The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Wings
#3 Most liked
Chicken wings, available in 5 or 10, with options for regular or healthy baked. Choose from various sauces or dry rubs, including teriyaki, garlic herb, and multiple buffalo styles.
$9.49•97% (44)
Large 14" Create Your Own Pizza
Large 14" pizza with options for traditional or thin crust. Sauce choices include original, spicy, marinara, sweet, garlic, and BBQ. Customize with your favorite toppings.
$17.49•94% (38)
Medium 12" Create Your Own Pizza
12" pizza with choice of traditional or thin crust. Selections of sauces: original, spicy, marinara, sweet, garlic, BBQ.
$14.49•94% (34)
Cheesy Breadsticks
Served with marinara sauce.
$7.25•95% (43)
Spaghetti or Penne
With our homemade marinara sauce.
$9.99•81% (33)
BBQ Ribs with 2 Sides
St. Louis style pork ribs basted in our award winning BBQ sauce served with your choice of 2 sides.
$20.99•87% (31)
Calzone with Two Toppings
Calzones with 2 toppings, served with pizza sauce.
$11.49•100% (37)
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with marinara dipping sauce.
$11.49•100% (28)
Small 8" Create Your Own Pizza
#2 Most liked
8" pizza with choice of traditional or thin crust. Select from original, spicy, marinara, sweet, garlic, or BBQ sauce.
$9.25•97% (48)
Boneless Wings
Half-Pound
$12.49•80% (15)
Sandwiches
Italian Meatball Sandwich
Homemade Italian meatballs loaded with sauce and Provolone cheese.
$14.49
The Criminal
Grilled Cheese on Texas Toast with 2 over easy eggs- don't ask for the eggs dry-we won't ruin a great sandwich!
$11.49
Italian Sausage Sandwich
Fresh sausage topped with grilled green peppers and onion or Provolone cheese and spaghetti sauce.
$14.49
Corned Beef Sandwich
Stacked high on rye.
$15.49
Reuben Sandwich
Reuben sandwich with choice of side: fries, slaw, beans, potatoes, mac-n-cheese, onion rings, chips, tots.
$16.49•90% (10)
Dublin Dip Sandwich
Thinly sliced rib eye served on a hoagie bun with cheese and au jus.
$15.49•88% (9)
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Thinly sliced rib eye grilled with peppers, onions, and mushrooms smothered with cheese.
$15.49•85% (7)
Gyro Sandwich
Grilled lamb with tomatoes, onions, and cucumbers.
$15.49
Chicken Philly Sandwich
Chicken grilled with peppers, onions, and mushrooms smothered with cheese.
$15.49•100% (7)
West Side Grill Sandwich
Char-broiled chicken breast topped with mushrooms, bacon, and melted Mozzarella cheese, served on a bun with lettuce and tomato.
$15.49
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Italian chicken breast covered in Provolone cheese and marinara sauce.
$15.49•63% (11)
Hoagie
Hot or cold. Loaded with ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
$14.49
Italian Beef
Topped with Gianardiniera Sauce - wet & sloppy - just like Chicago, but not
$15.49•85% (7)
The Bail Out
Fried chicken sandwich with your choice of spicy or sweet mayo
$13.49
8" Small Specialty Pizza
BBQ Rib Pizza - 8" Small
Award-winning. With our famous Geppetto's bbq sauce, boneless rib meat, and onion topped with Provolone and Cheddar.
$15.99
Meat Feast Pizza - 8" Small
Feast your eyes on generous portions of pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, and homemade meatballs.
$15.99
Pepperoni Feast Pizza - 8" Small
Extra pepperoni with lots and lots of cheese.
$15.99•100% (42)
Let's Go To Hawaii Pizza - 8" Small
Say aloha to a delicious combo of ham, bacon, and pineapple with special island spices.
$15.99
Loaded Potato Pizza - 8" Small
Loaded with potato, ranch, and bacon, Cheddar/Provolone mix, and a touch of garlic butter.
$15.99
House Deluxe Pizza - 8" Small
Our award-winning pizza with your choice of 5 standard toppings.
$15.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 8" Small
Award-winning Geppetto's sauce covered tender chicken chunks with Provolone and Cheddar.
$15.99
Buffalo Boneless Chicken Pizza - 8" Small
Chicken breast, Provolone cheese, crumbled Bleu cheese, and buffalo sauce.
$15.99
Mexican Fiesta Pizza - 8" Small
A south of the border taco sauce, taco meat, onions, green peppers, olives, tomatoes, tortilla chips, and two cheeses.
Top round steak, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, cheese and cheese and more cheese
$15.99
Starters
Pepperoni Bites
Sweet and Spicy Served with marinara sauce
$8.25•100% (33)
Rueben Rolls
Served with 1000 Island and Horsey Sauce
$16.49
Combo Platter
A sampling of our famous wings, Mozzarella sticks, BBQ ribs, potato skins, and chicken fingers.
$26.49•93% (16)
Chicken Fingers
Lightly breaded chicken tossed in your favourite wing sauce.
$11.49
Loaded Nachos
Pile it on - ground beef, cheese, sour cream, black olives, green peppers, onions, & pepper rings.
$15.49
Loaded Fries
#1 Most liked
Our fresh cut French fries smothered with cheese and bacon.
$10.49•98% (66)
Cheesy Breadsticks
Served with marinara sauce.
$7.25•95% (43)
Jumbo Johnny's
Soft pretzel sticks served with beer cheese sauce.
$11.49
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with marinara dipping sauce.
$11.49•100% (28)
Chicken Quesadilla
Sub Steak extra 1.99 on a tortilla shell served with sour cream and Salsa.
$15.49
Breaded Mushrooms
Crispy Breaded Mushrooms, Golden and Perfectly Seasoned
$11.49•100% (7)
Breaded Green Beans
Served with cool Buffalo.
$11.49
Potato Skins
Loaded with bacon and cheese.
$11.49•96% (32)
Basket of Onion Rings
Thick cut, beer battered, double dipped, and seasoned, piled high, and served with cool Buffalo dipping sauce.
$11.49
Deep Fried Pickles
With horsey sauce.
$11.49
Garlic Bread with cheese
Crisp garlic bread, available plain or topped with melted cheese.
$7.25•100% (6)
Cheese Curds
Lightly breaded with a garlic dusting served with marinara
$10.49
Johnny Bites
Pretzel bites tossed in garlic sauce and served w/ cheese sauce
$11.49
Mussels
Served w/ our famous garlic butter sauce
$13.49
Wings That Wow!
Wings
#3 Most liked
Chicken wings, available in 5 or 10, with options for regular or healthy baked. Choose from various sauces or dry rubs, including teriyaki, garlic herb, and multiple buffalo styles.
$9.49•97% (44)
Boneless Wings
Half-Pound
$12.49•80% (15)
Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Chicken strips, Romaine lettuce, croutons, and Caesar dressing.
$12.49
Cool Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken tenders spun in our spicy cool Buffalo sauce and served with lettuce and Blue cheese dressing.
$12.49
Breakfast Wrap
2 fried egg, potatoes, ham, sausage, bacon, and with a dash of hot sauce all wrapped up.
$12.49
OHHH Boy Wrap
Breaded shrimp tossed in our bonsai sauce. Wrapped with lettuce, onion, and Provolone cheese.
$12.49
Spicy Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken tenders spun in our original Buffalo sauce with lettuce and Provolone cheese.
$12.49
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Chicken, bacon, Provolone cheese, lettuce, and Ranch dressing.
$12.49•92% (13)
Burgers
Black & Bleu Burger
Blackened to perfection with our special Cajun seasoning and topped with Bleu cheese dressing.
$14.49
The Malloy Classic Burger
Half pound of fresh ground chuck topped with melted Swiss, then smothered in grilled onions, and sautéed mushrooms.
$14.49
Bourbon Bacon Burger
Our half pound burger with Cheddar, bacon, and our southern style chow chow topped with honey bourbon glaze.
$14.49
Sunrise Burger
Half pound burger with American cheese, bacon, and a fried egg.
$14.49•100% (6)
St. Patty Melt Burger
Half pound of fresh ground chuck topped with grilled onions and Swiss cheese on rye bread.
$14.49
BBQ Burger
Half pound of fresh ground chuck drippin' in Geppetto's bbq sauce, then topped with crisp bacon.
$14.49
Cleveland Hero Burger
2-1/4 lb. patties with salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, special Italian dressing, and mayo.
$14.49
All American Burger
Half pound of fresh ground chuck topped with bacon and American cheese.
$14.49•100% (7)
Deputy Sheriff
Quarter pound burger with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and our super special Sheriff sauce on a Brioche bun
$11.49
Salads
Chef Salad
Meat this favorite - ham, salami, pepperoni,on a bed of lettuce with cucumber, tomato, and pepperoncini.
$13.49•100% (6)
Garden Salad
Lettuce serve you. Tomato, cucumber, and pepperoncini.
$7.49•78% (14)
Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken breast, pepperoncini, and red ripe tomatoes.
$13.49
Cobb Salad
Chopped mixed greens, bacon, chicken, tomato, eggs, black olives, cucumber, and crumbled Blue cheese.
$15.49•100% (9)
Caesar Salad
Romaine and croutons, served with creamy Caesar dressing with chicken.
$11.49
Geppetto's Famous Pizza
Small 8" Create Your Own Pizza
#2 Most liked
8" pizza with choice of traditional or thin crust. Select from original, spicy, marinara, sweet, garlic, or BBQ sauce.
$9.25•97% (48)
Medium 12" Create Your Own Pizza
12" pizza with choice of traditional or thin crust. Selections of sauces: original, spicy, marinara, sweet, garlic, BBQ.
$14.49•94% (34)
Large 14" Create Your Own Pizza
Large 14" pizza with options for traditional or thin crust. Sauce choices include original, spicy, marinara, sweet, garlic, and BBQ. Customize with your favorite toppings.
$17.49•94% (38)
12" Medium Specialty Pizza
BBQ Rib Pizza - 12" Medium
Award-winning. With our famous Geppetto's BBQ sauce, boneless rib meat, and onion topped with Provolone and Cheddar.
$22.99
Meat Feast Pizza - 12" Medium
Feast your eyes on generous portions of pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, and homemade meatballs.
$22.99
Pepperoni Feast Pizza - 12" Medium
Extra pepperoni with lots and lots of cheese.
$22.99
Let's Go To Hawaii Pizza - 12" Medium
Say aloha to a delicious combo of ham, bacon, and pineapple with special island spices.
$22.99
Loaded Potato Pizza - 12" Medium
Loaded with potato, ranch, and bacon, Cheddar and Provolone mix, and a touch of garlic butter.
$22.99
House Deluxe Pizza - 12" Medium
Our award winning pizza with your choice of 5 standard toppings.
$22.99•90% (10)
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 12" Medium
Award-winning Geppetto's sauce covering tender chicken chunks with Provolone and Cheddar.
$22.99
Buffalo Boneless Chicken Pizza - 12" Medium
Chicken breast, Provolone cheese, crumbled Bleu cheese, and Buffalo sauce.
$22.99
Mexican Fiesta Pizza - 12" Medium
A south of the border taco sauce, taco meat, onions, green peppers, olives, tomatoes, tortilla chips, and two cheeses.
Crisp green beans, available in small or large sizes.
$4.50
Redskin Potatoes
Redskin potatoes, offered in small or large sizes.
$4.50
Homemade Mac & Cheese
Creamy macaroni enveloped in rich cheese sauce. Options: small, large.
$4.50
Baked Beans
Hearty baked beans in a savory sauce. Available in small or large sizes.
$4.50
Onion Rings
With cool buffalo sauce.
$4.50
Potato Chips
Thinly sliced potatoes, baked until crisp, typically seasoned with a light sprinkle of salt.
$4.50
Cleveland Kraut
Cleveland kraut available in small or large size.
$4.50
Tater Tots
Crispy golden tots, perfect for dipping. A comforting classic side dish.
$4.50
Calzones
Calzone with Two Toppings
Calzones with 2 toppings, served with pizza sauce.
$11.49•100% (37)
Beverages
Bottled Water
Pure, refreshing bottled water, perfect for quenching your thirst.
$1.50
Desserts
Cinnabites
Fried Dough sprinkled with sugar and cinnamon, served with icing.
$8.99•100% (10)
Extra Sauces
Wing Sauce
Wing sauce options ranging from dry rubs like chipotle smoke and lemon pepper to zesty and sweet varieties including honey bourbon bbq and spicy honey mustard.
$1.00•87% (8)
Dipping Sauce
Selection of dipping sauces including ranch, honey mustard, marinara, bleu cheese, BBQ, sour cream, and salsa.
$1.00•94% (18)
Salad Dressing
Choose from a variety of dressings: bleu cheese, French, honey mustard, creamy Italian, balsamic vinaigrette, buttermilk ranch, poppy seed, Italian, and low-fat Italian.