Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Market (N Shadeland Ave) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

logo
Sign In / Sign Up

Caplingers Fresh Catch Seafood Market

7460 Shadeland Avenue, Indianapolis, IN
Loading
Online ordering hours: 10:00 AM - 7:30 PM
13 min
ready for pickup

Featured Items

Catfish Filet Dinner
$20.79
Caplinger Special Dinner
$18.99
Whole Catfish Dinner 2pc
$18.99
Grouper Dinner
$27.99
Big Catch Sandwich
$14.99
Shrimp Dinner
$18.19
Great Lakes Perch Dinner
$17.69
Cod Sandwich
$12.99
Raw 6PC Oysters
$14.59
Lobster Roll
$23.99
Shrimp Po Boy
$10.99
Caplinger Special Sandwich
$10.49
Salmon Dinner
$18.19
Catfish Nugget Dinner
$14.99
Catfish Po Boy
$9.99
Cod Dinner
$21.99
The Platter Dinner
$23.99
Fish & Shrimp Dinner
$20.09
Whiting Dinner
$12.99
1PC Salmon Filet
$12.49
Coconut Shrimp Dinner
$21.99
Whole Catfish Dinner 1pc
$14.99
Calamari Fries
$12.99
Fried Oyster Dinner
$23.99
Walleye Dinner
$26.99
Full Menu
10:00 am - 7:30 pm

Most Ordered

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Collard Greens

The best you will ever eat.
$2.99+•90% (72)
#3 Most liked

Catfish Filet Dinner

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$20.79

Caplinger Special Dinner

Our #1 Seller! This dinner is served with 2 pieces of Basa, 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.
$18.99

Cornbread

Our sweet cornbread is almost like eating dessert with your dinner.
$2.99+•94% (36)

Great Lakes Perch Dinner

This new item will soon be a best seller. White Lake Perch from Lake Erie is fried perfectly and served with your choice of 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and choice of sauce.
$17.69

Calamari Fries

Best Seller! Tender strips of calamari breaded and fried to golden perfection. Served with your choice of sauce.
$12.99•87% (33)

Whole Catfish Dinner 2pc

Two pieces of whole catfish with your choice of fried or grilled. Accompanied by two sides from a variety including cornbread, yams, mac & cheese, and more.
$18.99

Fish & Shrimp Dinner

1 piece of Basa and 1/4# shrimp fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$20.09

Hushpuppies

These tasty little morsels are a staple with any fried fish meal.
$2.99+

Yams

Almost as good as dessert.
$2.99+

Best Sellers

Fish & Shrimp Dinner

1 piece of Basa and 1/4# shrimp fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$20.09

Catfish Filet Dinner

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$20.79

Salmon Dinner

Grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$18.19

Whiting Dinner

Fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$12.99

Caplinger Special Sandwich

Our #1 selling sandwich. Mild and flaky whitefish cooked to perfection. Great fried or grilled.
$10.49

Lobster Roll

Voted Top 20 in the USA! Our "lobsta" rolls are made with claw and knuckle meat and tossed with just a few other fresh secret ingredients and piled into one of our fresh toasted locally baked rolls.
$23.99

Ocean Perch Dinner

A sweet, flaky full flavored fish fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.
$16.29

Caplinger Special Dinner

Our #1 Seller! This dinner is served with 2 pieces of Basa, 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.
$18.99

Catfish Nugget Dinner

This is a great value and one of our favorites. USA raised catfish fried to perfection. Served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.
$14.99

Sides

Cornbread

Our sweet cornbread is almost like eating dessert with your dinner.
$2.99+•94% (36)

Buffalo Fries

Our fries are a waffle cut with a seasoned coating that goes perfectly with all dinners.
$2.99+

Green Beans

We cook our green beans in beef broth giving them a great flavor.
$2.99+

Collard Greens

The best you will ever eat.
$2.99+•90% (72)
#3 Most liked

Red Beans & Rice

A southern favorite. Our red beans and rice are paired with andouille sausage, giving it a nice kick.
$2.99+

Yams

Almost as good as dessert.
$2.99+

Hushpuppies

These tasty little morsels are a staple with any fried fish meal.
$2.99+

Loaded Potato Salad

Creamy potato salad flavored just right.
$2.99+•100% (7)

Okra

A southern favorite. Lightly breaded and fried. Great with a side of remoulade sauce.
$2.99+•87% (8)

Baked Beans

Our baked beans are sweet and tangy.
$2.99+

Meal Deals

Shrimp & Fries

1/4# Fried Shrimp, Fries, 2 hushpuppies, sauce, and a fountain drink
$12.49•87% (33)

Perch & Fries

1/2# ocean perch fillets perfectly fried, fries, 2 hushpuppies, sauce and a fountain drink.
$14.49•87% (33)

Catfish Nuggets & Fries

#2 Most liked
1/2# perfectly fried catfish nuggets, fries, 2 hushpuppies, sauce, and a fountain drink.
$10.99•90% (73)

Dinners

Whole Snapper & Shrimp

Comes with 1 Whole Red Snapper, 5 Jumbo Shrimp fried or grilled. Comes with 2 sides and 2 hushpuppies
$24.99

Kids Fish Dinner

Choice of fried or grilled fish. Served with one side: options like cornbread, baked beans, yams, or creamy mac & cheese among others.
$13.49

Gator Dinner

"It tastes like chicken." Really it does. Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$23.99

Walleye Dinner

This large 10 to 12 ounce fillet is a mild and sweet flavored fish is great fried or grilled. Served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$26.99

Shrimp Scampi Dinner

Garlicky shrimp with a choice of two sides. Varied sides include Southern staples like cornbread, collard greens, loaded potato salad, mac & cheese, and more.
$16.99

Tilapia Dinner

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$19.29

Bayou Blackened Redfish Dinner - 1pc

Blackened redfish served with cornbread, red beans & rice, collard greens and remoulade sauce.
$22.99

Grouper Dinner

12 ounces of perfectly cooked flaky grouper. Its at it's best fried but grills up great too. Served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and your choice of sauce
$27.99•78% (14)

Clam Dinner

Hearty clam strips, fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.
$17.99

Kids Chicken Dinner

Choice of fried or grilled chicken with a side. Options include cornbread, veggies, slaws, salads, classics like mac & cheese, and more. Suitable for kids.
$13.49

Chicken Breast Dinner

Two boneless & skinless chicken breasts breaded & fried or grilled with a seasoning of vour choice.
$19.29

Fish & Chicken Dinner

A Basa fillet and a chicken breast served with 2 sides of your choice, 2 hushpuppies and 2 sauces of your choice.
$21.09

Shrimp & Grits

#1 Most liked
Succulent shrimp paired with creamy grits. Choice of classic Southern sides like cornbread, collard greens, hushpuppies, and more.
$18.99•85% (94)

Bluegill Dinner

Bluegill served fried or grilled. Choice of two sides: classics like cornbread, hushpuppies, baked beans, yams, collard greens, and more.
$23.99

Golden Battered Fish & Shrimp Dinner

Fish and shrimp paired with your choice of sides like cornbread, yams, or collard greens. Option for grilled or fried shrimp and basa.
$18.99

Bayou Blackened Redfish Dinner - 2pc

Blackened redfish served with cornbread, red beans & rice, collard greens and remoulade sauce.
$27.99

Lobster Roll Dinner

Toasted roll filled with fresh lobster, typically accompanied by creamy mayo and crisp fries, complemented by homemade coleslaw.
$25.99

Whole Catfish Dinner 1pc

Whole catfish, choice of fried or grilled. Select two sides: diverse options including cornbread, beans, slaw, potato salad, greens, fries, hushpuppies, mac & cheese, rice, and more.
$14.99

Shrimp Trio

Get your favorite shrimp all in one dinner. 1/4# shrimp scampi, 5pc Coconut Shrimp, 2 sides, 1 Sauce plus our famous Piña Colada Dipping Sauce and 2 Hushpuppies.
$28.29

Catfish Filet Dinner

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$20.79

12 PC Jumbo Shrimp

12 jumbo shrimp served fried or grilled along with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and your choice of sauce.
$22.09•88% (9)

Kitchen Sink

Try it all with this one. 1 pc Basa Fillet, 5pc Jumbo Shrimp, 1pc Maryland Crab Cake, 1/4# Clam Strips served with choice of 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and 2 sauces.
$39.99

Ocean Perch Dinner

A sweet, flaky full flavored fish fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.
$16.29

10 PC Golden Battered Jumbo Shrimp Dinner

10 jumbo shrimp coated in our signature golden batter and fried crisp Served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and your choice of sauce.
$21.99

The Platter Dinner

1 fillet of Basa, 1/4# shrimp, and 1/4# clams, fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and 2 sauces.
$23.99

Shrimp Dinner

A half pound of shrimp, fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$18.19

The Everything Platter

Shrimp, oysters, stuffed crab, fish fillet, coleslaw, and hushpuppies, offering a variety of seafood delights typically found in a classic seafood platter.
$37.99

Great Lakes Perch Dinner

This new item will soon be a best seller. White Lake Perch from Lake Erie is fried perfectly and served with your choice of 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and choice of sauce.
$17.69

Special Crab Cake Dinner

Crab cakes served with a choice of two sides like cornbread, mac & cheese, or green beans.
$24.99

Coconut Shrimp Dinner

10 jumbo shrimp coated with a fabulous coconut breading fried perfectly and served with our own pina colada dipping sauce, 2 sides and 2 hushpuppies.
$21.99

Whole Catfish Dinner 2pc

Two pieces of whole catfish with your choice of fried or grilled. Accompanied by two sides from a variety including cornbread, yams, mac & cheese, and more.
$18.99

Golden Battered Shrimp Dinner

Golden battered shrimp, served with two sides. Choose from options like cornbread, baked beans, or mac & cheese, among others.
$17.99

Catfish Nugget Dinner

This is a great value and one of our favorites. USA raised catfish fried to perfection. Served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.
$14.99

Shellfish Platter

The best of the sea is found in this platter. 5pc Jumbo Shrimp, 1pc Premium Lump Crab Cake, 1/4# Fried Clams, 2 sides, 2 Sauces and 2 hushpuppies.
$29.99

Lake Smelt Dinner

Delicate lake smelt served with your choice of two sides, including options like cornbread, yams, okra, and hushpuppies.
$16.69

Whiting Dinner

Fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$12.99

Fish & Shrimp Dinner

1 piece of Basa and 1/4# shrimp fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$20.09

Caplinger Special Dinner

Our #1 Seller! This dinner is served with 2 pieces of Basa, 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.
$18.99

Kids Shrimp Dinner

Shrimp dinner for kids. Choose Fried or Grilled shrimp. Side options include classic Southern favorites like cornbread, baked beans, or mac & cheese among others.
$13.49

Cod Dinner

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$21.99

The Land and Sea Platter

Grilled steak and assorted seafood, typically featuring shrimp, crab, and fish fillets, offering a diverse taste of land and sea.
$36.99

Fried Oyster Dinner

1/2 lb of our plump West Coast oysters breaded and fried perfectly and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.
$23.99

Frog Legs Dinner

Full pound of frog legs fried to perfection. Comes with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.
$23.99

Salmon Dinner

Grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.
$18.19

Calamari Steak Dinner

Tender calamari steak paired with choice of two sides, including cornbread, yams, mac & cheese, and more.
$19.99

Fish & Chips

Try this classic seafood dinner. Haddock fillets battered in our very own blend fried to golden perfection, served with fries, 2 hushpuppies, 1 sauce and your choice of 1 side.
$17.29

Capligner's Signature Battered Cod Fish & Chips

Flaky cod fried in our vey own batter, served with fries, 1 side 2 hushpuppies and your choice of sauce
$23.99

Crawfish Tail Dinner

Crawfish tails served with choice of texture: crispy, hard, regular, or soft.
$16.99

Jumbo Shrimp Boil

An AMP Special! It comes with 10 Jumbo Shrimp, corn, Onions, 2 Hard Boiled Eggs, Potatoes, Butter, & Sausage. Add 1/2# Snow Crab for extra.
$22.99

Crab Cake Dinner

Our delicious Maryland Style Crab Cakes are loaded with sweet Blue Crab and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.
$29.99

Drinks

Teas me Bottled Tea

Bottled tea featuring a blend of brewed tea leaves, typically unsweetened or sweetened, offering a convenient and refreshing beverage option.
$4.99

Bottled Pepsi 20 oz

20 oz of classic or diet sodas. Choose from a variety including cola, citrus, root beer, and more.
$3.19

Fountain Drink

Assorted soda and iced tea options. Choose from Pepsi lineup, Root Beer, Mountain Dew variations, lemonade, or tea selections.
$3.09

Premium Bottled Pepsi Product

A premium bottled Pepsi product, offering a bold and refreshing cola experience with sweet, fizzy bubbles.
$3.99

Jarritos

Mexican soda typically made with cane sugar, available in fruit flavors like mandarin, pineapple, lime, and tamarind.
$3.09

Ice Mountain Bottled Water

Ice Mountain bottled water is pure and refreshing, typically sourced from natural springs for essential hydration.
$2.79

Fresh Brewed Teas

Fresh brewed teas typically include selections like sweet or unsweetened options, offering a refreshing beverage choice.
$3.09

Pepsi - Special Price

Pepsi: A bold, refreshing, robust cola typically enjoyed as a classic beverage choice.
$1.79

Add Ons

1PC Calamari Steak

Lightly fried calamari steak, typically seasoned with herbs, offering a tender and mild seafood experience.

Extra Tartar

A classic creamy tartar sauce, typically made with mayonnaise and mustard, ideal for enhancing seafood dishes.
$0.79

Jumbo Shrimp

5 big jumbo shrimp fried or grilled and served with our homemade cocktail sauce.
$9.99+

1PC Salmon Filet

Single salmon filet.
$12.49

1PC Cod

Single cod filet.
$8.99

Extra Ranch

$0.79

Frog Legs

Served in half-pound or one-pound portions. Choose between fried or grilled presentation.
$12.99+

Lobster Bisque Cold

Sweet lobster in a creamy bisque. A perfect accompaniment to any meal.
$9.59

Raw 12PC Oysters

You will enjoy 12 Virginia Blue Point Oysters on the half shell served with lemon wedge and our famous cocktail sauce.
$39.99

1 PC Catfish Filet

Choice of fried or grilled catfish filet.
$7.29

Lobster Bisque Hot

Sweet lobster in a creamy bisque. A perfect accompaniment to any meal.
$9.59

Calamari Fries

Best Seller! Tender strips of calamari breaded and fried to golden perfection. Served with your choice of sauce.
$12.99•87% (33)

1PC Ocean Perch

One piece of Ocean Perch
$1.99

Shrimp

Our best selling add-on. You get 6 to 8 pieces served with our homemade cocktail sauce.
$7.99+

Clam Chowda Hot

This is our homemade New England style clam chowder. It is rich and creamy with lots of clams. You won't find chowder better anywhere.
$9.59

1/2# Lake Smelt

Lightly breaded and fried lake smelt, offering a crispy texture and mild flavor, typical of this small freshwater fish.
$11.49

12 Char Grilled Oysters

Char-grilled oysters seasoned and cooked to enhance their natural briny flavor, served with lemon wedges for a citrusy zest.
$29.99

Shrimp Scampi 16pc

Sautéed shrimp in garlic butter and white wine sauce, typically featuring 16 pieces.
$10.99

Buns

Soft, steamed buns typically accompany seafood dishes, providing a light and fluffy texture to complement the main course.
$1.50

Extra Cocktail

$0.79

1/2# Crawfish Tail Meat

Louisiana crawfish tail meat, typically cooked and seasoned, offering a classic taste of Cajun cuisine.
$12.39

Extra BBQ Sauce

$0.79

Catfish Nuggets

Catfish nuggets available in half-pound or full-pound sizes. Choose between fried or grilled options.
$8.99+

1PC Whiting Filet

Single whiting fillet.
$1.99

Extra Chipotle Aioli

Chipotle aioli typically combines mayonnaise with smoky chipotle peppers for a creamy, mildly spicy sauce.
$0.79

1PC Basa

Single fillet of Basa
$7.39•100% (23)

Coconut Shrimp

6 pc jumbo coconut shrimp with our pina colada dipping sauce.
$13.29

1/2# Gator Bites

1/2 lb of gator tail cut into bite sized nuggets and served with your choice of sauce.
$18.99

1/4# Clams

1/4 lb of whole Quahog clams fried and served with your choice of sauce.
$7.29

Extra Pina Colada Sauce

Creamy pina colada sauce, often served as a sweet and tropical complement to seafood dishes, made with coconut and pineapple flavors.
$0.79

Shrimp Cocktail

You can't go wrong with this one. 5 jumbo cooked shrimp served with our famous cocktail sauce.
$10.69

1PC Tilapia

Single tilapia fillet.
$8.69

1PC Chicken Breast

Single chicken breast.
$6.99

1 PC Catfish Whole

Whole catfish, available fried or grilled.
$7.79

6 Char Grilled Oysters

Char-grilled oysters featuring fresh shucked oysters, typically seasoned with garlic butter and parmesan cheese, finished on the grill for a savory seafood experience.
$16.99

Raw 6PC Oysters

Fresh oysters served raw, highlighting their natural briny flavor. Six pieces included.
$14.59

Crab Cake

These Maryland Style crab cakes are loaded with sweet blue crab and cooked to perfection. They are best served with our famous remoulade sauce.
$7.99

Buns & Fixings

Soft buns typically paired with lettuce, tomato, and pickles, offering classic accompaniments for seafood dishes.
$3.49

Fried Oysters

1/4 lb of fried oysters served with our famous remoulade sauce.
$9.89+

Clam Chowda Cold

This is our homemade New England style clam chowder. It is rich and creamy with lots of clams. You won't find chowder better anywhere.
$9.59

Extra Remoulade

Mayonnaise-based remoulade sauce, typically seasoned with a blend of spices, often served as a complement to seafood dishes.
$0.79

Sandwiches

Haddock Sandwich

We use our famous battered haddock fillets and stack them onto a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$10.49

Lobster Melt

Our amazing lobster roll mix, sauteed onions and peppers piled into a fresh roll and covered with a blanket of melted Mozzarella and Provolone cheese.
$24.99

Tuna Salad Sandwich

Our "almost famous" homemade smoked tuna salad served on a fresh toasted bun with vour choice of fixins.
$10.99

Clam Po Boy

Fried clam strips typically topped with lettuce, tomato, and remoulade sauce, served on a toasted French bread roll.
$10.39

Grouper Sandwich

This classic is a favorite of many. It is great fried and can also be grilled.
$16.99•75% (12)

Salmon Sandwich

Atlantic salmon grilled to perfection with your choice of seasonings and toppings.
$15.19

Cod Sandwich

We use the loin cut of the cod making for a tasty flaky marvel of the seafood world.
$12.99

Calamari Steak Sandwich

Breaded calamari steak served on a roll with lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce.
$10.39

Shrimp Po Boy

A quarter pound of fried shrimp topped with lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll.
$10.99

Walleye Sandwich

This mild and sweet flavored fish is great fried or grilled.
$16.99

Catfish Sandwich

Our catfish is all raised right here in the USA. Great fried, good grilled.
$11.99

Chicken Sandwich

A boneless, skinless chicken breast fried or grilled & served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
$10.69

Caplinger Special Sandwich

Our #1 selling sandwich. Mild and flaky whitefish cooked to perfection. Great fried or grilled.
$10.49

Catfish Po Boy

USA raised catfish nuggets fried to perfection and piled onto our fresh baked roll topped with your favorite toppings and our famous remoulade sauce.
$9.99

Tilapia Sandwich

A can't miss". Tilapia is a tender white flaky fish that goes great with anything. Great fried or grilled.
$12.99

Gator Po Boy

1/2# Gator fried to perfection piled onto our fresh baked roll served with your choice of fixings and topped with our famous remoulade sauce.
$18.99

Big Catch Sandwich

Double-Decker Mild and flaky whitefish cooked to perfection. Great fried or grilled.
$14.99

Blackened Redfish Sandwich

Bayou-blackened redfish served on a toasted bun with remoulade
$15.99

Whiting Sandwich

Great moderately flavored whitefish. Only available fried.
$9.99

Pork Tenderloin

A "Hoosier Favorite" our pork tenderloin is fried to perfection and served on a freshly toasted bun and served with your choice of fixins.
$11.99

Ocean Perch Sandwich

Fried to perfection. Our ocean perch can be either a US or Canadian product. Not available grilled.
$10.49

Seafood Philly

Crab, lobster, and shrimp all piled high in a fresh roll with sauteed onions, peppers, remoulade sauce, and a blanket of melted Mozzarella and Provolone cheese.
$24.99•94% (17)

Great Lakes Perch Sandwich

Sweet and firm white perch fillets from Lake Erie make a perfect fried fish sandwich.
$9.99

Crawfish Po Boy

Sandwich with tender crawfish. Choice of bread texture: crispy, hard, regular, or soft.
$12.39

Lobster Roll

Voted Top 20 in the USA! Our "lobsta" rolls are made with claw and knuckle meat and tossed with just a few other fresh secret ingredients and piled into one of our fresh toasted locally baked rolls.
$23.99

Crab Cake Sandwich

Enjoy our sweet and succulent blue crab cake dressed with your favorite fixins.
$17.99

Tuna Melt

Our famous smoked tuna salad atop a fresh baked roll topped with sauteed onions peppers and american cheese.
$12.49

Blue Crab Melt

Crab meat piled into one of our fresh baked rolls topped with mayo and mounds of Mozzarella and Provolone cheese melted to perfection.
$24.99

Oyster Po Boy

A quarter pound of fried oysters topped with lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll.
$15.49

Desserts

Cookie

A classic cookie typically includes flavors like chocolate chip, peanut butter, or oatmeal, offering a simple, sweet treat.

Cookies & Cream Pie

Creamy pie with a crumbly cookie crust, topped with cookie crumbles.
$4.99

Chocolate Cake

Layers of moist chocolate cake typically topped with rich chocolate frosting and a smooth chocolate ganache.
$4.99

Oreo Cake

Layers of creamy filling and moist sponge cake, topped with thin slices of lemon and coconut flakes.
$4.99•60% (20)

Pecan Pie

Rich, buttery crust topped with a creamy pecan filling, offering a nutty and sweet finish.
$4.99•77% (9)

Whole Key Lime Pie

Graham cracker crust filled with a tangy key lime custard, typically topped with fresh whipped cream.
$20.99•100% (10)

Dulce de Leche

Sweet milk caramel, known as dulce de leche, typically features a creamy, smooth texture and rich, caramelized flavor, often enjoyed as a standalone dessert.
$5.99

Key Lime Pie

Creamy lime-infused filling atop a crumbly crust, garnished with a sprinkle of zest.
$3.99•54% (53)

Italian Lemon Creme

Smooth lemon creme with a hint of citrus, typically featuring a creamy texture and subtle Italian influences, offering a delicate balance of sweet and tangy flavors.
$6.99

Cheesecake

Creamy cheesecake slice with a smooth, rich filling on a crumbly graham cracker crust.
$5.99•80% (15)

Carrot Cake

Moist carrot cake layered with cream cheese frosting, featuring grated carrots, aromatic spices, and crunchy walnuts.
$5.99•60% (20)

Sugar Cream Pie

A buttery pie crust filled with a creamy sugar custard, typically topped with a layer of whipped cream for a sweet finish.
$4.99
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
© 2026 DoorDash
Caplingers Fresh Catch Seafood Market 7460 Shadeland Avenue – Order pickup and delivery