Buttercooky Bakery & Café (New York Ave) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Buttercooky Bakery & Café
495 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743, USAOpens 6:30 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
Tres Leche Cake
$41.95
The Dubai Chocolate Croissant
$10.95
Personal Tres leche Cake
$12.95
Large Fruit Tart
$36.95
Strawberry Cheesecake
$26.95
Cronut (Jelly Filled Fried Croissant)
$6.95
Chocolate Mousse Pastry
$8.95
Cannoli Cake
$33.95
Chocolate Boston Cream Donut
$4.95
Pistachio Croissant
$6.95
Funfetti Cake
$31.95
1 Pound Cookie Tray
$32.50
Black & White
$6.00
Cookie Tray 2lb
$49.95
Plain Croissant
$6.50
Fudge Brownie
$6.00
Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie
$6.00
Chocolate Devil's Food Cake
$31.95
Chocolate Mousse Cake
$38.95
Carrot Cake Slice
$6.95
The Crookie (Croissant-Cookie)
$6.95
Buttercooky Bakery of Huntington
6:30 am - 6:45 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
The Dubai Chocolate Croissant
Pistachio & Kunafa Filling
$10.95
Chocolate Boston Cream Donut
$4.95
Cronut (Jelly Filled Fried Croissant)
$6.95•100% (8)
Tres Leche Cake
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries.
$41.95
Personal Tres leche Cake
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries.
$12.95
Pistachio Croissant
$6.95
Black & White
$6.00
Chocolate Mousse Pastry
Rich and creamy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of moist chocolate cake topped with chocolate curls
$8.95
Fudge Brownie
$6.00
Coffee Station proudly serving La Colombe Roasters
Large Cappuccino
$6.00
Small Latte
$5.50
Large Draft Latte
$6.75
Large Cold Brew
$5.95
Large Coffee
$4.00
Large Latte
$6.00
Large Iced Latte
$6.50
Large Iced Cappucino
$6.50
Small Chai Latte
$6.00
Large Iced Coffee
$5.95
Small Iced Mocha
$6.95
Small Iced Coffee
$5.00
Double Espresso
$4.50
Small Coffee
$3.50
Small Hot Chocolate
$6.00
Small Cold Brew
$5.75
Small Draft Latte
$6.00
Large Chai Latte
$6.95
Espresso
$4.00
Small Cappuccino
$5.25
Small Mocha
$6.25
Large Mocha
$6.95
Small Machiato
$4.75
Large Iced Tea
$5.00
Small Iced Latte
$6.00
Small Iced Cappuccino
$5.75
Cortado
$5.00
Small Americano
$4.50
Large Americano
$5.50
Large Hot Chocolate
$6.50
Flat White
$5.00
Pumpkin Draft Latte Small
$6.75
Pumpkin Draft Latte Large
$7.75
Bread
Rustic Sourdough
$6.50
Egg Rolls
Plain
Sesame
Poppy
$2.00
Bagel
Plain
Sesame
Poppy
$2.00
Semolina
$5.50
Italian Bread
$4.50
White Bread
$5.50
Salt Stick
$2.00
Kaiser Roll
Plain
Sesame
Poppy
$2.00
Whole Wheat Bread
$5.50
Rye Bread Seedless
$6.50
Rye Bread
Seeds
$6.50
Challah Bread
$6.50
Pumpernickel Round
$6.50
12 assorted rolls
$16.00
Pastries/Eclairs
NY Cheesecake with Strawberry Pastry
$8.95
Hazelnut Mousse Finger Pastry
Hazelnut mousse infused with chocolate mousse dipped in hazelnut wafer chocolate crunch set atop a buttery chocolate sablé cookie, finished with hazelnut whipped ganache and chopped hazelnuts
$8.95
Key Lime Pie (mini)
$8.95
Crème Brulee
$8.95
NY Cheesecake Pastry
$8.95
Red Velvet Pastry
$8.95
Chocolate Mousse Pastry
Rich and creamy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of moist chocolate cake topped with chocolate curls
$8.95
Silk & Satin Pastry
Rich and creamy chocolate mousse infused with our famous NY style cheesecake set atop a thin layer of chocolate cake, covered in chocolate ganache
$8.95
Banana Milk Chocolate Bar
Banana bread and banana mousse infused with salted caramel, encased in milk chocolate wafer crunch, topped with whipped ganache
$8.95
Oreo Cheesecake Pastry
$8.95
Black Forest Pastry
Silky Chocolate mousse infused with sour cherry set atop a thin layer of sponge soaked in black cherry syrup encased in dark chocolate topped with whip cream
$8.95
Oreo Mousse Pastry
Rich and creamy vanilla mousse blended with chunks of oreo cookie set atop a chocolate sable, topped with chocolate and white chocolate wafers
$8.95
Coconut Chocolate Pastry
Creamy Coconut Mousse enclosed in a soft peak of coconut Bavarian cream, resting on moist chocolate cake infused with coconut cream in chocolate ganache topped with chocolate shavings and chocolate shards
$8.95
Pistachio Sunflower French Pastry
Pistachio mousse dipped in crunchy pistachio wafer chocolate set beneath a raspberry crémeux sphere, resting on soft vanilla cake & a buttery vanilla sablé cookie finished with a handcrafted white chocolate sunflower and a dollop of raspberry jam
$8.95
Biscoff French Pastry
Creamy biscoff cookie butter set atop layers of moist vanilla cake topped with caramel glaze, finished with a Lotus Biscoff cookie, biscoff cookie crumble & a fresh strawberry
$8.95
Passion Fruit Mango French Pastry
Tropically sweet yet tangy passion fruit mousse, mango cremeux and vanilla cake set atop a buttery vanilla sable cookie topped with whipped vanilla ganache and passion fruit jelly, enclosed in white chocolate and studded with gold leaf
$8.95
Raspberry Cheesecake French Pastry
New York Style Cheesecake set atop of graham cracker crust with a raspberry preserve on top and garnished with fresh raspberries
$8.95
The Strawberry Pastry
Strawberry Filling atop a sable cookie.
$9.95•88% (9)
The Mango Pastry
White chocolate Shell containing soft Mango Filling, Mango cremeux and fresh mango
$9.95•88% (9)
Apple Crumble Tart
Freshly diced apples doused in our special cinnamon sugar blend resting in a vanilla sable tart shell topped with baked golden buttery crumble
$9.75
Fresh Fruit Tart
Silky rich custard cream in a dark chocolate dipped buttery vanilla sablé tart topped with strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, blackberries, mandarin oranges and kiwi.
$9.95
Salted Caramel Chocolate Mousse Tart
Rich chocolate ganache and a liquid salted caramel center in a buttery chocolate sablé tart shell, topped with chocolate mousse lightly coated in caramel ganache & chocolate crunchies and finished with a chocolate disk and cocoa powder
$8.95
The Mandarin Pastry
#2 Most liked
Mandarin Pastry — made with mandarin mousse, fresh mandarin, and mandarin marmalade.
$9.95•88% (9)
By The Slice / Cannoli's
Cannoli
Our signature cannoli filling in a crispy fried shell
$6.00
Carrot Cake Slice
Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and lush cream cheese icing & a marzipan carrot
$6.95
Lobster Tail Pastry
Crispy flaky shell baked gorgeously golden filled with light and delicious bavarian cream
$6.95•88% (9)
Tiramisu Slice
Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream & dusted with cocoa powder
$6.95
Chocolate Cannoli
Our signature cannoli filling in a chocolate covered crispy fried shell
$6.00
Seven Layer Slice
Rich chocolate buttercream sandwiched between seven layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with dark chocolate ganache
$6.95
Philly Fluff (Cream Cheese Pound Cake)
Moist and fluffy pound cake made with cream cheese and cinnamon . Marble or plain.
$16.95
Coconut Cake Slice
Coconut Sponge Cake, Coconut Cream Filling, Coconut Icing, Coconut Flakes
$8.95
Cakes
Feeds 8-10 People 8"
Tres Leche
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted 3-milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries
$41.95
Strawberry Shortcake
Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in strawberry syrup, garnished with vanilla chantilly cream and fresh strawberries
$32.95
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, a dark chocolate pencil and chocolate cake crumbs
$38.95
Fresh Fruit Salad Cake
Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries, bananas, peaches, and pineapples set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in simple syrup, garnished with dashes of vanilla chantilly cream and fresh berries
$32.95
Vanilla Chocolate Cake
Vanilla Cake
Chocolate Filling
Chocolate Icing
$31.95
Chocolate Devil's Food Cake
Decadent moist devil's food chocolate cake with creamy melt-in-your-mouth chocolate fudge, topped with chocolate swirls and chocolate shards. ALL chocolate
$31.95
Cannoli Cake
Layers of moist vanilla cake and our delicious cannoli cream with chocolate chips finished with a chocolate drip and pieces of cannolis
$33.95
Red Velvet Cake
Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop thin layers of moist velvet cake coated in smooth cream cheese icing, finished with ruby red chocolate ganache drip, vanilla buttercream, and red velvet cake crumbs
$38.95
Traditional Tiramisu
Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream dusted with cocoa powder and enclosed with lady fingers.
$38.95
Silk & Satin Mousse
Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous NY style cheesecake set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with a nest of chocolate ganache, gold dusted lines and lathered in roasted almond slices
$38.95
French Strawberry Shortcake
Vanilla Cake with Fresh Strawberries and Bavarian Cream topped with Marzipan
$38.95
Passion Fruit Mango Mousse
Tropical sweet yet tangy passion fruit creme set atop thin moist vanilla cake lightly soaked in Malibu vanilla creme filled with Mango Mousse brulee syrup finished with a tie-dye tropical fruit glaze and garnished with fresh berries
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
$38.95
Carrot Cake
Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist layers of carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and lush sweet cream cheese, a marzipan carrot and lathered in toasted coconut flakes
$31.95
Funfetti Cake
Smooth and silky buttercream between thin layers of vanilla funfetti cake, finished with bright ombre vanilla buttercream, a sweet white chocolate ganache drip, and colorful confetti sprinkles
$31.95
Oreo Buttercream Cake
Creamy vanilla buttercream loaded with chunks of oreo between layers of moist chocolate cake, finished with oreo buttercream, a dark chocolate ganache drip, topped with buttercream swirls and oreo cookies
$31.95
Vanilla Shadow Cake
Ever-so-light buttercream between thin layers of moist vanilla and chocolate cake, finished with vanilla buttercream, a decadent dark chocolate ganache drip, and a marachino cherry
$31.95
Seven Layer Cake
Rich chocolate buttercream sandwiched between seven layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with creamy chocolate fudge, vanilla cake crumbs, and a marachino cherry
$25.95
Napoleon Cake (Milhojas)
$33.95
Mini Birthday Cake Chocolate
Rich chocolate buttercream between. thin layers of soft chocolate cake, finished with chocolate buttercream, carefully handcrafted buttercream flowers, and chocolate cake crumbs
$14.95
Mini Birthday Cake Vanilla
Vanilla buttercream between layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with smooth vanilla buttercream, carefully handcrafted buttercream flowers, and vanilla cake crumbs
$14.95•100% (6)
Coconut Cake
Coconut Sponge Cake, Coconut Cream Filling, Coconut Icing, Coconut Flakes
$35.00
Cheesecakes
Oreo Cheesecake
$26.95
Strawberry Cheesecake
$26.95
New York Cheesecake
$24.95
Pies & Fruit Tart
Large Fruit Tart
$36.95
Key Lime Pie
$28.95
8" Lemon Meringue Pie
$29.95
Apple Pie
$26.95
Blueberry Pie
$26.95
Cherry Pie
$26.95
Apple Crumb Pie
$26.95
Brownie Tart
Brownie with Ganache icing in Tart Shell
$9.95
Small Apple Pie
$9.95
Small Blueberry Pie
$9.95
Small Cherry Pie
$9.95
Small Pecan Pie
$9.95
Large Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$6.00•75% (8)
Black & White
$6.00
Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie
$6.00
Reese's Peanut Butter Cookie
$6.00
Chinese Cookie
$6.00
Sugar Cookie
$6.00
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$6.00
M & M Cookie
$6.00
Chocolate Sprinkle Cookie
$6.00
Croissants
The Dubai Chocolate Croissant
Pistachio & Kunafa Filling
$10.95
Plain Croissant
$6.50
Chocolate Croissant
$6.95
Raspberry Cheese Croissant
$6.95
Almond Croissant
#3 Most liked
$6.95•100% (8)
The Crookie (Croissant-Cookie)
Crunchy croissant exterior and a chewy chocolate chip cookie interior (warm it up)
$6.95
Pistachio Croissant
$6.95
Strawberry Almond Twice Baked Croissant
$6.95
Cronut (Jelly Filled Fried Croissant)
$6.95•100% (8)
Nutella Croissant
$6.95•100% (8)
Apple Croissant
$6.95
Ham & Swiss Croissant
Freshly Baked Everyday
$10.95
Bear Claw Croissant
Chocolate & Toasted Coconut Croissant
$6.95
Brownies
Oreo Brownie
$6.00
Fudge Brownie
$6.00
Breakfast Rings
Fruit Ring
$16.95
Chocolate Horn Ring
$16.95
Pecan Ring
$16.95
Apple Horn Ring
$16.95
Cheese Danish Ring
$16.95
Almond Paste Ring
$16.95
Blueberry Pudding Ring
$16.95
Assorted Danish
Cheese Danish
$6.00
Pecan Danish
$6.00
Cinnamon Danish
$6.00
Apricot Danish
$6.00
Prune Danish
$6.00
Blueberry Danish
$6.00
Pineapple Danish
$6.00
Cherry Danish
$6.00
Almond Danish
$6.00
Raspberry Danish
$6.00
Mochaccino Danish
Chocolate Babka & Espresso based danish/bun
$6.00
1 Dozen Assorted Danish
$58.00
Crumb Cake Slice
Crumb Cake Slice
$4.95
Crumb Bun Slice
$4.95
Blueberry Slice with Vanilla Hard Icing on top
$6.95
Donuts
Jelly Donut
$4.95
Powdered Cruller Donut
$4.95
Vanilla French Cruller Donut
$4.95
Chocolate French Cruller Donut
$4.95
Vanilla Boston Cream Donut
$4.95
Chocolate Boston Cream Donut
$4.95
Glazed Donut
$4.95
One Dozen Assorted Donuts
$55.00
Muffins
Bran Muffin
$5.25
Corn Muffin
$5.25
Bluberry Muffin
$5.25
Lemon Poppy Muffin
$5.25
Chocolate Chip Muffin
$5.25
Gluten Free Muffin
$5.25
Carrot Muffin
$5.25
Apple Muffin
$5.25
All Chocolate Muffin
$5.25
1 Dozen Assorted Muffins
$55.00
Scones
Blueberry Scone
$5.25
Chocolate Chip Scone
$5.25
Cranberry Walnut Scone
$5.25
Raisin and Pecan Scone
$5.25
1 Dozen Assorted Scones
$55.00
Turnovers
Apple Turnover
$5.25
Cherry Turnover
$5.25
Blueberry Turnover
$5.25
Hamantaschen
Raspberry Hamantaschen
$5.25
Prune Hamantaschen
$5.25
Breakfast Pastries
Apple Strudel
$16.95
Peach Boat Puff Pastry
$6.00
1lb Assorted Rugelach
Apricot, Chocolate and Raspberry
$18.95
Chocolate Cigar
(Puff Pastry Dough)
$6.00•100% (7)
Palmier (Elephant Ear Cookie)
$6.00
Chocolate Dipped Almond Horn
$6.00
Sugar Free Pastry
Apple, Cherry, Blueberry
$6.00
Powdered Almond Horn
$6.00
FAMOUS TRES LECHE CAKE
Tres Leche Cake
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries.
$41.95
Personal Tres leche Cake
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries.
$12.95
Cookie Trays
1lb Pignoli Cookie
$41.95
1lb Rainbow Cookies
$31.95
1 Pound Cookie Tray
$32.50
Cookie Tray 1.5LB
one and a half pounds of butter cookies
$41.95
Cookie Tray 2lb
$49.95
Sugar Free Cookie Tray
$29.95
Cupcakes & Cake Pops
Red Velvet Cupcake
$5.95
Oreo Cupcake
$5.95
Carrot Cupcake
$5.95
Hostess Cupcake
$5.95
Chocolate Classic Cupcake
Chocolate
With Sprinkles and Cherry on Top
$5.95•100% (7)
Vanilla Classic Cupcake
Soft vanilla cupcake topped with smooth white frosting, colorful sprinkles, and a cherry.
$5.95
Chocolate Cake pop
$3.95
Vanilla Cake Pop
$3.95
Gluten Free Items
7" NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free)
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
$28.15
7" Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free)
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
$33.45
Gluten Free Brownie
$5.00
Gluten Free Cookie
Chocolate Chip or Sugar
$5.00
Individual NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free)
Smooth and silky cream cheese (gluten-free).
$6.25
Individual Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free)
Smooth and silky cream cheese finished with fluffy whipped cream and a fresh strawberry (gluten-free).
$8.10
Creme Brulee
$6.95
1 Pound Pignoli Cookie
$38.00
Cold Beverages
Orange Juice
$3.00
Apple Juice
$3.00
Diet Coke
$3.00
Coco-Cola
$3.00
Pure Leaf Tea
$3.00
Pure Leaf Unsweetened Tea
$3.00
Pellegrino
$3.00
Figi Water
$3.00
Poland Spring
$2.00
Cranberry Juice
$3.00
Grape Juice
$3.00
Sparkling Ice Black Raspberry
$3.50
Nesquik Chocolate Milk
$3.00
Sprite
$3.00
Custom Order ( Pre-ordered with our staff)
Custom Order
Please call the store first to place your order.
Enter the invoice number in special instructions.
(631) 424 -4034
$25.00
Thanksgiving Dessert
Cannoli
$6.00
Christmas Dessert
Sfoigetelle
$4.95
Gingerbread House
Pre-packaged Gingerbread house made with shortbread cookies! The perfect holiday treat or gift!
$60.00
Mother's Day Menu
The Mango Pastry
Airy mango mousse infused with fresh mango pieces at its center and layered with house made mango marmalade enclosed in a white chocolate coating and finished with a silky cocoa butter velvet
$12.95
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash