Yoder’s of Pinecraft (Bahia Vista St) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Yoder’s of Pinecraft (Bahia Vista St)
Sign In / Sign Up

Yoder’s of Pinecraft

3434 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota, FL
Loading
Online ordering hours: 11:00 AM - 7:40 PM
Unavailable

Featured Items

#1 Most liked
Homemade Pies - Cream Pies (Per Slice)
$9.75
#2 Most liked
Mom's Meatloaf
$20.50
1/3 Pound Fresh Ground Beef Burger
$11.95
8" Pie (serves 4-6)
$29.95
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato
$11.95
Cobb Salad
$21.50
Garlic Chicken Breast
$19.50
Homemade Soup of the Day
$7.50
Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
$4.75
Roast Beef
$19.25
Shrimp
$23.95
10" Pie (serves 6-8)
$33.95
Breaded or Grilled Chicken Salad
$21.50
Chicken Fingers
$22.95
Homemade Pies - Baked Pies (Per Slice)
$9.75
Meatloaf
$19.25
Mom's Homemade Chili
$7.50
Amish Noodles
$4.75
Cup of Chili and Half Chicken Salad Sandwich
$12.25
Fish & Chips
$23.95
Liver & Onions
$17.95
Roasted Turkey Breast & Stuffing
$23.95
Shrimp & Grits
$23.95
Southern Fried Chicken B.l.t
$19.25
Taco Salad
$17.95
Lunch Dinner
11:00 am - 7:40 pm

Whole Cream Pies

Whole Cream Pies

8" Pie (serves 4-6)

Rich cream pie featuring a smooth chocolate filling, topped with whipped cream, chocolate chips, and a sprinkle of cookie crumbs. Serves 4-6.
$29.95

10" Pie (serves 6-8)

A 10-inch cream pie topped with fresh strawberries and a layer of whipped cream, serving 6-8.
$33.95

Salads & More

Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Cobb Salad

Gluten free. Chopped turkey, egg, peas, bacon, cheese and tomatoes. Layered on a bed crisp lettuce. Served with homemade fruit bread. Our customers' favorite!
$21.50•12

Breaded or Grilled Chicken Salad

Your choice of breaded chicken tenders or grilled chicken breast, sliced on top of crisp lettuce with cucumber, cheese, tomato and egg. Served with homemade fruit bread.
$21.50

Taco Salad

Bed of crisp lettuce with onions, cheese and tomatoes. Served with mom's homemade chili over the top and tortilla chips.
$17.95•5

Onion Rings

Thick cut onion rings, battered and deep fried till golden crisp. Served with your choice of dipping sauce.
$9.95

Wavy Gravy

French Fries covered with beef gravy & melted cheddar.
$10.95

Soups & Chili

Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Homemade Soup of the Day

Monday- Potato with Ham Tuesday- Beef Vegetable Wednesday- Ham & Bean Thursday- Chicken Noodle Friday- Broccoli & Cheese Saturday- Cheeseburger
$7.50•14

Mom's Homemade Chili

Hearty blend of beans, tomatoes, and ground meat. Choose from cup or bowl.
$7.50•21

Cup of Chili and Half Chicken Salad Sandwich

Daily Soup Choices: Monday- Potato with Ham Tuesday- Beef Vegetable Wednesday- Ham & Bean Thursday- Chicken Noodle Friday- Broccoli & Cheese Saturday- Cheeseburger
$12.25

Beef & Pork

Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Mom's Meatloaf

Costumers Favorite. A country style favorite! Perfectly seasoned and smothered in our made-from-stock beef gravy.
$20.50•46
#2 Most liked

Liver & Onions

Grilled tender and topped with cooked onions.
$17.95•12

Smoked Ham

Gluten free. Sliced thick and grilled. Our Amish guests say it's the best!
$16.75•9

Country Fried Steak

Golden fried chopped beef steak, smothered in a rich pepper country gravy.
$19.50•29

Roast Beef

Well done and served Amish chunky style. Smothered in our made-from-stock beef gravy.
$23.95•19

Chicken & Turkey

Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Garlic Chicken Breast

Gluten free. 8 oz. skinless, boneless breast marinated in our special garlic recipe and sautéed. Plain breast also available.
$19.50•6

Chicken Fingers

Tender strips of chicken breaded and deep fried. Comes with BBQ sauce for dipping or your choice of dressing.
$22.95•10

Roasted Turkey Breast & Stuffing

Pulled roasted white meat turkey breast and homemade stuffing all smothered in gravy.
$23.95•40

Baked Chicken & Stuffing

Bone in chicken lightly dusted in our homemade seasoning, baked until juicy and delicious. Served with stuffing and your choice of two sides.
$21.50•20

Quarter Chicken (2 Pc.)

Costumer favorite.
$21.50•10

Half Chicken (4 Pc.)

Costumer favorite.
$25.50•42
#3 Most liked

Seafood

Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Shrimp

Your choice of breaded butterflied shrimp or grilled, or blackened shrimp. Served with cocktail sauce.
$23.95

Fish & Chips

Fish fried crispy and delicious, served with fries & slaw.
$23.95

Shrimp & Grits

Southern goodness. Grilled blackened shrimp served on homemade cheesy grits with one side.
$23.95

Build Your Own Burger

Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

1/3 Pound Fresh Ground Beef Burger

Costumer favorite. Top it with any of your favorites.
$11.95•9

Sandwiches

Served on your choice of bread or hamburger roll. Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato

Served traditionally with mayonnaise.
$11.95•7

Southern Fried Chicken B.l.t

Crispy fried chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, dijonnaise, fresh lettuce and tomato on a hoagie roll.
$19.25•14

Pot Roast Melt

Costumer favorite. Topped with sautéed onions and melted provolone on a sub roll. Served with au jus.
$19.25•7

Grilled Chicken Breast

Garlic seasoned or plain.
$16.95

BBQ Pork Sandwich

Slow-cooked pork in BBQ sauce, typically includes coleslaw, served on a soft bun.
$13.25

Chicken Salad

Chicken salad with celery, mayo, and lettuce. Offered on white, roll, croissant, or wheat bread.
$11.95

Fried Fish Sandwich

Breaded fried fish served on a bun with lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce.
$13.25

Grilled Cheese

Choose from American, swiss, cheddar or Colby.
$9.95

Manhattans

On homemade bread, served with real mashed potatoes and smothered in gravy. Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Roast Beef

Well done and served amish chunky style. smothered in our made-from-stock beef gravy.
$19.25•11

Meatloaf

Savory meatloaf with size options: small or regular.
$19.25

Turkey

Manhattan-style turkey available in small or regular sizes.
$19.25•9

Sides

Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Mashed Potatoes with Gravy

Gluten free.
$4.75•11

Amish Noodles

Amish noodles are a comforting side dish, typically made by tossing egg noodles in a buttery sauce, often enriched with chicken broth for added flavor.
$4.75•7

Chicken Stuffing

Bread cubes and fried chicken pieces combined with onions, celery, and herbs, typically bound together with eggs and chicken stock.
$4.75•9

Cheesy Grits

Creamy grits blended with a rich mix of melted cheese.
$4.75

Mac & Cheese

Creamy, classic macaroni in a rich, velvety cheese sauce.
$4.75•12

French Fries

Crispy golden strips of deliciousness served hot and seasoned to perfection.
$4.75

Corn Bread

Golden, fluffy cornbread, perfect as a side or for savoring on its own.
$4.75•34

Fried Okra

Crispy golden Okra bites, perfectly seasoned and fried to perfection.
$4.75•8

Bean Salad

Gluten free.
$4.75

Buttered Corn

Gluten free.
$4.75

Cole Slaw

Gluten free.
$4.75

Green Beans

Gluten free.
$4.75•15

Baked Hot Apples

Gluten free.
$4.75•7

Salad Salad

Gluten free.
$5.95•27

Vegetable Medley

Gluten free.
$4.75

Desserts

Our pies are baked fresh from scratch every morning. No meal at yoder's is ever complete without a piece of homemade pie. Consumer advisory - consuming raw or undercooked meat, eggs, poultry, or seafood increases your risk of contracting a food-borne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Homemade Pies - Cream Pies (Per Slice)

Slices of homemade cream pie with options including customer favorites like peanut butter, banana, and coconut cream. Also, offers chocolate, strawberry, butterscotch, and traditional Florida key lime in graham crust.
$9.75•68
#1 Most liked

Homemade Pies - Baked Pies (Per Slice)

Sliced homemade pies, options include apple, blueberry, cherry, and more. Features customer favorites like Dutch apple crumb and southern pecan. Sugar-free apple available.
$9.75•40

Gluten Free Pie of the Day

Gluten free.
$9.75

Homemade Cheesecake

A homemade cheesecake, typically featuring a smooth, creamy filling atop a crumbly graham cracker crust, often garnished with a fruit compote or drizzle.
$9.95

Yoder's Chocolate Cake

Costumer Favorites.
$9.50•15

Homemade Sweetroll

Freshly baked sweet dough, typically includes a sweet filling or topping such as cream cheese or fruit preserves.
$8.95

Hand-dipped Ice Cream

Sweet vanilla cream.
$5.95

Beverages

Fountain Drinks

Coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, raspberry tea, pink lemonade.
$4.25•17

House Brewed Iced Tea

House brewed iced tea, available in sweet, unsweet, or with a hint of mint.
$4.25•22

Orange Juice

Classic citrus refreshment.
$4.50

Grapefruit Juice

Tart and refreshing
$4.50

Milk

Milk served in choice of whole, lowfat, or chocolate; available in regular or large sizes.
$4.25

Local Fresh Roasted Coffee

Locally roasted coffee available in regular or decaf, with optional cream.
$3.95

Hot Tea-regular

Steeped from quality tea leaves, this beverage offers a comforting and simple taste.
$3.50
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
© 2026 DoorDash
Yoder’s of Pinecraft 3434 Bahia Vista Street – Order pickup and delivery