Peters Foods & Deli (5090 W COLLEGE AVE) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Peters Foods & Deli
5090 W College Ave, Greendale, WI 53129, USAOpens 11:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
3 pc Icelandic Cod , Comes with Rye bread, tarter sauce, lemon wedge and coleslaw.
$19.35
#2 Most liked
The Club 8 inch
$9.09
16”
$25.70
The Your Way 16 Inch
$16.89
The Your Way 8 Inch
$9.09
Fries
$5.20
All Day
11:00 am - 7:45 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
3 pc Icelandic Cod , Comes with Rye bread, tarter sauce, lemon wedge and coleslaw.
#1 Most liked
3 pc Icelandic Cod: Tender cod served with a selection of sides including French fries, potato pancakes with applesauce, potato salad.
$19.35•92% (13)
The Club 8 inch
#2 Most liked
Provolone cheese, Ham, Turkey, Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes, Oregano, and Mayo
$9.09•84% (13)
Fries
$5.20
The Your Way 8 Inch
Select 1 Meat And 1 Cheese for 6.99. Additional Meats are 1.99 and Additional Cheese is 1.00 Veggies and Sauces are at no cost
$9.09
16”
Thin Crust
$25.70
The Your Way 16 Inch
Select 1 Meat and 1 Cheese with Additional Toppings for 12.99 Additional Meat 1.99 and Additional Cheese 1.00
$16.89
4 Pcs. Dinner
#3 Most liked
Four pieces of fried chicken with a side choice of French fries, potato pancakes with applesauce, potato salad, or coleslaw.
$18.19•100% (7)
Grandmas Potato Salad
Inspired by traditional recipes, typically includes tender potatoes, a creamy dressing, and a mix of onions, celery, and herbs for a homestyle taste.
$9.10•75% (8)
The Italian 16 inch
Cappacolla, Bologna, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes,, Oreganoand Mayo.
$16.89•100% (6)
German potato Salad
Potato salad with a tangy dressing, typically includes bacon, onions, and a vinegar base, following a traditional German recipe.
$9.10
Ham or Beef
Availble hot on weekends only.
Hot Beef Sundays (includes 6 free rolls per pound )
Available after 7:00 Sunday. Includes 6 free rolls per pound - up to 2 pounds only
$18.19
Baked Ham Weekdays ( no free rolls)
Our same succulent Ham available cold weekdays
$13.54
Hot Ham Saturday - no free rolls
Our freshly baked Hot Ham
$9.49
Weekday Ham
Weekday ham typically includes deli ham, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on white bread.
$13.54
Weekday Beef
Roast beef, swiss cheese, arugula, red onions, and horseradish mayo on sourdough.
$13.99
Bakery
Freshly Made Rolls
Chocolate Chip Cookies
In house baked large chocolate cookies.
$1.65
Pizza
12”
Thin Crust
$22.10
14”
Thin Crust
$24.65
16”
Thin Crust
$25.70
12" Peters Special
Includes: sausage, pepperoni, onion, green peppers, black olives, and mushroom. Please write in notes if you would like to add or exclude any of the toppings.
$33.25
14" Peters Special
Includes: sausage, pepperoni, onion, green peppers, black olives, and mushroom. Please write in notes if you would like to add or exclude any of the toppings.
$34.55
16" Peters Special
Includes: sausage, pepperoni, onion, green peppers, black olives, and mushroom. Please write in notes if you would like to add or exclude any of the toppings.
$37.08
Fish Fry (available Friday)
3 pc Icelandic Cod , Comes with Rye bread, tarter sauce, lemon wedge and coleslaw.
#1 Most liked
3 pc Icelandic Cod: Tender cod served with a selection of sides including French fries, potato pancakes with applesauce, potato salad.
$19.35•92% (13)
6 pc Bucket Cod, rye bread, tarter sauce, coleslaw and lemon wedge. Choice of potato.
6 pc bucket: A generous serving of fried fish. Comes with rye bread, sauces including tartar and cocktail, or lemon. And potato selection
$35.65
9 pc Bucket
Crispy fried fish served with a choice of two sides: various potato options, coleslaw, rye bread, sauces including tartar and cocktail, lemon.
$51.55
6 pc Faintail Shrimp Dinner
6 pc fantail shrimp, crispy and golden. Choose two sides: assorted potatoes, coleslaw, rye bread, sauces including tartar and cocktail, lemon wedge.
$22.05
Icelandic Baked Cod
Icelandic cod, baked. Choice of side: fries, potato pancakes w/ applesauce, salad, coleslaw, rye bread, tartar/cocktail sauce, lemon.
$23.35
Sides
Garlic Bread
2 pieces.
$4.90
Garlic Cheese Bread
2 pieces.
$6.20
Fries
$5.20
Potato Pancake
2 pc
$3.00
Freshly made chocolate chip cookies
Freshly made chocolate chip cookies, often featuring a blend of melted chocolate chips within a golden-brown, tender dough.
$1.25
Grandmas Potato Salad
Inspired by traditional recipes, typically includes tender potatoes, a creamy dressing, and a mix of onions, celery, and herbs for a homestyle taste.
$9.10•75% (8)
German potato Salad
Potato salad with a tangy dressing, typically includes bacon, onions, and a vinegar base, following a traditional German recipe.
$9.10
Coleslaw
Crisp shredded cabbage in a creamy, tangy dressing.
$9.10
Cucumber salad
Crisp cucumber slices tossed in a light, refreshing vinaigrette.
$9.10
Italian Pasta Salad
Spiral pasta mixed with cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, and Italian cheeses, dressed with Italian dressing.
$12.99
Everyday Chicken Dinner
Choose a side: French fries, potato pancakes with applesauce, potato salad, or coleslaw.
4 Pcs. Dinner
#3 Most liked
Four pieces of fried chicken with a side choice of French fries, potato pancakes with applesauce, potato salad, or coleslaw.
$18.19•100% (7)
8 Pcs. Bucket Dinner
8 pcs. fried chicken served with choice of side: French fries, potato pancakes and applesauce, potato salad, or coleslaw.
$35.05
12 Pcs. Bucket Dinner
12 pcs. bucket of fried chicken. Choose one side: french fries, potato pancakes with applesauce, potato salad, or coleslaw.
$51.95
Submarine Sandwiches
Choose one of our featured sub sandwiches
The Club 8 inch
#2 Most liked
Provolone cheese, Ham, Turkey, Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes, Oregano, and Mayo
$9.09•84% (13)
The Italian 8 inch
Cappacolla, Bologna, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes,, Oregano and Mayo.
$9.09
The Club 16 inch
Provolone cheese, Ham, Turkey, Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes, Oregano, and Mayo
$16.89
The Italian 16 inch
Cappacolla, Bologna, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes,, Oreganoand Mayo.
$16.89•100% (6)
Meatball and Provolone - Hot 8 inch
Hot meatballs with marinara sauce and melted provolone
$9.09
Meatballs and Provolone -Hot 16 inch
Hot meatball with Marinara Sauce Smotheres with melted Provolonr
$16.89
The Your Way 8 Inch
Select 1 Meat And 1 Cheese for 6.99. Additional Meats are 1.99 and Additional Cheese is 1.00 Veggies and Sauces are at no cost
$9.09
The Your Way 16 Inch
Select 1 Meat and 1 Cheese with Additional Toppings for 12.99 Additional Meat 1.99 and Additional Cheese 1.00
$16.89
The Tuna 8 inch
A blend of tuna and mayonnaise with lettuce, onions, tomatoes and oragano
$9.09
The Tuna 16 inch
A blend of Tuna and Mayonnaise with lettuce, onions, tomatoes and oregano
$16.89
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash