Ice Cream Cottage (Montauk Hwy) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Ice Cream Cottage
1590 Montauk Highway, Mastic, NY
Online ordering hours: 10:00 AM - 8:45 PMOpens 10:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
Sprinkle Delight (8-10 Servings)
$46.94
Small Sheet (18-22 Servings)
$73.62
Oreo (8-10 Servings)
$55.04
Chocolate Overdose (8-10 Servings)
$55.04
Neopolitan (8-10 Servings)
$51.29
Large Round (10-12 Servings)
$56.14
M&M (8-10 Servings)
$55.04
#2 Most liked
Large Cup (4 Scoops)
$8.21
Deluxe Bartman (8-10 Servings)
$55.04
Bonnet cone Box of 4
$17.17
Super Sundae
$13.19
#1 Most liked
Medium Cup (3 Scoops)
$6.74
Oreo Deluxe Saucers
$19.94
Choc Chip Cookie Deluxe Saucers
$19.94
Small Round (8-10 Servings)
$46.94
Chocolate Chip Deluxe Saucers
$19.94
#3 Most liked
Small Cup (2 Scoops)
$5.03
Sprinkle Deluxe Saucers
$19.94
Sundae (5 Scoops)
$10.99
Quart- 32 oz
$17.37
Regular Strawberry Saucers
$18.41
Regular Pistachio Saucers
$18.41
Pint -16oz
$12.63
Regular Saucers
$18.41
Banana Barge
$14.54
Full Menu
10:00 am - 8:45 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Medium Cup (3 Scoops)
$6.74•89% (184)
#1 Most liked
Large Cup (4 Scoops)
$8.21•92% (96)
#2 Most liked
Small Cup (2 Scoops)
$5.03•87% (87)
#3 Most liked
Sundae (5 Scoops)
$10.99•91% (47)
Super Sundae
5 scoops. choice of 3 flavors and 3 toppings.
$13.19•98% (60)
Pint -16oz
If you want Pint with toppings, you can order as Super Sundae
$12.63•93% (33)
Quart- 32 oz
Choice of flavor
$17.37•95% (24)
Banana Barge
Choice of 3 flavors and 3 toppings.
$14.54•61% (13)
Take Home Dry Toppings 8oz
$6.08
Choc Chip Cookie Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6
$19.94•100% (8)
Cups
Banana Barge
Choice of 3 flavors and 3 toppings.
$14.54•61% (13)
Quart- 32 oz
Choice of flavor
$17.37•95% (24)
Pint -16oz
If you want Pint with toppings, you can order as Super Sundae
$12.63•93% (33)
Sundae (5 Scoops)
$10.99•91% (47)
Large Cup (4 Scoops)
$8.21•92% (96)
#2 Most liked
Medium Cup (3 Scoops)
$6.74•89% (184)
#1 Most liked
Small Cup (2 Scoops)
$5.03•87% (87)
#3 Most liked
Super Sundae
5 scoops. choice of 3 flavors and 3 toppings.
$13.19•98% (60)
Cakes
Small Round (8-10 Servings)
Vanilla & Chocolate layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle
$46.94
No Fat No Sugar Added (8-10 Servings)
Vanilla & Chocolate no Fat no Sugar added ice cream layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle
$46.94
Large Round (10-12 Servings)
Vanilla & Chocolate layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle
$56.14
Small Sheet (18-22 Servings)
Vanilla & Chocolate layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle
$73.62
Deluxe Bartman (8-10 Servings)
Bartman ice cream with Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter and Butterfinger on top
$55.04
Chocolate Overdose (8-10 Servings)
Chocolate Overdose ice cream with Hot Fudge, Chocolate Chip and Brownie Pieces on top
$55.04
Oreo (8-10 Servings)
Cookies and Cream ice cream with Hot Fudge and Oreos on top
$55.04
Sprinkle Delight (8-10 Servings)
Vanilla ice cream with Rainbow Sprinkles in the middle and on top
$46.94
Neopolitan (8-10 Servings)
Chocolate, Vanilla and Strawberry ice cream layered with crunchies in between the layers
$51.29
Mint Chip (8-10 Servings)
Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream with Chocolate crunchies in the middle, Hot Fudge and Chocolate Chips on top.
$55.04
M&M (8-10 Servings)
Vanilla M & M ice cream with Hot Fudge and mini M & Ms on top.
$55.04
Novelties
Toni Box of 6
Vanilla ice cream topped with Toasted coconut and a cherry
$15.15
Tartufo Box of 4
$17.17
Spumoni Box of 4
$17.17
Bonnet cone Box of 4
2 vanilla cone with one with chocolate bonnet and one with cherry bonnet / 2 chocolate cone one chocolate bonnet and one with cherry bonnet
$17.17•87% (8)
Mini Sundae Box of 6
3 Choc with chocolate sprinkles and cherry and
3 Vanilla with rainbow sprinkles and cherry
$15.15
Canoli Box of 4
2 plain and 2 dipped in chocolate shells filled with our canoli ice cream
$20.00
Saucers
Regular Saucers
Pack of 6
$18.41
Regular Strawberry Saucers
Pack of 6
$18.41
Choc Chip Cookie Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6
$19.94•100% (8)
Chocolate Chip Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6
$19.94
Oreo Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6
$19.94•100% (6)
Regular Pistachio Saucers
Pack of 6
$18.41
Sprinkle Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6
$19.94
Other items
Candles-Regular
$3.72
Empty wafer Cone
$1.29•85% (7)
Empty waffle cones
$2.03
Take Home Dry Toppings 8oz
$6.08
Take Home Wet Toppings
8 oz
$6.99•100% (6)
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash