OddFellows Ice Cream Co. DUMBO Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Oddfellows Ice Cream
60 Water Street, Brooklyn, NY
Online ordering hours: 12:00 PM - 9:45 PMOpens 12:00 PM
Order for later
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
Cookies & Mint
$11.50
3 To-Go Tub Pack
$30.00
New Flavor 3 Pack
$30.00
Brooklyn Blackout
$11.50
DIY Ice Cream Sandwich
$10.00
Cookie Jar
$11.50
Vegan Grasshopper
$11.50
Vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice
$11.50
Vegan Chocolate Chunk
$11.50
Exotic Fruits Sorbet
$11.50
Salted Caramel Toffee
$11.50
Cookies & Cream
$11.50
Pumpkin Spice Mocha
$11.50
Vegan Coconut Pandan
$11.50
Strawberry Jam
$11.50
Milkshake
$12.00
Chocolate Chunk
$11.50
Coffee Crunch
$11.50
Sprinkles
$11.50
Vanilla Bean
$11.50
Boylans Cane Soda
$5.00
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 9:45 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
DIY Ice Cream Sandwich
Two chewy chocolate chip cookies with OddFellows ice cream sandwiched inside! Yum.
$10.00
Vegan Chocolate Chunk
Vegan macadamia-cashew-milk dark chocolate base with chunks of dark chocolate. Contains macadamia, cashew, coconut oil.
$11.50
Exotic Fruits Sorbet
Mango, banana, papaya, passionfruit, guava, kalamansi sorbet. Vegan and gluten free. Contains: Coconut oil.
$11.50
Vegan Grasshopper
Vegan chocolate cashew-based ice cream flavored with mint and spun with tons of chocolate sandwich cookies. Minty chocolate goodness. Allergens: cashew, gluten.
$11.50
Milkshake
16oz milkshake made with our homemade ice cream.
$12.00
Vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice
Coconut-based ice cream with mango swirls & gobs of mochi rice. Contains: Coconut, Gluten.
$11.50
Boylans Cane Soda
Order a bottle of Boylans delicious Cane Soda and make your own ice cream float at home!.
$5.00
Cookie Jar
Sweet cream ice cream with crushed Oreo cookies, chocolate chip cookie dough, and rainbow sprinkles. Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten
$11.50
3 To-Go Tub Pack
Save $4.50 when you purchase this 3 pack of to-go tubs. Choose 3 flavors and have a little party at home.
$30.00
Brooklyn Blackout
Chocolate ice cream with siwlrs of chocolate pudding and chunks of housemade chocolate cake. Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten
$11.50
Party Packs
14oz. To-Go Containers
3 To-Go Tub Pack
Save $4.50 when you purchase this 3 pack of to-go tubs. Choose 3 flavors and have a little party at home.
$30.00
6 To-Go Tub Pack
Save $9.00 when you party! Perfect for parties! Choose six to-go tubs of our unique ice cream flavors in a convenient to-go pack.
$60.00
Root Beer Float Pack
Create a classic soda float at home. Comes with two glass bottles of Boylan's Root Beer and a to-go tub of Vanilla Bean ice cream. Scoop, sip and float away.
$16.00
New Flavor 3 Pack
We just added three new flavors to our pint collection.Get one tub of each of the following flavors:
Brooklyn Blackout
Cookie Jar
Salted Caramel Toffee
$30.00
Classic Flavors
14oz. To-Go Containers
Vanilla Bean
Vanilla ice cream flecked with rich floral Madagascan vanilla beans.
Contains dairy and egg.
$11.50
Chocolate Chunk
Chocolate Ice Cream with dark chocolate chunks. Contains: Dairy, eggs, coconut
$11.50
Cookies & Cream
Sweet cream ice cream studded with chocolate cookie crumbs. The classic. Contains dairy, egg, and gluten.
$11.50
Cookies & Mint
A naturally green mint ice cream with chocolate cookie soil mixed in.
Contains dairy, egg, and gluten.
$11.50•6
#1 Most liked
Sprinkles
Our classic sweet cream ice cream with crunchy rainbow sprinkles. Contains dairy and egg.
$11.50
Coffee Crunch
Coffee based ice cream with house made coffee soil mixed in. Contains: Eggs, Dairy, Gluten, Almond Flour
$11.50
Strawberry Jam
Strawberry ice cream with fresh strawberry jam swirls throughout. Contains: dairy, eggs
$11.50
OddFellows Original Flavors
14oz. To-Go Containers
Pumpkin Spice Mocha
Spiced Pumpkin ice cream with a brown sugar cinnamon swirl and chocolate espresso flakes.
Contains: dary, eggs
$11.50
Salted Caramel Toffee
Sweet cream ice cream with swirls of salted caramel and chunks of chocolate coated toffee. Contains: dairy, eggs, tree nuts
$11.50
Brooklyn Blackout
Chocolate ice cream with siwlrs of chocolate pudding and chunks of housemade chocolate cake. Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten
$11.50
Cookie Jar
Sweet cream ice cream with crushed Oreo cookies, chocolate chip cookie dough, and rainbow sprinkles. Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten
$11.50
Vegan Flavors
14oz Packaged Tubs
Vegan Chocolate Chunk
Vegan macadamia-cashew-milk dark chocolate base with chunks of dark chocolate. Contains macadamia, cashew, coconut oil.
$11.50
Exotic Fruits Sorbet
Mango, banana, papaya, passionfruit, guava, kalamansi sorbet. Vegan and gluten free. Contains: Coconut oil.
$11.50
Vegan Coconut Lemon Curd
Coconut milk based ice cream with swirls of vegan lemon curd.
$11.50
Vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice
Coconut-based ice cream with mango swirls & gobs of mochi rice. Contains: Coconut, Gluten.
$11.50
Vegan Grasshopper
Vegan chocolate cashew-based ice cream flavored with mint and spun with tons of chocolate sandwich cookies. Minty chocolate goodness. Allergens: cashew, gluten.
$11.50
Vegan Coconut Pandan
A smooth coconut milk based ice cream infused with pandan. Giving Coconut with a hint of vanilla.
$11.50
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Housemade seasonal ice cream sandwiches!
Chocolate Chip Cookie (No Ice Cream)
Chunks of rich chocolate embedded in soft, buttery cookies.
$2.00
DIY Ice Cream Sandwich
Two chewy chocolate chip cookies with OddFellows ice cream sandwiched inside! Yum.
$10.00
Beverages
Milkshake
16oz milkshake made with our homemade ice cream.
$12.00
Boylans Cane Soda
Order a bottle of Boylans delicious Cane Soda and make your own ice cream float at home!.
$5.00
Water Bottle
16.9 fl oz poland springs water bottle
$3.00
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash