Sweet Pea’s(Main St) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Sweet Pea’s
4 South Main Street, Mayville, WI
Online ordering hours: ClosedOpens Sep 30
Order for later
Featured Items
Caramel Apple Crumble Pie, 10"
$20.99
Cherry Pie, 10"
$22.99
Pistachio Cream Pie
$21.99
Key Lime Pie
$21.99
Pecan Pie
$24.99
Berrylicious Pie
$20.99
Smore's Pie
$21.99
Shake or Malt
$6.79
4" Mini Cake
$12.95
Cake Parfait
$4.65
Peanut Butter Flavor of the Week
$7.50
Coffee or Espresso Variety
$7.50
Cotton Candy, Blue Moon, Superman, or Birthday Cake
$7.50
Açaí Bowl with fruit and granola
$9.45
Mint Variety
$7.50
Ultimate Oreo or Cookie Dough
$7.50
Nut Ice Cream
$7.50
This $&@! Just Got Serious Ice Cream
$7.50
Dubai ice Cream Sundae
$9.50
Ice Cream Sandwich
$4.99
Root Beer Float
$4.25
Full Menu
closedMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Açaí Bowl with fruit and granola
Dairy free, vegan. Açaí sorbet topped with house made granola, bananas, berries and drizzled with honey or peanut butter.
$9.45
Shake or Malt
Our shakes and malts are made with Chocolate Shoppe Super Premium Ice cream and milk then topped with whipped cream. Simple, delicious. 14 oz.
$6.79
4" Mini Cake
Double layer mini cake stylishly decorated. To share or not to share, that is the only question.
$12.95
Cake Parfait
Cake is layered with cream, pudding, or buttercream in these delicious and adorable cake parfaits.
$4.65
Ice Cream Sandwich
We start with a housemade sugar or chocolate chip cookie, add a generous amount of our super premium Chocolate Shoppe ice cream. It's finger licking good! Hope you are hungry.
$4.99
This $&@! Just Got Serious Ice Cream
Gluten free. Pint. Award-winning, smooth salted caramel ice cream brimming with rich sea salt fudge and salted cashews.
$7.50
Peanut Butter Flavor of the Week
Pint. Call before ordering if you need to know what variety is available for delivery today. You might get Fat Elvis, Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Moose Tracks, Yippee Skippy, Peanut Butter Cup, PB Hearts, etc.
$7.50
Cotton Candy, Blue Moon, Superman, or Birthday Cake
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. We will send whichever of these flavors we have on hand in our case. Call before ordering if you would like to know which flavor we will deliver today.
$7.50
Ultimate Oreo or Cookie Dough
Nut free. Pint. Scrumptious Oreo ice cream made with boat-loads of whole Oreos or vanilla ice cream with chocolate flakes and chunks of cookie dough. We rotate these super popular flavors.
$7.50
Dubai Strawerry Cup
Fresh Strawberries are sliced and layered with chocolate, pistachio kinda sauce and then topped with pistachios and kinda crumch
$14.95
Dubai Chocolat
We offer three Dubai Chocolate Items
Dubai Strawerry Cup
Fresh Strawberries are sliced and layered with chocolate, pistachio kinda sauce and then topped with pistachios and kinda crumch
$14.95
Dubai ice Cream Sundae
Our award winning vanilla ice cream is layered with chocolate, pistachio kinda sauce and strawberries then topped with whipped cream and more sauce
$9.50
Dubai Chocolate Bar
Creamy milk chocolate bar infused with rich pistachio flavor and hints of traditional Kunafa, offering a delightful blend of sweetness and nuttiness.
$14.95
Pints: Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream
If you want nutrition, eat carrots! Manufactured in a facility in Madison, WI, that also processes wheat, soy, peanuts and all types of tree nuts.
Cotton Candy, Blue Moon, Superman, or Birthday Cake
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. We will send whichever of these flavors we have on hand in our case. Call before ordering if you would like to know which flavor we will deliver today.
$7.50
Oat Milk Ice Cream
Pint. Dairy free, vegetarian, vegan, gluten free ice cream that is smooth and creamy. We can't tell the difference! Varieties vary and might include Blue Moon, Vanilla, chocolate chip, black cherry, oatmeal cookie dough )contains gluten), caramel me oatchata, or mint oreo (contains gluten).
$7.50
Italian Ice
Dairy free, nut free, gluten free and bursting with tangy flavor and fruit juices. Pint. We will send whatever variety we have in the case today. Varies between carrot mango, passion fruit, raspberry lemon, strawberry hibiscus, and electric watermelon. If you want to know what is available please call the store before ordering.
$7.50
Coffee or Espresso Variety
Pint. Selection varies and might include Exhausted Parent, Iced Latte Dah, Espresso Oreo, and Espresso Almond Fudge. Call to find out today's selection before ordering.
$7.50
Nut Ice Cream
Pint. We always have at least one ice cream featuring nuts in our case. We might have rocky road, pistachio, butter pecan, coconut almond bliss, or another nut lovers favorite variety. Please call the store before you order if you need to know what variety will be delivered today.
$7.50
Seasonal Favorite
Pint. Examples of a seasonal variety is gingerbread man, peppermint stick, blackberry lemon bar, lemon meringue, banana cream pie, and rhubarb crumble. Our pint selection changes daily so call before you order if you want to select your own flavor.
$7.50
Mint Variety
Nut free. Pint. We might have Mint Avalanceh, Zanzamint, mint chip, mint oreo or in the holiday season Peppermint Chip - they are all a mint lover's paradise! Please call the store if you need to know what variety we have available for delivery today.
$7.50
Chocolate Variety Ice Cream
Pint. It could be Malt Amore, Sticks and Stones, Haley's Comet, Raspberry Truffle, or even Peanut Butter Cup, but we always have at least one chocolate based ice cream in our case. Call if you'd like to know what we will send with your delivery today.
$7.50
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. An award-winning and all-natural classic vanilla ice cream made with Wisconsin cream, cane sugar and pure vanilla.
$7.50
Rainbow Sherbet
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. Orange, lime, and raspberry flavored sherbets classically swirled together.
$7.50
This $&@! Just Got Serious Ice Cream
Gluten free. Pint. Award-winning, smooth salted caramel ice cream brimming with rich sea salt fudge and salted cashews.
$7.50
Ultimate Oreo or Cookie Dough
Nut free. Pint. Scrumptious Oreo ice cream made with boat-loads of whole Oreos or vanilla ice cream with chocolate flakes and chunks of cookie dough. We rotate these super popular flavors.
$7.50
Fruit Ice Cream
Pint. Fruit ice cream is one of our favorites! In the case you might find strawberry, black cherry, blueberry cheesecake, kitty kitty bang bang, door county cherry or other delicious ice creams with fruit at center stage. Pint varieties can change daily so give us a call before you order if you want to choose which flavor we send.
$7.50
Peanut Butter Flavor of the Week
Pint. Call before ordering if you need to know what variety is available for delivery today. You might get Fat Elvis, Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Moose Tracks, Yippee Skippy, Peanut Butter Cup, PB Hearts, etc.
$7.50
Zanzibar® Chocolate Ice Cream
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. All-natural and award-winning chocolate ice cream made with three kinds of cocoa for a rich, fudge brownie taste.
$7.50
Butter Pecan
Pint. Buttery pecan ice cream with boat-loads of crispy, lightly roasted and salted pecans.
$7.50
Açaí Bowl
We start with organic açaí sorbet then we add our housemade granola, berries, bananas, and your choice of honey or peanut butter drizzle.
Açaí Bowl with fruit and granola
Dairy free, vegan. Açaí sorbet topped with house made granola, bananas, berries and drizzled with honey or peanut butter.
$9.45
Dubai Strawberry Smoothie Bowl
Açaí base topped with fresh strawberries, chocolate chunks, and a drizzle of green matcha.
$14.45
Midnight Kiss Smoothie Bowl
Acai sorbet and dragonfruit sorbet are topped with house-made granola, candied almonds, strawberries and raspberry sauce.
$11.75
Beverages
Grab a specialty bottled beverage made in Wisconsin.
Sprecher Root Beer (16 oz glass made with honey)
Traditional A&W Root Beer in a 12 oz can.
$2.99
Prime - available flavors vary
16.9 oz each bottle contains 10% coconut water, zero sugar, BCAA's, antioxidants, electrolytes, and zinc for immunity.
$2.75
Ice Cream Drinks and Treats
In case a pint of ice cream just won't do, try one of these tasty treats made with super premium Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream
Root Beer Float
A&W root beer and vanilla ice cream combine for a classic tasty treat
$4.25
Affogato
4 ounces of coffee poured over a scoop of vanilla ice cream and topped with caramel drizzle.
$4.49
Shake or Malt
Our shakes and malts are made with Chocolate Shoppe Super Premium Ice cream and milk then topped with whipped cream. Simple, delicious. 14 oz.
$6.79
Ice Cream Sandwich
We start with a housemade sugar or chocolate chip cookie, add a generous amount of our super premium Chocolate Shoppe ice cream. It's finger licking good! Hope you are hungry.
$4.99
Bakery Treats
Cake slices, cake pops, pie tarts, cookies, brownies, marshmallow cereal treats and more! Selection varies weekly.
4" Mini Cake
Double layer mini cake stylishly decorated. To share or not to share, that is the only question.
$12.95
Cookies
Selection: chocolate chip, sugar, or coconut macaroons
$2.49
Cereal Treats
Housemade soft and buttery krispie cereal treats.
$2.49
Cake Pops
Soft confetti cake center coated in white chocolate or chocolate cake covered in dark chocolate.
$2.99
Cake Parfait
Cake is layered with cream, pudding, or buttercream in these delicious and adorable cake parfaits.
$4.65
Dog Treat
Give your pet a special occassion treat! We bake our treats using human grade ingredients and coat them with yogurt chips so they have minimal sugar.
$2.50
Handcrafted Pie
Our pie is made from scratch in small batches using family recipes. Did you notice you smiled when you read the word pie? We think the world needs more smiles, so we're just gonna keep on makin' our seriously craveable pie.
Smore's Pie
A 9" graham cracker crust is filled with fluffy, milk chocolate goodness then topped with mini marshmallows. Serves 6-8
$21.99
Berrylicious Pie
Our vegan 10" pastry is bursting with flavor. The Pie Guy's favorite pie has raspberries, blueberries, blackberries and a hint of ginger.
$20.99
Cherry Pie, 10"
Tart cherries, double pastry crust - it's a classic.
$22.99
Honey Pie, 10"
We start with our vegan pastry crust and then add a honey custard made with local honey (when possible), eggs, cream and a little bit of greek yogurt to balance the sweetness. It's smooth, creamy and tastes great warm or cold. Some people like to add a sprinkle of coarse flake salt to the top or some toasted nuts for crunch.
$21.99
Caramel Apple Crumble Pie, 10"
This is one of our top fall favorites. Tart apples get covered in cinnamon and caramel then topped with a butter, brown sugar, and oat crumble.
$20.99
Pistachio Cream Pie
Graham cracker crust layered with fluffy cream cheese, pistachio pudding, and whipped cream and a sprinkle of crushed pistachios.
$21.99
Lemon Ice Box Pie
Graham cracker crust filled with tangy, sweet, creamy, fluffy lemon whipped filling and topped with lemon zest. Yeah, you need this in your life!
$21.99
Key Lime Pie
A sweet graham cracker crust is filled with tangy, smooth baked lime custard then topped with whipped cream dollops.
$21.99
Peanut Butter Chocolate Creme Pie
Peanut butter creme and chocolate pudding iare layered n a graham crust and finished off with cream and chocolate and peanut butter drizzle.
$21.99
Pecan Pie
It's a classic, but ours isn't overly sweet and sticky . one of our favorites that's only around september through easter. dig in with two forks.
$24.99
French Silk Pie
Graham crust is filled with homemade smooth and silly chocolate then topped with whipped cream and mini chocolate chips. One of our original recipes that is so good we didn't see any reason to change it. Contains: eggs, milk, wheat, soy
$24.99
Raspberry Icebox Pie
Fluffy, sweet, and tangy raspberry cream fills a graham cracker crust then gets a decorative whipped cream finish.
$21.99
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash