Carissa's Bakery - Pantigo Rd Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Carissa's Bakery - Pantigo Rd
Sign In / Sign Up

Carissa's Bakery

221 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton, NY
Loading
Online ordering hours: 8:30 AM - 2:40 PM
Opens at 8:30 AM

Featured Items

Carissas x Leset Sweatshirt
$132.00
6" Flourless Chocolate Cake with Meringue
$66.00
Chicken Pot Pie
$55.00
Carrot Cake
$55.00
6" Flourless Chocolate Cake with Berries
$60.50
6" Apple Honey Cake
$49.50
Kettl Kohata Matcha Powder
$52.80
French Style Cheese Cake 6”
$44.00
Pastry Box
$36.30
Individual Seasonal Market Salad
$23.10
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
$19.80
Roast Beef Sandwich
$19.80
Avocado Toast
$18.70
Algae Cooking Nara's Roasted Garlic Oil
$30.80
Restorative Chicken Soup Quart
$26.40
Chicken Bahn Mi
$19.80
Jambon Beurre Sandwich
$17.60
Sourdough Half Boule
$14.30
Smoked Salmon Sandwich
$19.80
Carissa's Custom Blend Decaf Coffee
$26.40
Beet + Kimchi Reuben
$22.00
Chicken Salad
$16.50
Full Menu
8:30 am - 2:40 pm

Most Ordered

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Smoked Turkey Sandwich

Nitrate-free turkey, kohlrabi slaw, green tomatoes, romaine, and smoked tomato aioli, on house-baked ciabatta.
$19.80

Jambon Beurre Sandwich

Our first sandwich, based on the French classic. French ham with cornichon pickles and butter served on a baguette.
$17.60

Individual Seasonal Market Salad

Large seasonal salad of greens, radicchios, carrots, radishes and fennel with a shallot mustard dressing, topped with roasted almonds and a cube of Meredith Dairy cheese. (GF)
$23.10

Miso Chocolate Chunk Cookie

A twist on a classic favorite. Our Miso Chocolate Chunk Cookie features rich, nutty browned butter, chocolate chunks, and a hint of white miso for a deeply satisfying, subtly savory finish. Allergens: Contains wheat, dairy, eggs, soy.
$5.50

Chicken Bahn Mi

Pulled chicken, pickled daikon, carrots, fresnos, cucumber, cilantro with garlic aioli on a baguette
$19.80

Latte

Our proprietary espresso blend + steamed milk of your choice.
$7.15

Roast Beef Sandwich

House roasted beef, arugula, pickled mustard seeds, horseradish cream and served on baguette.
$19.80

Chicken Salad

With celery, mayonnaise, lemon juice and zest.
$16.50

Bread

Gluten Free Seeded Bread

Gluten-free bread with rice and tapioca flours, plus corn and potato starch. Coated in a crunchy seed mix: sesame, pumpkin, sunflower, chia, and poppy.
$13.20

Salted Soured Pickled Rye

Baked with whole wheat, rye, pickles, brine, caraway seeds, our natural sour starter, and salt.
$9.35

Sourdough Half Boule

There’s no yeast in this loaf — it’s naturally leavened with our own sourdough starter, first cultivated in 1965 and still fed daily. The result is a slow, living fermentation that creates remarkable depth of flavor and character. Vegan.
$14.30

Pickled Rye Crisps

Thinly sliced crisps of our salted soured pickled bread.
$13.20

Cubed Stuffing Bread

A mixture of our sourdough, baguette, pickled rye and ciabatta breads.
$13.20

Viennoiseries

Pistachio Chocolate Croissant

Chocolate croissant filled with pistachio ganache.
$9.90

Blackberry Almond Croissant

Filled with blackberry-almond cream. Allergens: gluten, nuts, dairy
$9.90

Almond Croissant

A sweeter version of our butter croissant, filled with frangipane, topped with sliced almonds, and garnished with confectioner’s sugar.
$9.90

Prosciutto + Gruyere Croissant

Prosciutto coto, gruyere cheese and grainy Dijon mustard.
$8.25

Raisin Snail

Our croissant dough filled with almond frangipane and golden raisins, rolled up and topped with an apricot glaze.
$6.60

Morning Bun

Our laminated croissant dough layered with cinnamon and sugar, shaped to showcase its delicate layers and baked until golden with a crisp, caramelized finish.
$6.60

Palmier

Puff pastry dough, thinly sliced, baked with sugar, and shaped like a palm. Also known as an "elephant ear." Contains: wheat, dairy, egg.
$8.80

Pastry Box

Assortment of 5 of our favorite pastries.
$36.30

Le Boursin Croissant

A buttery, flaky croissant typically filled with creamy Boursin cheese, offering a rich and savory twist on the classic Viennese pastry.
$11.00

Confections

Savory Scone

Feta spinach and scallions. Allergies: gluten, dairy, citrus, allium
$7.70

Tea Cake

Baked with our organic Olive oil, this season’s tea cake has a blood orange glaze.
$11.00

Miso Chocolate Chunk Cookie

A twist on a classic favorite. Our Miso Chocolate Chunk Cookie features rich, nutty browned butter, chocolate chunks, and a hint of white miso for a deeply satisfying, subtly savory finish. Allergens: Contains wheat, dairy, eggs, soy.
$5.50

Double Chocolate Chip & Hazelnut Cookie GF

Gluten free, contains nuts.
$8.80

Financier

Almond cake with a crisp edge and soft center, filled with raspberry jam.
$5.50

Macaron Set of Four GF

Assorted flavors. GF. Contains almond flour.
$11.00

Miso Chococolate Chunk Cookie Dough

Miso chocolate chunk cookie dough combines rich chocolate chunks with savory miso, offering a unique twist on classic cookie dough, typically featuring a balance of sweet and salty flavors.
$27.50

Cakes Tarts & Pies

6" Apple Honey Cake

Moist cake with carmelized apples on top. Serves 6 to 8. Allergens: dairy, gluten
$49.50

Carrot Cake

Spiced layers of carrot cake , cream cheese frosting and tart layer of cranberry confit. Serve 6-8 people.
$55.00

Fig Tart

Almond frangipane base with mascarpone whipped cream, fig and orange peel marmalade, and fresh figs on top. Contains: Dairy, gluten, citrus, nuts.
$71.50

Chicken Pot Pie

Our classic, all butter pie crust which includes locally grown freshly milled wheat, chicken chunks Leeks, carrots, celery, onions, peas, spices + herbs. This product is frozen and requires re-heating. Serves 8. Contains: Egg, wheat, dairy, alliums
$55.00

6" Flourless Chocolate Cake with Meringue

Chocolate flourless cake with meringue peaks, chocolate pearls and gold leaf . Gluten and nut free. Please note we do not offer writing on our cakes.
$66.00

6" Flourless Chocolate Cake with Berries

A more traditional flourless cake with berries and a sprinkle of powdered sugar. Please note we do not offer writing on our cakes.
$60.50

French Style Cheese Cake 6”

Fluffy and creamy French-style cheesecake with lady finger crumb base. Topped with seasonal fruit. Serves 6-8. Please note we do not offer writing on our cakes.
$44.00

Marble Pound Cake Slice

This dense, buttery cake is marbled with delicate swirls of vanilla and chocolate, offering a beautifully balanced flavor in every slice. Enveloped in rich dark chocolate and accented with caramelized puffed rice for a touch of crisp texture. Contains: Gluten, dairy.
$11.00

Sorbet & Gelato Pints

Chocolate Sorbet

Vegan
$15.40

Coconut Sorbet

Vegan.
$15.40

Vanilla Bean Gelato

Contains dairy.
$15.40

Turkish Coffee Gelato

Contains dairy.
$15.40

Blackberry Sorbet

Vegan.
$15.40

Cassis Sorbet

Vegan.
$15.40

Purple Fig Sorbet

Vegan.
$15.40

Spicy Mango Sorbet

Vegan.
$15.40

All Day Sandwiches & Salads

Avocado Toast

Avocado mash with mixed greens, parsley, and fava beans on sourdough with shallot dressing.
$18.70

Individual Seasonal Market Salad

Large seasonal salad of greens, radicchios, carrots, radishes and fennel with a shallot mustard dressing, topped with roasted almonds and a cube of Meredith Dairy cheese. (GF)
$23.10

Individual Seasonal Farro Bowl

Farro, roasted & fresh vegetables, mixed green lettuce, green tahini - DF V
$19.80

Smoked Salmon Sandwich

Catsmo smoked salmon, chive crème fraiche, cucumbers served on pickled rye bread
$19.80

Chicken Bahn Mi

Pulled chicken, pickled daikon, carrots, fresnos, cucumber, cilantro with garlic aioli on a baguette
$19.80

Smoked Turkey Sandwich

Nitrate-free turkey, kohlrabi slaw, green tomatoes, romaine, and smoked tomato aioli, on house-baked ciabatta.
$19.80

Jambon Beurre Sandwich

Our first sandwich, based on the French classic. French ham with cornichon pickles and butter served on a baguette.
$17.60

Roast Beef Sandwich

House roasted beef, arugula, pickled mustard seeds, horseradish cream and served on baguette.
$19.80

Roasted Brussels Sprout Sandwich

Shaved and roasted Brussels sprouts, Vaca Rosa parmesan, fresno chili hot sauce and preserved lemon aioli served on baguette.
$19.80

Beet + Kimchi Reuben

Roasted beets with kimchi slaw, gruyere cheese, and Russian dressing on sourdough.
$22.00

Coffee & Tea

Drip Coffee

Our proprietary blend of specialty grade, single-origin coffees from East Africa and South America. This all-year blend is full-bodied and balanced in flavor. A medium-dark roast that leans slightly darker.
$5.50

Cold Brew

A medium-dark roast that leans slightly darker .
$6.60

Americano

Our proprietary espresso blend + water.
$6.05

Espresso

Our proprietary blend of specialty grade, single-origin coffees from East Africa and South America. This all-year blend is full-bodied and balanced in flavor. A medium-dark roast that leans slightly darker.
$5.50

Latte

Our proprietary espresso blend + steamed milk of your choice.
$7.15

Cappuccino

Our proprietary espresso blend + steamed milk foam of your choice.
$6.60

Flat White

Our proprietary espresso blend + mircofoam.
$6.05

Macchiato

Our proprietary espresso blend + a small amount of steamed milk.
$5.50

Cortado

Our proprietary espresso blend + equal parts steamed milk.
$6.05

Matcha

Vibrant and invigorating, our Matcha is round and silky with a balanced sweetness and pervasive finish. This is our top tier Usucha, or thin grade of matcha from Yame. This very special matcha green tea offers a deep rich flavor with a powerful fragrance and embodies a truly refined Usucha experience.
$7.70

Matcha Latte

Vibrant and invigorating, our Shinme Matcha is round and silky with a balanced sweetness and pervasive finish. This is our top tier Usucha, or thin grade of matcha from Yame. This very special matcha green tea offers a deep rich flavor with a powerful fragrance and embodies a truly refined Usucha experience.
$8.80

Iced Blackberry Matcha Latte

Ceremonial grade Kettl Tea matcha over ice with house made blackberry syrup.
$11.00

Golden Milk Latte

Organic blend of tumeric, cinnamon, ginger, cardamom and black pepper.
$6.60

Hot Tea

All options are organic.
$7.70

Iced Black Tea

An aromatic blend of organic Ceylon tea served over ice.
$5.50

Iced Hibiscus Tea

Vibrant hibiscus tea infused with citrus slices and garnished with fresh mint leaves.
$6.60

Ginger Tumeric Honey Tea

Made with fresh ginger, tumeric and honey from our bee hives.
$8.80

Juices & Bottled Drinks

Fresh Orange Juice

Freshly squeezed every morning with seasonal oranges.
$8.80

Limeade

House squeezed limeade, a little sweet.
$8.80

Limeade-Iced Tea Mix

A Carissa's take on a classic.
$7.70

Iced Hibiscus Cooler

A refreshing blend of hibiscus with citrus notes, garnished with a slice of orange and fresh mint leaves.
$8.80

Green Fennel Juice

Freshly blended juice featuring fennel, typically combined with cucumber, spinach, celery, and green apple for a refreshing, nutrient-rich beverage.
$13.20

Matcha Limeade

Vibrant blend of matcha and lime with a hint of mint, garnished with a lemon slice.
$11.00

Loonen Still Water

Spring-sourced water with balanced minerality and a crisp, refreshing taste. Filtered for purity, with a smooth finish, and bottled exclusively in glass.
$4.00+

Loonen Sparkling Water

Spring-sourced water with balanced minerality and a crisp, refreshing taste. Filtered for purity, with a smooth finish, and bottled exclusively in glass.
$4.00+

United Ferments Jasmine Green Tea

Sourced from hand-rolled green tea pearls, naturally scented over multiple rounds with fresh jasmine blossoms—no artificial perfumes, no shortcuts. This ferment softens jasmine’s intensity, offering a layered expression of its floral character. Notes of eucalyptus, tuberose, and green peach unfold gently with each sip. Pairs beautifully with stone fruits, delicate broths, or soft-ripened cheeses. Serve chilled and allow the aromatics to open as it comes to temperature. Ingredients: Filtered water, sugar, kombucha starter, jasmine green tea pearls.
$35.20

C. Cassis N.A.

A refreshing 0% blackcurrant aperitif made with vibrant botanicals, citrus, and subtle bitters. A grown-up alternative for when you’re not drinking— lightly sweetened with honey, packed with antioxidants and vitamin C.
$37.40

Soups

Restorative Chicken Soup Quart

This soup takes inspiration from southeast Asia with medicinal herbs, and ginger. Served with a side of rice, cilantro and lime garnish.
$26.40

Leek and Potato Soup Quart

Dairy free.
$26.40

White Bean Kale Minestrone Soup Quart

$26.40

Sides

Hummus

Chickpeas, tahini, lemon juice, garlic, olive oil.
$8.80

Whitefish Salad

With onions, celery, white pepper, mayo & lemon juice. 1/2 pint.
$16.50

Chicken Salad

With celery, mayonnaise, lemon juice and zest.
$16.50

Merchandise

The Breakfast Box Gift Set

This package serves 6 people and includes 1 Box of Carissa's Signature Coffee (12 oz.) 1 Jar of Four Berry Jam (8 oz.) 1 Jar of Seasonal Preserve (8 oz.) 1 Package of Granola (16oz) 1 Loaf of Pickled Rye or GF Seeded Bread
$94.60

Carissa's Nylon Embroidered Hat


A lightweight six-panel nylon cap with an adjustable Velcro® closure.
$57.20

Carissa's x Leset Apron

Carissa's x Leset apron typically includes durable fabric and adjustable straps, designed for everyday kitchen use.
$66.00

Carissas x Leset Sweatshirt

LESET'S Oversized Fleeced Hoodie is a game-changer. With its ultra-soft fleece and bold oversized fit, it’s the perfect piece to elevate any collection. 42% cotton, 53% polyester, 5% other fibers
$132.00

Lefa Tote Basket

Chic shopping basket made of Lefa, a durable leather, and natural latex fiber. Aluminum handles. Take it to the market, beach or a picnic. Gift it filled with Carissa's favorites.
$66.00

Pamela Hanson: The '90s

A new book by our friend Pamela Hanson revisits her iconic 1990s fashion images — intimate, energetic photographs of the era’s most recognizable faces, captured through her distinctive female gaze. Fresh, timeless, and beautifully of its moment.
$82.50

Simply Ina

Simply Ina is a collection of comforting, approachable recipes from Ina Garten, celebrating the pleasure of good food and gathering around the table. We're delighted that Carissa's Bakery's signature avocado toast is featured inside!
$38.50

Ina Garten-Go-To Dinners

A collection of Ina Garten's signature dinner recipes, offering classic American dishes that typically include comforting, home-cooked meals inspired by her culinary expertise.
$38.50

Ina Garten Be Ready When the Luck Happens: A Memoir

A memoir by Ina Garten, sharing personal stories and insights on embracing unexpected opportunities in life.
$38.50

Ina Garten Cooking for Jeffrey

Ina Garten finds joy in cooking for loved ones, especially her husband, Jeffrey. Cooking for Jeffrey, her most personal cookbook, features their favorite recipes and charming stories from their 48 years together. It includes updated classics like Brisket with Onions and Tsimmes, plus new favorites like Skillet-Roasted Lemon Chicken. Salads range from Maple-Roasted Carrot to Kale with Pancetta, while desserts span Apple Pie Bars to Vanilla Rum Panna Cotta. A new bread and cheese chapter offers delights like Fig and Goat Cheese Bruschettas. With Ina’s tested recipes, you can cook with confidence for those you love.
$38.50

Eric Ripert Vegetable Simple

A collection of simple vegetable recipes by renowned chef Eric Ripert, typically featuring fresh, seasonal produce with straightforward preparation methods for home cooking.
$38.50

Unplugged: Adventures from MTV to Timbuktu

A memoir detailing the journey from MTV to global adventures, exploring diverse cultures and personal growth.
$33.00

The S@#t I've Heard at Yoga: What I Learned in Downward Dog by Michael J. Norton

S@#t I’ve Heard at Yoga is a collection of humorous, unexpected, and insightful essays that reveals how yoga helped a Type A cynic transform to a Type Y(oga) optimist.
$20.90

Coffee & Tea

Carissa's Custom Blend Drip Coffee

Our very own medium-dark blend of arabica beans, with tasting notes of cream, dark chocolate, and cherry. Freshly roasted by our friends at Shared Roasting in Brooklyn.
$26.40

Carissa's Custom Blend Decaf Coffee

Our very own decaffeinated medium-dark blend of arabica beans, with tasting notes of cream, dark chocolate, and cherry. Freshly roasted by our friends at Shared Roasting in Brooklyn.
$26.40

Carissa's Columbian Blend Coffee

Grown by a high quality family producer. This is a high altitude, handpicked coffee grown in rich soil surrounding the Nevado del Huila volcano. Sweet citrus and stone fruit flavors.
$38.50

Carissa's Custom Blend Coffee 5lb Bag

5lbs of our very own medium-dark blend of arabica beans, with tasting notes of cream, dark chocolate, and cherry. Freshly roasted by our friends at Shared Roasting in Brooklyn.
$99.00

Kettl Seisho Matcha

Matcha from Kettl's Seisho, whisked with water, typically offering a smooth and earthy flavor profile.
$39.60

Kettl Kohata Matcha Powder

A best in class blended matcha from the famed Kohata Region of Uji in Kyoto. An elegant, lighter bodied matcha - Kohata is soft and pillowy with a rich fragrance and a slightly nutty, balanced umami.
$52.80

Kettl Wakoucha Black Tea Bags 12pcs

Wakoucha is a peerless black tea handcrafted in Fukuoka, Japan. A blend of the Yabukita and Tsuyuhikari cultivars, this full leaf black tea offers a rich aroma, soft sweetness and understated savory finish. Artisinal yet approachable, our Wakoucha represents a new level of quality not seen before in a bagged tea. 12 x 3g individually wrapped bags per box.
$20.90

Kettl Tea Genmaimatcha Tea Bags 12pcs

Genmaicha or Brown rice tea is simply a blend of green tea, sencha, and roasted brown rice. The combination of nutty sweetness from the rice and refreshing grassiness from the green tea makes for a cup that is pleasant and easy to enjoy. We add a touch of matcha which adds a depth of color and more developed sweetness.
$20.90

Kettl Tea Houjicha Tea Bags 12pcs

Houjicha refers to a style of Japanese green tea that undergoes a secondary process of roasting. While many green teas undergo "hiire" - a type of firing to adjust moisture and bring out sweetness and balance - the roasting applied to houjicha is completely different. Roasting the green tea imbues it with a nutty, toasty fragrance and lowers the overall caffeine content of the tea making it the perfect accompaniment to food as well as an everyday classic.
$20.90

Kettl Tea Soba Cha Tea Bags 12 pcs

Soba Cha Tea is crafted from heirloom buckwheat sourced from the pristine mountainside of Nagano, Japan. 100% caffeine free, our loose and bagged soba cha have a deep, satisfying flavor and aroma.
$20.90

Fleurs D'Hiver Herbal Tea Lollipops

Inspired by a passion for organic produce, Fleurs d’hiver brings you a range of small batch, unique hand made teas. Gathered from artisan growers, dried herbs and flowers are encased in a golden disk of a honey caramel. When submerged in warm water the honey melts, the plants release and infuse to create a truly unique experience.
$11.00

Postcard Tea Lemon Pekoe

This bright and fragrant blend is a citrus-forward take on a traditional Earl Grey, using pure Sicilian lemon oil in place of bergamot. The oil is cold-pressed by essential oil pioneer Gianfranco Todisco, who selects the finest naturally grown lemons, cultivated without chemicals, for this distinctive tea. Blended in London, the base combines black teas from small farms in Darjeeling and Kerala, chosen to complement Todisco’s aromatic lemon oil. The result is a lively, sherbet-like cup with a smooth sweetness and zesty finish—an excellent alternative for those who enjoy citrus-scented blends.
$16.50

Dairy & Meats

Meredith Dairy Goat Cheese

soft, spreadable goat cheese, marinated in blended Australian extra virgin olive oil, garlic and herbs. This luxurious cheese is incredibly addictive and versatile.
$15.40

Kriemhild Dairy Unsalted Butter

Meadow Butter is made is small batches only during the growing season when the cow's are grazing on quality, fresh pasture grasses. 100% grass-fed milk from a single family farm, Red Gate Farm in Hamilton, NY. This sweet cream butter is churned slowly and finished with an 85% butterfat, resulting in a decadently rich smooth textured butter.
$20.90

Pepe Saya Salted Cultured Butter

Churned by the Amish from farm fresh cream that has been cultured, creating crème fraiche, and then batch churned to create the unique creamy, tangy flavour.
$15.40

TÁCHE Pistachio Milk Unsweetened

The Unsweetened version is deliciously well-rounded and Keto-friendly. It has a naturally nutty flavor that's light and refreshing. We source our pistachios specifically for their flavor profile, so there's no watery nut-milk here.
$9.90

Oatly

Barista edition oatmilk that makes ideal foam for lattes, but can also be utilized in other drinks. LIMIT 4 PER ORDER.
$9.90

White Moustache Kiss

The Kiss yogurts are thick, Greek-style flavored with orange blossom honey and chopped toasted walnuts.
$8.80

White Moustache Greek

White Moustache Greek yogurt typically includes whole milk and live probiotic cultures, offering a creamy texture and rich taste, inspired by traditional Greek yogurt-making methods.
$8.25

La Salumina N’duja

A soft, spicy, spreadable pork sausage from the Calabrian region of Italy.
$16.50

Tinned Fish & Vegetables

Row 7 Sweet Garleek Tin

Garlic-leek hybrid cooked confit-style in a bright, sweet-savory vinaigrette. Bold allium flavor, bright acid backbone—mellow enough to eat by the forkful. Organic.
$12.10

Row 7 Badger Flame Beets Tin

Golden, mild, and sweet, without the earthiness that turns people off. These Badger Flame beets are cooked tender and packed in a bright vinaigrette, so they're ready to enjoy straight from the tin - no roasting, no peeling, just sweet, vibrant flavor in every bite. Organic.
$12.10

Row 7 Sweet Prince Tomatoes Tin

Row 7 captured peak-summer perfection in a tin. Sweet Prince tomatoes, bursting with intensity—sweet, bright, and bold, with the depth of slow-roasted tomatoes. Organic.

$12.10

Conserverie Ferrigno Trio

Lemon, ratatouille, and pissaladiere
$39.60

Fangst Færøsk Laks Faroe Islands Salmon

Its remote location in the North Atlantic, clear waters, cool steady temperatures, strong currents and protected fjords make the Faroe Islands the perfect place for salmon. Here people have lived off the ocean for centuries and have strong traditions for respecting nature’s resources. This is also reflected in high standards for sustainability in local fish farming. This FANGST salmon has been flash grilled and preserved in cold pressed rapeseed oil.
$13.20

Fangst Freshwater Danish Trout

Smoked wiith juniper and lemon thyme. In his childhood, Martin co-founder of FANGST, enjoyed his many visits on trout farms with his father, a biologist dedicated to developing World class farming of trout in Danish freshwater. In this can, we have preserved a bit of that memory - and some delicious smoked trout with juniper and lemon thyme.
$13.20

Yurrita Bonito Del Norte White Tuna in Jar

Chunks of Bonito del Norte from the coast of the Bay of Biscay. They are caught during the summer months using traditional fishing methods through sustainable fishing management. After carefully selecting the freshest tuna, cutting and selecting the belly, the fillets are boiled and cleaned to get rid of the outer skin by expert hands who for generations have worked preparing these canned products. Sliced by hand and packed in olive oil.
$22.00

Yurrita Cantabrico Anchovies in Olive Oil

Anchovies from the Cantabrian Sea. Meaty and tender with an excellent flavor and texture. Salted and hand-packed in traditional tins and cured for at least 20 months by Yurrita - the oldest canning company in the Basque Country and one of the oldest agrifood industries in operation in Spain. 50g (1.76 oz) tin
$13.20

Jose Gourmet Mackerel Fillets in Olive Oil

The traditional abundance of mackerel in Portuguese waters, and its frequent intake has provided it with a special status at our table. Captured in the north-eastern Atlantic Ocean, this fish represents a food product which has attracted increasing interest, motivated by scientific evidence regarding its nutritional properties.
$14.30

Jose Gourmet Sardines with Lemon & Olive Oil

Atlantic and Mediterranean, our delicious sardines are kept fresh from the moment they are caught. They become even tastier and nutritionally rich with the lemon that flavours the olive oil. Savour this flavour with a bit of rustic bread or toasts, accompanied by a nice glass of white or red wine.
$12.10

Conserverie Ferrigno Sardines with Candied Lemon

Indulge in the exquisite blend of flavors with Ferrigno's Sardines, meticulously handcrafted in France and infused with the zesty charm of candied lemon, tender onions, and vibrant green olives. Each tin, containing 115g of culinary delight, showcases the finest sardines from the Eastern Central Atlantic Ocean or Mediterranean Sea, steamed to perfection.
$13.20

Jose Gourmet Spiced Mackerel Pate

A blue fish (mackerel) pâté with a creamy texture and the softly spicy aroma
$8.80

Jose Gourmet Smoked Salmon In Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Tender smoked salmon delicately preserved in extra virgin olive oil, offering a rich and savory taste experience.
$14.30

Jose Gourmet Spiced Calamari in Ragout Sauce

Flavored with spices, pepper, cloves and laurel, the simplicity of this recipe guarantees the quality and freshness of the fish. Coming from the Atlantic Ocean and the Pacific Ocean, the squid selected to make this stew offer the nutrients needed for the well-being and health of the body. For those who have tried it and for those who have never tasted it, this delicious delicacy is essential.
$16.50

Jose Gourmet Octopus In Olive Oil

Contains garlic
$24.20

La Narval Galician Razor Clams in Sea Water

Tender Galician razor clams immersed in sea water, capturing the essence of the ocean.
$17.60

La Narval Galician Mussels with Garlic and Chili

Galician mussels in a garlic and chili sauce, offering a savory and spicy flavor profile.
$12.10

Island Creek Scallops in Vieira Sauce

These scallops are savory and hearty in a traditional, full-bodied sauce with a floral note that lingers like a sip of jasmine tea. Excellent broiled on toast or over rice topped with fresh herbs.
$19.80

Island Creek Littleneck Clams

with confit garlic and chili in olive oil.
$24.20

Matiz Wild Sardines with Piri Piri

Wild sardines caught in Spain, handpacked with olive oil and piri piri chiles.
$8.80

Siesta Small Sardines in Yuzu Kosho

Siesta Co.'s Small Sardines in Yuzu Koshō pair the mild, delicate flavors of small sardines with the distinct, citrusy bite of yuzu koshō. These tender sardines, immersed in our premium organic extra virgin olive oil, are elevated by the unique blend of yuzu's aromatic zest and subtle spiciness.
$14.30

Miss Can Mackerel Fillets with Curry & Chili

Turn up the heat with our wild-caught mackerel fillets infused with curry and chili pepper. These flavorful fillets have just the right kick. For a quick dinner idea, toss them with basmati rice, fresh cilantro, and a squeeze of lime for a fiery twist on a classic curry bowl.
$13.20

Miss Can Stuffed Squid

Dive into deliciousness with our wild-caught stuffed squids, Portuguese style. Tender savory squid packed with a nutrients and health benefits. This is comfort food straight from the sea. Perfect for adventurous eaters or first-timers. For a simple twist, heat them up and serve over a bed of wild rice, sautéed veggies and enjoy a drizzle of olive oil.
$17.60

Miss Can Sardines in Spicy Olive Oil

Turn up the heat with our wild-caught sardines in spicy olive oil. These little powerhouses pack a punch of flavor and a boost of bone-strengthening calcium. The kick of chili brings these tender sardines to life.
$12.10

Gueyo Chargrilled Razor Clams

Wild razor clams from Asturias, Spain, lightly chargrilled over hardwood coals for a delicate smoky flavor and tender texture. Preserved in premium Castillo de Canena extra virgin olive oil, which becomes infused with the clams' rich flavor. Enjoy with crusty bread, pasta, salads, or simply with a squeeze of lemon.
$52.80

Gueyo Chargrilled Sardine Loins

Hand-trimmed sardine loins from Spain, grilled over hardwood embers and packed in Castillo de Canena Arbequina extra virgin olive oil. Tender and richly flavored with delicate smoke, natural sweetness, and exceptional live-fire depth. A 2026 SOFI Award finalist and one of our favorite conservas.
$29.70

Olive Oil, Vinegar & Sauces

Westwind Orchard Raspberry Apple Cider Vinegar

Infused with organic raspberries. Hand bottled and wax sealed by our friends at Westwind Orchard.
$26.40

Terga Gastronomie Balsamique Bianco

White Balsamic from Modena, Italy. Extraordinarily fruity, with natural notes of white peaches.
$35.20

Terga Gastronomie Fig Balsamique Vinegar

This beautiful, fruit-infused vinegar has everything you would expect from ripe Italian figs combined with a balsamic base. Perfectly blends delicate acidity with figs achieving the perfect aroma and texture meant to complement any salad, cheese plate, or marinade. Wonderful with foie gras or a seared duck breast.
$35.20

Capobianco Organic Datterino Plum Tomatoes — Trilly

Organic Italian Datterino tomatoes, prized for their naturally sweet, rich flavor. Perfect for pasta, sauces, seafood, or simply warmed with olive oil.
$17.60

Capobianco Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes — Spyro

Whole peeled organic Italian tomatoes, packed at peak ripeness. Sweet and balanced, ideal for sauces, soups, braises, and pizza.
$16.50

Capobianco Organic Spicy Arrabbiata Sauce

Robust tomato sauce with organic ingredients, featuring a spicy kick from red chili peppers, ideal for pasta dishes.
$17.60

Capobianco Organic Tomato + Basil Sauce

Rich organic tomato and basil sauce, crafted with fresh ingredients for a classic Italian flavor. Perfect for enhancing pasta dishes or as a savory base for various recipes.
$17.60

Lucesca Extra Virgin Olive Oil Mini

Perfect for everyday use in the kitchen. 100% Extra virgin olive oil. Cold extracted with Frantoio, Moraiolo, Leccino, and Pendolino olives. The mix of the four olives gives the oil a rich, buttery flavor with hints of rosemary and lemon.
$31.90

Lucesca Extra Virgin Olive Oil Ceramic Bottle

100% Extra virgin olive oil. Cold extracted with Frantoio, Moraiolo, Leccino, and Pendolino olives. The mix of the four olives gives the oil a rich, buttery flavor with hints of rosemary and lemon.
$66.00

Lucesca Virgin Olive Oil Tin

Perfect for everyday use in the kitchen. 100% Extra virgin olive oil. Cold extracted with Frantoio, Moraiolo, Leccino, and Pendolino olives. The mix of the four olives gives the oil a rich, buttery flavor with hints of rosemary and lemon.
$46.20

Agreco Farms Olive Oil - Small - Green

Full of aromas made from hand-picked olives from Agreco Farms. Fruity, unique, full-bodied flavor. Organic.
$18.70

Agreco Farms Olive Oil-Large-Pink

Full of aromas made from hand-picked olives from Agreco Farms. Fruity, unique, full-bodied flavor. Organic.
$39.60

Agreco Farms Olive Oil Ex Large-Blue

Full of aromas made from hand-picked olives from Agreco Farms. Fruity, unique, full-bodied flavor. Organic.
$71.50

Queens Gochujang

Jujube infused fermented red chili paste. Hand harvested and fermented in Apple Valley, California.
$19.80

Algae Cooking Oil

Experience the purity and versatility of chef-grade algae cooking oil, rich in good-for-cooking and good-for-you Omega-9 fats. This oil can do it all; sear, bake, roast, dressings, dips, and more.
$23.10

Algae Shiitake Mushroom Oil

Crafted with Chef Daniel Humm of Eleven Madison Park, this Shiitake Mushroom Oil delivers rich umami through a slow eight-hour infusion of six different spices. Achieving this rich, savory flavor takes hours of careful cooking and the use of unique ingredients—now conveniently captured in a bottle.
$19.80

Algae Gochugaru Chili Oil

Crafted with Chef Daniel Humm of Eleven Madison Park, this infused oil adds a touch of vibrant heat, enhancing each dish with a delicious depth. Rich in Omega-9, algae oil is Earth’s purest, light, and slightly buttery oil—perfect for bold infusions.
$19.80

Algae Cooking Nara's Roasted Garlic Oil

Algae Cooking Club Nara’s Roasted Garlic Oil is a deeply savory, aromatic oil infused with the rich flavor of slow-roasted garlic. Smooth and well-balanced, it adds warmth and depth without overpowering. Perfect as a finishing touch or cooking staple, drizzle it over pasta, roasted vegetables, pizza, or grilled meats, or mix it into dressings and marinades for an extra layer of flavor.
$30.80

Il Boschetto Chili Infused Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Immerse your senses in the rich aroma as you drizzle this chili-infused EVOO over salads, pasta, grilled vegetables, or any dish of your choice. The harmonious blend of high-quality olive oil and the fiery notes of chili creates a symphony of flavors that will leave a lasting impression on your taste buds. Whether you're a culinary enthusiast or someone looking to spice up their everyday meals, our chili-infused EVOO is the perfect addition to your kitchen arsenal.
$35.20

Laurel & Ash Farms Apple Cider Vinegar

Golden elixir starts with tart, crisp Hudson Valley apples, handpicked at their juiciest as autumn arrives. Pressed into cider, they undergo a slow fermentation before aging in New York State white oak barrels. Crafted in small batches, this raw, vibrant vinegar bursts with a perfect balance of sharp and sweet flavors. Drizzle on salads, shake up your marinades, or splash it into a shrub.
$19.80

Laurel & Ash Farms Maple Cider Vinegar

Fermented with tart and crisp Hudson Valley apples and 100% pure New York state Grade A, maple syrup, this raw and unfiltered vinegar 'with mother' is full of complex flavor. Aged for over six months in new toasted oak barrels, Laurel & Ash Farm Barrel Aged Maple Vinegar is a flavorful addition to a multitude of recipes. A unique balance of sweet and sour, this vinegar is a perfect addition to vinaigrettes, salad dressings, shrubs and cocktails.
$26.40

Giuseppe Giusti Balsamic Vinegar

Aged balsamic vinegar from Giuseppe Giusti, made in Modena since 1605. Crafted from cooked grape must and aged in historic casks, it has a rich, balanced profile with notes of mature fruit, licorice, and black pepper, with a smooth, dense finish. Ideal for salads, vegetables, and meat or fish carpaccio.
$35.20

Chocolates & Candy

Potter's Table Marshmallows

Pillowy, handmade vanilla bean marshmallows by Potters Table Bakery in Catskills, NY!
$8.80

Kettl Matcha Chocolate with Soba Crunch

Kettl's Matcha Chocolate with soba is handcrafted with shade grown, stone milled Japanese matcha, Belgian white chocolate and studded with our crunchy, nutty Nagano Soba Cha (roasted buckwheat). Each bar contains 2.5 servings of matcha and showcases the intense color, aroma and natural sweetness that only pinnacle grade matcha can provide. The added Soba adds a layer of nutty flavor and satisfying crunch
$14.30

Eclat Coffee & Cardamon Bar

Rich, dark roasted coffee and pungent, floral cardamom is a classic flavor parallel from the Middle East.
$13.20

Eclat Desert Rose Chocolate Bar

A blend of Éclat chocolate and La Boîte spices. Made with 39% Milk Chocolate infused with Desert Rose (halva, rose petals, sesame and spices).
$14.30

Eclat Dark Chocolate Dutch Pretzel

Inspired by the historical Pennsylvania Dutch Swiss and German immigrants who introduced the pretzel to America in the 1800s, this Destination bar is a 54% dark chocolate blended with Lancaster County pretzels.
$12.10

Eclat Cacao Nibs Mondiant

First of its kind, the Mondiant™ is a perfect balance of delicate filling enrobed in Éclat Chocolate’s sustainably sourced chocolate. Inspired by form and function to deliver the perfect chocolate experience. 16 pieces
$41.80

Eclat Assorted Mondiants

The modern approach to the classic mendiant. First of its kind, the Mondiant™ is a perfect balance of delicate filling enrobed in Éclat Chocolate’s sustainably sourced chocolate. Inspired by form and function to deliver the perfect chocolate experience. Flavor includes Peanut Butter, Cacao Nibs and Caramel.
$41.80

Big Picture Farms Goat Milk Caramels

farmstead goat milk sea salt & vanilla caramels.
$15.40

Kolsvart Roding Raspberry Candy Fish

Kolsvart strives to find a perfect balance between taste, purity, and texture. Do you care about the ingredients in your candy? Then this Swedish candy is for you. They are vegan, gluten-free, with no artificial additives and coloring. Made in Malmo, Sweden
$9.90

Kolsvart Elderflower Candy Fish

The candy fish in this bag has the shape of a real Swedish pike. Its elderflower flavor brings back childhood memories and is a celebration of the Swedish summer with endless fun and games. Not only does it taste delicious, it's also vegan and gluten free. Part of the proceeds from this product is donated to support the restoration of the natural habitats of the Swedish pike.
$9.90

Kolsvart Sour Blueberry Candy Fish

The candy fish in this bag is a replica of a Swedish Turbot. It has a fresh blueberry flavor and is rolled in a sour sweet powder giving it a nice extra kick. It’s vegan and gluten free and of course free from artificial colorings and additives. Today, many unique water environments are threatened by overfishing and pollution. We donate part of the proceeds from this product to promote healthy waters and fish stocks in Scandinavia.
$9.90

Kolsvart Licorice Candy Fish

Our classic salty licorice fishes with a salty sharp flavor profile.
$9.90

Little Syl Cherry Fruit Snacks

Juicy cherry-flavored fruit snacks with a tart twist, reimagined in delightful shapes.
$8.80

Little Syl Strawberry Fruit Snacks

Strawberry-shaped fruit snacks reimagined as chewy, bite-sized treats with a sweet, jam-like flavor.
$8.80

Little Syl Apricot Fruit Snacks

Apricot fruit snacks featuring sweet and tart flavors, offering a chewy texture and vibrant taste of apricots.
$8.80

Litttle Syl Fruit Salad Snacks

What is Little Syl’s Fruit Salad? Little Syl’s Fruit Salad is a seriously delicious mix of summer fruits - sweet and fragrant strawberries, jammy sweet apricots and juicy and tart cherries. Perfect for healthy snacking, a quick energy boost and enjoying the lingering taste of summer fruits. Fruit Salad tastes like real fruit and has the shape of real fruits. Created to ignite your child's imagination, promotes the discovery of shapes, colors, and flavors, and engage sensory and motor skills. Little Syl invites you and your child to enter her fantasy orchard filled with shapes and colors, where fruits and flavors are bigger, and imagination ignites play.
$8.80

Gavottes Crepes

Delicate, crisp French butter crêpes rolled into paper-thin layers for a light, irresistible crunch. Made in Brittany using a traditional recipe, they’re perfect on their own, with coffee, or crumbled over ice cream. Ingredients: Wheat flour, sugar, butter (milk), malt extract (barley), salt
$9.35

Granola Crackers & More

Carissa's Housemade Granola

A mix of oats, nuts, and dried fruit with a hint of brown sugar and maple syrup to sweeten. INGREDIENTS: Oats Almonds Coconut Coconut Oil Maple Syrup Brown Sugar Dried Cherries Dried Blueberries
$17.60

Potter's Table Olive Oil Flatbread Crackers

Nutty and utterly addictive, these seeded flatbreads are lovingly hand rolled and baked to perfection.
$15.40

Potter’s Table Seeded Crisps - Gluten Free

Nutty and utterly addictive, these gluten-free*, vegan, keto-friendly seeded crisps are lovingly hand rolled and baked to perfection.
$15.40

Laurel & Ash Farm Heirloom Grain Pancake Mix

Crafted with heirloom grains and sweetened with New York maple sugar pearls, this wholesome pancake mix delivers a rich, nutty flavor and a tender texture. Made with organic whole einkorn and red wheat stone-ground by local mills, it celebrates the unique regional character of the Hudson Valley. We source from regenerative New York farms, supporting healthy soil and vibrant communities.
$22.00

L'Isolina Spaghetti Dust

Spaghetti Dust is a ready-made version you can use anywhere. Made with toasted garlic, Calabrian chili, parsley, and sea salt, it adds bold flavor instantly. Sprinkle it on pasta, pizza, fish, steak, vegetables, salads, guacamole, and more.
$11.00

L'Isolina Pasta Radiatori

Bronze-cut and slowly air-dried for four days, these radiatori are made with organic durum wheat semolina and regeneratively farmed red wheat from Amber Waves Farm. Their signature ridges and folds are designed to hold onto every bit of sauce, delivering flavor in every bite. A versatile pantry staple with exceptional texture, equally at home with a simple tomato sauce, pesto, or a slow-simmered ragù. Ingredients: Organic Durum Wheat Semolina, Amber Waves Farm Regeneratively Farmed Red Wheat, Filtered Water.
$13.20

PHiSTiK Shell On Pistachios

Shell-On Antep Pistachios offer a simple reminder to slow down and savor the moment. A staple of hospitality in Turkey, these pistachios are traditionally shared with guests, enjoyed after meals, and passed around the table during long conversations. Grown in Antep, Turkey, and harvested at peak ripeness, they are gently roasted and lightly salted to highlight their naturally rich, buttery flavor and vibrant green color. Nutty, aromatic, and subtly sweet, they reflect the fertile soil, warm climate, and generations of growing tradition that make Antep pistachios so prized. Perfect for snacking, entertaining, or gifting, they embody PHiSTiK's commitment to sharing exceptional single-origin pistachios that are simple, honest, and true to their natural terroir.
$18.70

PHiSTiK Shell Off Pistachios

PHiSTiK Antep Pistachio Kernels are raw, unsalted, and shell-free, offering the pure flavor of one of the world's most celebrated pistachio-growing regions. Grown in Antep, Turkey, these vibrant green pistachios are rich, buttery, naturally sweet, and deeply aromatic, reflecting the fertile soil and warm climate that make them so distinctive. Nothing is added to alter their character—enjoy them by the handful or sprinkled over yogurt, salads, pastries, and desserts. Simple, honest, and true to their terroir, these single-origin pistachios showcase what pistachios are meant to taste like.
$12.10

Primis Imports Greek Sea Salt Flakes

Greek sea salt flakes hand-harvested from the sparkling waters of Messolonghi. These crunchy, pyramid-shaped crystals add a clean, briny finish and satisfying crunch without overpowering.
$15.40

Westwind Orchard Pepperoncino Chili Flakes

Grown organically at Westwind Orchard. 23 g.
$19.80

Individually Packaged Salads, Intended As A Main Course.

Individual Seasonal Market Salad

Large seasonal salad of greens, radicchios, carrots, radishes and fennel with a shallot mustard dressing, topped with roasted almonds and a cube of Meredith Dairy cheese. (GF)
$23.10

Individual Seasonal Farro Bowl

Farro, roasted & fresh vegetables, mixed green lettuce, green tahini - DF V
$19.80
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
© 2026 DoorDash
Carissa's Bakery 221 Pantigo Rd – Order pickup and delivery