Mr. Tod's Pies Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Mr. Tod's Pies

201 Halsey St, Newark NJ 07102-2804, United States

Online ordering hours: 8:00 AM - 12:40 PM

Opens 7:00 AM

Order for later

Featured Items

Mr. Tod's Individual Peach Cobbler

$7.75

Mr. Tod's 4" Sweet Potato Pie

$7.50

Mr. Tod's Individual Apple Cobbler

$7.75

Mr. Tod's 4" Apple Crumb Pie

$8.75

Mr. Tod’s Brick City Brew™ Coffee (12oz)

$3.49

Full Menu

8:00 am - 12:40 pm

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Mr. Tod's 4" Sweet Potato Pie
Perfectly portioned Sweet Potato Pie for one (or two if you share 😉).
$7.50

Mr. Tod's Individual Peach Cobbler
Fresh peaches baked under golden cobbler topping. Comfort in every spoonful. 🍑
$7.75

Mr. Tod's 4" Buttermilk Coconut Pie
Coconut + buttermilk magic in a personal-sized pie. 🥥
$7.50

Mr. Tod's Individual Apple Cobbler
Warm apples, cinnamon spice, buttery cobbler top. 🍏 Classic comfort.
$7.75

Mr. Tod's 4" Pecan Pie
Little pie, big flavor. Classic pecan in a perfect 4" size.
$7.50

Mr. Tod's Individual Blueberry Cobbler
Juicy blueberries baked to bubbly perfection. 🫐
$7.75

Mr. Tod's 4" Chocolate Pecan Pie
Chocolate. Pecans. Mini. Dangerous. 😍
$7.50

Mr. Tod's Mini Pasteis De Nata
The perfect European breakfast! These world-famous pastries come from a recipe dating back to 17th century Portugal, and you can taste that history in every delicious bite of these pasteis de natas. They are the perfect compliment to your morning espresso! Flaky and buttery! Each pastry is hand-crafted with our golden puff-pastry dough; a labor-intensive recipe that is baked with care. It gives each bite that signature crunch that keeps pastry-lovers coming back for seconds. Creamy and sweet! 
$5.25

Mr. Tod's 4" Blueberry Crumb Pie
Maine wild blueberries in a flaky crust, finished with a buttery crumb topping made from Plugrá European-style butter. A perfectly portioned classic.
$8.75

Mr. Tod's Mini Key Lime Pie
A perfectly balanced Southern Key Lime Pie made with fresh key lime juice and a graham cracker crust. Smooth, creamy, and refreshingly tart — the perfect single-serving indulgence.

$6.99

Beverages

Premium beverages

Acqua Panna - Premium Still Water (8.45 fl oz)
Smooth Tuscan
$3.99

Tropicana Pure Premium® 100% Orange Juice (11 oz)
Tropicana Pure Premium® 100% Orange Juice (11 oz) — chilled, no pulp.
$3.49

Premium Hot Chocolate (12 oz)
Rich Ghirardelli chocolate blended with steamed milk and finished with cocoa and whipped cream.
$5.95

Premium Hot Chocolate (16 oz)
Rich Ghirardelli chocolate blended with steamed milk and finished with cocoa and whipped cream.
$6.95

Mr. Tod’s Brick City Brew (Coffee & Espresso)

Mr. Tod’s signature Brick City Brew™ — a smooth Colombian roast, plus cappuccinos, lattes, mochas, and more. Perfect with our famous pies.

Mr. Tod’s Brick City Brew™ Coffee (12oz)
Our signature Brick City Brew™ — smooth Colombian roast, bold and balanced. Perfect anytime, especially with a slice of pie.
$3.49

Mr. Tod’s Brick City Brew™ Coffee (16oz)
Mr. Tod’s signature Brick City Brew™ in a larger 16oz pour. A smooth, bold Colombian roast that pairs perfectly with our famous pies.
$3.99

Mr. Tod’s Iced Brick City Brew™  (16oz)
Our signature Brick City Brew™, chilled and poured over ice. Smooth, bold Colombian roast — refreshing and perfect with pie.
$3.99

Mr. Tod’s Iced Brick City Brew™  (20oz)
Brick City Brew™ in a larger 20oz iced pour. Smooth Colombian roast, crisp and refreshing. The perfect all-day pick-me-up.
$4.49

Mr. Tod’s Americano (12oz)
Smooth espresso poured over hot water for a bold, clean cup. Simple, strong, and satisfying with any dessert.
$3.99

Mr. Tod’s Cappuccino (12oz)
Rich espresso topped with velvety steamed milk and a light foam crown. A classic cappuccino, crafted to pair with our desserts.
$5.49

Mr. Tod’s Cappuccino (16oz)
Espresso with steamed milk and foamy finish, made in our signature style. Perfect with any pie slice or treat.
$5.99

Mr. Tod’s Latte (12oz)
Smooth espresso blended with silky steamed milk. Creamy, balanced, and made to enjoy with our pies.
$5.49

Mr. Tod’s Latte (16oz)
Espresso and steamed milk poured to perfection. A larger latte to keep you fueled all day.
$5.99

Mr. Tod’s Mocha -Ghirardelli (12oz)
Espresso, rich cocoa, and steamed milk blended together. A chocolate lover’s dream with a pie on the side.
$5.99

Mr. Tod’s Mocha -Ghirardelli (16oz)
Our espresso meets cocoa and milk for a creamy, indulgent mocha. Perfect with our classic desserts.
$6.49

4" Individual Pies

Each pie serves one person and is individually packaged.

Mr. Tod's 4" Sweet Potato Pie
Perfectly portioned Sweet Potato Pie for one (or two if you share 😉).
$7.50

Mr. Tod's 4" Buttermilk Coconut Pie
Coconut + buttermilk magic in a personal-sized pie. 🥥
$7.50

Mr. Tod's 4" Pecan Pie
Little pie, big flavor. Classic pecan in a perfect 4" size.
$7.50

Mr. Tod's Mini Pasteis De Nata
The perfect European breakfast! These world-famous pastries come from a recipe dating back to 17th century Portugal, and you can taste that history in every delicious bite of these pasteis de natas. They are the perfect compliment to your morning espresso! Flaky and buttery! Each pastry is hand-crafted with our golden puff-pastry dough; a labor-intensive recipe that is baked with care. It gives each bite that signature crunch that keeps pastry-lovers coming back for seconds. Creamy and sweet! 
$5.25

Mr. Tod's 4" Chocolate Pecan Pie
Chocolate. Pecans. Mini. Dangerous. 😍
$7.50

Mr. Tod's 4" Blueberry Crumb Pie
Maine wild blueberries in a flaky crust, finished with a buttery crumb topping made from Plugrá European-style butter. A perfectly portioned classic.
$8.75

Mr. Tod's 4" Apple Crumb Pie
Fresh apples, hand-spiced with cinnamon and sugar, topped with a golden brown crumb topping. Baked to perfection for a classic single-serve apple pie experience.

$8.75

Mr. Tod's Mini Key Lime Pie
A perfectly balanced Southern Key Lime Pie made with fresh key lime juice and a graham cracker crust. Smooth, creamy, and refreshingly tart — the perfect single-serving indulgence.

$6.99

Mr. Tod’s 4" Lemon Chess Pie
A personal-sized Southern classic. This 4" lemon chess pie features a rich, tangy custard baked in a flaky, golden crust. Sweet, tart, and unforgettable.
$7.50

Mr. Tod's 4" Peach Crumb Pie
Sweet Southern-style peach filling topped with a buttery crumb made from European butter and brown sugar.
$8.75

Sweet Potato Cobbler
Our signature sweet potato pie filling baked in a cup with all-butter dumplings underneath — warm, rich, and soul-satisfying.
$7.75

10" Pies

Mr. Tod's 10" Sweet Potato Pie
Rich, creamy Southern sweet potato pie baked fresh in our signature flaky crust.
$37.50

Mr. Tod's 10" Buttermilk Coconut Pie
Sweet buttermilk custard blended with shredded coconut in a buttery crust.

$37.50

Mr. Tod’s 10" Lemon Chess Pie
A Southern classic made from scratch with fresh lemon juice, pure butter, and a smooth custard filling baked in a flaky, handmade crust. Bright, rich, and perfectly sweet-tart.
$37.50

Individual Fruit Cobblers

Mr. Tod's Individual Peach Cobbler
Fresh peaches baked under golden cobbler topping. Comfort in every spoonful. 🍑
$7.75

Mr. Tod's Individual Apple Cobbler
Warm apples, cinnamon spice, buttery cobbler top. 🍏 Classic comfort.
$7.75

Mr. Tod's Individual Blueberry Cobbler
Juicy blueberries baked to bubbly perfection. 🫐
$7.75

Milkshakes & Ice Cream

Where pie meets ice cream. Our signature shakes blend whole slices of Mr. Tod’s Pies with rich, creamy ice cream — finished with whipped cream & toppings.

Mr. Tod’s Chocolate Pecan Explosion Milkshake
A true indulgence — each shake is blended with half of a 4" scratch-made  chocolate pecan pie, topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle. Over-the-top, unforgettable, and worth every sip.
$13.49

Mr. Tod’s Classic Milkshake
Our 16 oz Tahitian Vanilla milkshake, topped with whipped cream. Switch it up with Strawberry, Butter Pecan, or Death by Chocolate. Add toppings for the perfect indulgence.
$10.99

Mr. Tod’s 2 Scoops Cup (12 oz)
Two scoops of ultra-premium ice cream in a 12 oz cup. Pick any two flavors: Tahitian Vanilla, Strawberry, Butter Pecan, or Death by Chocolate. Add toppings for the sundae experience.
$6.99

Individual Cheesecakes

Mr. Tod's NY Style Individual Cheesecake
Classic 7 oz New York–style cheesecake made with rich Philadelphia cream cheese, eggs, sour cream, lemon zest & real vanilla. Baked low and slow in a water bath for a dense, creamy finish.
$7.99

Mr. Tod's NY Style Individual Chocolate Swirl Cheesecake
Our 7 oz signature cheesecake swirled with rich chocolate for a marbled finish. Baked from scratch with Philly cream cheese, eggs & vanilla. Creamy, decadent, and made to impress.
$7.99

Mr. Tod's NY Style Individual Strawberry Cheesecake
Smooth NY-style cheesecake topped with real strawberry sauce made in-house using fresh strawberries. A perfect 7 oz balance of creamy, fruity, and tangy.
$8.49

Mr. Tod’s NY Style Individual Salted Caramel Cheesecake
Small-batch cheesecake on a buttery graham cracker crust, finished with swirls of caramel and a dash of sea salt. Creamy, rich, and individually portioned for the perfect indulgence.
$7.99

Mr. Tod's NY Style Reese's Cheesecake
Rich, creamy cheesecake blended with real Reese’s peanut butter and topped with crushed Reese’s pieces. Made fresh in-house for the perfect sweet-and-salty bite.
$8.49

Cupcakes

TEXAS-SIZED RED VELVET
A jumbo red velvet cake baked Texas-style and topped with smooth cream cheese icing and a dusting of cocoa. Soft, rich, and ridiculously good with our coffee and hot chocolate.
$6.50

Carrot Muffin with Cream Cheese Icing & Walnuts
Scratch-baked carrot muffin made with real shredded carrots, warm spices, and European butter. Finished with our house-made cream cheese icing and topped with chopped walnuts. Moist, comforting, and made with love.
$6.50

Breakfast

Buttermilk Waffle
Our signature buttermilk waffle with a golden crust, served with butter and maple syrup and fresh blueberries.
$12.95

½ Dozen Assorted Cake Donuts
A premium mix of our scratch-made cake donuts — cinnamon-sugar, glazed, sprinkle, and maple-pecan. Made with real butter and buttermilk for that classic old-fashioned bite.
$29.99

Bagel with Cream Cheese
Freshly toasted bagel generously spread with smooth cream cheese.
$4.99

Bagel with Butter
Freshly toasted bagel with real butter — simple, warm, and classic.
$3.99

BEC on a bagel
Classic bacon, egg & cheese on a toasted bagel — hearty, melty, and made to order.
$11.49

BEC on a croissant
Flaky, buttery croissant stacked with crispy bacon, fresh egg & melted cheese.
$12.49

Mr. Tod’s Traditional Donuts
Hand-glazed and soft inside, available in chocolate, vanilla, or sprinkled — made fresh daily.
$4.99

Portuguese Roll with Butter
A warm Portuguese roll, lightly toasted and buttered - a New Jersey breakfast classic.
$3.25

Lite Lunch

Tuna on Toast
House-made fresh tuna on your choice of bagel or croissant.  Served with a pickle spear.
$14.95

TURKEY, CHEDDAR & APPLEWOOD BACON CROISSANT
Flaky all-butter croissant filled with roasted turkey, sharp cheddar cheese, and extra-thick applewood-smoked bacon, finished with crisp lettuce. Warm, savory, and built for lunch.
$16.95

Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy