
Amys Custom Cakery
83 West Canal Street, Dover, PA
Online ordering hours: ClosedOpens 10:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
8" Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
$55.00
8" Strawberry Crunch Cake
$55.00
8" Carrot Cream Cheese Cake
$55.00
8" Banana Split Cake
$55.00
8" Confetti Cake
$55.00
Confetti Cakeballs 6pk
$20.00
Whole Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
$30.00
Whole Strawberry Crunch Pie
$30.00
Oreo Cakeball 6pk
$20.00
Chocolate Chip Cakeball 6pk
$20.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cakeball 6pk
$20.00
Gluten Free Chocolate Cupcake
$5.25
Gluten Free White Buttercream Cupcake
$5.25
Gluten Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcake
$5.25
Full Menu
closedMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Whole Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
This cream cheese based peanut butter pie has become one of our best sellers and will surely be one of your new favorite desserts!
$30.00
Gluten Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcake
Gluten free chocolate cake with our light and fluffy peanut butter whipped icing, topped with crushed reese's cups and chocolate drizzle!
$5.25
8" Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
Chocolate cake with our whipped peanut butter icing, garnished with crushed reese's cups and chocolate drizzle! **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
Confetti Cakeballs 6pk
Just like a cake pop, but without the stick!
$20.00
Oreo Cakeball 6pk
Just like a cake pop, but without the stick!
$20.00
8" Confetti Cake
Confetti cake with buttercream icing. **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
Gluten Free White Buttercream Cupcake
gluten free white cupcake topped with our sweet buttercream icing! (seasonal sprinkles vary)
$5.25
Gluten Free Chocolate Cupcake
gluten free chocolate cupcake topped with our sweet buttercream icing! (seasonal sprinkles vary)
$5.25
8" Strawberry Crunch Cake
Strawberry cake, buttercream icing and homemade strawberry crunch topping! This cake tastes just like a good humor ice cream bar! **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cakeball 6pk
Just like a cake pop, but without the stick!
$20.00
Gluten Free Desserts
Gluten Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcake
Gluten free chocolate cake with our light and fluffy peanut butter whipped icing, topped with crushed reese's cups and chocolate drizzle!
$5.25
Gluten Free White Buttercream Cupcake
gluten free white cupcake topped with our sweet buttercream icing! (seasonal sprinkles vary)
$5.25
Gluten Free Chocolate Cupcake
gluten free chocolate cupcake topped with our sweet buttercream icing! (seasonal sprinkles vary)
$5.25
Pies
Whole Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
This cream cheese based peanut butter pie has become one of our best sellers and will surely be one of your new favorite desserts!
$30.00
Whole Strawberry Crunch Pie
Just like a good humor ice cream bar, this strawberry crunch pie will tantalize your taste buds!
$30.00
Cakeballs
Confetti Cakeballs 6pk
Just like a cake pop, but without the stick!
$20.00
Oreo Cakeball 6pk
Just like a cake pop, but without the stick!
$20.00
Chocolate Chip Cakeball 6pk
Just like a cake pop, but without the stick!
$20.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cakeball 6pk
Just like a cake pop, but without the stick!
$20.00
Cakes
8" Banana Split Cake
Banana cake with a whipped icing filling, chopped maraschino cherries, crushed peanuts, strawberry puree, chocolate drizzle and sprinkles! **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
8" Strawberry Crunch Cake
Strawberry cake, buttercream icing and homemade strawberry crunch topping! This cake tastes just like a good humor ice cream bar! **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
8" Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
Chocolate cake with our whipped peanut butter icing, garnished with crushed reese's cups and chocolate drizzle! **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
8" Oreo Cake
Chocolate cake with a light Oreo mousse filling and whipped oreo icing! **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
8" Confetti Cake
Confetti cake with buttercream icing. **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
8" White Raspberry Cake
White cake with raspberry filling and buttercream icing. **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
8" Carrot Cream Cheese Cake
Carrot cake with cream cheese icing. **CAKE WILL COME EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED AND PHOTOED, THE ONLY CUSTOMIZATION ALLOWED IS TO ADD WRITING** If you would like writing on your cake, please add that in the special instructions section along with a preferred color
$55.00
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash