Pete's Sweet Treats Handcrafted Artisan Ice Cream & Italian Ice Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Pete's Sweet Treats Handcrafted Artisan Ice Cream & Italian Ice
Sign In / Sign Up

Pete's Sweet Treats

6616 Superior Avenue, Sarasota, FL
Loading
Online ordering hours: 3:00 PM - 9:40 PM
Opens 3:00 PM
Order for later

Featured Items

Hot Fudge Sundae
$11.44
Peanut Butter Sundae
$11.44
Brownie Sundae
$11.44
Lavender-Honey Pint
$11.44
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
$11.44
Pistachio - Pint
$11.44
Chocolate - Cup
$7.64
Chocolate Overload Cake
$7.99
Pistachio Ricotta Cake - Slice
$7.99
Grape Italian Ice - Cup
$6.03
Lemon Italian Ice - Cup
$6.03
Full Menu
3:00 pm - 9:40 pm

Most Ordered

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Brownie Sundae

A warm, house-baked brownie topped with a generous scoop of hand-crafted Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a classic cherry.
$11.44

S'mores Sundae

Two scoops chocolate ice cream layered with buttery graham cracker crumbles and velvety marshmallow cream. Perfectly sized for a classic, natural treat.
$11.44

Peanut Butter Sundae

Vanilla ice cream with Peanut Butter sauce whipped cream butterfinger & reeses pieces
$11.44

Hot Fudge Sundae

Two scoops of vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry!
$11.44

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae

Pound Cake topped with hefty scoops of vanilla ice cream, strawberry sauce, whipped cream strawberry shortcake - a slice of pound cake with a heaping scoop of vanilla ice cream , Strawberry topped with whipped cream
$11.44

Pistachio - Cup

Pistachio-flavored ice cream typically includes real pistachio pieces, served in a cup.
$7.64

Chocolate - Cup

Creamy chocolate ice cream in a cup, typically made with high-quality cocoa, milk, cream, sugar, and vanilla.
$7.64

Vanilla Bean - Cup

Made with real vanilla beans, this creamy ice cream in a cup typically includes flecks of natural vanilla beans throughout.
$7.64

Pistachio Ricotta Cake - Slice

Pistachio and ricotta creams separated by sponge cake, decorated with crushed pistachios and dusted with powdered sugar.
$7.99

Chocolate Chip Brownie Homemade

Extra fudgy, ultra-rich brownie packed with milk chocolate chips. Baked to perfection and bound to make you say, “Mmm.”
$6.84

Ice Cream

Vanilla Bean - Cup

Made with real vanilla beans, this creamy ice cream in a cup typically includes flecks of natural vanilla beans throughout.
$7.64

Hot Fudge Sundae

Two scoops of vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry!
$11.44

Dirty Pale - Sundae

Layers of chocolate cookie pieces, Chocolate Ice Cream topped with gummy worms
$11.44

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae

Pound Cake topped with hefty scoops of vanilla ice cream, strawberry sauce, whipped cream strawberry shortcake - a slice of pound cake with a heaping scoop of vanilla ice cream , Strawberry topped with whipped cream
$11.44

Brownie Sundae

A warm, house-baked brownie topped with a generous scoop of hand-crafted Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a classic cherry.
$11.44

Black & White Sundae

Rich chocolate ice cream topped with sweet marshmallow topping, paired with vanilla ice cream and hot fudge sauce, finished with whipped cream and a cherry.
$11.44

S'mores Sundae

Two scoops chocolate ice cream layered with buttery graham cracker crumbles and velvety marshmallow cream. Perfectly sized for a classic, natural treat.
$11.44

Peanut Butter Sundae

Vanilla ice cream with Peanut Butter sauce whipped cream butterfinger & reeses pieces
$11.44

Apple Crisp Sundae

Vanilla ice cream loaded with cinnamon-sweet baked apples and crunchy streusel topping.
$11.44

Chocolate - Cup

Creamy chocolate ice cream in a cup, typically made with high-quality cocoa, milk, cream, sugar, and vanilla.
$7.64

Pistachio - Cup

Pistachio-flavored ice cream typically includes real pistachio pieces, served in a cup.
$7.64

Mint Chip - Cup

Mint Ice Cream Chocolate Chips
$7.64

Apple Pie - Cup

Vanilla ice cream layered with apple pie filling, cinnamon, caramel sauce, and graham cracker crumbs in a cup.
$7.64

Pumpkin Spice - Cup

Creamy pumpkin spice ice cream with warm notes of cinnamon and nutmeg, blended into a smooth, rich treat.
$7.64

Cookie Dough - Quart

Vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough, creating a classic dessert combination.
$22.94

Oreo Cookie - Cup

Vanilla ice cream blended with crushed Oreo cookies, served in a cup for a classic cookies and cream experience.
$7.64

Salted Caramel - Cup

Caramel ice cream with a salted caramel ripple and pieces of salted caramel in a cup.
$7.64

Cookie Butter Sundae

Our creamy vanilla ice cream with rich, irresistible Biscoff sauce, loaded with crunchy cookie pieces, and finished with a fluffy cloud of whipped cream. Sweet, creamy, crunchy, and absolutely heavenly! ✨
$11.44

Macadamia Raspberry Swirl - Cup

$7.64

Italian Ice

Lemon Italian Ice - Cup

Lemon Italian ice made with fresh lemon juice and water, typically sweetened with cane sugar.
$6.03

Gelati

A delightful combination of Italian ice and creamy soft serve, typically featuring flavors like lemon, cherry, or blue raspberry.
$7.18

Cotton Candy Italian Ice - Cup

Cotton candy flavored Italian ice, typically featuring vibrant pink and blue hues, served in a cup.
$6.03

Swedish Fish Italian ice - Cup

Smooth and tangy Italian ice infused with the nostalgic flavor of Swedish Fish candy.
$6.03

Chocolate Italian Ice - Cup

Chocolate Italian ice typically includes a smooth, chocolate-flavored ice base, offering a refreshing and subtly sweet taste in a cup.
$6.03

Grape Italian Ice - Cup

Grape Italian Ice - Cup: Italian ice typically made from fresh grapes.
$6.03

Salted Caramel Italian Ice - Cup

$6.03

strawberry Italian Ice - Cup

Made with Real Strawberries
$6.03

Blue Vanilla Italian Ice - Cup

$6.03

Cherry Italian Ice - Cup

Smooth and refreshing Italian ice typically made with sweet cherries.
$6.03

Mango Italian Ice - Cup

Smooth mango Italian ice made from fresh mango, water, and sugar, offering a refreshing and fruity dessert experience.
$6.03

Beverages

Pepsi Can

Carbonated wild berry beverage featuring a blend of essential energy-boosting ingredients. Contains zero sugar.
$2.01

Dr Pepper Can

A refreshing 12-ounce can of Dr. Pepper, featuring a unique blend of 23 flavors.
$2.01

A&W Root beer - Can

A classic soda with the signature sweet and smooth taste of aged vanilla.
$2.01

Cream Soda - Can

Cream soda in a can.
$2.01

Gatorade Glacier Freeze

Typically includes electrolytes to help rehydrate and replenish lost fluids.
$3.16

Gatorade - Glacier Cherry

Energizing beverage with a crisp, cherry flavor.
$3.39

Cakes

Limoncello Cake - Slice

Layers of moist sponge cake infused with limoncello, filled with creamy lemon-flavored frosting, and garnished with white chocolate shavings and lemon wedges.
$7.99

Chocolate Chip Brownie Homemade

Extra fudgy, ultra-rich brownie packed with milk chocolate chips. Baked to perfection and bound to make you say, “Mmm.”
$6.84

Pistachio Ricotta Cake - Slice

Pistachio and ricotta creams separated by sponge cake, decorated with crushed pistachios and dusted with powdered sugar.
$7.99

dulce de leche cake

Two layers of rich Dulce de L eche Mousse on soft, stweer vanilta cake, topped with tri-colored chocolate ribbons
$7.99

Chocolate Overload Cake

A CHOCOLATE LOVER'S DREAM Alternating layers of chocolate cake and chocolate mousse are topped with dark chocolate ganache and finished with a generous sprinkling of chocolate shavings
$7.99

Tiramisu - Tub

Layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream, dusted with cocoa powder.
$12.59

Ice Cream Pints

Vanilla Bean - Pint

Vanilla bean ice cream, typically featuring real vanilla bean seeds and pure vanilla extract, providing a rich and classic flavor.
$11.44

Black Raspberry Chip - Pint

Black Raspberry Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips
$11.44

Lavender-Honey Pint

Lavender-infused ice cream with local honey for a floral and sweet treat. Contains milk.
$11.44

Butter Pecan - Pint

Buttery ice cream with roasted pecans, offering a classic nutty and creamy flavor in each pint.
$11.44

Pistachio - Pint

Pistachio ice cream made with real pistachio pieces and a creamy base. Typically includes tree nuts and milk.
$11.44

Cookie Butter - Pint

Speculoos cookie butter ice cream with a cinnamon sugar, gingerbread-like taste.
$11.44

Salted Caramel - Pint

Caramel ice cream with a touch of sea salt for a balanced sweet and savory flavor.
$11.44

Pumpkin Spice - Pint

Creamy ice cream infused with pumpkin spice, capturing the essence of fall flavors in a pint-sized treat.
$11.44

Italian Ice Pints

Lemon Italian Ice - Pint

Lemon Italian ice typically includes a smooth, refreshing blend of tart lemon flavors.
$10.06

Cotton Candy Italian Ice - Pint

Cotton candy Italian ice typically includes a sweet and nostalgic flavor reminiscent of carnival treats, crafted into a smooth and refreshing Italian ice pint.
$10.06

Watermelon Italian Ice - Pint

Watermelon Italian ice typically includes fresh watermelon purée, providing a refreshing and fruity treat.
$10.06

Swedish Fish Italian ice - Pint

Swedish Fish Italian Ice Pint: Smooth and tangy Italian ice flavored with the sweet, fruity taste of Swedish Fish candy.
$10.06

Blueberry Italian Ice - Cup

Made with Real Blueberries
$6.03

Grape Italian Ice - Pint

Typically includes fresh grape flavor in a smooth, refreshing Italian ice.
$10.06

Italian Ice Quart

Lemon Italian Ice Quart

Smooth and tangy lemon dessert, typically includes a refreshing blend of lemon juice and sugar.
$17.82

Swedish Fish Italian Ice - Quart

Hand packed quart of Italian ice, typically featuring the sweet, chewy flavor of Swedish Fish candy.
$17.82

Watermelon Italian Ice Quart

Smooth and refreshing Italian ice typically made from fresh watermelon.
$17.82

Grape Italian Ice - Quart

Grape Italian ice typically includes grape flavor blended into a smooth, refreshing Italian ice.
$17.82

Ice Cream Sandwich

Ice Cream Nuggets

Ice cream covered in your favorite  cereal with your choice of dipping sauce ( Hot Fudge Or Caramel Sauce)
$10.29

Ice Cream Sandwich

Chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream.
$6.03

Appeal

Orioles Mini Helmet -

Ice cream served in a mini Orioles helmet, typically includes toppings like whipped cream, nuts, and chocolate syrup.
$6.03

Pirates MLB Mini Helmet -

Pirates MLB Mini Helmet: A collectible mini baseball helmet typically filled with a dessert treat, inspired by the Pittsburgh Pirates.
$6.03

Tampa Bay MLB Mini Helmet -

Ice cream served in a Tampa Bay MLB mini helmet, typically includes various toppings like sprinkles, nuts, and syrups.
$6.03

Ice Cream Koozie

Ice Cream Koozie
$13.74

Pete's Sweet Treats Tee Shirt (1)

Pete's Sweet Treats Tee Shirt
$22.98

Pete's Sweet Treats Tee Shirt (2)

Pete's Sweet Treats Tee Shirt
$22.98

Pete's Sweet Treats Tee Shirt (3)

Pete's Sweet Treats Tee Shirt
$22.98

Toppings & Sauces TOGO

Waffle Cone - Homemade

Crispy homemade waffle cone with a light, golden texture and classic grid pattern.
$1.72

Sugar Cone

A crisp sugar cone, ideal for holding your favorite ice cream or dessert toppings.
$1.43

Cake Cone

A single cake cone, typically served alongside ice cream, made from a light and airy batter.
$1.43

Broken Waffle Cone

A waffle cone broken into pieces, typically enjoyed as a crunchy topping for desserts. Contains gluten.
$0.86

Reese's Pieces (TOGO)

Reese's pieces typically feature a crunchy candy shell filled with creamy peanut butter, often used as a topping or mix-in for desserts.
$1.09

Heath Bar (TOGO)

Heath bar topping typically features finely chopped pieces of toffee and milk chocolate, adding a crunchy texture to your dessert.
$1.09

Chocolate Jimmy's (TOGO)

Chocolate jimmy's are typically small chocolate sprinkles, ideal for adding a sweet touch to desserts or ice cream.
$1.09

Graham Cracker (TOGO)

Crushed graham crackers, often used as a topping, provide a sweet and slightly crunchy texture to enhance your dessert experience.
$1.09

Rainbow Sprinkles (TOGO)

Rainbow jimmy's typically feature vibrant, multi-colored sugar sprinkles, ideal for adding a festive touch to your dessert.
$1.09

Skittles (TOGO)

Colorful, chewy candies that typically include a mix of fruity flavors, ideal for adding a sweet and vibrant touch to your dessert.
$1.09

Butterfinger Pieces (TOGO)

Butterfinger pieces typically feature a flaky peanut butter center coated in milk chocolate, offering a crispy and crunchy texture.
$1.09

Chocolate Chips (TOGO)

Chocolate pieces typically include small chunks of chocolate, ideal for adding a rich, sweet touch to your dessert.
$1.09

Toasted Coconut Flakes (TOGO)

Shredded coconut typically adds texture and a hint of sweetness, ideal for enhancing desserts or adding a tropical touch.
$1.09

Cookie Pieces (TOGO)

Crumbled cookie pieces typically used as a topping to add a sweet, crunchy texture to your dessert creations.
$1.09

KitKat Pieces (TOGO)

KitKat pieces: Crunchy chocolate-covered wafer bits, typically enjoyed as a topping for desserts.
$1.09

M&M's (TOGO)

Mini colorful chocolate candies, typically containing milk and soy ingredients, packaged separately for easy addition to your dessert.
$1.09

Chocolate Sauce (TOGO)

8 Oz Chocolate Sauce
$6.84

Hot Fudge (TOGO)

8 Oz Hot Fudge Sauce
$6.84

Marshmallow Sauce (TOGO)

8 Oz Marshmallow Sauce
$6.84

Peanut Butter Sauce (TOGO)

8 Oz Peanut Butter Sauce
$6.84

Gummyworms (TOGO)

Gummy worms typically feature a chewy texture and fruity flavor, often enjoyed as a standalone treat or as a topping for desserts.
$1.09

Caramel Sauce (TOGO)

8 Oz Caramel Sauce
$6.84

Oreo Pieces (TOGO)

Crushed Oreo cookie pieces, ideal for adding a crunchy texture and classic chocolatey flavor to your desserts.
$1.09

Ice Cream Quarts

Chocolate - Quart

Chocolate ice cream quart, typically crafted with rich cocoa and fresh cream for a classic, smooth dessert experience.
$22.94

Pistachio - Quart

Pistachio-flavored ice cream featuring real pistachio pieces, hand-packed in a quart for a creamy, nutty dessert experience.
$22.94

Vanilla - Quart

Vanilla ice cream quart, typically featuring real vanilla bean specks, hand-packed for a classic dessert experience.
$22.94
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
© 2026 DoorDash
Pete's Sweet Treats 6616 Superior Avenue – Order pickup and delivery