Guerriero Gelato (West Orange) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Guerriero Gelato (West Orange)
Sign In / Sign Up
Guerriero Gelato
476 Pleasant Valley Way, West Orange, NJ
Online ordering hours: 2:00 PM - 9:35 PM20 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
Espresso & Tiramisu Cake (Same Day)
$43.94
Oreo Cake (Same Day)
$43.94
Baci Cake (Same Day)
$43.94
#1 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream (Pint and Quart)
$13.18
#2 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream (Cups)
$5.77
Stock Cakes (Same Day)
$32.94
Mini Oreos (one dozen)
$19.74
Pumpkini (Pumpkin Oreos)
$20.84
Death by Peanut Butter Pie
$27.44
Coffee Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
$27.44
Soft Serve Cups
$5.77
Italian Ice (Pints and Quarts)
$9.88
Mini Dot Cakes (5 Pack)
$17.58
Mini Cones (dozen)
$23.04
Mini Chips (dozen)
$21.94
Build Your Own Breezy
$9.35
Mini Monsters (dozen)
$21.94
Big Chips (4 Pack)
$19.74
Gelato (Pints and Quarts)
$15.38
Gelato (Cups)
$6.18
(Gelato) Milkshake
$8.25
6 Pack IC Sandwich
$12.65
(Ice Cream) Milkshake
$8.23
Quik Quarts
$10.98
Italian Ice (Cups)
$5.48
Full Menu
2:00 pm - 9:35 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Hard Ice Cream (Pint and Quart)
Slow churned, high butterfat ice cream. Winner of Best Ice Cream in Morris & Essex County.
$13.18•100% (23)
#1 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream (Cups)
Our classic homemade hard ice cream.
$5.77•95% (22)
#2 Most liked
Build Your Own Breezy
Layered Soft Serve with toppings in a shake cup.
$9.35
Soft Serve Cups
Soft Serve Ice Cream in a cup,
$5.77
Italian Ice (Cups)
$5.48
(Ice Cream) Milkshake
Classic Milkshakes made with ice cream.
$8.23
Gelato (Cups)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$6.18
Granita
A mix of Soft Serve Ice Cream and our homemade Italian ice.
$8.78
Gelato (Pints and Quarts)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$15.38•87% (8)
Big Chips (Single)
Two chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream in the middle, rolled in chocolate chips.
$5.50
Featured/New
Gelato Panini
An ice cream sandwich between two house-made brownies, cookies, or cakes.
$7.64
Build Your Own Breezy
Layered Soft Serve with toppings in a shake cup.
$9.35
Mini Dot Cakes (5 Pack)
Mini Ice Cream Cakes in a cup! Vanilla and Chocolate ice cream with fudge and crunchies.
$17.58
Dot Cake (8oz)
8oz
$8.78
Slice of Cheesecake
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake.
$6.58
Quik Quarts
Quarts packed directly from our batch freezer to preserve the highest quality, but at a great price! Cheaper than a pint!
$10.98
Pumpkini (Pumpkin Oreos)
One Dozen Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches made with pumpkin oreo ice cream.
$20.84
Cups, Pints & Quarts
Hard Ice Cream (Cups)
Our classic homemade hard ice cream.
$5.77•95% (22)
#2 Most liked
Hard Ice Cream (Pint and Quart)
Slow churned, high butterfat ice cream. Winner of Best Ice Cream in Morris & Essex County.
$13.18•100% (23)
#1 Most liked
Gelato (Cups)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$6.18
Gelato (Pints and Quarts)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$15.38•87% (8)
Italian Ice (Cups)
$5.48
Italian Ice (Pints and Quarts)
$9.88
Soft Serve Cups
Soft Serve Ice Cream in a cup,
$5.77
Granita
A mix of Soft Serve Ice Cream and our homemade Italian ice.
$8.78
Build Your Own Breezy
Layered Soft Serve with toppings in a shake cup.
$9.35
Empty Cones
Choice of cone on the side: sugar, wafer, waffle, rainbow sprinkle waffle, or chocolate crunchy waffle cone.
$0.55+•100% (8)
#3 Most liked
SF (Cups)
Our same recipe, but made with Splenda.
$5.88
Yogurt/Dole
Vanilla Yogurt, Dole Whip, or Twist!
$5.77
Sugar-Free (Cups)
Our Sugar-Free Products are made with the same exact recipe as our regular products, just using Splenda as a sugar alternative.
$6.18
Sugar-Free (Pints and Quarts)
2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
$14.85
Quik Quarts
Quarts packed directly from our batch freezer to preserve the highest quality, but at a great price! Cheaper than a pint!
$10.98
Shakes and Drinks
(Ice Cream) Milkshake
Classic Milkshakes made with ice cream.
$8.23
(Gelato) Milkshake
Milkshake made with Gelato.
$8.25
Soda Float (one size)
Ice cream float with your choice of soft serve: Twist, Vanilla, or Chocolate.
$7.68
Can of Sode
Soda: Choice of water bottle or Pepsi.
$1.10
Bottle of Water
16.9oz bottle of water
$1.65
Novelties and Sandwiches
Mini Cones (dozen)
A package of 12 mini Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry Cones dipped in White, Dark, and Ruby Chocolate.
$23.04
Mini Chips (dozen)
One Dozen Mini Chip sandwiches featuring our nut free house baked chocolate chips.
$21.94
Mini Monsters (dozen)
A package of one dozen mini sandwiches made with cookie monster ice cream.
$21.94
Mini Oreos (one dozen)
One Dozen Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches.
$19.74
6 Pack IC Sandwich
6 pack of ice cream sandwiches made with soft serve ice cream.
$12.65
Gluten Free Mini Oreos
Pack of 12 Gluten Free Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches. Made with gluten free oreos and Vanilla Ice Cream
$23.04
Ice Cream Sandwich (Single)
Creamy vanilla ice cream layered between two soft, chocolate cookies.
$3.28
Big Chips (4 Pack)
(4 PACK) Two chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream in the middle, rolled in chocolate chips.
$19.74
Big Chips (Single)
Two chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream in the middle, rolled in chocolate chips.
$5.50
Slice of Cheesecake
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake.
$6.58
Gelato Panini
An ice cream sandwich between two house-made brownies, cookies, or cakes.
$7.64
Quik Quarts
Quarts packed directly from our batch freezer to preserve the highest quality, but at a great price! Cheaper than a pint!
$10.98
Pumpkini (Pumpkin Oreos)
One Dozen Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches made with pumpkin oreo ice cream.
$20.84
Ice Cream Cakes
Stock Cakes (Same Day)
Nut Free - Vanilla & Chocolate with Fudge and Crunchies, decorated the way you would like! (flavors cannot be changed)
$32.94
Oreo Cake (Same Day)
These cakes come in Oreo but are just one flavor with no middle filling, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.
$43.94
Strawberry Shortcake (Same Day)
4 layers. ice cream, preserves, pound-cake, and vanilla ice cream. 8" cake serves 12-14.
$43.94
Cookie Monster Cake (Same Day)
These cakes come in Cookie Monster and are just one flavor with no middle filling, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.
$43.94
Baci Cake (Same Day)
These cakes come in Hazelnut and Chocolate Hazelnut with almonds and chocolate chunks, with Fudge and Cookie Crunch in the middle. Decorated with a chocolate whipped cream. 8" cake serves 12-14.
$43.94
Espresso & Tiramisu Cake (Same Day)
Tiramisu and Espresso Chip Gelato cake with coffee soaked Ladyfingers in the middle. (8" cake serves 12-14)
$43.94
Ice Cream Pies
Mint Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of fudge, layer of ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, Oreos, and chocolate drizzle. Available in Vanilla or Mint.
$27.44
Death by Peanut Butter Pie
Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of peanut butter, layer of choc. peanut butter ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, peanut butter cups, peanut butter, and chocolate drizzle.
$27.44
Coffee Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
Coffee Oreo Ice Cream, house-made brownie bottom, ltopped with fresh chocolate whip cream, Oreos, espresso pillows, and chocolate drizzle.
$27.44
Cookie Monster Brownie Pie
Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of fudge, layer of ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, Cookie Dough, Oreos, and chocolate drizzle.
$27.44
Homemade Cheesecakes
Slice of Cheesecake
A Slice of our homemade cheesecake.
$6.58
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash