Caked Up Cafe (Main St) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Caked Up Cafe (Main St)
Sign In / Sign Up

Caked Up Cafe

40 South Main Street, New City, NY
Loading
Online ordering hours: 10:00 AM - 5:10 PM
2 min
ready for pickup

Featured Items

#2 Most liked
Death by Chocolate Cupcake
$4.95
#1 Most liked
Red Velvet Cupcake
$4.95
#3 Most liked
Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake
$4.95
Pack of Minis
$16.75
Piñata Confetti Cake
$44.95
Cookie Dough Cake
$44.95
Half Baked Cake
$49.95
Cookies and Cream Cake
$44.95
Original Crumb Cake
$23.95
Dulce de Leche Cake
$44.95
Carrot Cupcake
$4.95
Half Baked Cupcake
$4.95
Cookies & Cream Cupcake
$4.95
Cookie Dough Cupcake
$4.95
Coconut Samoa Cake
$4.95
Top of the Crumb
$13.50
Unicorn Cupcake
$4.95
Confetti Crumb Cake
$23.95
Maple Bacon Cupcake
$4.95
Confetti Cupcake
$4.95
Italian Rainbow Crumb Slice
$5.75
Cosmic Brownie
$5.00
French Toast Cupcake
$4.95
Reeses Pieces
$4.95
S' Mores Cupake
$4.95
Full Menu
10:00 am - 5:10 pm

Most Ordered

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Red Velvet Cupcake

Classic red velvet cake filled and topped with whipped cream cheese buttercream.
$4.95•31
#1 Most liked

Death by Chocolate Cupcake

Chocolate cake filled and topped with chocolate buttercream, and decorated with chocolate crunchies, chocolate sauce, and a chocolate bar.
$4.95•22
#2 Most liked

Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake filled with strawberry buttercream, topped with vanilla buttercream, and strawberry streusel.
$4.95•19
#3 Most liked

Pack of Minis

12 pack of assorted mini cupcakes.
$16.75•19

Confetti Cupcake

Confetti sprinkle cake filled and topped with vanilla buttercream and decorated with rainbow sprinkles.
$4.95•13

Half Baked Cupcake

Your choice of vanilla or chocolate cake filled with cookie dough buttercream and topped with vanilla cream, mini brownie, and a cookie.
$4.95•17

Cookie Dough Cupcake

Yellowcake filled and topped with cookie dough buttercream, and a mini chocolate chip cookie.
$4.95•12

Carrot Cupcake

Classic carrot cake filled and topped with whipped cream cheese buttercream and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.
$4.95•15

Cookies & Cream Cupcake

Chocolate cake filled and topped with cookies and cream buttercream, and a chocolate sandwich cookie.
$4.95

1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip

Classic gooey chocolate chip cookie.
$4.95•6

Cookies, Brownies & Bites

Confetti Cake Pop

Confetti dipped in white chocolate
$3.00

Oatmeal Stuffed Cookie

Oatmeal cookies stuffed with marshmallow cream!
$4.50•6

Chocolate Cake Pop

Chocolate dipped in semi-sweet chocolate
$3.00

Classic Brownie

Chocolate chip brownie
$3.50•6

Cosmic Brownie

Brownie bottom with a cookie dough layer, topped with ganache and cosmic candies!
$5.00

Snickers Brownie

Brownie base with layers of caramel, nougat, peanuts, and ganache.
$4.95

Top of the Crumb

Our classic buttery crumb topping in bite size pieces!
$13.50

1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip

Classic gooey chocolate chip cookie.
$4.95•6

Coconut Macaroons

$2.75

Italian Rainbow Cookies

Traditional Italian rainbow cookies with almond, raspberry, & ganache
$2.95•8

Crumb Cake

Confetti Crumb Cake

8x8. Classic vanilla crumb, but with sprinkles!
$23.95

Italian Rainbow Crumb Slice

Rainbow cookie flavored slice of crumb cake
$5.75•7

Original Crumb Cake

8x8. Classic yellow cake topped with a thick layer of cinnamon streusel.
$23.95

Gourmet Cupcakes

Candles

Pack of assorted birthday candles
$3.95

Carrot Cupcake

Classic carrot cake filled and topped with whipped cream cheese buttercream and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.
$4.95•15

Chocolate Raspberry Cupcake

Chocolate cake filled with vanilla buttercream, and topped with raspberry buttercream and chocolate shavings.
$4.95

Coconut Samoa Cake

Chocolate cake filled caramel and topped with coconut buttercream, toasted coconut, caramel, and chocolate drizzle.
$4.95

Confetti Cupcake

Confetti sprinkle cake filled and topped with vanilla buttercream and decorated with rainbow sprinkles.
$4.95•13

Cookie Dough Cupcake

Yellowcake filled and topped with cookie dough buttercream, and a mini chocolate chip cookie.
$4.95•12

Death by Chocolate Cupcake

Chocolate cake filled and topped with chocolate buttercream, and decorated with chocolate crunchies, chocolate sauce, and a chocolate bar.
$4.95•22
#2 Most liked

Half Baked Cupcake

Your choice of vanilla or chocolate cake filled with cookie dough buttercream and topped with vanilla cream, mini brownie, and a cookie.
$4.95•17

Maple Bacon Cupcake

Maple infused cake filled and topped with vanilla buttercream, with maple syrup, crispy bacon pieces and a stack of pancakes.
$4.95•6

Pack of Minis

12 pack of assorted mini cupcakes.
$16.75•19

Red Velvet Cupcake

Classic red velvet cake filled and topped with whipped cream cheese buttercream.
$4.95•31
#1 Most liked

S' Mores Cupake

Chocolate cake filled and topped with marshmallow buttercream, toasted, and decorated with chocolate and graham cracker.
$4.95

Strawberry Cheesecake Cupcake

Graham cracker bottom vanilla cake, filled with strawberry compote and topped with whipped cream cheese buttercream, decorated with graham cracker crumbs and fresh strawberry.
$4.95

Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake filled with strawberry buttercream, topped with vanilla buttercream, and strawberry streusel.
$4.95•19
#3 Most liked

Vanilla Caramel Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake filled with caramel, topped with vanilla buttercream and an extra drizzle of caramel.
$4.95

Vanilla Chocolate Cupcake

Yellow cake filled and topped with milk chocolate buttercream with seasonal sprinkles
$4.95

Vanilla Vanilla Cupcake

Yellowcake filled and topped with homemade vanilla buttercream.
$4.95

Pretty Pink Princess

Pink velvet cake filled and topped with pink vanilla buttercream, decorated with edible glitter and a fondant crown.
$4.95•11

Chocolate Chip Pancake

Maple infused cake filled and topped with vanilla buttercream, covered in chocolate chips with a stack of pancakes.
$4.95

Classic Hostess

Your choice of chocolate or vanilla!
$4.95

Cookies & Cream Cupcake

Chocolate cake filled and topped with cookies and cream buttercream, and a chocolate sandwich cookie.
$4.95

French Toast Cupcake

Cinnamon sugar cake infused with maple syrup, filled and topped with vanilla buttercream and cinnamon cereal.
$4.95•7

Over the Rainbow

Blue velvet cupcake with blue vanilla buttercream, rainbow nonpareils and a candy rainbow on top!
$4.95

Reeses Pieces

Chocolate cupcake filled with Reeses pieces, topped with peanut butter buttercream and Reeses candies!
$4.95

Unicorn Cupcake

Confetti cupcake with vanilla buttercream, unicorn sprinkle mix and a fondant unicorn horn.
$4.95•7

Vanilla Coconut Cupcake

Vanilla cake filled and topped with coconut buttercream and coconut flakes.
$4.95•5

6 inch Cakes

Cakes to feed 10-12 people, let us know if you want us to write something on it for you!

Half Baked Cake

A layer of brownie sandwiched between layers of vanilla cake. One layer of brownie buttercream, and one layer of cookie dough buttercream.
$49.95

Cookie Dough Cake

Vanilla cake with cookie dough buttercream
$44.95

Cookies and Cream Cake

Chocolate cake with layers of cookies and cream buttercream with chocolate drip.
$44.95

Double Chocolate Cake

Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream and a chocolate drip
$44.95

Dulce de Leche Cake

Layers of vanilla cake with dulce de leech buttercream filling
$44.95

Piñata Confetti Cake

Confetti cake, layers of vanilla buttercream, filled with candy and rainbow sprinkles.
$44.95

Strawberry Cake

Layers of vanilla cake with strawberry buttercream filling.
$44.95
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
© 2026 DoorDash
Caked Up Cafe 40 South Main Street – Order pickup and delivery