
Jeremiah's Italian Ice
4355 West Lake Mary Boulevard, Lake Mary, FL
Online ordering hours: 12:00 PM - 10:25 PM16 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
#2 Most liked
Quart Italian Ice
$7.99
#1 Most liked
Medium Italian Ice
$4.59
Medium Jelati
$5.59
6 Pack - Ice Cream Sandwiches
$14.99
Quart Jelati
$8.99
Bullfrog Jelati
$6.59
Oreo Mud Pie
$5.19+
Medium Soft Ice Cream
$5.39
Peanut Butter Cup
$5.19+
Bullfrog Soft Ice Cream
$6.39
Strawberry Shortcake
$5.19+
Quart Soft Ice Cream
$8.99
Small Jelati
$4.59
Grasshopper
$5.19+
Pumpkin Pie
$5.19+
Bullfrog Italian Ice
$5.59
Small Soft Ice Cream
$4.39
Build-Your-Own Flavorite
$4.19+
Frozen Hot Chocolate
$5.19+
Peppermint Bark
$5.19+
Small Italian Ice
$3.59
Tadpole Mini Italian Ice
$3.19
Tadpole Mini Soft Ice Cream
$3.99
Birthday Cake
$5.19+
Blue Razz Crunch
$5.19+
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 10:25 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Medium Italian Ice
Choose from a variety of Italian ice flavors, including classics like Cherry and Mango or unique options such as Key West Tropical and Cake Batter.
$4.59•43
#1 Most liked
Medium Jelati
Choice of medium-sized gelato with diverse flavors and soft ice cream options. Add layer-ins like cookie crumbles, sprinkles, or candy for extra texture and taste.
$5.59
Strawberry Shortcake
Cake batter italian ice, strawberry italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, cookie crumbles.
$5.19+
Oreo Mud Pie
With cookies and cream italian ice, swirl soft ice cream, oreo cookie crumbles.
$5.19+
Grasshopper
With scoop froggy frog italian ice, cookies and cream italian ice, swirl soft ice cream, oreo cookie crumbles.
$5.19+
Bullfrog Jelati
Wide variety of flavors including classics like Chocolate and Mango. Soft ice cream options plus layer-ins such as Oreo crumbles and rainbow sprinkles.
$6.59
Medium Soft Ice Cream
Vanilla, swirl, or chocolate flavors. Choice of Oreo crumbles, cookie butter, chocolate chips, sprinkles, or more. Served in cup or cone.
$5.39
Peanut Butter Cup
With p-nutty italian ice, chocolate soft ice cream, hershey's mini chocolate chips.
$5.19+
Quart Jelati
Choose from a variety of flavors including and classics. Enhance with creamy soft ice creams and add texture with options like cookie crumbles or candy pieces.
$8.99
Small Jelati
Choice of jelati flavors like Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Mango, or Strawberry. Soft ice cream options include Vanilla, Swirl, or Chocolate. Add-ins such as Oreo Crumbles or Rainbow Sprinkles available.
$4.59
Flavorites
The perfect layering of authentic Italian Ice, indulgent Soft Ice Cream & decadent Layer-Ins!
Grasshopper
With scoop froggy frog italian ice, cookies and cream italian ice, swirl soft ice cream, oreo cookie crumbles.
$5.19+
Strawberry Shortcake
Cake batter italian ice, strawberry italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, cookie crumbles.
$5.19+
Blue Razz Crunch
The perfect layering of Blue Razz Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, Rainbow Nerds Candy
$5.19+
Sugar Cookie
Cake batter italian ice, cookie butter italian ice, vanilla ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
$5.19+
PB & J
P-nutty italian ice, strawberry italian ice, vanilla ice cream, cookie butter crumbles.
$5.19+
Peanut Butter Cup
With p-nutty italian ice, chocolate soft ice cream, hershey's mini chocolate chips.
$5.19+
Oreo Mud Pie
With cookies and cream italian ice, swirl soft ice cream, oreo cookie crumbles.
$5.19+
Birthday Cake
With cake batter italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
$5.19+
Orange Mango Tango
With orange smash italian ice, mango italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
$5.19+
Spiced Mango
The perfect layering of Mango Italian Ice, Vanilla Ice Cream, Tajin & Chamoy
$5.19+
Build-Your-Own Flavorite
Build your own perfect layering of authentic Italian Ice, indulgent Soft Ice Cream & decadent Layer-Ins!
$4.19+
Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin pie italian ice, vanilla ice cream, biscoff cookie crumbles.
$5.19+
Peppermint Bark
The perfect layering of Cookies and Cream Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, Crushed Peppermint Candy
$5.19+
Frozen Hot Chocolate
The perfect layering of Hot Chocolate Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, Mini Marshmallows
$5.19+
Candy Cane Hot Chocolate
The perfect layering of Hot Chocolate Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, Mini Marshmallows, Crushed Peppermint Candy
$5.19+
Jelati
The perfect layering of Italian Ice & Soft Ice Cream!
Tadpole Mini Jelati
Mini gelato cups with a variety of classic and adventurous flavors like fruity, sweet, and chocolatey. Soft ice cream options and diverse toppings for customizable enjoyment.
$4.19
Small Jelati
Choice of jelati flavors like Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Mango, or Strawberry. Soft ice cream options include Vanilla, Swirl, or Chocolate. Add-ins such as Oreo Crumbles or Rainbow Sprinkles available.
$4.59
Medium Jelati
Choice of medium-sized gelato with diverse flavors and soft ice cream options. Add layer-ins like cookie crumbles, sprinkles, or candy for extra texture and taste.
$5.59
Bullfrog Jelati
Wide variety of flavors including classics like Chocolate and Mango. Soft ice cream options plus layer-ins such as Oreo crumbles and rainbow sprinkles.
$6.59
Quart Jelati
Choose from a variety of flavors including and classics. Enhance with creamy soft ice creams and add texture with options like cookie crumbles or candy pieces.
$8.99
Jelati Cakes
LIMIT ONE CAKE PER ORDER
Peppermint Bark Jelati Cake
Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with refreshing Italian Ice, creamy Soft Ice Cream, and decadent Layer-Ins perfectly layered in this shareable treat... From Ice to Slice!
*48 Hour Pre-Order Required. Grab-n-Go Jelati Cakes may also be available - call your local Jeremiah's Ice to verify.
$29.99
Italian Ice
Refreshing & Indulgent - Made Fresh Daily!
Tadpole Mini Italian Ice
Mini Italian ice with a variety of flavors including fruit, chocolate, and classic options.
$3.19
Small Italian Ice
A variety of Italian ice flavors including fruit, chocolate, and options like Pina Colada, Caffe Latte, and Black Raspberry.
$3.59•8
Medium Italian Ice
Choose from a variety of Italian ice flavors, including classics like Cherry and Mango or unique options such as Key West Tropical and Cake Batter.
$4.59•43
#1 Most liked
Bullfrog Italian Ice
A refreshing treat with a wide range of flavors including fruity options like Mango and Watermelon, indulgent choices like Chocolate and Cookies & Cream, and unique creations such as Key West Tropical.
$5.59
Quart Italian Ice
A quart of Italian Ice. Choose from a wide array of flavors like fruity, nutty, and classic varieties, including options such as Black Raspberry, Caffe Latte, and Pina Colada.
$7.99•12
#2 Most liked
Soft Ice Cream
Certified Rich & Creamy!
Tadpole Mini Soft Ice Cream
Mini soft ice cream served with options of vanilla, chocolate, or swirl flavors. Choose from various layer-ins like cookie crumbles, candy, or sprinkles.
$3.99
Small Soft Ice Cream
Choice of Vanilla, Swirl, or Chocolate ice cream. Optional layer-ins like cookie crumbles, sprinkles, or Nerds candy. Served in a cup or various cones.
$4.39
Medium Soft Ice Cream
Vanilla, swirl, or chocolate flavors. Choice of Oreo crumbles, cookie butter, chocolate chips, sprinkles, or more. Served in cup or cone.
$5.39
Bullfrog Soft Ice Cream
Creamy soft serve with options of vanilla, chocolate, or swirl. Customize with a variety of toppings, including candy, cookie crumbles, or sprinkles.
$6.39
Quart Soft Ice Cream
Quart of soft ice cream with your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or swirl flavors. Customize with toppings like cookie crumbles, chocolate chips, sprinkles, or graham cracker crust.
$8.99
Ice Cream Sandwiches
The perfect handheld treat on-the-go!
6 Pack - Ice Cream Sandwiches
Creamy vanilla ice cream sandwiched between chocolate cookies, adorned with chocolate chips or colorful sprinkles.
$14.99
Classic Ice Cream Sandwich
Creamy vanilla ice cream nestled between two chocolate cookies.
$2.99
Chocolate Chips Ice Cream Sandwich
Creamy ice cream layered between two chocolate cookies, accented with a generous coating of chocolate chips.
$2.99
Rainbow Sprinkles Ice Cream Sandwich
Creamy ice cream nestled between chocolate cookies, adorned with vibrant rainbow sprinkles.
$2.99
Peppermint Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich
$2.99
Extras
Enticing Add-ons!
Bottled Water
$2.25
Waffle Cone on the Side
Crispy waffle cone with a golden-brown finish, perfect for complementing your dessert.
$0.99•9
#3 Most liked
Small Cooler Bag
Insulated green cooler bag featuring Jeremiah's Italian Ice logo, ideal for keeping items chilled.
$6.99
Large Cooler Bag
Color varies by location.
$9.99
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash