
Josh & John's Naturally Homemade Ice Cream
1981 Jessup Drive, Fort Collins, CO
Online ordering hours: 12:00 PM - 9:35 PM10 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
#2 Most liked
Salted Peanut Butter Cup Pint
$9.95
#3 Most liked
Moose on the Loose Pint
$9.95
#1 Most liked
Purple Mountain Majesty Pint
$9.95
Colorado Cookies & Cream Pint
$9.95
Malted Mazel Toff Pint
$9.95
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pint
$9.95
Mint Chocolate Chip Pint
$9.95
Dutch Chocolate Pint
$9.95
Vanilla Bean Pint
$9.95
Strawberry Pint
$9.95
Almond Joy Pint
$9.95
Colorado Cookies & Cream Cookie Sandwich
$7.95
Yellow Cake Pint
$9.95
Ice Cream Mud Pie
$24.95+
Dairy Free Cookie Butter Crumble Pint
$9.95
Salted Peanut Butter Cup Cookie Sandwich
$7.95
Oatmeal Cookie Pint
$9.95
Dairy Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Pint
$9.95
Mocha Java Jolt Pint
$9.95
Vanilla Bean Cookie Sandwich
$7.95
Grandma Molly's Homemade Hot Fudge
$5.00
Dairy Free Orange Creamsicle Pint
$9.95
Dairy Free Cookie Butter Crumble Cookie Sandwich
$7.95
Dairy Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich
$7.95
Sprinkles
$5.00
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 9:35 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Purple Mountain Majesty Pint
Taro ice cream with chocolate covered raspberry cups
$9.95•16
#1 Most liked
Salted Peanut Butter Cup Pint
Salted peanut butter ice cream with mini peanut butter cups. Yumm!
$9.95•12
#2 Most liked
Moose on the Loose Pint
Chocolate mousse with fudge brownie chunks and chocolate covered caramel cups
$9.95•11
#3 Most liked
Colorado Cookies & Cream Pint
Oreo cookies in a sweet cream base
$9.95•10
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pint
Vanilla with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips
$9.95
Malted Mazel Toff Pint
Malted vanilla with chocolate chips and large chunks of toffee
$9.95•8
Strawberry Pint
Real strawberries in a sweet cream base. We add extra heavy cream to ensure a smooth, creamy ice cream.
$9.95•8
Colorado Cookies & Cream Cookie Sandwich
Two Mary's Mountain chocolate chip cookies with a scoop of Colorado Cookies & Cream
$7.95
Dutch Chocolate Pint
Ice cream made from a blend of European Dutch cocoas
$9.95
Almond Joy Pint
Coconut almond with dark polar bits, chocolate covered almonds and coconut flakes
$9.95
Online Featured Flavors
Dairy Free Candy Cane
Sweet cream base with crushed candy canes, dairy-free.
$10.95
White Christmas
White chocolate ice cream with snowy white chocolate chips and peppermint candies.
$10.95
Online Craft Pints
Strawberry Pint
Real strawberries in a sweet cream base. We add extra heavy cream to ensure a smooth, creamy ice cream.
$9.95•8
Salted Peanut Butter Cup Pint
Salted peanut butter ice cream with mini peanut butter cups. Yumm!
$9.95•12
#2 Most liked
Purple Mountain Majesty Pint
Taro ice cream with chocolate covered raspberry cups
$9.95•16
#1 Most liked
Oatmeal Cookie Pint
A cinnamon nutmeg base with oatmeal cookie chunks.
$9.95
Moose on the Loose Pint
Chocolate mousse with fudge brownie chunks and chocolate covered caramel cups
$9.95•11
#3 Most liked
Mocha Java Jolt Pint
Mocha mousse with espresso pillows and chocolate covered coffee cups
$9.95
Mint Chocolate Chip Pint
Peppermint ice cream with dark polar bits that melt in your mouth
$9.95
Malted Mazel Toff Pint
Malted vanilla with chocolate chips and large chunks of toffee
$9.95•8
Dutch Chocolate Pint
Ice cream made from a blend of European Dutch cocoas
$9.95
Colorado Cookies & Cream Pint
Oreo cookies in a sweet cream base
$9.95•10
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pint
Vanilla with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips
$9.95
Almond Joy Pint
Coconut almond with dark polar bits, chocolate covered almonds and coconut flakes
$9.95
Vanilla Bean Pint
Real bourbon vanilla with vanilla bean seeds. Anything but ordinary, this should be named "the best vanilla ice cream in the world".
$9.95
Yellow Cake Pint
Cake batter ice cream with Nilla wafers. This is a kid (or kid in you) all-time favorite.
$9.95
Online Dairy Free Craft Pints
Dairy Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Pint
Dairy free pea protein base flavored with real Dutch cocoa and peanut butter
$9.95
Dairy Free Cookie Butter Crumble Pint
Dairy free pea protein base flavored with cookie butter and Biscoff cookie pieces
$9.95
Dairy Free Orange Creamsicle Pint
Dairy free pea protein base with oranges
$9.95
Dairy Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich
Two Mary's Mountain chocolate chip cookies with a scoop of Colorado Cookies & Cream
$7.95
Dairy Free Cookie Butter Crumble Cookie Sandwich
Two Mary's Mountain chocolate chip cookies with a scoop of Colorado Cookies & Cream
$7.95
Salted Peanut Butter Cup Cookie Sandwich
Two Mary's Mountain chocolate chip cookies with a scoop of Colorado Cookies & Cream
$7.95
Vanilla Bean Cookie Sandwich
Two Mary's Mountain chocolate chip cookies with a scoop of Colorado Cookies & Cream
$7.95
Colorado Cookies & Cream Cookie Sandwich
Two Mary's Mountain chocolate chip cookies with a scoop of Colorado Cookies & Cream
$7.95
Sundae Toppings & Root Beer (O)
Grandma Molly's Homemade Hot Fudge
The best darn hot fudge money can buy. This is a recipe that comes from co-founder John Krakauer's mother.
$5.00
Maraschino Cherries
Add a cherry on top!
$5.00
Sprinkles
No sundae would be complete without rainbow sprinkles!
$5.00
Bakery Cakes & Pies (available as soon as today!)
6" Round Cake (Same Day Pick-Up)
These are in-stock cakes and we do not write on them. Two layers of gourmet ice cream separated with a thick layer of fudge and frosted with our homemade buttercream frosting. Don't forget the candles!
$39.00+
Dairy Free Mud Pies
Dairy Free Ice cream in a fudge layered graham cracker crust. Each pie will serve 8 Vegan or Lactose Intolerant friends.
$24.95+
Ice Cream Mud Pie
Ice cream in a fudge layered graham cracker crust. Each pie will serve 8 friends.
$24.95+
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash