Formaggio's Pie Shack Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Formaggio's Pie Shack
1600 Highbury Ave N, London, ON N5Y 5N7, CanadaOpens 11:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
Large (5 lbs)
CA$42.50
Medium (3lbs)
CA$38.50
Large Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
CA$27.25
#3 Most liked
Medium Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
CA$23.00
#1 Most liked
Nachos
CA$21.00
#2 Most liked
Garlic Bread With cheese
CA$10.05
1 lb Jumbo Baked Wings
CA$16.00
4 Bevvies
CA$5.25
Pepper Poppers ( 6 pcs)
CA$9.77
Combo Platter
CA$9.85
Full Menu
4:00 pm - 8:10 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Nachos
Your choice of chicken or beef w/ mixed cheese, onion, tomato, green peppers, hot peppers w/ salsa & sour cream on the side for dipping
CA$21.00•100% (9)
Garlic Bread With cheese
If you really want to put your garlic bread over the edge, you can add bacon for an additional charge. Ciabatta bread with heaps of garlic butter & fresh parsley, with two cheese blend piled high on top!
CA$10.05•87% (8)
Medium Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Medium pizza, choice of 3 toppings: vegetables, meats including pepperoni, sausage, various peppers. Sauce options: original, spicy, sweet tomato, garlic ranch, BBQ.
CA$23.00•100% (7)
Large (5 lbs)
5 lbs deep dish pizza with choice of three toppings from vegetables, meats, including peppers, olives, pineapple, mushrooms, various sausages, and bacon variations.
CA$42.50•87% (8)
Medium (3lbs)
3lbs deep dish pizza with choice of three toppings from an extensive selection including various vegetables, meats, and unique options like pineapple and pickles.
CA$38.50•100% (6)
Large Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Large pizza, select 3 toppings from a variety including vegetables, meats, and cheese. Choose a homemade sauce: Formaggio's original, spiced, sweet, garlic ranch, or BBQ.
CA$27.25
1 lb Jumbo Baked Wings
Jumbo chicken wings, 1 lb, choice of BBQ, hot, honey garlic, or dry rub. Optional salt and pepper or lemon pepper seasoning.
CA$16.00
Single Style ( 1 lbs)
"Small but mighty"
CA$19.95•75% (8)
Regular With 3 Regular Toppings
Panzerotti filled with choice of three toppings from vegetables, meats to pineapple and garlic. Sauce options include original, spicy, sweet tomato, garlic ranch, BBQ.
CA$21.00
Personal Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Customizable personal pizza; choose 3 toppings: veggies, meats (pepperoni, sausage variants, bacon types), or distinct flavors like pickles and garlic. Select from 5 homemade sauces, including unique creamy garlic ranch and BBQ.
CA$13.70
Pizza
You are the chef with each & every one of our pizzas! Create an endless combo of unique favorites!
Personal Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Customizable personal pizza; choose 3 toppings: veggies, meats (pepperoni, sausage variants, bacon types), or distinct flavors like pickles and garlic. Select from 5 homemade sauces, including unique creamy garlic ranch and BBQ.
CA$13.70
Medium Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
#3 Most liked
Medium pizza, choice of 3 toppings: vegetables, meats including pepperoni, sausage, various peppers. Sauce options: original, spicy, sweet tomato, garlic ranch, BBQ.
CA$23.00•100% (7)
Large Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Large pizza, select 3 toppings from a variety including vegetables, meats, and cheese. Choose a homemade sauce: Formaggio's original, spiced, sweet, garlic ranch, or BBQ.
CA$27.25
X Large Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Extra-large pizza, choose 3 toppings from veggies like olives, peppers to meats such as pepperoni, sausage. Sauce options include original, spiced, sweet tomato, garlic ranch, BBQ.
CA$35.25
Gluten Free With 3 Regular Toppings
Gluten-free pizza base with choice of three toppings from a diverse range including vegetables, meats, and more. Homemade sauce options: original, spiced, sweet, garlic ranch, BBQ.
CA$22.00
Two Pizza Deal
2 Medium Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Two medium pizzas, each customizable with a selection from over 20 toppings including various meats, vegetables, and special items like pineapple and pickles.
CA$38.00
2 Large Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Two large pizzas with a choice of three toppings each, from a selection including various vegetables like peppers, onions, olives, and proteins like pepperoni, sausage, and bacon.
CA$43.50
2 X Large Pizza With 3 Regular Toppings
Two large pizzas with choice of three toppings from an extensive selection including various veggies, meats, and unique options like pineapple and pickles.
CA$62.00
Panzerotti
You've had this before, but now it's time to try OURS! Baked to golden perfection, never fried!
Regular With 3 Regular Toppings
Panzerotti filled with choice of three toppings from vegetables, meats to pineapple and garlic. Sauce options include original, spicy, sweet tomato, garlic ranch, BBQ.
CA$21.00
Large With 3 Regular Toppings
Large panzerotti filled with your choice of three toppings from vegetables like green peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes; meats such as pepperoni, sausage, bacon; and unique selections like pickles. Choose from sauces including Formaggio's original, spicy or sweet tomato, creamy garlic ranch, or BBQ.
CA$27.00
The Deeeeep Dish Pizza
So big, we don't cut it! All the same fresh ingredients we use for our other pizzas, but more of it & piled higher! for the formaggio's sauce lovers, this pizza style really showcases our homemade sauce! and don't get us started on the cheese! S000 much cheese! read the reviews of our very enthusiastic fans of this big pie! To ensure all the deliciousness stays put we don't slice these big pies before we send them out. you'll want to be in charge of the size of your slice once you see it!
Medium (3lbs)
3lbs deep dish pizza with choice of three toppings from an extensive selection including various vegetables, meats, and unique options like pineapple and pickles.
CA$38.50•100% (6)
Large (5 lbs)
5 lbs deep dish pizza with choice of three toppings from vegetables, meats, including peppers, olives, pineapple, mushrooms, various sausages, and bacon variations.
CA$42.50•87% (8)
Single Style ( 1 lbs)
"Small but mighty"
CA$19.95•75% (8)
Chicken Wings
Jumbo size wings baked to perfection in your choice of one of our original sauces: BBQ, hot or honey garlic or dry rub: salt and pepper or lemon pepper.
1 lb Jumbo Baked Wings
Jumbo chicken wings, 1 lb, choice of BBQ, hot, honey garlic, or dry rub. Optional salt and pepper or lemon pepper seasoning.
CA$16.00
Bevvies
Ice Tea
CA$1.50
Root Beer
CA$1.50
Coke
Carbonated soft drink with a classic cola flavor.
CA$1.50
Diet Coke
A refreshing, zero-calorie cola with a crisp, clean taste.
CA$1.50
Sprite
CA$1.50
Ginger ale
CA$1.50
4 Bevvies
Selection of four beverages: a mix of sodas, juices, and tea. Options include apple, orange, root beer, cola varieties, and more. Mix and match to preference.
CA$5.25
Dips
Salsa
Zesty, fresh chopped tomato blend with cilantro, onions, and a hint of lime.
CA$1.45
Sour Cream
Sour cream dip, a smooth blend typically served as a companion to a variety of snacks.
CA$1.45
Chipotle Mayo
Our chipotle mayo dip combines the smoky heat of chipotle peppers with the creamy texture of mayonnaise, typically served as a smooth, rich condiment.
CA$1.45
Caesar
A blend of traditional Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, and croutons, typically served as a spread or dip.
CA$1.45
Ranch
Creamy and rich, perfect for dipping. Classic flavor that complements any snack.
CA$1.45
Creamy Garlic Ranch
A blend of rich ranch and creamy garlic, typically includes a mix of herbs and spices to enhance its flavor profile. Ideal for dipping or drizzling.
CA$1.45
Creamy Garlic
A smooth blend of garlic and cream, often accompanied by herbs and spices to enhance its flavor.
CA$1.45•87% (8)
Sweet Thai Chili
This dip combines the sweet heat of Thai chili with a hint of Italian flair, offering a unique blend for an intriguing dipping experience.
CA$1.45
Cheesy Jalapeño
A blend of melted cheeses and diced jalapeños, creating a creamy and slightly spicy dip.
CA$1.45
Spiced Tomato Sauce
Our Famous Original Sauce.
CA$1.45
Sweet Tomato Sauce
Our Famous Original Sauce.
CA$1.45
Menu
Pepper Poppers ( 6 pcs)
From the recipe box of our very own sister-in-law! Fresh jalapeño peppers stuffed with cheddar cream cheese and bacon, baked to perfection!
CA$9.77
Stuffed Caps ( 6 pcs)
One of Niki's famous appetizers she is asked to make for every get-together! Six large mushroom caps filled with a cream cheese and bacon blend, baked to a golden brown.
CA$9.82
Stuffed Pickles
Two of our xtra large strubbs pickles sliced and loaded with a blend of cheeses and bacon.
CA$9.77
Combo Platter
For those times when you just can't decide!, The combo platter includes two pepper poppers, two stuffed mushroom caps and two loaded slices of our Strubbs pickle.
CA$9.85
Bruschetta Flatbread
Our latest menu item! A mixture of fresh basil, feta cheese and our own tomato/balsamic/olive oil & herb mixture on a freshly baked flatbread.
CA$15.96
Three Cheese Garlic Ranch Flatbread
A mixture of mozzarella, cheddar and fresh parmesan cheese baked to a golden brown over our own garlic ranch sauce on freshly baked flatbread..yum!
CA$15.96
BBQ Chicken Flat Bread
Grilled chicken, bacon, green pepper, red onion, shredded cheddar cheese and our own BBQ sauce layered on freshly baked flatbread.
CA$17.20
Regular Garlic Bread
If you really want to put your garlic bread over the edge, you can add bacon for an additional charge. Ciabatta bread w/ heaps of garlic butter & fresh parsley.
CA$6.95
Garlic Bread With cheese
#2 Most liked
If you really want to put your garlic bread over the edge, you can add bacon for an additional charge. Ciabatta bread with heaps of garlic butter & fresh parsley, with two cheese blend piled high on top!
CA$10.05•87% (8)
Sandwiches
All of our sammys are served on a freshly toasted ciabatta bun and come with a giant Strubbs pickle & plain old fashioned potato chips.
The Spicey Sammy
Hot Italian sausage and salami topped with mozza cheese & our famous spiced tomato sauce.
CA$12.40
Big Boy Grilled Cheese With Bacon
Blend of cheddar & mozzarella cheese with a stack of bacon & dollop of ketchup for dipping
CA$12.40
The Meatball Sammy
All beef meatballs, formaggio's tomato sauce and fresh parmesan cheese on ciabatta bread
CA$12.40
The Chicken Club
Sliced chicken breast, bacon, tomato, lettuce and cheddar cheese piled high on our ciabatta bread with chipotle mayo.
CA$13.00
The Chicken Caesar Wrap
Sliced chicken breast, bacon, lettuce & fresh parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing wrapped in a large tortilla shell.
CA$13.00
Greek Wrap
Chicken, black olives, tomato, onion, romaine lettuce and feta cheese wrapped in a large tortilla shell.
CA$13.00
Nachos
Nachos
#1 Most liked
Your choice of chicken or beef w/ mixed cheese, onion, tomato, green peppers, hot peppers w/ salsa & sour cream on the side for dipping
CA$21.00•100% (9)
Salads
Caesar Salad
fresh romaine, real bacon, parmesan cheese & garlic croutons
CA$11.20
Greek Salad
fresh romaine, tomato, black olives, red onion, feta cheese &
cucumber served with greek dressing
CA$11.35
Summertime Salad
Mixed greens with baby spinach, shaved almonds, mandarin oranges & feta cheese served with poppyseed dressing
CA$11.35
Whatta Deal!
The Family Deal
Large 3 topping pizza, Caesar salad & 3 piece garlic bread with cheese.
CA$47.25
Game Night Deal
Extra Large 3 Topping Pizza & Loaded regular size nacho (chicken or beef)
CA$49.22
Panzerotti Deal
Large 3 topping panzerotti and Caesar salad
CA$36.25
Pizza and Chicken Wing Deal
Medium 3 topping pizza and 1 lb jumbo chicken wings.
CA$41.97
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash