Guerriero Gelato Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Guerriero Gelato
Sign In / Sign Up
Guerriero Gelato
194 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell, NJ
Online ordering hours: 11:00 AM - 10:40 PM20 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream (Cups)
$5.77
Oreo Cake (Same Day)
$43.94
Stock Cakes (Same Day)
$32.94
Baci Cake (Same Day)
$43.94
Mini Cones (dozen)
$23.04
#3 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream (Pint and Quart)
$13.18
Mini Oreos (one dozen)
$19.74
Mini Chips (dozen)
$21.94
Espresso & Tiramisu Cake (Same Day)
$43.94
Soft Serve Cups
$5.77
#2 Most liked
(Ice Cream) Milkshake
$8.23
Mint Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
$27.44
Mini Monsters (dozen)
$21.94
Death by Peanut Butter Pie
$27.44
Gelato (Cups)
$6.18
Granita
$8.78
Big Chips (4 Pack)
$19.74
Coffee Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
$27.44
Gelato (Pints and Quarts)
$15.38
Mini Dot Cakes (5 Pack)
$17.58
Greek Yogurt Soft Serve
$5.77
Italian Ice (Cups)
$5.48
Italian Ice (Pints and Quarts)
$9.88
Pumpkini (Pumpkin Oreos)
$20.84
Build Your Own Breezy
$9.35
Full Menu
11:00 am - 10:40 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Hard Ice Cream (Cups)
Our classic homemade hard ice cream.
$5.77•86% (37)
#1 Most liked
(Ice Cream) Milkshake
Classic Milkshakes made with ice cream.
$8.23•78% (19)
#2 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream (Pint and Quart)
Slow churned, high butterfat ice cream. Winner of Best Ice Cream in Morris & Essex County.
$13.18•92% (13)
#3 Most liked
Gelato (Cups)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$6.18•100% (12)
Build Your Own Breezy
Layered Soft Serve with toppings in a shake cup.
$9.35
Soft Serve Cups
Soft Serve Ice Cream in a cup,
$5.77•90% (11)
Italian Ice (Cups)
$5.48•85% (7)
Granita
A mix of Soft Serve Ice Cream and our homemade Italian ice.
$8.78
Gelato (Pints and Quarts)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$15.38
Mini Chips (dozen)
One Dozen Mini Chip sandwiches featuring our nut free house baked chocolate chips.
$21.94•100% (7)
Featured/New
Gelato Panini
An ice cream sandwich between two house-made brownies, cookies, or cakes.
$7.64
Build Your Own Breezy
Layered Soft Serve with toppings in a shake cup.
$9.35
Mini Dot Cakes (5 Pack)
Mini Ice Cream Cakes in a cup! Vanilla and Chocolate ice cream with fudge and crunchies.
$17.58
Dot Cake (8oz)
8oz
$8.78
Slice of Cheesecake
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake.
$6.58
Quik Quarts
Quarts packed directly from our batch freezer to preserve the highest quality, but at a great price! Cheaper than a pint!
$10.98
Pumpkin Marble Cheesecake Slice
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake. Pumpkin and chocolate flavored cheesecake.
$6.58
Pumpkini (Pumpkin Oreos)
One Dozen Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches made with pumpkin oreo ice cream.
$20.84
Cups, Pints & Quarts
Hard Ice Cream (Cups)
Our classic homemade hard ice cream.
$5.77•86% (37)
#1 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream (Pint and Quart)
Slow churned, high butterfat ice cream. Winner of Best Ice Cream in Morris & Essex County.
$13.18•92% (13)
#3 Most liked
Gelato (Cups)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$6.18•100% (12)
Gelato (Pints and Quarts)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$15.38
Italian Ice (Cups)
$5.48•85% (7)
Italian Ice (Pints and Quarts)
$9.88
Soft Serve Cups
Soft Serve Ice Cream in a cup,
$5.77•90% (11)
Granita
A mix of Soft Serve Ice Cream and our homemade Italian ice.
$8.78
Build Your Own Breezy
Layered Soft Serve with toppings in a shake cup.
$9.35
Empty Cones
Selection of empty cones, including sugar, wafer, waffle, sprinkle waffle, or chocolate crunchy waffle.
$0.55+
SF (Cups)
Our same recipe, but made with Splenda.
$5.88
Sugar-Free (Cups)
Our Sugar-Free Products are made with the same exact recipe as our regular products, just using Splenda as a sugar alternative.
$6.18
Sugar-Free (Pints and Quarts)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$14.85
Greek Yogurt Soft Serve
Soft Serve Greek Yogurt soft serve. Creamy, tart, less sugar, low fat, whole food, frozen dessert. Never any Artificial flavors or colors.
$5.77
Quik Quarts
Quarts packed directly from our batch freezer to preserve the highest quality, but at a great price! Cheaper than a pint!
$10.98
Shakes and Drinks
(Ice Cream) Milkshake
Classic Milkshakes made with ice cream.
$8.23•78% (19)
#2 Most liked
(Gelato) Milkshake
Milkshake made with Gelato.
$8.25
Soda Float (one size)
Ice cream float with soft serve options: Twist, Vanilla, or Chocolate.
$7.68
Can of Sode
Choice of water bottle or Pepsi.
$1.10
Bottle of Water
16.9oz bottle of water
$1.65
Hot Latte
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$4.34
Iced Latte
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$5.44
Cappuccino
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$4.38
Cold Brew
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$3.28
Frappe'
Classic Milkshake spiked with Espresso.
$8.23
Gelato Frappe'
Gelato Milkshake spiked with espresso.
$8.25
Matcha Latte
Ceremony grade Matcha
$4.38
Iced Matcha Latte
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$5.48
Novelties and Sandwiches
Mini Cones (dozen)
A package of 12 mini Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry Cones dipped in White, Dark, and Ruby Chocolate.
$23.04
Mini Chips (dozen)
One Dozen Mini Chip sandwiches featuring our nut free house baked chocolate chips.
$21.94•100% (7)
Mini Monsters (dozen)
A package of one dozen mini sandwiches made with cookie monster ice cream.
$21.94
Mini Oreos (one dozen)
One Dozen Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches.
$19.74
6 Pack IC Sandwich
6 pack of ice cream sandwiches made with soft serve ice cream.
$12.65
Gluten Free Mini Oreos
Pack of 12 Gluten Free Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches. Made with gluten free oreos and Vanilla Ice Cream
$23.04
Ice Cream Sandwich (Single)
Creamy vanilla ice cream layered between two chocolate cookies.
$3.28
Big Chips (4 Pack)
(4 PACK) Two chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream in the middle, rolled in chocolate chips.
$19.74
Big Chips (Single)
Two chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream in the middle, rolled in chocolate chips.
$5.50
Slice of Cheesecake
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake.
$6.58
Gelato Panini
An ice cream sandwich between two house-made brownies, cookies, or cakes.
$7.64
Quik Quarts
Quarts packed directly from our batch freezer to preserve the highest quality, but at a great price! Cheaper than a pint!
$10.98
Pumpkini (Pumpkin Oreos)
One Dozen Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches made with pumpkin oreo ice cream.
$20.84
Pumpkin Marble Cheesecake Slice
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake. Pumpkin and chocolate flavored cheesecake.
$6.58
Ice Cream Cakes
Stock Cakes (Same Day)
Nut Free - Vanilla & Chocolate with Fudge and Crunchies, decorated the way you would like! (flavors cannot be changed)
$32.94
Oreo Cake (Same Day)
These cakes come in Oreo but are just one flavor with no middle filling, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.
$43.94
Strawberry Shortcake (Same Day)
4 layers. ice cream, preserves, pound-cake, and vanilla ice cream. 8" cake serves 12-14.
$43.94
Cookie Monster Cake (Same Day)
These cakes come in Cookie Monster and are just one flavor with no middle filling, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.
$43.94
Baci Cake (Same Day)
These cakes come in Hazelnut and Chocolate Hazelnut with almonds and chocolate chunks, with Fudge and Cookie Crunch in the middle. Decorated with a chocolate whipped cream. 8" cake serves 12-14.
$43.94
Espresso & Tiramisu Cake (Same Day)
Tiramisu and Espresso Chip Gelato cake with coffee soaked Ladyfingers in the middle. (8" cake serves 12-14)
$43.94
Ice Cream Pies
Mint Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of fudge, layer of ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, Oreos, and chocolate drizzle. Available in Vanilla or Mint.
$27.44
Death by Peanut Butter Pie
Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of peanut butter, layer of choc. peanut butter ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, peanut butter cups, peanut butter, and chocolate drizzle.
$27.44
Coffee Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
Coffee Oreo Ice Cream, house-made brownie bottom, ltopped with fresh chocolate whip cream, Oreos, espresso pillows, and chocolate drizzle.
$27.44
Cookie Monster Brownie Pie
Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of fudge, layer of ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, Cookie Dough, Oreos, and chocolate drizzle.
$27.44
Coffee Bar
Hot Latte
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$4.34
Iced Latte
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$5.44
Cappuccino
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$4.38
Cold Brew
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$3.28
Matcha Latte
Ceremony grade Matcha
$4.38
Iced Matcha Latte
Double shot of espresso, choice of milk. 12oz drink.
$5.48
Homemade Cheesecakes
Slice of Cheesecake
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake.
$6.58
Pumpkin Marble Cheesecake Slice
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake. Pumpkin and chocolate flavored cheesecake.
$6.58
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash