Bagel Fair (E 86th St) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Bagel Fair (E 86th St)
Sign In / Sign Up
Bagel Fair
1300 East 86th Street, Indianapolis, IN
Online ordering hours: 7:00 AM - 1:45 PMOpens 7:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
Egg & Cheese
$4.99
#3 Most liked
Plain Cream Cheese Spread
$3.99
Turkey Sandwich
$7.49
8oz Container of Scallion Cream Cheese
$6.00
8oz Container of Strawberry Cream Cheese
$6.00
Pastrami Sandwich
$8.49
Scallion Cream Cheese Spread
$4.59
8oz Container of Brown Sugar Cinnamon Cream Cheese
$6.00
Ham Sandwich
$7.49
8oz Container of Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese
$6.00
8oz Container of Lox Cream Cheese
$7.00
8oz Container of Vegetable Cream Cheese
$6.00
B.L.T.
$6.49
Strawberry Cream Cheese Spread
$4.59
Salami Sandwich
$6.49
Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese Spread
$4.59
Corned Beef Sandwich
$8.49
Low Fat Cream Cheese Spread
$3.99
Full Menu
7:00 am - 1:45 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Egg & Cheese
Your choice of bagel with a slice of deli cheese and and fried egg patty. Add meat or cream cheese for an additional charge.
$4.99•98% (138)
#1 Most liked
Plain Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese on your choice of bagel.
$3.99•96% (64)
#3 Most liked
8oz Container of Scallion Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of cream cheese with green onion, garlic and carrots mixed in.
$6.00•100% (20)
Scallion Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese with green onions, garlic, and carrots mixed into it on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (32)
Turkey Sandwich
$7.49•100% (14)
8oz Container of Brown Sugar Cinnamon Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of cream cheese mixed with cinnamon and brown sugar.
$6.00•100% (24)
Strawberry Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese mixed with strawberry jam on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (18)
Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese with jalapeños and Cheddar cheese mixed into it on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (21)
8oz Container of Plain Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of plain cream cheese.
$5.00•98% (50)
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese mixed with cinnamon and brown sugar on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (20)
Bagels
Plain, sesame, poppy, everything, bialy, onion, garlic, salt, blueberry, cinnamon raisin, apple cinnamon cranberry, multi grain, pumpernickel or jalapeño cayenne.
Plain Bagel
$1.75•100% (49)
Everything Bagel
$1.75•97% (67)
#2 Most liked
Sesame Seed Bagel
$1.75•100% (29)
Poppy Seed Bagel
$1.75•100% (8)
Apple Cinnamon Cranberry Bagel
$1.75•77% (9)
Blueberry Bagel
$1.75•97% (48)
Onion Bagel
$1.75•96% (33)
Garlic Bagel
$1.75•100% (8)
Salt Bagel
$1.75•100% (30)
Bialy Bagel
A bagel with poppy seeds and onions baked into the dough.
$1.75•100% (24)
Jalapeño Cayenne Bagel
$1.75•100% (12)
Multi-Grain Bagel
$1.75•100% (10)
Pumpernickel Bagel
$1.75•93% (16)
Cream Cheese
8oz. Containers of cream cheese spread.
8oz Container of Plain Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of plain cream cheese.
$5.00•98% (50)
8oz Container of Vegetable Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of cream cheese with fresh celery, radishes, and green peppers mixed in.
$6.00•100% (13)
8oz Container of Scallion Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of cream cheese with green onion, garlic and carrots mixed in.
$6.00•100% (20)
8oz Container of Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of cream cheese with Cheddar cheese and jalapeños mixed in.
$6.00•85% (14)
8oz Container of Strawberry Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of cream cheese mixed with strawberry jam.
$6.00•88% (9)
8oz Container of Brown Sugar Cinnamon Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of cream cheese mixed with cinnamon and brown sugar.
$6.00•100% (24)
8oz Container of Lox Cream Cheese
An 8 oz container of cream cheese mixed smoked salmon.
$7.00•100% (20)
Bagels with Spread
A bagel with your choice of cream cheese or butter on it.
Plain Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese on your choice of bagel.
$3.99•96% (64)
#3 Most liked
Low Fat Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese on your choice of bagel.
$3.99
Vegetable Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese with fresh celery, radishes and green peppers mixed into it on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (10)
Scallion Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese with green onions, garlic, and carrots mixed into it on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (32)
Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese with jalapeños and Cheddar cheese mixed into it on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (21)
Strawberry Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese mixed with strawberry jam on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (18)
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese mixed with cinnamon and brown sugar on your choice of bagel.
$4.59•100% (20)
Lox Cream Cheese Spread
Cream cheese mixed with smoked salmon on your choice of bagel.
$5.19•100% (32)
Butter Bagel
Butter on your choice of bagel.
$2.89•100% (15)
Sandwiches
Egg & Cheese
Your choice of bagel with a slice of deli cheese and and fried egg patty. Add meat or cream cheese for an additional charge.
$4.99•98% (138)
#1 Most liked
Pastrami Sandwich
$8.49•96% (26)
Corned Beef Sandwich
$8.49•100% (8)
Turkey Sandwich
$7.49•100% (14)
Salami Sandwich
$6.49•87% (8)
B.L.T.
$6.49•85% (7)
Ham Sandwich
Choice of various bagels and cheeses with ham. Bagel options include plain, savory, sweet, and spicy flavors. Cheese options: American, Cheddar, Pepper-Jack, Provolone, Swiss, or none.
$7.49
Lox and Cream Cheese
Bagel with cream cheese and smoked salmon options. Choose from various bagel flavors, ranging from classic plain to jalapeño cayenne.
$12.99
Chips
Miss Vickie's Jalapeño Chips
$1.99
Miss Vickie's Sea Salt Chips
$1.99
Miss Vickie's BBQ
$1.99
Miss Vickie's Sea Salt and Vinegar
$1.99
Sun Chips Harvest Cheddar
Crunchy multigrain chips typically featuring a blend of whole grains, seasoned with a mild cheddar cheese flavor for a savory snack experience.
$1.99
Drinks
Orange Juice
Classic citrus refreshment.
$2.49
Apple Juice
$2.49
Mountain Ice Water
A 20 oz bottle of mountain ice water.
$1.99
Yoo-Hoo
$2.49•100% (7)
Gold Peak Sweet Tea
A high quality ready-to-drink iced tea with an authentic home brewed taste.
$2.99
Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea
A high quality ready-to-drink iced tea with an authentic home brewed taste.
$2.99
Nesquik Chocolate Milk
Nesquik chocolate milk combines rich cocoa with smooth milk, offering a sweet and satisfying drink typically enjoyed during breakfast.
$2.49
Box of Coffee
96oz Box of Coffee. Includes cups, sugars and creamers.
$25.99
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash