sunflower Bagel, Sunflower Flagel, White Bread, Whole Wheat Bagel, Whole Wheat Bread, Whole Wheat Roll, Whole Wheat Sunflower Bagel or Whole Wheat Wrap
$21.00•Icon Loading85% (7)

1 Dozen Assorted Bagels & 1 Half-Pound Spread
12 bagels of your choice & 1/2 LB of cream cheese.                                                                             
 Choose from: Bialy, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Egg Bagel, Egg Everything Bagel, Egg Onion Roll, Everything Bagel, Everything Flagel, Everything Twist, Garlic Bagel, HERO, Onion Bagel, Pain Roll, Plain Bagel, Plain Twist, Plain Wrap, Poppy Bagel, Poppy Roll, Pumpernickel Bagel, Rye Bagel, Rye Bread, Salt Bagel, Sesame Bagel, Sesame Flagel, Sesame Twist, Sunflower Bagel, Sunflower Flagel, White Bread, Whole Wheat Bagel, Whole Wheat Bread, Whole Wheat Roll, Whole Wheat Sunflower Bagel or Whole Wheat Wrap
$25.00•Icon Loading100% (7)

Side of Home Fries
Our soon-to-be famous home fries, "crispy potato cubes."
$5.50•Icon Loading87% (32)

Side Hash Brown Patty
A side hash brown patty typically consists of shredded potatoes, formed into a patty and fried until golden brown and crispy.
$2.50•Icon Loading100% (11)

Iced Coffee
Iced coffee, available in small or large.
$4.00•Icon Loading100% (10)

Deli Iced Tea
Deli iced tea with choice of size: small or large.
$3.00•Icon Loading100% (12)

Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy