Benkert's Bakery Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Benkert's Bakery
2216 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720, USA3 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
Death by Chocolate Cake
$27.99
Small Pastry Platter
$40.00
Cookie Trays
$34.99
Cannoli Cake
$27.99
Rainbow Layer Cake
$27.99
Whipped Cream Birthday Cake
$29.99
Red Velvet Cake
$27.99
#2 Most liked
Strawberry Short Cake
$27.99
Oreo Layer Cake
$27.99
Chocolate Cheese Supreme Cake
$27.99
Cannoli Cheesecake
$23.99
Fudge Crunch Cake
$27.99
Rainbow Cookie Box
$30.00
Balloon Layer Cake
$27.99
Half & Half Layer Cake
$27.99
Rainbow Cookies
$22.99
Strawberry Cheesecake
$23.99
Mocha Layer Cake
$27.99
White Fudge Layer Cake
$27.99
Oreo Cheesecake
$23.99
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
$23.99
Chocolate Cream Pie
$14.99
Carrot Cake
$27.99
Plain Cheesecake
$19.99
7 Layer Cake
$27.99
Full Menu
6:00 am - 5:45 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Strawberry Short Cake
Our moist yellow cake, with a strawberry preserve filling, topped in whipped cream with a strawberry garnish and yellow cake crumbs around the sides.
$27.99•100% (35)
#2 Most liked
Custard Eclairs
Custard-filled éclair, with size options of small or large.
$4.25•88% (25)
Funfetti Cupcake
A funfetti cake with vanilla buttercream icing with confetti sprinkles.
$3.49•100% (12)
Cookie Trays
Assorted Italian cookies.
$34.99•100% (19)
Cannoli Cupcake
A yellow cupcake with cannoli cream icing dipped in chocolate ganache.
$4.25•83% (12)
Small Pastry Platter
18 assorted small pastries.
$40.00•95% (21)
Rainbow Cookies
Traditional rainbow cookies sold by the pound.
$22.99•100% (14)
Large Whipped Cream Eclairs
Choux pastry filled with whipped cream, topped with chocolate glaze and garnished with a maraschino cherry.
$4.25•80% (21)
Large Napoleone's
#1 Most liked
$3.99•90% (40)
Italian Bread
Crisp crust, soft interior. Optional sliced.
$3.50•92% (14)
Cakes
Death by Chocolate Cake
Chocolate cake with fudge filling iced in a rich chocolate ganache topped with chocolate curls and powder sugar.
$27.99•100% (9)
Fudge Crunch Cake
Chocolate cake with a creamy chocolate fudge filling and icing and chocolate crunches around the sides.
$27.99
All Chocolate Layer Cake
Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream filling and iced in chocolate fudge.
$27.99
7 Layer Cake
7 layers of our moist yellow cake with chocolate buttercream filling and chocolate fudge icing.
$27.99
Half & Half Layer Cake
2 layers of yellow cake and one layer of chocolate cake with vanilla and chocolate buttercream.
$27.99•100% (14)
Chocolate Cheese Supreme Cake
2 layers of chocolate cake and one layer of our creamy marble cheesecake with a chocolate butter cream filling and iced in chocolate fudge.
$27.99
White Fudge Layer Cake
Our moist yellow cake with a chocolate buttercream filling and a chocolate fudge icing.
$27.99
Red Velvet Cake
Our rich red velvet cake, with a creamy cream cheese filling, and icing garnished with red velvet cake crumbs.
$27.99
Carrot Cake
A traditional carrot cake, with a creamy cream cheese filling, and icing garnished with napoleon cake crumbs.
$27.99•100% (11)
Zebra Layer Cake
A chocolate cake, with a layer of chocolate fudge filling, a layer of vanilla buttercream filling, and iced in vanilla buttercream with chocolate sprinkles around the sides.
$27.99
Cannoli Cake
A rum soaked yellow cake, with creamy cannoli filling topping in whipped cream with a toasted almond garnish.
$27.99
Strawberry Short Cake
Our moist yellow cake, with a strawberry preserve filling, topped in whipped cream with a strawberry garnish and yellow cake crumbs around the sides.
$27.99•100% (35)
#2 Most liked
Black Forest Cake
A rum soaked chocolate cake, with a black cherry filling.
$27.99
Shadow Layer Cake
2 layers of chocolate cake, 1 layer of yellow cake, with a vanilla buttercream filling, and icing with a hard chocolate drop on top of cake decorated with assorted colors of flowers.
$27.99
Mocha Layer Cake
2 layers of yellow cake, 1 layer of chocolate cake, with a mocha buttercream filling, and icing with chocolate sprinkles around the sides.
$27.99
Maple Walnut Layer Cake
A yellow cake, with a maple flavored buttercream filling, and icing with a walnut garnish.
$27.99
Chocolate Raspberry Layer Cake
Our rich chocolate cake, with a raspberry filling iced in chocolate buttercream with a chocolate ganache drizzle, and chocolate sprinkles around the sides.
$27.99
Balloon Layer Cake
Our moist yellow cake, with a vanilla buttercream filling, icing decorated with buttercream balloons, and rainbow sprinkles.
$27.99
Oreo Layer Cake
A chocolate cake, with an Oreo buttercream filling iced in vanilla buttercream with an Oreo garnish, and chocolate crunchies around the sides.
$27.99•100% (7)
Whipped Cream Birthday Cake
A yellow cake with a choice of strawberry or chocolate pudding filling with whipped cream icing.
$29.99
Chocolate Delight Birthday Cake
A chocolate cake, with chocolate pudding filling and chocolate fudge icing.
$29.99
Rainbow Layer Cake
A traditional rainbow cookie in cake form iced in chocolate fudge.
$27.99•100% (10)
Apple Pie
Cinnamon-spiced, tender apples encased in a flaky, buttery crust.
$14.99•100% (6)
Blueberry Pie
$14.99
Cherry Pie
Made with tart cherries and a flaky crust. Sweet and tangy dessert for any occasion.
$14.99
Chocolate Cream Pie
$14.99
Cup Cakes
Unicorn Cupcake
A yellow cake with a multi colored buttercream swirl in a unicorn cupcake holder, unicorn horn and ears.
$3.49•90% (10)
Sunflower Cupcake
Yellow cake with a yellow buttercream icing and a fudge dollop to look like a sunflower.
$3.50•100% (13)
Cannoli Cupcake
A yellow cupcake with cannoli cream icing dipped in chocolate ganache.
$4.25•83% (12)
Funfetti Cupcake
A funfetti cake with vanilla buttercream icing with confetti sprinkles.
$3.49•100% (12)
Rose Cupcake
A chocolate cupcake dipped in a hard chocolate with a buttercream rose on top.
$3.25•72% (11)
Kids Cupcake
A yellow cake with vanilla buttercream icing airbrushed in a variety of colors.
$2.99•100% (6)
Cheesecakes
Plain Cheesecake
A creamy New York style cheesecake.
$19.99•100% (9)
Tropical Fruit Cheesecake
Our creamy New York style cheesecake topped with a variety of fresh fruit.
$25.99
French Apple Cheesecake
A creamy cheesecake with sliced apples inside topped with crumbs and powder sugar with a cinnamon sugar apple garnish.
$23.99•100% (6)
Cannoli Cheesecake
Our creamy New York style cheesecake topped with cannoli cream and cannoli shells with a chocolate ganache drizzle.
$23.99•100% (8)
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
A creamy cheesecake with chocolate chips inside topped with chocolate fudge.
$23.99
Oreo Cheesecake
A creamy cheesecake with pieces of Oreo inside topped with vanilla buttercream and pieces of Oreo.
$23.99
Black Forest Cheesecake
Our creamy marble cheesecake with black cherry, chocolate fudge and chocolate buttercream garnishes.
$23.99
Strawberry Cheesecake
Our traditional New York style cheesecake with fresh strawberries with a strawberry glaze on top.
$23.99•100% (9)
Fruit Cheesecake
Our traditional New York style cheesecake with blueberry, cherry and pineapple preserves on top.
$23.99
Brooklyn Cheesecake
A creamy cheesecake make with pineapples and sour cream.
$12.99•100% (9)
Cookies
Cookie Trays
Assorted Italian cookies.
$34.99•100% (19)
Rainbow Cookies
Traditional rainbow cookies sold by the pound.
$22.99•100% (14)
Large Black & White Cookies
$2.95•95% (23)
Large Linzer Tarts
$2.95•100% (25)
#3 Most liked
Rainbow Cookie Box
Approx 1 3/4lb of rainbow cookies.
$30.00
Pastries
Small Pastry Platter
18 assorted small pastries.
$40.00•95% (21)
Large Napoleone's
#1 Most liked
$3.99•90% (40)
Cannolis
Crisp pastry shells filled with sweet, creamy ricotta. Available in small or large sizes.
$2.95•100% (17)
Custard Eclairs
Custard-filled éclair, with size options of small or large.
$4.25•88% (25)
Large Whipped Cream Eclairs
Choux pastry filled with whipped cream, topped with chocolate glaze and garnished with a maraschino cherry.
$4.25•80% (21)
Brownies
$2.99•82% (29)
Cannoli Dip Platter
12" platter with cannoli chips and cannoli filling as the dip.
$29.99
Large Cannoli
Crispy pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese, topped with powdered sugar and chocolate chips.
$4.50
Bread
Plain Rye Bread
Plain rye bread. Option for sliced or whole.
$5.99•100% (7)
Seeded Rye
Seeded rye bread, optional sliced serving.
$5.99•100% (7)
Italian Bread
Crisp crust, soft interior. Optional sliced.
$3.50•92% (14)
Pumpernickel
Dark, dense pumpernickel bread. Options for sliced or whole loaf.
$5.99•100% (11)
Pumpernickel Raisin
$5.99•100% (8)
Holiday Stollen
$15.99
Irish Soda Bread
$7.50
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash