By the Bucket Payson Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
By the Bucket Payson
Sign In / Sign Up
By the Bucket Payson
319 E State Highway 260, Payson, AZ
Online ordering hours: 11:30 AM - 6:40 PMOpens 11:30 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
*Medium Bucket (Feed 2-3)
$15.50
*Large Bucket (Feed up to 5)
$23.00
*Small Bucket (Feeds 1)
$11.00
Meatball Sub
$14.50
Chicken Parmesan Sub
$15.00
Caesar Salad Large
$12.50
Italian Sausage Sub
$14.00
Cheesy Bread Full Loaf
$10.50
Caesar Salad Medium
$9.00
Chicken Parmesan
$6.50
Caesar Salad Small
$5.00
Cheesy Bread Half Loaf
$6.00
New York Cheesecake
$5.50
Bread Pudding Traditional
$7.00
Shaved Parm 8oz by volume
$7.00
Garlic Bread Full Loaf
$7.00
Tiramisu
$7.00
Kids Bucket
$8.50
Chocolate Italian Mousse cake
$5.50
Garlic Bread Pizza
$6.50
Lemoncello Cake
$5.50
Garlic Bread Half Loaf
$4.00
Grilled Chicken (4oz)
$5.00
Sausage 4 oz
$5.00
Alfredo Sauce 4oz
$4.00
Full Menu
11:30 am - 6:40 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Garlic Bread Half Loaf
Delectable homemade garlic butter spread over an Italian loaf. Toasted.
$4.00
Meatball Sub
3 meatballs covered in our marinara, topped with Boar's Head mozzarella, on an eight-inch Italian hoagie.
$14.50
Cheesy Bread Half Loaf
Our delectable garlic bread with shredded, melted, Boar's Head mozzarella. Toasted.
$6.00
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Juicy tender parmesan chicken smothered in Marinara and Mozzerella
$15.00
Chicken Parmesan
4oz of our delicious Parmesan-crusted Chicken Breast. Smothered in marinara and cheeses
$6.50
*Medium Bucket (Feed 2-3)
Its our classic spaghetti to feed 2-3, Includes our classic marinara or choose a optional sauce
$15.50
Caesar Salad Small
Fresh Crisp Romaine with our Shaved Parmasan Cheese and Crunchy croutons
$5.00
Italian Sausage Sub
Our mild/sweet sliced Italian sausage is smothered in marinara and mozzarella cheese on a toasted hoagie roll.
$14.00
*Small Bucket (Feeds 1)
Its our classic spaghetti to feed 1, Includes our classic marinara or choose a optional sauce
$11.00
Garlic Bread Full Loaf
Delectable homemade garlic butter spread over an Italian loaf. Toasted. Four quarter loaves.
$7.00
Combo Specials
Special #1 Large Bucket, 8 Meatball, Large Salad, extra Sauce Full loaf of garlic bread
This is it! Our largest combo with a large bucket of spaghetti, 8 delicious large meatballs a large caesar salad with a side of more sauce.
$53.00
Special #2 Large Bucket 6 meatballs, Full Loaf Garlic Bread
Our generous Large portion of barrilla pasta with 24oz of our famous marinara, 6 delicious large meatballs.Includes a full loaf of garlic bread.
$37.00
Special #3 Medium Bucket 4 meatballs, Half Loaf Garlic Bread
Our generous medium portion of barrilla pasta with 16oz of our famous marinara, 4 delicious large meatballs. Includes a half loaf of garlic bread
$25.50
Buckets
*Small Bucket (Feeds 1)
Its our classic spaghetti to feed 1, Includes our classic marinara or choose a optional sauce
$11.00
*Medium Bucket (Feed 2-3)
Its our classic spaghetti to feed 2-3, Includes our classic marinara or choose a optional sauce
$15.50
*Large Bucket (Feed up to 5)
Our large classic bucket with our rich red marinara. Or choose an optional sauce.
$23.00
Sub Sandwich
Meatball Sub
3 meatballs covered in our marinara, topped with Boar's Head mozzarella, on an eight-inch Italian hoagie.
$14.50
Italian Sausage Sub
Our mild/sweet sliced Italian sausage is smothered in marinara and mozzarella cheese on a toasted hoagie roll.
$14.00
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Juicy tender parmesan chicken smothered in Marinara and Mozzerella
$15.00
Meats & Proteins
Meatball
A delicious combination of 2 ounces of beef, pork, ricotta, and Romano cheese.
$2.50
Sausage 4 oz
4 oz of delicious mild italian sausage. Does not contain dairy and is gluten free
$5.00
Chicken Parmesan
4oz of our delicious Parmesan-crusted Chicken Breast. Smothered in marinara and cheeses
$6.50
Grilled Chicken (4oz)
Lean grilled chicken breast perfect for your Alfredo or on your caesar salad
$5.00
Bucket of Meatballs (10)
Just a bucket of 10 of our world famous Juicy meatballs swimming in our classic marinara. Our meatballs are made with Beef, Pork, and Italian cheeses.....mmmmmmmm
$26.00
Bucket of Meatballs (20)
Save money on this item! 20 of our large, world famous juicy meatballs swimming in Marinara. Made with Beef Pork and Italian cheeses for an amazing eating experience.
$45.00
Garlic Bread A-la-Carte
Garlic Bread Quarter Loaf
Quarter loaf of Italian bread typically topped with garlic butter and Italian herbs, then toasted to a golden brown.
$3.00
Garlic Bread Half Loaf
Delectable homemade garlic butter spread over an Italian loaf. Toasted.
$4.00
Garlic Bread Full Loaf
Delectable homemade garlic butter spread over an Italian loaf. Toasted. Four quarter loaves.
$7.00
Cheesy Bread A-la-Carte
Cheesy Bread Quarter Loaf
Our delectable garlic bread with shredded, melted, Boar's Head mozzarella. Toasted. (half loaf pictured)
$4.50
Cheesy Bread Half Loaf
Our delectable garlic bread with shredded, melted, Boar's Head mozzarella. Toasted.
$6.00
Cheesy Bread Full Loaf
Our delectable garlic bread with shredded, melted, Boar's Head mozzarella. Toasted.
$10.50
Salads
Caesar Salad Small
Fresh Crisp Romaine with our Shaved Parmasan Cheese and Crunchy croutons
$5.00
Caesar Salad Medium
Fresh Crisp Romaine with Shaved Parmesan and Crunchy Croutons with Kens dressing on the side
$9.00
Caesar Salad Large
Fresh Crisp Romaine with Shaved Parmesan and Crunchy Croutons with Kens dressing on the side 4-5 Servings
$12.50
Desserts
New York Cheesecake
A rich and beautiful cheesecake that is totally New York style, You'll think you are downtown on Central Ave with this popular By the Bucket dessert! Add a drizzle of your choice at no charge!
$5.50
Lemoncello Cake
Oh my! This is a traditional Italian lemon cake that will take to deep into the heart of Rome and its dessert cafes'
$5.50
Chocolate Italian Mousse cake
This is the richest and most decadent chocolated mousse yet. Chocolate cake sponge with a thick layer of rich chocolate mousse.
$5.50
Tiramisu
This is our rich and traditional in house recipe for the best dessert in Payson!
$7.00
Bread Pudding Traditional
Made in house for a delicious traditional treat. Drenched in caramel sauce, so good!
$7.00
Drinks
12 oz Can Soda
Choose your favorite Coke inspired product. Perfect with your meal!
$2.00
Water Bottle
A clear, tasteless, and odorless liquid, essential for hydration.
$1.50
Bottle Coca Cola
This is classic coke made with cane sugar! Goes perfect with your delicious By the Bucket fav!
$3.50
Extras/Sides
Butter Spread 2oz
Butter and Garlic - Mic Drop
$3.00
Shaved Parm 8oz by volume
Need more Shredded Parm? Alot more :)
$7.00
Shredded Mozz 8oz by volume
Need alot more cheese? Boars Head of course!
$6.00
Extra Mozzarella Serving approx 1oz
Need more cheese? Boars Head Mozzarella!
$1.50
Extra shaved Parm Serving approx 1oz
More Parm for your enjoyment! Boars Head of course
$1.50
Godfather Mac n Cheese
Get Ready for a delicious blend of cheddar, pepper jack, green chiles and lots of bacon. Generous porttion to share with your besties!
$14.00
Sauce A La Carte
Marinara 8oz
This is our signature flavorable marinara blend that has made us famous. Grab this for an extra amount of flavor for you pasta or garlic bread dip.
$3.00
Marinara 16oz
This is our signature flavorable marinara blend that has made us famous. Grab this for an extra amount of flavor for you pasta or garlic bread dip.
$6.00
Marinara 24oz
This is our signature flavorable marinara blend that has made us famous. Grab this for an extra amount of flavor for you pasta or garlic bread dip.
$8.50
Meat Sauce 8oz
Just like home. This is a blend of our famous marinara with beef crumbles, seasoned perfectly. Very hearty
$4.00
Meat Sauce 16oz
Just like home. This is a blend of our famous marinara with beef crumbles, seasoned perfectly. Very hearty
$8.00
Meat Sauce 24oz
Just like home. This is a blend of our famous marinara with beef crumbles, seasoned perfectly. Very hearty
$10.50
Alfredo Sauce 12oz
12 oz of our signature alfredo made in house of only Garlic, Butter, Cream and Parmesan
$9.00
Alfredo Sauce 4oz
4 oz of our signature alfredo made in house of only Garlic, Butter, Cream and Parmesan
$4.00
Alfredo Sauce 8oz
8 oz of our signature alfredo made in house of only Garlic, Butter, Cream and Parmesan
$7.50
Kids Bucket
Small portion of our classic spaghetti and marinara with a meatball. Includes a piece of garlic bread. Perfect for our smaller family members! Comes with Small portion of Garlic Bread.
$8.50
Garlic Bread Pizza
Quarter loaf of garlic bread with your choice of Cheese and Pepperoni or both.
$6.50
Cater
Cater Ceasar Salad Serves 15-20
Its our beautiful Ceasar but for 15-20 lucky eaters! Fresh hand cut romaine topped with our fragrant and richly flavored shaved Parmesan cheese and crunchy croutons. Creamy Ceasar dressing on the side!
$33.50
Cater Spaghetti Tray (Serves 10)
This is our classic spaghetti with our rich marinara served in a catering tray and includes 10 pieces of garlic bread. Perfect for your office lunch or family gathering. See sauce options for more delicious choices
$46.00
Cater- Mac n Cheese Serves 20-25
This a BTB classic. A rich blend of butter, half and half, hand grated boarshead chedder and monterey jack cheeses. With our classic Barilla pasta. Bacon, Green chilli salsa, Extra Mozzarella and Bread crumbs are optional
$114.00
Cater-Delivery
Delivery within 10 mile radius
$23.00
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash