Toasted Turtle Tavern Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Toasted Turtle Tavern
Sign In / Sign Up
Toasted Turtle Tavern
51425 State Road 19, Elkhart, IN 46514, USAOpens 8:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
Mills Chop
$21.60
Beer Battered Cod
$26.40
Bison Meatloaf
$28.80
Argentina Shrimp Cocktail
$19.20
Full Menu
8:00 am - 2:40 pm; 4:00 pm - 8:10 pmDockside Starters
Alligator Tail
Alligator tail served as an appetizer or paired with a meal option.
$19.20
Argentina Shrimp Cocktail
Chilled shrimp with classic cocktail sauce. Available as an appetizer or meal accompaniment.
$19.20
Chicken on a Stick
Skewered chicken. Available as an appetizer or paired with a meal.
$16.80
Clam Chowder
Creamy clam chowder. Available as an appetizer or alongside your meal.
$18.00
Crab Dip
Creamy seafood starter, available as an appetizer or part of a meal.
$20.40
Meatball
Hearty meatball appetizer or meal option.
$16.80
Reuben Egg Rolls
Crispy egg rolls filled with corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese. Choose as an appetizer or alongside your meal.
$16.80
Whiskey Filet Bites
Tender filet bites with whiskey glaze. Choose as a starter or with a meal.
$26.40
Lakehouse Favorites
Beer Battered Cod
Cod filet coated in beer batter, fried until golden, typically served with tartar sauce and a lemon wedge.
$26.40
Bison Meatloaf
House-made bison meatloaf with a savory glaze, accompanied by mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables.
$28.80
Butter Basted Perch
Butter-basted perch, pan-fried to golden perfection, typically accompanied by lemon and caper butter.
$28.80
Chicken & Waffles
Fried chicken paired with a Belgian waffle, typically accompanied by maple syrup and honey butter.
$21.60
Chilean Sea Bass
Pan-seared Chilean sea bass with a lemon caper butter sauce, accompanied by fingerling potatoes and roasted vegetables.
$50.40
Filet Mignon
Tender cut of beef. Temperature options range from rare to well done.
$46.80
Mills Chop
Grilled chop typically served with seasonal vegetables and a savory sauce, offering a hearty taste of American cuisine.
$21.60
Shrimp & Grits
Saut�ed shrimp with smoked sausage, peppers, and onions served over creamy cheddar grits, typically garnished with scallions and bacon.
$28.80
Sandwiches
Dockside Rueben
House-smoked corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, marble rye, and 1000 Island.
$21.60
Italian Sausage
Salami, peppered bacon, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, olives, green and banana peppers, onion, pepperjack cheese with Italian dressing and garlic mayo on a toasted hoagie.
$18.00
Pub Burger
Juicy beef patty with choice of doneness. Served with a variety of sides like fries, sweet potato tots, or fresh fruit.
$19.20
T Bar Burger
Juicy beef patty, temperature of your choice. Served with a selection of sides including fries, tots, or veggies.
$21.60
Grilled Cheese
Melted cheese between slices of bread, served with a choice of assorted sides like salad, fruits, or fries.
$11.99
Meatball Sandwich
Hearty sandwich with seasoned meatballs. Choose from a variety of sides like salads, fries, or fruit to complement your meal.
$21.60
Leafy Legends
Filet Salad
Grilled filet mignon, mixed greens, roasted peppers, blue cheese crumbles, and soy ginger dressing.
$28.80
Chicken Tavern Salad
A mix of baby greens, avocado, cucumbers, tomatoes, gorgonzola, and fried leeks, typically drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette.
$19.20
Caesar Wedge
Peppered bacon, hard-boiled egg, bleu cheese crumbles, cherry tomatoes on a Romaine wedge tossed in caesar dressing finished with Parmesan Cheese
$16.80
Lakehouse Crab & Avocado
North Atlantic Red Crab, Fresh Avocado, Cucumber, Yellow Onion, Hard Boiled Egg, Mandarin Orange & Pineapple on a bed of Spring Mix with a Lemon Vinaigrette
$21.60
Flat Bread
Pepperoni Flat
Cup Pepperoni, Red Sauce, Mozzarella, Provolone & Muenster
$19.20
Hawaiian Flat
Tavern Ham, Peppered Bacon, Red Sauce, Pineapple, Mozzarella, Provolone & Muenster
$20.40
Argentina Shrimp Flat
Grilled shrimp layered on flatbread, typically featuring a blend of cheeses, caramelized onions, and a drizzle of garlic butter or spicy glaze.
$22.80
Chicken Caprese Flat
Grilled chicken, Roma tomatoes, bocconcini cheese, and basil on flatbread, finished with a balsamic reduction.
$21.60
Soups
Clam Chowder
Clam chowder typically includes fresh clams, diced potatoes, and bacon, simmered in a creamy base with celery and onions.
$18.00
Cup Italian Wedding Soup
Italian-style soup with small meatballs, greens, and pasta in a savory broth. Choose as appetizer or with meal.
$6.00
Bowl Italian Wedding Soup
Savory meatballs, tender greens, and orzo in a light broth. Available as an appetizer or with your meal.
$9.60
Cup Irish Soup
$6.00
Bowl Irish Soup
$9.60
Desserts
Turtle Cheesecake
New York style cheesecake on a graham cracker crust, layered with dark fudge, covered in caramel sauce, and garnished with chopped pecans.
$16.80
Fair Donuts
Your favorite mini dessert donuts covered in cinnamon sugar served with caramel or chocolate dipping sauce!
$8.40
Orange Dream
A blend of fresh orange, banana, and almond milk, complemented by vanilla protein for a smooth, satisfying dessert experience.
$14.40
Black Bottom Banana Cream Pie
$9.60
Dinner Kids
Kids Grilled Cheese
Classic grilled cheese for kids. Choice of side: veggie, fries, salad, fruit, or soup. Options vary from healthy to comfort.
$7.20
Kids Chz Flat
Cheese flatbread for kids with a choice of side: veggie options like broccoli salad or sweet potato tots, or classics like fries and fruit.
$9.60
Kids Burger
3oz burger with cheese on a toasted potato bun with choice of side
$8.40
Kids Quesadilla
Warm tortilla with melted cheese, served alongside a choice of side such as broccoli salad, cheesy hash browns casserole, or more.
$7.20
Kids Chicken on Stick
Grilled chicken skewers served with choice of side like fries or fruit, plus BBQ or ranch dipping sauce.
$8.40
Kids Pepperoni Flatbread
Cheesy flatbread with pepperoni. Choose a side: vegetables, potatoes, soup, or salad.
$10.80
Sides
Broccoli Salad
Broccoli combined with bacon, cheddar cheese, red onion, and dried cranberries, typically dressed in a creamy mayo and vinegar sauce.
$4.80
Mashed Yukons
Yukon gold potatoes mashed with butter and cream, typically seasoned with salt and pepper for a smooth and creamy texture.
$4.80
Crinkle Fries
Classic crinkle-cut fries, golden and crispy, typically seasoned with a light sprinkle of salt.
$4.80
Cheesy Grits
Grits prepared with cheddar cheese, typically featuring a creamy texture and rich flavor.
$6.00
House Veggies
A medley of zucchini, squash, red bell pepper, and mushrooms, typically prepared as a side dish.
$4.80
Hashbrown Cassrole
Shredded potatoes baked with a creamy mixture, typically featuring cheese and onions, creating a savory and satisfying hashbrown casserole.
$6.00
Fresh Fruit
A mix of fresh-cut seasonal fruits, often featuring pineapple, grapes, strawberries, and melons.
$4.80
Side Salad
Mixed greens, fresh veggies. Available as appetizer or side with main dish.
$6.00
Sweet Tots
Sweet potato tots, deep-fried for a crispy, golden brown exterior, typically offering a subtly sweet flavor reminiscent of sweet potato fries.
$4.80
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash