e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from McGillicuddy's Restaurant & Tap House at 84 Main Street in New Paltz. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

McGillicuddy's Restaurant & Tap House 84 Main Street - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to McGillicuddy's Restaurant & Tap House to pick up this order: 84 Main Street

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

A basket full of fries, tossed in garlic, parmesan cheese and parsley.

Garlic Fries

With melted cheddar jack cheese and fresh pico de gallo. Served with salsa and sour cream.

Quesadilla

Honey BBQ

Classic burger topped with lettuce, and tomato.

Classic Burger

Deep fried macaroni and pepper jack cheese. Served with a side of sour cream.

Spicy Mac Bites

Served with BBQ sauce or honey mustard. Add a Half Portion of Fries for an additional charge. 

Chicken Tenders

Crispy chicken, fresh mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers and pesto mayo. Served on grilled ciabatta bread.

Chicken Godfather

Bowl of Rich and creamy, full of potatoes and bacon.

Irish Potato Soup

Hand-crafted, fried mozzarella cheese sticks five pieces. Served with a side of marinara sauce.

Mozzarella Sticks

Volcanic (Medium Buffalo)

Popular Items

All sandwiches served with fries and pickle.

Crispy chicken tenders tossed in our smoldering sauce with lettuce, tomato, red onion and bleu cheese dressing. Served on a grilled egg twist roll.

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Our house-made corned beef, with sauerkraut and swiss cheese, topped with thousand island dressing. Served on grilled rye bread.

Corned Beef Reuben

Sliced turkey, fresh avocado, crispy bacon, lettuce and tomato. Served on a grilled egg twist roll with chipotle mayo.

Turkey Avocado BLT

Bbq pulled pork topped with cheddar cheese. Served on a grilled egg twist roll.

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Grilled steak and sauteed onions, topped with homemade habanero cheese sauce and garlic fries on the sandwich. Served on a grilled semolina club roll.

Philly Cheesesteak

Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce and tomato. Served in a warm tortilla wrap.

Grilled Chicken Club Wrap

Marinated portabella mushrooms, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella cheese, and pesto mayo, served on grilled ciabatta bread.

Portabella Godfather

Sliced Turkey, with sauerkraut and swiss cheese, topped with thousand island dressing. Served on grilled rye bread.

Turkey Reuben

Beer battered cod, lemon pepper tartar, lettuce and tomato, served on a grilled batard roll.

Fisherman's Catch

Chicken cutlet, Nashville hot sauce, pickles, mayo, shreeded lettuce, served on a brioche bun.

Nashville Hot Chicken

Sandwiches

Ten wings per order. Served with celery and bleu cheese.

Pepper Spray

Red Hot BBQ

Gold Fever

Inferno (Hot Buffalo)

3 Alarm (Hot Buffalo)

Habanero Honey Buffalo

Nashville Hot

Brazilian Fire (Dry Rub)

Honey Buffalo

Smoldering (Mild Buffalo)

Awesome Sauce

Sweet Heat BBQ

Cajun Spice (Dry Rub)

Jamaican Jerk (Dry Rub)

Sweet Thai Chili

Teriyaki

Gold Rush

Garlic Parmesan

Wings

Our hot beef chili, topped with sour cream, shredded cheddar jack cheese and tortilla chips.

911 Chili

Homemade onion soup. Topped with French bread and our three cheese melt.

French Onion Soup

Soups

Chicken tenders, tossed in our smoldering sauce, over mixed greens, with celery, shredded carrots, tomato wedges and bleu cheese crumbles. Served with a side of bleu cheese dressing.

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Your choice of chicken, steak or black bean. Served over mixed greens with avocado, bacon, corn salsa, hard boiled egg, mixed cheese and tortilla chips. Served with a side of sriracha ranch dressing.

Southwest Cobb Salad

Fresh mixed greens, shredded carrots, cucumbers, red onion, croutons and grape tomatoes. Served with your choice of dressing.

Market Salad

Sliced Local Apples, toasted pecans, cheddar, cucumber, red onion, mixed greens, apple cider vinaigrette

Apple Pecan Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce, tossed in Caesar dressing, topped with parmesan cheese and croutons.

Caesar Salad

Whole romaine heart wedge, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, grape tomato, cucumber, red onion, balsamic glaze, choice of dressing

Steakhouse Wedge

Tempura shrimp, Thai chili glaze, mixed greens, rice noodles, grape tomato, cucumber, avocado, carrots, peanut butter vinaigrette

Thai Glazed Crispy Shrimp Salad

Salads

Seasoned waffle fries with chopped bacon and melted cheddar jack cheese. Served with a side of ranch dressing.

Irish Nachos

Fried brussel sprouts, topped with crumbled bleu cheese, chopped bacon, and cuddy's secret sauce. 

Crispy Brussel Spouts

Tortilla chips, topped with homemade habanero cheese sauce, fresh pico de gallo, shredded lettuce, salsa and sour cream. Add Guacamole for an additional charge. 

Nachos

Pickle spears, breaded and fried six pieces. Served with a side of sriracha ranch.

Frickles

corned beef, mixed cheese, Swiss cheese, 1000 island dressing, sauerkraut

Irish Eggrolls

Three cheese pierogi, bacon scallion sour cream dipping sauce

Fried Pierogi

Three Bavarian Pretzel Sticks, served with a side of our homemade habanero cheese sauce. 

Pretzels

A warm, creamy blend of spinach and Chicken, with melted cheddar jack cheese, in a bread bow.

Chicken and Spinach Dip

Garlic Waffle Fries

Garlic Sweet Potato Fries

Starters

All burgers served on a grilled brioche roll with fries.

Bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, fried onion straws, lettuce, and tomato.

Bleu Bacon Burger

Fresh avocado, pico de gallo, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and chipotle mayo.

Cali Burger

Cheddar cheese, fried onion straws, BBQ sauce, lettuce and tomato.

Cowboy Burger

Lettuce, tomato, pickles, bacon, and cheddar. 

All American Burger

Homemade black bean burger, topped with lettuce, and tomato.

Black Bean Burger

grilled portobello, swiss cheese, lettuce, and tomato.

Mushroom Swiss Burger

caramalized onions, Swiss, onion jus, garlic mayo

French Dip Burger

4 hawaiian rolls, bacon bits, ranch, caramelized onions

Burger Bites

maple bourbon glaze, apple compote, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato

Maple Apple Burger

Burgers

slow roasted chicken, veg, toasted biscuits

Irish Stout Chicken Pot Pie

A blend of smoked gouda, Colby jack, cheddar and parmesan cheese.

Mac & Cheese

Battered and fried cod, served with fries and a side of tartar sauce.

Fish & Chips

Penne Ala Vodka

Blend of beef, veggies, and mashed potatos, topped with cheddar jack cheese, and gravy. 

Shepherd's Pie

USDA choice ribeye, mashed potato, seasonal vegetables, roasted garlic horseradish cream

Chargrilled Ribeye

garlic butter, white wine, diced tomato, parmesan, cracked black pepper 

Garlic Shrimp Penne

Entrees

Mashed Potatoes

Cauliflower, broccoli, carrots, Yellow squash, zucchini.

Chef Choice Vegetable

French Fries

Small side salad, with crisp romaine lettuce, tossed in housemade caesar dressing, topped with parmesan cheese, and croutons. 

Side Caesar Salad

Small side salad, with fresh mixed greens, cucumber, red onion, tomato, and croutons. 

Side Salad

Sweet Potato Fries

Waffle Fries

Sides

5 Boneless Wings served with a side of apple sauce.
Add special instructions to add any sauce. 

Kids Boneless Wings

Small Kids burger served with a side of apple sauce.

Kids Burger

Small kids burger with american cheese, served with a side of apple sauce. 

Kids Cheeseburger

Grilled cheese, with american cheese, on white bread, served with a side of apple sauce.

Kids Grilled Cheese

Hot dog served with a side of apple sauce.

Kids Hot Dog

Kids portion of our homemade mac and cheese. 

Kids Mac & Cheese

Kids Pasta, penne or linguini, with marinara or butter

Kids Pasta

Chicken Tenders, served with a side of apple sauce.

Kids Tenders

5 Plain Wings served with a side of apple sauce. 
Add special instructions to add any sauce. 

Kids Wings

Kids Meals

All Day

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

<<taggedItemId=155950666>>Chicken godfather<</taggedItemId>> is always an amazing go-to. I love that it almost even tastes better the next day reheated.
<<taggedItemId=155950565>>Irish nachos<</taggedItemId>> for the win! Great portions

Chicken godfather is always an amazing go-to. I love that it almost even tastes better the next day reheated.
Irish nachos for the win! Great portions

The <<taggedItemId=155950709>>honey buffalo<</taggedItemId>> chicken was super good! I'd definitely recommend this along with the <<taggedItemId=155950580>>garlic fries<</taggedItemId>> as a side. The fries don't even need any ketchup or added salt to be good!

The honey buffalo chicken was super good! I'd definitely recommend this along with the garlic fries as a side. The fries don't even need any ketchup or added salt to be good!

Fish and chips very good but potato soup really, really good.  Just a side came with dinner but next time would definitely order a full portion.


Nashville Hot Chicken was super greasy and lacking lettuce /pickles. 
Fish n Chips was just one big fish fillet. It was also very greasy and had a fishy flavor like it was old. 
Maybe it would been better eating at the restaurant, idk . But the greasiness was gross. 

barely any chicken in salad (despite $4 extra), and wings were very small despite being expensive as well.

McGillicuddy's Restaurant & Tap House

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

Sandwiches

Wings

Soups

Salads

Starters

Burgers

Entrees

Sides

Kids Meals

McGillicuddy's Restaurant & Tap House Near Me - Pickup and Delivery