Coterie Pizza Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Coterie Pizza
Sign In / Sign Up
Coterie Pizza
1850 S Randolph St, Garrett, IN 46738, USA17 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
Hot Honey
$15.54
#1 Most liked
12" pizza
$14.39
Cheese Pizza
$13.19
Margherita
$14.39
Chicken Bacon
$15.54
#3 Most liked
Cheese Bread
$9.59
Brisket
$17.94
#2 Most liked
Beer Cheese
$8.39
Classic Penne
$8.39
Beer Cheese & Bacon
$10.79
Gluten Free
$16.79
Mushroom Medley
$15.54
Spinach Artichoke
$15.54
Italian Sandwich
$13.19
Italian Chop Salad
$8.39
Chicken Bruschetta
$15.54
Cajun
$15.54
Full Greek Goddess
$11.03
Gluten Free Hot Honey
$17.94
Full House
$11.03
Sausage Sandwich
$13.19
Half House
$6.49
Coterie Caesar
$8.39
Caprese Salad
$7.19
Half Greek Goddess
$6.49
Full Menu
11:00 am - 8:35 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
12" pizza
#1 Most liked
A 12" pizza topped with pepperoni and sausage, featuring a golden-brown crust and a generous layer of melted cheese.
$14.39•96% (75)
Beer Cheese
#2 Most liked
Fresh Baked Bread with Garlic Butter Accompanied with Creamy Beer Cheese Dip
$8.39•91% (46)
Cheese Bread
#3 Most liked
Fresh Baked Bread with Garlic Butter and Cheese with Marinara Dipping Sauce
$9.59•92% (27)
Hot Honey
Ricotta Cheese, Pepperoni, Honey Drizzle, Crushed Red Pepper Flakes
$15.54•94% (17)
Cheese Pizza
A classic pizza topped with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a crisp, golden-brown crust.
$13.19•100% (15)
Chicken Bacon
Roasted Chicken, Cherry Smoked Bacon
Choice of Sauce: Ranch, BBQ, Hot Sauce, Cajun Heat
$15.54•100% (11)
Margherita
Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Olive Oil Drizzle
$14.39•100% (7)
Brisket
Burnt Ends, Mushrooms, Shallots, House Made BBQ Sauce
$17.94•88% (9)
Italian Sandwich
Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese & Side of Italian Dressing
$13.19•92% (13)
Mushroom Medley
A medley of mushrooms, likely including varieties such as crimini, oyster, and shiitake, combined with a blend of cheeses and aromatic herbs, presented on a pizza crust.
$15.54•100% (10)
Cheese Pizza
Cheese Pizza
A classic pizza topped with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a crisp, golden-brown crust.
$13.19•100% (15)
Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
This gluten-free cheese pizza features a gluten-free crust, typically topped with a rich tomato sauce and a generous blend of cheeses.
$15.59
Create Your Own Pizza
12" pizza
#1 Most liked
A 12" pizza topped with pepperoni and sausage, featuring a golden-brown crust and a generous layer of melted cheese.
$14.39•96% (75)
Gluten Free
A gluten-free crust pizza that allows for customization with a variety of toppings.
$16.79
Stone Baked Sandwiches
Italian Sandwich
Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese & Side of Italian Dressing
$13.19•92% (13)
Ham and Cheese Sandwich
Served With a Side of Brown Deli Mustard
$11.99•90% (11)
Veggie Sandwich
Ricotta Cheese, Spinach, Artichokes, Tomatoes & Mozzarella Cheese
$11.99
Sausage Sandwich
House Beef Sausage, Marinara Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese
$13.19
Sauces & Dressings
3oz BBQ
A 3oz serving of BBQ sauce, typically consisting of a rich blend of tomatoes, vinegar, sweeteners, and spices, offering a smoky and tangy flavor profile.
$0.90
3oz Beer Cheese
A 3oz serving of beer cheese, typically a creamy blend incorporating beer and cheese, often used as a dip or sauce.
$0.90•100% (12)
3oz Caesar
A 3oz serving of Caesar dressing, typically includes a blend of parmesan cheese, garlic, and anchovies.
$0.90
3oz Deli Mustard
A 3oz serving of deli mustard, typically featuring a tangy and slightly spicy flavor profile.
$0.90
3oz Hot Honey
Slices of spicy sausage atop melted cheese and tangy tomato sauce on a crispy pizza crust.
$0.90
3oz Hot Sauce
A 3oz serving of hot sauce, typically made with a blend of spicy peppers and vinegar for a robust kick.
$0.90
3oz Italian
A 3oz serving of Italian dressing, typically made with a blend of olive oil, vinegar, herbs, and spices.
$0.90
3oz Marinara
A 3oz serving of marinara sauce, typically made with a blend of ripe tomatoes, fresh herbs, and a hint of garlic, suitable for dipping.
$0.90
3oz Mayo
A 3oz serving of our classic mayo, simple and versatile for a variety of dishes.
$0.90
3oz Ranch
A 3oz serving of ranch, typically a creamy blend of buttermilk, herbs, and spices, ideal for dipping or as a dressing.
$0.90•100% (22)
6oz Beer Cheese
A 6oz serving of beer cheese, typically crafted with a blend of cheese and beer, offering a rich and creamy texture suitable for dipping.
$1.80•100% (18)
6oz Marinara
A 6oz serving of our house-made marinara sauce, crafted with a blend of ripe tomatoes, garlic, and Italian herbs, ideal for dipping.
$1.80
Creations
Brisket
Burnt Ends, Mushrooms, Shallots, House Made BBQ Sauce
$17.94•88% (9)
Cajun
Roasted Chicken, House Beef Sausage, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Cajun Heat Drizzle
$15.54
Chicken Bacon
Roasted Chicken, Cherry Smoked Bacon
Choice of Sauce: Ranch, BBQ, Hot Sauce, Cajun Heat
$15.54•100% (11)
Chicken Bruschetta
Fresh Tomato Sauce, Chicken, Shallots, Cherry Tomatoes, Mozzarella Cheese, Basil, Olive Oil, & Balsamic Vinegar
$15.54
Hot Honey
Ricotta Cheese, Pepperoni, Honey Drizzle, Crushed Red Pepper Flakes
$15.54•94% (17)
Margherita
Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Olive Oil Drizzle
$14.39•100% (7)
Mushroom Medley
A medley of mushrooms, likely including varieties such as crimini, oyster, and shiitake, combined with a blend of cheeses and aromatic herbs, presented on a pizza crust.
$15.54•100% (10)
Spinach Artichoke
Spinach, Artichoke, Ricotta Cheese
$15.54
Gluten Free Brisket
Burnt Ends, Mushrooms, Shallots, House Made BBQ Sauce
$20.34
Gluten Free Cajun
Roasted Chicken, House Beef Sausage, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Cajun Heat Drizzle
$17.94
Gluten Free Chicken Bacon
Roasted Chicken, Cherry Smoked Bacon
Choice of Sauce: Ranch, BBQ, Hot Sauce, Cajun Heat
$17.94
Gluten Free Chicken Bruschetta
Fresh Tomato Sauce, Chicken, Shallots, Cherry Tomatoes, Mozzarella Cheese, Basil, Olive Oil, & Balsamic Vinegar
$17.94
Gluten Free Hot Honey
Ricotta Cheese, Pepperoni, Honey Drizzle, Crushed Red Pepper Flakes
$17.94
Gluten Free Margherita
Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Olive Oil Drizzle
$16.79
Gluten Free Mushroom Medley
A blend of mushrooms atop a gluten-free crust, typically includes a variety of mushrooms seasoned with herbs.
$17.94
Gluten Free Spinach Artichoke
Spinach, Artichoke, Ricotta Cheese
$17.94
Pasta
Beer Cheese & Bacon
Pasta coated in a homemade beer cheese sauce, typically includes pieces of bacon for added flavor.
$10.79•100% (9)
Classic Penne
Penne pasta served with a traditional tomato sauce, often seasoned with herbs and spices.
$8.39
Rustic Penne
Penne pasta tossed with a selection of rustic ingredients, which typically includes a hearty blend of vegetables and herbs, mixed in a traditional sauce.
$10.79
Salads
Half House
Green salad mix with choice of ranch, Caesar, or Italian dressing.
$6.49
Half Greek Goddess
A blend of romaine and iceberg lettuce, complemented by feta cheese, olives, and a variety of vegetables, typically dressed with a Greek-inspired vinaigrette.
$6.49
Full Greek Goddess
A mix of fresh greens, kalamata olives, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, and feta cheese, typically dressed with a housemade Greek vinaigrette.
$11.03
Full House
Mixed greens topped with choice of ranch, Caesar, or Italian dressing
$11.03
Coterie Caesar
Chopped Kale, Parmesan Crisp, Sliced Tomato, Bacon
$8.39
Italian Chop Salad
Mixed Greens, Salami, Pepperoni, Banana Peppers, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Italian Dressing
$8.39
Caprese Salad
Fresh Mozzarella, Cherry Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar Drizzle
$7.19
Appetizers
Beer Cheese
#2 Most liked
Fresh Baked Bread with Garlic Butter Accompanied with Creamy Beer Cheese Dip
$8.39•91% (46)
Cheese Bread
#3 Most liked
Fresh Baked Bread with Garlic Butter and Cheese with Marinara Dipping Sauce
$9.59•92% (27)
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash