Which Wich Settlers Market (416) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Which Wich Settlers Market (416)
Sign In / Sign Up
Which Wich
4645 Casey Boulevard, Williamsburg, VA
Online ordering hours: 9:45 AM - 7:45 PMOpens 9:45 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
Turkey
$11.25
#3 Most liked
Hand-Dipped Milk Shakes
$6.90+
Grinder
$11.25
Wicked®
$13.55
Turkey Club
$13.55
Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
$11.25
Steak
$11.25
Tuna Salad
$11.25
Turkey Bacon Ranch
$13.55
Reuben
$11.25
Ham
$11.25
Meatball
$11.25
French Dip
$11.25
Black Bean Patty
$11.25
Kids PB&Jwich™
$7.50
Fries
$5.20
Krab Salad
$11.25
Ham & Egg
$11.25
Grilled Cheese
$7.50
Full Menu
9:45 am - 7:45 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Turkey
Oven roasted turkey breast. 370-740 calories
$11.25•60
#1 Most liked
Hand-Dipped Milk Shakes
Choice of 16oz, 21oz, or 32oz milkshakes. Flavors include Oreo cookie, chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, banana, and cookie.
$6.90+•31
#3 Most liked
Fries
Our crinkle cut fries.
$5.20•29
Grinder
Salami, Pepperoni & Capicola
$11.25•24
Turkey Club
Turkey, Ham & Bacon
$13.55•27
Wicked®
Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Pepperoni, Bacon, Any 3 Cheeses
$13.55•24
Ham
Thinly sliced ham.
$11.25•28
Steak
510-1030 calories
$11.25•14
Reuben
Corned Beef, Swiss, Sauerkraut & 1000 Island
$11.25•12
French Dip
Roast Beef with Au Jus
$11.25•7
CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD WRAP
Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
Chicken, lettuce, parmesan cheese, house-made croutons, and Caesar dressing in a fresh wrap.
$11.25
FRIDAY'S DEAL (SEAFOOD)
Wich Deal of the Day!
Tuna Salad
Tuna Salad
This photo is just a tasty idea featuring ingredients from below—choose your ingredients and make it uniquely yours!
$8.05•12
Tuna Melt
Tuna Salad & Cheddar
This photo is just a tasty idea featuring ingredients from below—choose your ingredients and make it uniquely yours!
$8.05
Krab Salad
Krab Salad
This photo is just a tasty idea featuring ingredients from below—choose your ingredients and make it uniquely yours!
$8.05•10
Cali Roll
Krab Salad, Avocado & Cucumbers
This photo is just a tasty idea featuring ingredients from below—choose your ingredients and make it uniquely yours!
$8.05
Land & Sea
Steak & Krab Salad
This photo is just a tasty idea featuring ingredients from below—choose your ingredients and make it uniquely yours!
$8.05
WICKED®
Our Signature Sandwich! 5 Meats + 3 Cheeses! Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Pepperoni, Bacon & Any 3 Cheeses
Wicked®
Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Pepperoni, Bacon, Any 3 Cheeses
$13.55•24
TURKEY
Turkey
Oven roasted turkey breast. 370-740 calories
$11.25•60
#1 Most liked
Turkey Club
Turkey, Ham & Bacon
$13.55•27
Turkey Bacon Ranch
Turkey, bacon & ranch
$13.55
Turkey Vibewich™
Turkey, Coleslaw & 1000 Island
$11.25
Thank You Turkey™
Turkey, Stuffing & Cranberry Sauce
$11.25•11
HAM & PORK
Ham
Thinly sliced ham.
$11.25•28
BLT
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato
$11.25
BBQ Pork
BBQ Pulled Pork, Coleslaw & BBQ Sauce
$11.25
Cuban
Pulled Pork, Ham, Pickles & Yellow Mustard
$11.25
Bac-Hammon™
Bacon & Ham
$13.55
BEEF
Roast Beef
380-760 calories
$11.25•13
French Dip
Roast Beef with Au Jus
$11.25•7
Steak
510-1030 calories
$11.25•14
Phillywich™
Steak & Cheez Whiz®
$11.25•12
Reuben
Corned Beef, Swiss, Sauerkraut & 1000 Island
$11.25•12
CHICKEN
Chicken
Oven roasted chicken breast.
$11.25•6
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken, Buffalo Sauce & Bleu Cheese Crumbles
$11.25
Chicken Pesto
Chicken & Pesto Sauce
$11.25
Chicken Parm
Chicken, Marinara & Mozzarella
$11.25
Chicken Salad
Thinly sliced oven roasted chicken breast. 110-930 cal.
$11.25
SEAFOOD
Tuna Salad
House-made tuna salad.
$11.25•12
Tuna Melt
Tuna Salad & Cheddar
$11.25
Krab Salad
House-made krab salad.
$11.25•10
Cali Roll
Krab Salad, Avocado & Cucumbers
$11.25
Land & Sea
Steak & Krab Salad
$11.25
VEGETARIAN
Black Bean Patty
Vegan
$11.25•6
Tomato & Avocado
Tomato & Avocado
$11.25
Caprese
Mozzarella, Tomato & Pesto
$11.25
Triple Cheese Please™
Choose up to 3 cheeses
$11.25
Hummus
Hummus
This photo is just a tasty idea featuring ingredients from below—choose your ingredients and make it uniquely yours!
$11.25
ITALIAN
Grinder
Salami, Pepperoni & Capicola
$11.25•24
Muffuletta
Salami, Ham & Olive Salad
$11.25•6
Meatball
Meatballs, Marinara & Parmesan
$11.25•6
Pizzawich®
Pepperoni, Marinara & Mozzarella
$11.25
Italian Beef
Steak, Provolone & Hot Pepper Mix
$11.25
CLASSICS
Gyrowich
Cucumbers & Tzatziki
$11.25
Egg Salad
House-made egg salad.
$11.25
PB&Jwich™
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Benefitting Project PB&J®
$11.25
Elviswich
Bacon, Peanut Butter, Banana & Honey
$13.55
Chzbgrwich™
Steak, Cheddar & 1000 Island
$11.25
BREAKFAST
Bacon & Egg
Served anytime
$11.25
Cheese & Egg
Served anytime
$11.25
Ham & Egg
Served anytime
$11.25
Steak & Egg
Served anytime
$11.25
Veggies & Egg
Served anytime
Choose your veggies
$11.25
KIDS
Turkey Kidswich™
Choose your own combination: white or wheat bread with turkey, served hot or cold. Add cheese, lettuce, mayo, and more. Side of chips or fries. Drink included.
$7.50
Ham Kidswich™
Choose bread type, served hot or cold. Select from various toppings like cheese, lettuce, and condiments. Comes with chips or fries. Includes a drink choice of milk, juice, or soda.
$7.50
Roast Beef Kidswich™
Roast beef, cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo
$7.50
Cheese Pizzawich®
Melted provolone cheese and pomodora sauce on white bread. includes kids sandwich, apple slices, carrots, choice of drink, and yellow chocolate candies.
$7.50
Grilled Cheese
Melted provolone and cheddar cheese includes a wich, chips, choice of drink and a special treat 340-690 calories
$7.50
Kids PB&Jwich™
Choice of white or wheat bread with peanut butter and jelly. Served with chips or fries. Includes a children's drink like milk or juice.
$7.50
SIDES & SWEETS
Fries
Our crinkle cut fries.
$5.20•29
Chips
Miss vickie's kettle cooked: salt & vinegar, bbq, jalapeno, sea salt. regular lay's, baked lay's, doritos, sour cream & onion.
$2.90•59
#2 Most liked
Courtney's Cookie
310 calories. chocolate chips, toffee and made with m&ms.
$2.90•10
DRINKS & SHAKES
Regular Fountain
Choice of soft drink flavors including popular sodas, tea varieties, lemonade, or bottled water.
$3.20•17
Large Fountain
Actual drink comes in cup. depends on availability. we will send either in cup or bottle
$3.75•25
Hand-Dipped Milk Shakes
Choice of 16oz, 21oz, or 32oz milkshakes. Flavors include Oreo cookie, chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, banana, and cookie.
$6.90+•31
#3 Most liked
Bottled Water
0 cal.
$3.20
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash