Jeremiah's Italian Ice of Maitland (Orlando Ave) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

logo
Sign In / Sign Up

Jeremiah's Italian Ice

433 South Orlando Avenue, Maitland, FL
Loading
Online ordering hours: 12:00 PM - 10:25 PM
16 min
ready for pickup

Featured Items

#3 Most liked
Quart Italian Ice
$7.99
#1 Most liked
Medium Italian Ice
$4.59
#2 Most liked
Small Italian Ice
$3.59
Quart Jelati
$8.99
Medium Jelati
$5.59
Bullfrog Jelati
$6.59
Quart Soft Ice Cream
$8.99
Oreo® Mud Pie Jelati Cake
$29.99
Medium Soft Ice Cream
$5.39
Small Jelati
$4.59
Small Soft Ice Cream
$4.39
Strawberry Shortcake
$5.19+
Build-Your-Own Flavorite
$4.19+
Bullfrog Italian Ice
$5.59
Grasshopper
$5.19+
Sugar Cookie
$5.19+
Birthday Cake
$5.19+
Pumpkin Pie
$5.19+
Peanut Butter Cup
$5.19+
Bullfrog Soft Ice Cream
$6.39
Oreo Mud Pie
$5.19+
Blue Razz Crunch
$5.19+
6 Pack - Ice Cream Sandwiches
$14.99
Peppermint Bark
$5.19+
Tadpole Mini Italian Ice
$2.99
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 10:25 pm

Most Ordered

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Medium Italian Ice

Choose from over 20 flavors, including options like brownie batter, black cherry, and coconut. Medium-sized Italian ice, refreshing and diverse selection to satisfy any craving.
$4.59•26
#1 Most liked

Medium Jelati

Choose from a variety of flavors like fruity, chocolatey, or nutty. Optional vanilla, swirl, or chocolate soft ice cream. Add Oreo crumbles, sprinkles, or other layer-ins for extra texture.
$5.59

Oreo Mud Pie

With cookies and cream italian ice, swirl soft ice cream, oreo cookie crumbles.
$5.19+

Grasshopper

With scoop froggy frog italian ice, cookies and cream italian ice, swirl soft ice cream, oreo cookie crumbles.
$5.19+

Strawberry Shortcake

Cake batter italian ice, strawberry italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, cookie crumbles.
$5.19+

Small Jelati

Small gelati dessert. Various flavors like Brownie Batter, Pina Colada, and others. Choose from vanilla or chocolate soft ice cream. Optional layer-ins: sprinkles, cookie crumbles, and more.
$4.59

Bullfrog Jelati

Assorted bullfrog jelati flavors like tropical fruits, chocolate, and coffee. Choose from vanilla, swirl, or chocolate soft ice cream. Variety of layer-ins, including candies and cookie crumbles.
$6.59

Quart Jelati

Quart of jelati with a wide array of flavors, including fruity, nutty, and classic options. Enhance with soft ice cream or optional layer-ins like cookie crumbles and sprinkles.
$8.99

Birthday Cake

With cake batter italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
$5.19+

Medium Soft Ice Cream

Medium-sized, American-style soft ice cream. Choose from vanilla, swirl, or chocolate. Customize with assorted toppings like cookies, candies, or spices. Served in a cup, cake cone, or waffle cone.
$5.39

Flavorites

The perfect layering of authentic Italian Ice, indulgent Soft Ice Cream & decadent Layer-Ins!

Grasshopper

With scoop froggy frog italian ice, cookies and cream italian ice, swirl soft ice cream, oreo cookie crumbles.
$5.19+

Strawberry Shortcake

Cake batter italian ice, strawberry italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, cookie crumbles.
$5.19+

Blue Razz Crunch

The perfect layering of Blue Razz Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, Rainbow Nerds Candy
$5.19+

Frosted Animal Cracker

With cookie butter italian ice, cotton candy italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
$5.19+

Sugar Cookie

Cake batter italian ice, cookie butter italian ice, vanilla ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
$5.19+

PB & J

P-nutty italian ice, strawberry italian ice, vanilla ice cream, cookie butter crumbles.
$5.19+

Peanut Butter Cup

With p-nutty italian ice, chocolate soft ice cream, hershey's mini chocolate chips.
$5.19+

Oreo Mud Pie

With cookies and cream italian ice, swirl soft ice cream, oreo cookie crumbles.
$5.19+

Birthday Cake

With cake batter italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
$5.19+

Orange Mango Tango

With orange smash italian ice, mango italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
$5.19+

Spiced Mango

The perfect layering of Mango Italian Ice, Vanilla Ice Cream, Tajin & Chamoy
$5.19+

Build-Your-Own Flavorite

Build your own perfect layering of authentic Italian Ice, indulgent Soft Ice Cream & decadent Layer-Ins!
$4.19+

Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin pie italian ice, vanilla ice cream, biscoff cookie crumbles.
$5.19+

Peppermint Bark

The perfect layering of Cookies and Cream Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, Crushed Peppermint Candy
$5.19+

Frozen Hot Chocolate

The perfect layering of Hot Chocolate Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, Mini Marshmallows
$5.19+

Candy Cane Hot Chocolate

The perfect layering of Hot Chocolate Italian Ice, Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, Mini Marshmallows, Crushed Peppermint Candy
$5.19+

Jelati

The perfect layering of Italian Ice & Soft Ice Cream!

Tadpole Mini Jelati

Assorted mini gelato with numerous flavors like tropical fruits, sweet treats, and sugar-free options. Complement with vanilla, swirl, or chocolate soft serve. Optional toppings include cookies, sprinkles, and candies.
$4.19

Small Jelati

Small gelati dessert. Various flavors like Brownie Batter, Pina Colada, and others. Choose from vanilla or chocolate soft ice cream. Optional layer-ins: sprinkles, cookie crumbles, and more.
$4.59

Medium Jelati

Choose from a variety of flavors like fruity, chocolatey, or nutty. Optional vanilla, swirl, or chocolate soft ice cream. Add Oreo crumbles, sprinkles, or other layer-ins for extra texture.
$5.59

Bullfrog Jelati

Assorted bullfrog jelati flavors like tropical fruits, chocolate, and coffee. Choose from vanilla, swirl, or chocolate soft ice cream. Variety of layer-ins, including candies and cookie crumbles.
$6.59

Quart Jelati

Quart of jelati with a wide array of flavors, including fruity, nutty, and classic options. Enhance with soft ice cream or optional layer-ins like cookie crumbles and sprinkles.
$8.99

Jelati Cakes

LIMIT ONE CAKE PER ORDER

Oreo® Mud Pie Jelati Cake

Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A Box', serving 8-10 slices. Our Oreo® Mud Pie Jelati Cake features Cookies & Cream Italian Ice, creamy Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, and Oreo® Cookie Crumbles, perfectly layered in a shareable treat.... From Ice to Slice! LIMIT ONE CAKE PER ORDER
$29.99

Strawberry Shortcake Jelati Cake

Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A Box', serving 8-10 slices. Our Strawberry Shortcake Jelati Cake features Cake Batter & Strawberry Italian Ice, creamy Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, and Cookie Butter Crumbles, perfectly layered in a shareable treat.... From Ice to Slice! LIMIT ONE CAKE PER ORDER
$29.99

Birthday Cake Jelati Cake

Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A Box', serving 8-10 slices. Our Birthday Cake Jelati Cake features Cake Batter Italian Ice, creamy Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, and Rainbow Sprinkles, perfectly layered in a shareable treat.... From Ice to Slice! LIMIT ONE CAKE PER ORDER
$29.99

Oreo® Cheesecake Pie Jelati Cake

Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A Box', serving 8-10 slices. Our Oreo® Mud Pie Jelati Cake features Cookies & Cream Italian Ice, creamy Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, and Oreo® Cookie Crumbles, perfectly layered in a shareable treat.... From Ice to Slice! LIMIT ONE CAKE PER ORDER
$29.99

Strawberry Cheesecake Jelati Cake

Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with our 'Party In A Box', serving 8-10 slices. Our Strawberry Shortcake Jelati Cake features Cake Batter & Strawberry Italian Ice, creamy Vanilla Soft Ice Cream, and Cookie Butter Crumbles, perfectly layered in a shareable treat.... From Ice to Slice! *48 Hour Pre-Order Required. Grab-n-Go Jelati Cakes may also be available - call your local Jeremiah's Ice to verify.
$29.99

Pumpkin Pie Jelati Cake

Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with refreshing Italian Ice, creamy Soft Ice Cream, and decadent Layer-Ins perfectly layered in this shareable treat... From Ice to Slice!
$29.99

Peppermint Bark Jelati Cake

Add a Jeremiah's twist to your next celebration with refreshing Italian Ice, creamy Soft Ice Cream, and decadent Layer-Ins perfectly layered in this shareable treat... From Ice to Slice! *48 Hour Pre-Order Required. Grab-n-Go Jelati Cakes may also be available - call your local Jeremiah's Ice to verify.
$29.99

Italian Ice

Refreshing & Indulgent - Made Fresh Daily!

Tadpole Mini Italian Ice

Mini Italian ice in a variety of flavors, including classic fruit flavors, indulgent dessert blends, and sugar-free options. Perfect for a refreshing treat.
$2.99

Small Italian Ice

Refreshing small Italian ice. Choose from a diverse selection of flavors including brownie batter, tropical fruits, or classic favorites like cookies & cream and cotton candy.
$3.59•17
#2 Most liked

Medium Italian Ice

Choose from over 20 flavors, including options like brownie batter, black cherry, and coconut. Medium-sized Italian ice, refreshing and diverse selection to satisfy any craving.
$4.59•26
#1 Most liked

Bullfrog Italian Ice

Wide variety of flavors, including brownie batter, cherry, coconut, mango, and more. Some sugar-free options available.
$5.59

Quart Italian Ice

Quart of Italian ice with a variety of flavors, including fruity, nutty, and choices. Sugar-free mango and sour green apple also available.
$7.99•8
#3 Most liked

Soft Ice Cream

Certified Rich & Creamy!

Tadpole Mini Soft Ice Cream

Choice of vanilla, swirl, or chocolate soft ice cream. Add-ons include Oreo crumbles, cookie butter, or colorful sprinkles.
$3.99

Small Soft Ice Cream

Creamy swirl of vanilla or chocolate in cup, cake, or waffle cone. Toppings like cookie crumbles, sprinkles, candy, or none.
$4.39

Medium Soft Ice Cream

Medium-sized, American-style soft ice cream. Choose from vanilla, swirl, or chocolate. Customize with assorted toppings like cookies, candies, or spices. Served in a cup, cake cone, or waffle cone.
$5.39

Bullfrog Soft Ice Cream

Creamy delight with options like vanilla, chocolate, and swirl flavors. Customize with choices like cookie crumbles, sprinkles, candy, or unique Tajin & Chamoy.
$6.39

Quart Soft Ice Cream

Quart of creamy soft ice cream. Choose vanilla, swirl, or chocolate. Optional toppings: cookie crumbles, chips, sprinkles, or candy.
$8.99

Ice Cream Sandwiches

The perfect handheld treat on-the-go!

6 Pack - Ice Cream Sandwiches

Creamy vanilla ice cream sandwiched between chocolate cookies, adorned with colorful sprinkles and chocolate chips.
$14.99

Classic Ice Cream Sandwich

Creamy vanilla ice cream nestled between two chocolate cookies.
$2.99

Chocolate Chips Ice Cream Sandwich

Creamy ice cream nestled between two chocolate cookies, garnished with chocolate chips.
$2.99

Rainbow Sprinkles Ice Cream Sandwich

Creamy ice cream nestled between chocolate cookies, adorned with colorful rainbow sprinkles.
$2.99

Peppermint Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich

$2.99

Extras

Enticing Add-ons!

Bottled Water

 
$2.25

Waffle Cone on the Side

Crispy, golden waffle cone with a delicate grid pattern, perfect for pairing with your favorite dessert.
$0.99

Small Cooler Bag

Bright green cooler bag with Jeremiah's Italian Ice logo, perfect for keeping your items chilled.
$6.99

Large Cooler Bag

Color varies by location.
$9.99
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
© 2026 DoorDash
Jeremiah's Italian Ice 433 South Orlando Avenue – Order pickup and delivery