VALLEY CHEESE Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
VALLEY CHEESE
Sign In / Sign Up
VALLEY CHEESE
2200 Market Street, Wheeling, WV
Online ordering hours: 10:00 AM - 4:10 PMOpens 10:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
#3 Most liked
Italian with Cheese
$7.00
#1 Most liked
Fresh Fruit Cup
$6.00
Roast Beef & Cheese
$6.00
Greek Salad
$8.50
Chicken Salad
$7.00
Chicken Salad
$8.00
Chicken Salad
$6.00
Turkey, Bacon & cheese
$8.00
Chef Salad
$8.50
Italian with Cheese
$8.50
Turkey & Cheese
$8.00
Roast Beef & Cheese
$8.50
Veggie Cup
$6.00
Italian with Cheese
$7.50
Turkey, Bacon & cheese
$6.50
Soup of The Day
$5.00
Roast Beef & Cheese
$6.50
Turkey & Cheese
$7.00
Turkey & Cheese
$6.00
Ham & Cheese
$6.00
Tossed Salad
$5.50
Full Menu
10:00 am - 4:10 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Fresh Fruit Cup
Fresh fruit served with homemade fruit dip!
$6.00•92% (96)
#1 Most liked
Soup of The Day
Seasonal. 12 oz. bowl.
$5.00•84% (33)
Italian with Cheese
ham, salami, pepperoni, & choice of cheese
$8.50•98% (52)
Veggie Cup
Fresh vegetables served with a homemade veggie dip!
$6.00•100% (26)
Turkey & Cheese
Sliced turkey and cheese in a choice of spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free wrap.
$7.00•100% (9)
Chef Salad
Ham, salami, pepperoni, iceberg lettuce, green pepper, tomato, cucumber, cheddar cheese & egg. Served with choice of dressing on the side.
$8.50•100% (19)
Turkey, Bacon & cheese
Turkey, bacon, and cheese sandwich. Choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.50•93% (16)
Turkey, Bacon & cheese
Slices of turkey and bacon paired with cheese on a toasted Italian sub roll, typically includes lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
$8.00•91% (12)
Club with Cheese
Ham, Turkey, bacon & 1 choice of cheese
$7.00•100% (13)
Sandwiches
White, wheat, or rye. Add extra meat or cheese to any sandwich for $1.25 additional charge. Add extra bacon to any sandwich for $1.25 additional charge. All lunchmeats and cheeses on these sandwiches come from Amish country!
Turkey, Bacon & cheese
Turkey, bacon, and cheese sandwich. Choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.50•93% (16)
Ham, Bacon & Cheese
Ham, bacon, and cheese sandwich with choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.50
Club with Cheese
Ham, Turkey, bacon & 1 choice of cheese
$7.00•100% (13)
Turkey & Cheese
Turkey & cheese sandwich with bread options: white, wheat, rye.
$6.00•85% (7)
Ham & Cheese
Ham and cheese sandwich with choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.00
Salami & Cheese
Salami & cheese sandwich on choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.00
Egg Salad
Made in house
$6.00•95% (20)
Chicken Salad
From amish country
$6.00•100% (43)
Tuna Salad
Made in-house, this tuna salad is made with white albacore tuna from Colemans Fish Market.
$6.00
Italian with Cheese
Ham, salami, pepperoni, & choice of cheese
$7.00•98% (52)
#3 Most liked
Fried Chicken Breast & Cheese
Fried Chicken Breast is a slicable lunchmeat that literally tastes like fried chicken.
$6.00
Roast Beef & Cheese
Roast Beef & Cheese Sandwich: Sliced roast beef, melted cheese, choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.00
Pastrami & Cheese
Pastrami & cheese sandwich with choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.00
Corned Beef & Cheese
Corned beef & cheese sandwich with choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.00
Bologna & Cheese
Bologna and cheese on choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.00
Chipped Ham & Cheese
Chipped ham and cheese sandwich with choice of white, wheat, or rye bread.
$6.00•100% (6)
Veggie with Choice of Cheese
Veggie sandwich with a choice of white, wheat, or rye bread and selection of cheese.
$6.00
8 Inch Sub
White sub only. Add extra meat or cheese to any sandwich for an $1.25 additional charge. Add extra bacon to any sandwich for $1.25 additional charge. All lunchmeats and cheese used on these items are from Amish country!
B.L.T.
Crispy Bacon, Fresh Lettuce, and Tomato on Toasted Bread
$8.00
Turkey, Bacon & cheese
Slices of turkey and bacon paired with cheese on a toasted Italian sub roll, typically includes lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
$8.00•91% (12)
Ham, Bacon & cheese
Ham, bacon, and cheese combined on an 8-inch Italian sub roll, typically includes lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
$8.00
Club
Ham, turkey & 1 choice of cheese
$8.50•100% (7)
Turkey & Cheese
Layers of turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and pickles, complemented with a hint of mustard, wrapped in a whole wheat sub roll.
$8.00
Ham & Cheese
Ham and provolone cheese on an 8-inch sub roll, typically includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and mayonnaise.
$8.00
Salami & Cheese
Salami and provolone on Italian bread, typically includes lettuce, tomato, onion, and a drizzle of Italian dressing.
$8.00
Egg Salad
Made in-house
$8.00•95% (20)
Chicken Salad
From Amish Country
$8.00•100% (43)
Tuna Salad
Made in-house with white albacore tuna from Colemans Fish Market
$8.00•100% (9)
Italian with Cheese
ham, salami, pepperoni, & choice of cheese
$8.50•98% (52)
Fried Chicken Breast & Cheese
This is a sliced lunchmeat that literally tastes like fried chicken breast
$8.00•100% (12)
Roast Beef & Cheese
Roast beef and cheese on a 8-inch sub roll with your choice of cheese, toppings & condiments
$8.50•100% (7)
Pastrami & Cheese
Pastrami on an 8-inch Italian sub roll with your choice of cheese, toppings & condiments
$8.00
Corned Beef & Cheese
Corned beef and cheese served on an 8-inch Italian sub roll with your choice of cheese,m toppings & condiments
$8.00
Bologna & Cheese
Bologna and cheese on an 8-inch sub with your choice of cheese, toppings & condiments
$8.00
Chipped Ham & Cheese
Chipped ham & cheese with your choice of cheese, toppings & condiments
$8.00
Veggie with Choice of Cheese
An 8" submarine sandwich filled with a variety of vegetables such as lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, and green peppers, complemented by a selection of cheese.
$8.00
Italian Bun
White only. Add extra meat or cheese to any sandwich for a $1.25 additional charge. Add extra bacon to any sandwich for $1.25 additional charge. All lunchmeats & cheeses used on these items are from Amish country!
Turkey & Cheese
Turkey on a bun with your choice of cheese, toppings & condiments
$6.50
Ham & Cheese
Sliced ham paired with cheese served on an Italian bun with your choice of toppings & condiments
$6.50
Salami & Cheese
Salami & cheese typically includes Genoa salami and provolone, accompanied by lettuce, tomato, and onion, often dressed with oil and vinegar.
$6.50
Egg Salad
Made in-house
$6.50•95% (20)
Tuna Salad
Made in-house with white Albacore tuna from Colemans Fish Market
$6.50•100% (9)
Italian with Cheese
Ham, salami, pepperoni, & choice of cheese
$7.50•98% (52)
Fried Chicken Breast & Cheese
This is a sliced lunchmeat that literally tastes like fried chicken
$6.50•100% (12)
Roast Beef & Cheese
Roast beef and cheese on a bun, typically includes lettuce, tomato, and a spread of mayonnaise.
$6.50•100% (6)
Pastrami & Cheese
Tender pastrami and melted cheese on a soft Italian bun, typically accompanied by mustard, lettuce, tomato, and pickles.
$6.50
Corned Beef & Cheese
Corned beef and cheese on an Italian bun, typically includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and a blend of cheeses.
$6.50
Bologna & Cheese
Bologna and cheese served on an Italian bun, typically includes a blend of traditional Italian bologna and cheese.
$6.50
Chipped Ham & Cheese
Sliced chipped ham and cheese, typically assembled on an Italian bun.
$6.50
Veggie with Choice of Cheese
A veggie burger typically includes a vegetable patty with a selection of cheese, accompanied by lettuce, tomato, and various toppings on a bun.
$6.50
Wraps
Spinach, white, or wheat. Add extra meat or cheese to any sandwich for an additional charge. Add extra bacon to any sandwich for additional charge. All lunchmeat & cheeses used on these items are from Amish Country!
Turkey & Cheese
Sliced turkey and cheese in a choice of spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free wrap.
$7.00•100% (9)
Ham & Cheese
Ham & Cheese Wrap: Sliced ham, cheese in a choice of spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free wrap.
$7.00
Salami & Cheese
Salami and cheese wrap ...selections include spinach, wheat, tomato, white, or gluten-free.
$7.00
Egg Salad
Made in house
$7.00•95% (20)
Chicken Salad
From Amish Country
$7.00•100% (43)
Tuna Salad
Made in house with white albacore tuna from Colemans Fish Market
$7.00•100% (9)
Italian with Cheese
Ham, salami, pepperoni, & choice of cheese, toppings & condiments
$7.50•88% (9)
Fried Chicken Breast & Cheese
This is a sliced lunchmeat that literally tastes like fried chicken
$7.00•100% (12)
Roast Beef & Cheese
Sliced roast & cheese in a wrap of spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free wrap
$7.00
Pastrami & Cheese
Pastrami & Cheese Wrap: Wrap options include spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free.
$7.00
Corned Beef & Cheese
Corned beef & cheese wrapped in spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free options.
$7.00
Bologna & Cheese
Bologna and cheese in your choice of spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free wrap.
$7.00
Chipped Ham & Cheese
Chipped ham and cheese wrap. Wrap choices include spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free.
$7.00
Veggie with Choice of Cheese
Veggie wrap, choice of cheese, with white, wheat, or rye bread. Select wrap: spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free.
$7.00
B.L.T.
BLT wrap with crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Choice of spinach, white, wheat, tomato, or gluten-free wrap.
$7.50•100% (6)
Sides
Cottage Cheese
Soft, fresh cheese made from curdled milk with a mild flavor.
$3.00•100% (16)
Baked Potato Salad
Tastes like a loaded baked potato with scallion, bacon bits & is sour cream based
$3.00•95% (24)
Macaroni Salad
Homemade
$3.00•97% (35)
Pasta Salad
Homemade with green peppers, black olives, tomatoes & asiago cheese
$3.00•98% (74)
#2 Most liked
Coleslaw
Homemade
$3.00
Dill Pickle
Kosher dill
$1.00•95% (23)
Fresh Fruit Cup
Fresh fruit served with homemade fruit dip!
$6.00•92% (96)
#1 Most liked
Veggie Cup
Fresh vegetables served with a homemade veggie dip!
$6.00•100% (26)
Fresh Salads
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomato, black olives, cucumber, green pepper, red onion & feta cheese. Served with Greek dressing on the side.
$8.50•100% (8)
Tossed Salad
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, green pepper, cheddar cheese, egg & black olives. Served with choice of dressing on the side.
$5.50•100% (14)
Chef Salad
Ham, salami, pepperoni, iceberg lettuce, green pepper, tomato, cucumber, cheddar cheese & egg. Served with choice of dressing on the side.
$8.50•100% (19)
Beverages
20 oz Coke
The cold 20oz, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$2.50•100% (10)
20 oz Pepsi
The bold, 20 oz refreshing, robust cola
$2.50
20 oz 7up
Crisp, refreshing lemon-lime soda, perfectly carbonated for a delightful sip.
$2.50
Coffee
16 oz.
$1.40
French Vanilla Cappuccino
16 oz. cup with whipped cream on top
$2.75•100% (9)
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
Sweet or unsweet 20 oz.
$2.75•100% (22)
Featured Items
Soup of The Day
Seasonal. 12 oz. bowl.
$5.00•84% (33)
Hot Dog
Choice of ketchup, mustard, onion, or relish
$1.50
Chili Dog
Choice of ketchup, mustard, onion, relish, and cheese.
$2.00•66% (9)
Cookies (2)
Two cookies, each offering a distinct taste and texture, typically crafted with classic Italian ingredients.
$1.50•95% (20)
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
Salted pretzels coated in a layer of rich chocolate, capturing a blend of crunchy and smooth textures.
$1.00•100% (21)
Amish Ciders
Served in 1/2 gallons. 100% juice blend-all natural apple cider mixed with fruit concentrate.
Blueberry
These are 100% juice blend...apple cider & juice concentrate blended together. Great just how it is or as a mixer. 180 shelf life
$10.00
Red Raspberry
These are 100% juice blend...apple cider & juice concentrate blended together. Great just how it is or as a mixer. 180 shelf life
$10.00
Peach
These are 100% juice blend...apple cider & juice concentrate blended together. Great just how it is or as a mixer. 180 shelf life
$10.00
BlackBerry
100% juice concentrate blended with apple cider
$10.00
Cherry
100% juice concentrate blended with apple cider
$10.00
Amish Mustards, Relish & Salsa
Hot Pepper Mustard
A spicy blend of ground hot peppers and mustard seeds, typically accented with vinegar and spices for a tangy kick.
$4.50
Sweet & Spicy Mustard
A harmonious mix of sweetness and heat, crafted with carefully selected spices and mustard seeds.
$4.50
Roasted Garlic Mustard
Roasted garlic mustard is a savory blend of roasted garlic incorporated into a smooth mustard base, often enjoyed with Italian dishes.
$4.50
Sweet Red Pepper Relish
Sweet red peppers finely chopped and blended with a tangy, slightly sweet sauce, perfect for enhancing sandwiches, salads, or as a dip.
$5.50
Vidalia Onion Relish
A sweet and tangy relish featuring finely chopped Vidalia onions, typically complemented by vinegar, sugar, and spices.
$4.50
Honey Mustard
A harmonious blend of sweet honey and tangy mustard, typically used as a dipping sauce or condiment.
$4.00
Horseradish Sauce
Grated horseradish root combined with vinegar, often found complementing Italian meats and sandwiches.
$4.00
Apple Butter BBQ Sauce
Apple butter BBQ sauce combines the sweetness of apple butter with the tangy, smoky flavors of traditional BBQ sauce for a unique condiment experience.
$4.25
Islay's BBQ Sauce
Islay's BBQ sauce is a unique blend, typically featuring a smoky base with hints of whiskey, inspired by Islay's renowned scotch, paired with traditional barbecue sauce ingredients.
$4.50
Peach Salsa
Peach salsa is a blend of diced peaches and traditional salsa ingredients, typically including onions, tomatoes, and a variety of herbs and spices.
$4.00
Pineapple Salsa
Pineapple salsa combines chunks of fresh pineapple with onions, cilantro, and jalapeños, typically dressed with lime juice and spices.
$4.00
Woeber's Reserve
Cranberry Honey, southwest mustard, Champagne dill, smokey horseradish, honey mustard.
$2.00
Amish Noodles
Home-Style Noodles
Wide, Medium or fine. These are UNCOOKED noodles from Amish Country. Take home & add to your favorite noodle recipe!
$3.00
Gluten-Free Noodles
Gluten-free noodles typically tossed with olive oil and garlic, featuring a mix of seasonal vegetables and herbs.
$6.00
Snacks & Stuff
Amish Beef Jerky
1 pound bags. Honey, mild, Jalapeno or spicy hot
$35.00
Fruit Twists
Blue Raspberry, Green Apple, Red, Black Licorice, cinnamon.
$3.75
Pistachios
Typically includes shelled, roasted pistachios, often seasoned with salt.
$6.00
Honey Roasted Cashews
Cashews gently roasted and coated in honey for a sweet and crunchy snack.
$5.25
Honey Roasted Sesame Sticks
Sesame sticks coated in honey and roasted to a golden crisp, offering a sweet and slightly nutty snack experience.
$4.00
Plain Sesame Sticks
Crispy, oven-baked sticks coated in sesame seeds, offering a simple yet satisfying snack.
$4.00
Saseens Salad Dressing
A blend of olive oil, vinegar, and select Italian herbs, typically used to dress salads.
$3.50
Rice Vinegar
Grilled shrimp and beef skewers, served with steamed rice, a boiled egg, fresh salad with cucumbers, tomatoes, and lettuce, garnished with cilantro and a lime wedge.
$8.50
Pickled Okra
Mild or Hot
$5.50
Pickled Brussels Sprouts
Mild or Hot
$5.50
Pickled Asparagus
Mild or hot
$7.50
Meat Loaf Sauce
Ground beef typically simmered in a rich tomato-based sauce, often seasoned with herbs like basil and oregano.
$4.25
Peaches
Peach Halves from Walnut Creek Amish Country
$7.50
Mancini Sliced Italian Bread
Mancini delivers daily so this bread is guaranteed fresh! It does not have any preservatives added which makes it taste even better! Mancini is a Pittsburgh, PA product approved by Valley Cheese...
$3.50
Roasted Pineapple Habanero Sauce
Roasted pineapple habanero sauce combines the sweetness of roasted pineapple with the fiery kick of habanero peppers, creating a versatile and bold condiment.
$5.50
Raspberry Chipotle Sauce
Our raspberry chipotle sauce combines raspberries with the smoky heat of chipotle peppers for a sweet and spicy condiment.
$5.50
Amish Vegetable Jars
Pickled Jalapeño Eggs
Eggs hard-boiled and pickled with sliced jalapeños, typically immersed in a vinegar-based brine with herbs and spices for a tangy kick.
$7.50
Pickled Beet Eggs
Hard-boiled eggs marinated in a blend of vinegar, sugar, and beet juice, typically garnished with slices of pickled beets.
$7.50
Pickled Baby Beets
Baby beets, pickled in a traditional Italian vinegar blend, typically includes aromatic herbs.
$7.50
Horseradish Pickles
Cucumbers brined with horseradish, offering a distinctive, tangy taste.
$5.00
Sweet Hot Dill Pickles
Cucumbers pickled with a blend of dill, vinegar, and a hint of sweetness and heat, following a traditional Amish recipe.
$5.00
Sweet Fire Pickles
Cucumbers pickled with a blend of sweet and spicy ingredients, typically including sugar and chili peppers.
$5.00
Hot Pickled Garlic
Garlic cloves pickled in a vinegar-based brine with Italian herbs and spices, offering a tangy and slightly spicy flavor.
$7.25
Sweet Pickled Garlic
Garlic cloves, sweetly pickled in a blend of vinegar, sugar, and Italian herbs, creating a delightful jarred condiment.
$7.25
Sweet Garlic Dill Pickles
Cucumbers preserved with a blend of sweet garlic and dill, typically jarred in a vinegar solution.
$5.00
Peaches
Peach halves from walnut creek amish country
$7.50
Grapevine Leaves
These are grape vine leaves you will take home & stuff your own with a great family recipe. NOT cooked & not ready to eat...
$10.00
Horseradish Pickles
Cucumbers brined with horseradish for a distinctively sharp and tangy flavor profile.
$5.00
Bread & Butter Pickles
Cucumbers sliced and preserved in a sweet and tangy brine with spices, typically including mustard seeds and turmeric.
$5.00
Amish Cheese
Per pound. Most of the following are from Amish Country. Some imported.
American
American cheese, known for its creamy, smooth texture, is a versatile addition to sandwiches and burgers.
$5.00
Amish Butter Cheese
A soft, creamy cheese that typically includes hints of buttery flavor, originating from Amish dairy traditions.
$8.50
Baby Swiss
Guggisberg Baby Swiss is an award winning cheese
$8.50
Bacon Cheddar
Incorporates Italian influences into a classic blend of crispy bacon and sharp cheddar cheese, typically enjoyed in various dishes for a savory experience.
$8.00
Chocolate Cheese
Made with cream cheese. Tastes like chocolate fudge.
$15.00
Garlic Cheddar
Infused with robust garlic, this cheddar cheese offers a bold twist on a classic Italian favorite, typically enjoyed with crackers or melted over dishes.
$9.00
Danish Blue Cheese
A distinctively sharp and slightly salty cheese originating from Denmark, often used to enhance the flavors of various dishes.
$18.00
Gorgonzola
Gorgonzola cheese, originating from Italy, often paired with fruits, nuts, and honey to enhance its bold, tangy flavor.
$12.00
Beer Cheese/German Brick
This is from Wisconsin...half limburger & half brick cheese
$9.00
Limburger
A distinctive cheese known for its strong aroma, often paired with simple accompaniments to balance its robust flavor.
$9.00
Colby / Longhorn
A semi-hard blend combining the smooth, mild flavor of Colby with the firm, tangy essence of Longhorn.
$8.00
Marble
A blend of white and colored cheeses, offering a smooth texture and mild taste.
$8.00
Farmers
Low sodium, fat & cholesterol.
$8.00
Swiss
Swiss cheese, originating from Italy, typically includes a smooth, mild flavor profile with a firm texture.
$8.50
Lacey Swiss
Low fat, low sodium.
$8.50
Sharp Swiss
A robust and tangy cheese, known for its distinctively strong flavor, originating from the Italian Alps.
$9.00
Swiss n Rye
Swiss cheese paired with rye, offering a classic combination that typically includes a distinctively nutty cheese with the robust flavor of rye.
$8.00
Italian Blend
Asiago & American
$8.00
Green Onion Cheese
Tastes like french onion chip dip.
$9.00
Hot Pepper
Infused with spicy peppers, this cheese offers a bold taste with a kick, typically paired with Italian dishes for an added layer of flavor.
$8.00
Chipotle Cheddar
Infused with smoky chipotle peppers, this cheddar cheese offers a distinctive spicy flavor.
$8.00
Ghost Pepper 8 oz
Infused with ghost peppers for a fiery kick.
$6.00
Habanero Cheddar
Incorporates spicy habanero peppers into cheddar cheese for a bold flavor profile.
$9.50
Pepper Jack
Pepper jack typically includes spicy jalapeños intermingled with Monterey Jack cheese, offering a balance of creamy texture and a mild heat kick.
$8.00
Salsa Jack
Salsa jack typically includes a blend of Monterey Jack cheese infused with a mix of tomatoes, onions, cilantro, and jalapeños, offering a slightly spicy and tangy flavor.
$8.00
Provolone
Provolone cheese combined with lettuce, tomato, and onion, offering a balance of mild and savory flavors.
$8.00
Mozzarella
Soft, creamy texture with a pleasantly sourish taste, often served fresh.
$8.00
Havarti
A Danish-origin cheese known for its creamy texture and mild, buttery taste, often featuring small, irregular holes.
$10.00
Dill Havarti
Creamy Havarti cheese infused with dill, offering a fresh and herby taste profile.
$10.00
Muenster
Muenster is a smooth, mildly tangy cheese that typically includes a soft texture and a distinctive orange rind.
$8.00
Smoked Cheddar
Aged cheddar cheese infused with a smoky flavor profile.
$8.50
Smoked Swiss
A robust cheese, gently smoked to enhance its natural flavors and add a subtle smoky note.
$8.50
Smoked Hot Pepper
Infused with smoked hot peppers, this cheese offers a robust and spicy flavor profile.
$8.50
Smoked Gouda
Smoked gouda from Italy, typically includes a rich, smoky flavor with a smooth, creamy texture.
$10.00
Smoked Horseradish
Infused with smoked horseradish for a distinctive tangy flavor.
$9.00
Gouda
A semi-soft cheese from Italy, made with cow's milk, offering a deep, tangy, and nutty flavor with hints of caramel.
$9.50
Super Sharp Cheddar
Aged for a distinctive taste, this Italian take on Amish cheese offers a bold and intense flavor profile.
$8.00
White Sharp Cheddar
White sharp cheddar is a matured, intensely flavored cheese known for its distinctive sharpness and smooth texture.
$16.00
Applewood Smoked Cheddar
Infused with the smoky flavor of applewood during the aging process.
$18.00
Feta
1 pound jar in brine
$10.00
Horseradish Cheese
Horseradish cheese is a bold blend, incorporating the pungent and spicy flavors of horseradish into the creamy texture of cheese.
$9.00
Brick
Brick cheese, originating from the Midwest, is a medium-soft cheese known for its earthy, slightly sweet flavor and smooth texture.
$9.50
Pepperoni Cheddar
Pepperoni cheddar combines sharp cheddar cheese with slices of pepperoni, offering a savory and slightly spicy flavor profile.
$10.50
Salami Cheddar
Salami cheddar combines Italian salami with cheddar, typically enjoyed in various Italian and Amish cheese dishes.
$8.00
Fontinella
Fontinella cheese typically includes a slightly sweet, tangy flavor profile with a creamy texture.
$10.00
Locatelli Romano
Aged sheep's milk cheese, known for its fine, grainy texture and sharp, salty flavor.
$18.00
Asiago
Asiago is a firm, aged Italian cheese known for its nutty flavor and ability to grate well, typically used in a variety of dishes for added depth.
$10.50
Crandale
A unique blend of cheeses, often featuring a distinct texture and taste profile, inspired by traditional Italian cheese-making techniques.
$20.00
Apricot Cheddar
Cheddar cheese typically combined with sweet dried apricots, creating a balanced blend of savory and fruity flavors.
$20.00
Blueberry Cheddar
A unique blend of sharp cheddar cheese infused with sweet blueberries, offering a delightful contrast of flavors.
$20.00
Gruyere
A hard, yellow cheese known for its rich, nutty flavor and creamy texture.
$18.00
Mediterranean Sunset
Sun dried tomaotes, olives, oregano. basil, thyme, fennel & other spices.
$10.50
Bruschetta Jack
Sun dried tomatoes, garlic, oregano, basil & other spices.
$8.00
Marble Blue
A blend of Italian blue cheese, offering a marbled texture with hints of rich, tangy flavors.
$9.00
Buffalo Wing Cheddar
Infused with the tangy essence of buffalo sauce and melded with smooth cheddar, typically reminiscent of classic buffalo wings.
$9.00
Spreads
Sold in 1/2 pound containers. Sharp Cheddar, Pimento, horseradish, port wine, buffalo, pepperoni pizza, vegetable or roasted red pepper
$4.50
Amish Deli Meats
Per pound.
Southern Smoked Ham
Southern smoked ham, served with a selection of Italian deli meats, typically includes provolone cheese.
$9.50
Virginia Ham
Virginia ham, thinly sliced, often accompanied by traditional Italian condiments or additions, reflecting its Amish deli meats category.
$9.50
Off The Bone Ham
Sliced off the bone ham, typically served with provolone cheese on Italian bread.
$9.50•100% (6)
Chipped Ham
Thinly sliced, seasoned ham, typically served as a deli meat for sandwiches or platters.
$5.50
Corned Beef
Tender slices of flavorful corned beef.
$10.50
Roast Beef
Roast beef typically includes tender slices of beef, often accompanied by a selection of vegetables and condiments, served on Italian bread.
$14.00
Islay's Chopped Ham
Islay's chopped ham, finely diced and blended with select seasonings, served as a hearty filling for sandwiches or as a main component in deli platters.
$6.50•100% (15)
Salami
Salami, typically paired with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a tangy Italian dressing.
$8.50
Capicola
Capicola is a seasoned and cured pork shoulder ham, typically served thinly sliced.
$10.00
Pan Roasted Turkey Breast
Pan roasted turkey breast, typically served with a selection of Italian herbs and a light drizzle of olive oil.
$10.50
Cajun Chicken Breast
Seasoned with a blend of Cajun spices, typically served with lettuce and tomato.
$10.50
Fried Chicken Breast
Fried chicken breast, prepared in the Amish deli tradition, typically includes a boneless chicken breast, lightly breaded and fried to a golden crisp.
$10.50
Sandwich Pepperoni
Pepperoni slices typically accompanied by provolone cheese and a spread of Italian dressing, served on a freshly baked Italian roll.
$8.50
Bologna
Regular or garlic.
$5.50
Dutch Loaf
Dutch loaf typically includes a blend of finely ground meats, seasoned and baked into a firm, sliceable loaf, often enjoyed in sandwiches.
$6.50
Pastrami
Thinly sliced pastrami, often accompanied by mustard and sometimes topped with provolone cheese, served on rye or Italian bread.
$10.50
Summer Sausage
Regular or Jalapeño Cheddar.
$6.50
Amish Trail Bologna
Ring Trail Bologna
$7.50
Sweet Lebanon Bologna
Cured and smoked beef, traditionally seasoned, often served with a hint of sweetness.
$9.00
Braunschweiger
A smooth, spreadable liver sausage, typically includes spices and is served as a deli meat.
$6.00
Lebanon Bologna
Regular Smoked
$9.00•100% (7)
Miscellaneous
Apple Butter
Regular or Sugarless.
$4.25
Jumbo White Eggs
Large white eggs, prepared to your preference, offering a simple yet classic dish.
$4.00
Organic Brown Eggs
Organic brown eggs are typically prepared in a style of your choosing, often accompanied by a selection of fresh, seasonal ingredients to complement the dish.
$5.00
Amish Country Roll Butter 2# rolls
Artisanal butter crafted in the Amish tradition, typically includes a sweet, rich and creamy texture.
$15.00
Sassafras Tea
Sassafras tea is an infusion made from the roots of the sassafras tree, typically enjoyed for its unique aroma and flavor.
$3.50
Pizzelles
Please choose Anise or vanilla
$6.00
Soup Base
Ham, Chicken, Beef, or Onion.
$5.50
Grape Leaves
These are grape vine leaves you will take home & stuff with your own family recipe. NOT cooked or ready to eat!
$10.00
Chicken Salad by the pound
Delicious chicken salad from the Amish Country. Little chunky, little creamy, a lot YUMMY!
$9.50
Honey
Pure honey, commonly used as a sweetener or ingredient in various dishes and desserts.
$10.50
Ham Salad by the pound
Delicious ham salad from Amish Country. A little sweetness...
$9.50
Tuna Salad by the pound
White albacore tuna from Colemans with our own famous recipe mixed in!
$9.50
Egg Salad by the pound
Our house made egg salad is a delight to the taste buds!
$6.00
Amish Jam & Jelly
Sugar Free Red Raspberry Spread
Red raspberries are used to create a sugar-free spread, offering a fruit-forward taste without added sugars.
$4.00
Sugar Free Strawberry Spread
Strawberries are used to create this sugar-free spread, offering a naturally sweet taste without added sugars.
$4.00
Sugar Free Mixed Berry Spread
A blend of various berries, this spread is crafted without sugar, offering a natural sweetness and fruitiness.
$4.00
Strawberry Rhubarb Jam
Combining fresh strawberries and rhubarb, this jam is a sweet and slightly tart spread, ideal for enhancing any dish.
$3.75
Black Cherry Jelly
Black cherry jelly, a smooth blend of pureed black cherries typically set with gelatin or pectin, creating a spreadable jelly.
$3.75
Blueberry Jam
Blueberry jam is a spread made from blueberries, typically includes sugar and pectin, capturing the fruit's natural sweetness and vibrant flavor.
$3.75
Red Raspberry Jam
Red raspberry jam is a spread made from ripe red raspberries, typically simmered to achieve a thick consistency.
$3.75
Red Raspberry Jelly
Red raspberry jelly, typically made by simmering ripe red raspberries to achieve a smooth and spreadable consistency.
$3.75
Blackberry Jam
Blackberry jam is a spread made from crushed blackberries, sugar, and often a hint of lemon juice, simmered until thickened.
$3.75
Blackberry Jelly
Blackberry jelly, often served as a spread, is made from pureed blackberries, typically sweetened and set into a firm shape using pectin.
$3.75
Tomato Jam
Tomato jam is a sweet and tangy spread made from ripe tomatoes, often simmered with sugar and a hint of spices to enhance its flavor.
$3.75
F.R.O.G. Jam
Fig, Raspberry, Orange peel , Ginger
$6.00
Christmas Jam
A festive blend of strawberries and cranberries, typically simmered to a sweet and slightly tart finish, capturing the essence of the holiday season.
$6.00
Triple Berry Jam
A blend of raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries, slowly simmered to create a rich, fruit-forward jam.
$6.00
Hot Pepper Jam
Hot pepper jam combines sweet fruit preserves with the fiery kick of hot peppers, creating a versatile condiment.
$6.00
Raspberry Jalapeño Jelly
Raspberry jalapeño jelly combines the sweetness of raspberries with the mild heat of jalapeño peppers, creating a unique spread.
$3.75
Apple Cinnamon Jelly
Apple cinnamon jelly is a sweet spread made with apple cider and cinnamon, often enjoyed on breads or as a dessert topping.
$3.75
B.E.A.R Jam
Blackberry, Elderberry, Apple, Raspberry
$4.00
Hot Pepper Jelly
Hot pepper jelly is a vibrant blend of spicy peppers and sweet jelly, creating a unique balance of flavors.
$3.75
Elderberry Jelly
Elderberry jelly is a smooth, spreadable jelly made from ripe elderberries, often combined with sugar and pectin to achieve its signature texture.
$3.75
Pumpkin Butter
Pumpkin butter is a spread made from pureed pumpkin and typically includes spices like cinnamon and nutmeg, offering a sweet and slightly spiced flavor profile.
$3.75
Peach Jam
Peach jam is a spread made from sweet peaches, typically simmered to a thick consistency.
$3.75
Apple Butter
Regular or sugar free.
$4.25
All Natural Peanut Butter
All Natural ...Just Peanuts & Salt
$4.50
Black Raspberry Jam
Black raspberry jam is a smooth, spreadable preserve made from ripe black raspberries, typically sweetened and cooked down to achieve a thick consistency.
$5.50
Black Raspberry Jelly
Black raspberry jelly is a smooth, spreadable jelly made from ripe black raspberries, typically sweetened and set into a firm texture, ideal for pairing with breads and desserts.
$5.50
Peanut Butter Spread
A smooth blend of peanut butter, often accompanied by a hint of sweetness, prepared as a versatile spread.
$4.00
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash