The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Conch Fritters
#1 Most liked
Tender pieces of conch, finely chopped with onions & peppers, mixed with spices and batter, fried to a golden brown
$14.99•94% (58)
Captain's Combo
#2 Most liked
Catch of the day, conch, and shrimp, prepared grilled, blackened, or fried, with choice of one side.
$28.99•85% (57)
Fish Fingers
#3 Most liked
Lemon seasoned fish, lightly breaded and deep fried, served with our pink sauce
$15.99•100% (46)
Fried Cracked Conch
Tenderized, breaded, and deep-fried conch, served with our homemade tartar sauce.
$17.99•91% (45)
New England Clam Chowder
Cream-based soup with chopped clams, celery, onions, and diced potatoes
$5.99•95% (40)
Lobster Mac & Cheese Croquettes
Lightly breaded, and deep fried to perfection topped with a parmesan cheese sauce
$9.99•68% (22)
Captain's Tail Sandwich
Freshly caught snapper fillet , perfectly seasoned and lightly breaded, fried to a golden crisp topped with cilantro-lime slaw & our remoulade pink sauce. On a brioche bun.
$17.99•91% (34)
Fried Calamari
Perfectly seasoned and lightly breaded, served with our home-made marinara sauce
$14.99•80% (20)
Key Lime Pie
$6.49•90% (20)
Grouper Sandwich
Prepared grilled, blackened or fried; topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and our pink sauce with your choice of French fries or cole slaw
$19.99•90% (22)
ON A BUN
*Your choice of French fries or cole slaw for the items below
Captain's Tail Sandwich
Freshly caught snapper fillet , perfectly seasoned and lightly breaded, fried to a golden crisp topped with cilantro-lime slaw & our remoulade pink sauce. On a brioche bun.
$17.99•91% (34)
Corvina Sandwich
Prepared grilled, blackened or fried; topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and our pink sauce with your choice of French fries or cole slaw
$18.50
King's Cracked Conch Bun
Tenderized, breaded, and deep-fried conch, topped with fresh slaw and our home-made tartar sauce
$19.99•81% (11)
Newman's Shrimp Po Boy
Perfectly seasoned shrimp sauteed with bell peppers, onions, and mushrooms, and topped with mozzarella, cheddar, and bacon on a light Ranch lathered bread roll
$18.99•85% (14)
Mahi Sandwich
Prepared grilled, blackened or fried; topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and our pink sauce with your choice of French fries or cole slaw
$17.50
Grouper Sandwich
Prepared grilled, blackened or fried; topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and our pink sauce with your choice of French fries or cole slaw
$19.99•90% (22)
STARTERS
Dave's Buffalo Shrimp
Gulf Coast shrimp, tossed in our home-made buffalo sauce, topped with crumbled blue cheese
$17.59•90% (11)
Lobster Mac & Cheese Croquettes
Lightly breaded, and deep fried to perfection topped with a parmesan cheese sauce
$9.99•68% (22)
Conch Fritters
#1 Most liked
Tender pieces of conch, finely chopped with onions & peppers, mixed with spices and batter, fried to a golden brown
$14.99•94% (58)
Fish Fingers
#3 Most liked
Lemon seasoned fish, lightly breaded and deep fried, served with our pink sauce
$15.99•100% (46)
Fried Cracked Conch
Tenderized, breaded, and deep-fried conch, served with our homemade tartar sauce.
$17.99•91% (45)
CJ Cakes
Fresh crabmeat cakes seasoned and fried to perfection with our pink sauce
$15.50•53% (15)
Fried Gulf Coast Shrimp
Perfectly seasoned and lightly breaded, fried to golden brown, with our pink sauce
$15.59•100% (8)
Conch Salad
Fresh conch tossed with onions, bell peppers, and home-made citrus dressing
$17.99•66% (21)
Fried Calamari
Perfectly seasoned and lightly breaded, served with our home-made marinara sauce
$14.99•80% (20)
Pan Seared Scallops
Sautéed in a garlic butter sauce
$16.99•81% (11)
Original Krab Salad
Captain's old recipe of imitation crab meat
$7.99•78% (14)
SOUPS & SALADS
Caribbean Fish Soup
Grouper fish broth with carrots, celery, cilantro and corn
$5.99
Shrimp Caesar Salad
Grilled Gulf Coast shrimp over our classic Caesar salad topped with parmesan cheese and croutons
$16.99
Conch Chowder
A slightly spicy, tomato-based soup with conch, chopped celery, onions, carrots, and diced potatoes.
$5.99•75% (8)
New England Clam Chowder
Cream-based soup with chopped clams, celery, onions, and diced potatoes
$5.99•95% (40)
Lobster Bisque
Cream-based soup with Florida lobster, pureed celery, onions, red bell peppers, carrots, and tomatoes
$5.99
Border Salad
Gulf Coast shrimp over mixed greens, bell peppers, cherry tomatoes, red onions, cilantro, corn, olives, and avocado tossed in a cilantro lime dressing
$17.99
Grilled Mahi Caesar Salad
Grilled mahi fillet over our classic Caesar salad topped with parmesan cheese and croutons
$16.99
CAPTAIN'S FAVORITES
Conch Platter
Prepared grilled, blackened, or fried with your choice of 1 side.
$26.99•83% (24)
Corvina Fillet
Prepared grilled, blackened, or fried with your choice of 1 side.
$19.99•100% (7)
Large Shrimp
$22.99•90% (22)
Mahi Fillet
Prepared grilled, blackened, or fried with your choice of 1 side.
$21.99
Pecan-Crusted Grouper
Grilled and served with fried Brussels sprouts drizzled in a coconut lime sauce
$29.99
Snapper Fillet & Shrimp Escabeche
Fish and shrimp perfectly seasoned and lightly breaded, topped with pickled vegetables and served with coconut rice and beans, and sweet plantains
$27.99•90% (20)
CJ's Blackened Fish Tacos
Served on soft tortillas with onions and cilantro-lime slaw
$16.99•100% (7)
Corvina Français
Corvina fillet dusted in flour, dipped in egg wash, and prepared in a light lemon sauce, served over linguine.
$26.99•85% (7)
Shrimp Tacos
Served on soft tortillas with onions and cilantro-lime slaw
$16.99•90% (11)
Scallop Scampi
Sautéed scallops in a garlic and lemon sauce, served with white rice or linguine.
$27.99
Shrimp & Grits
Large shrimp sautéed with bacon and scallions served over grits and topped with a cream-butter sauce
$23.99•82% (17)
Salmon Over Spinach
Grilled salmon served over a bed of sautéed spinach.
$25.99•91% (12)
Seafood Puttanesca
Shrimp, calamari, mussels, and clams with chopped tomatoes, garlic, black olives, capers, and a hint of spice, served over a bed of linguine.
$32.99
Chicken Parmesan
Parmesan-breaded chicken topped with Italian cheeses and marinara sauce served with linguine.
$21.99
Captain's Combo
#2 Most liked
Catch of the day, conch, and shrimp, prepared grilled, blackened, or fried, with choice of one side.
$28.99•85% (57)
Shrimp Creole
Shrimp prepared in a slightly spicy sauce with tomatoes, green peppers, onions, and garlic, served with white rice
$25.99
SIDES
French Fries
$5.25•76% (17)
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.25
Fried Hawaiian Plantains
Fried plantains typically paired with ham, caramelized pineapples, and melted cheese.
$5.25
Red Beans & Rice
$5.25•100% (11)
White Rice
$5.25
Cole Slaw
$4.99•81% (11)
Sweet Plantains
$5.25•100% (11)
Mashed Potatoes
$5.25•100% (6)
Creamed Spinach
$5.25•92% (14)
Sautéed Vegetables
$5.25
House Salad
$5.25
Caesar Salad
$5.25•100% (7)
Sautéed Spinach
$5.25•100% (12)
DESSERTS
Bread Pudding
$6.49•100% (8)
Coconut Guava Rum Cake
$7.99•100% (12)
Key Lime Pie
$6.49•90% (20)
KIDS MENU
Chicken Fingers and Fries
$8.99
Fish Fingers & Fries
$9.99•100% (9)
Linguine with Tomato Sauce and Cheese
$6.99
BEVERAGES
Coca-Cola
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$2.50
Diet Coke
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
$2.50
Ginger Ale
$2.50•100% (6)
Sprite
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.