The Dark Horse Tavern (Bay Shore) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
The Dark Horse Tavern (Bay Shore)
Sign In / Sign Up
The Dark Horse Tavern
53 W Main St, Bay Shore NY 11706-8307, United StatesOpens 12:00 PM
Order for later
Featured Items
Famous Dark Horse Wings
$16.00
California Wrap
$18.00
Brie Stuffed Pretzels
$14.00
Chicken Tenders
$14.00
Chicken Tenders
$10.00
Mac and Cheese
$16.00
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$17.00
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
$17.00
Quesadilla
$11.00
Chicken Panini
$16.00
Pub Style Tidbits
$16.00
Grilled Chicken Wrap
$17.00
Tavern Burger
$18.00
Braised Short Rib Cheese Steak
$18.00
Fish & Chips
$18.00
French Dip
$18.00
Pizza Rolls
$13.00
Shepherd's Pie
$19.00
The Juicy Lucy
$18.00
Sweet Potato Black Bean Burger
$17.00
Prime Steakhouse Burger
$19.00
Kids Cheese Burger
$10.00
Santa Fe Chicken Sandwich
$18.00
Proper Nachos
$16.00
Fresh Cut Fries
$7.00
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 9:10 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Famous Dark Horse Wings
Served bone-in or boneless with blue cheese, celery, carrots.
$16.00
California Wrap
Blackened grilled chicken, iceberg lettuce, tomato, avocado, bacon, cheddar, peppercorn parmesan dressing.
$18.00
Brie Stuffed Pretzels
Vegetarian. Fig jam.
$14.00
Chicken Tenders
Vegetarian. Served with Honey mustard.
$10.00
Chicken Tenders
Traditional or tossed in any of our famous wing sauces.
$14.00
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan, Caesar dressing.
$17.00
Mac and Cheese
Melted Cheddar, Parmesan, Jack Cheese, Shells, Breadcrumb
$16.00
Quesadilla
Vegetarian. Mozzarella, cheddar, onions.
$11.00
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Hot. Pepper jack, chipotle ranchero sauce, baguette.
$17.00
Pub Style Tidbits
Mozzarella, bbq sauce, garlic baguette.
$16.00
Pubfare - Sandwiches
Philly Cheese Steak
Cheese, Onions, Baguette. Choice of Chicken or Steak.
$18.00
Santa Fe Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken, guacamole, pepper jack, pico de gallo, pretzel bun.
$18.00
Braised Short Rib Cheese Steak
Homemade cheese sauce, sautéed onions, French bread.
$18.00
Pub Style Tidbits
Mozzarella, bbq sauce, garlic baguette.
$16.00
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Hot. Pepper jack, chipotle ranchero sauce, baguette.
$17.00
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pulled pork, coleslaw, brioche bun.
$17.00
French Dip
Sliced roast beef, mozzarella, sautéed onions, au jus, French bread.
$18.00
BLT
Texas toast, mayo.
$14.00
Grilled Cheese
Vegetarian. Texas toast, American.
$14.00
Quesadilla
Vegetarian. Mozzarella, cheddar, onions.
$11.00
Nonna's Alla Vodka Hero
Spicy or Regular, Fried Chicken Cutlet, Home-Made Alla Vodka Sauce, Melted Mozzarela, Parmesan, Garlic Baquette
$18.00
Pubfare - Paninis
Chicken Panini
Grilled chicken, mesclun greens, roasted red peppers, bacon, mozzarella cheese, balsamic glaze, ciabatta.
$16.00
Steak Panini
Grilled steak, tomatoes, red onions, arugula, mozzarella, balsamic glaze, ciabatta.
$19.00
Oslo Panini
Vegetarian. Breaded eggplant, roasted red peppers, spinach, mozzarella, balsamic glaze, flat bread.
$16.00
Small Bites
Chips & Guacamole
Vegetarian. Tortilla, red onion, cilantro, lime, jalapeño.
$15.00
Texas Chili
Dark horse lager, tortilla, cheddar, onion, sour cream.
$12.00
Firecracker Shrimp
Spicy sriracha.
$17.00
Brie Stuffed Pretzels
Vegetarian. Fig jam.
$14.00
Dumplings
Pork, ponzu dipping sauce.
$13.00
Spinach Dip
Vegetarian. Homemade spinach dip, bread bowl.
$18.00
Fried Pickles
Vegetarian. Cornmeal battered.
$12.00
Proper Nachos
Tortilla chips, beef, the works.
$16.00
Irish Nachos
Fresh cut fries, cheddar, mozzarella, bacon, sour cream, scallions.
$14.00
Tater Tot Nachos
Tots, bacon, cheddar, sour cream, scallions.
$15.00
Disco Fries
Fresh cut fries, mozzarella curds, homemade gravy.
$14.00
Trio of Sliders
Soft bun, pickle & choice of beef, grilled chicken, pulled pork.
$17.00
Hummus & Pita Chips
Vegetarian. Crispy pita, fresh housemade hummus.
$15.00
Loaded Potato Skins
Pulled pork, bacon, jack cheese, sour cream, scallions.
$16.00
Chicken Tenders
Traditional or tossed in any of our famous wing sauces.
$14.00
Jalapeño Poppers
Vegetarian. With a side of sour cream.
$12.00
Mozz Stix
Vegetarian. House marinara.
$13.00
Pizza Rolls
Pepperoni, cheese.
$13.00
Sampler Platter
Wings, mozz stix, jalapeño poppers, chicken tenders, pizza rolls.
$20.00
Avocado Fries
Crispy Fried Breaded Avocado, Spicy Aioli.
$14.00
Bacon Brussel Sprouts
Smokey Bacon, Sprouts, Savory Glaze
$14.00
Thai Chicken Lettuce Wraps
BBQ Chicken, Sweet Thai Chili, Peanut Sauce, Lettuce Bed.
$15.00
Sweet and Spicy Thai Cauliflower
Crisp Cauliflower Bites, Spicy Thai Chili Sauce
$16.00
Truffle Fries
Fresh Cut Fries, Truffle Oil, Grated Parmesan
$13.00
Baked Mac and Cheese
Mac and Cheese
Melted Cheddar, Parmesan, Jack Cheese, Shells, Breadcrumb
$16.00
Buffalo Mac and Cheese
Melted Cheddar, Parmesan, Jack Cheese, Shells, Breadcrumb, Fried Buffalo Chicken
$19.00
Bacon Mac and Cheese
Melted Cheddar, Parmesan, Jack Cheese, Shells, Breadcrumb, Crispy Bacon
$17.00
Flatbread and 14" Pies
Mediterranean
Vegetarian. Cherry tomato, arugula, goat cheese, balsamic reduction.
$15.00
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Dressing, Mozzarella Cheese, Parsley.
$16.00
Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Chicken, Blue Cheese, Melted Mozzarella cheese, Parsley.
$16.00
Traditional 14"
Mozzarella, Marinara
$16.00
Pepperoni 14"
Mozzarella, Marinara, Pepperoni
$19.00
Chicken Alla Vodka 14"
Chicken, Mozzarella, Alla Vodka Sauce
$20.00
Wings
Served bone-in or boneless with blue cheese, celery, carrots
Famous Dark Horse Wings
Served bone-in or boneless with blue cheese, celery, carrots.
$16.00
Salads
Dark Horse Salad
Vegetarian. Spinach greens, cranberries, walnuts, avocado, sliced apples, raspberry vinaigrette.
$15.00
Caesar Salad
Vegetarian. Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing.
$14.00
Cobb Salad
Iceberg lettuce, bacon, hard boiled egg, tomato, cucumber, cheddar jack, croutons, ranch.
$14.00
Harvest Salad
Mesclun greens, dried cranberries, almonds, blue cheese crumbles, cherry tomatoes.
$16.00
Wedge Salad
Iceberg lettuce, blue cheese crumbles, bacon, tomato, blue cheese dressing.
$16.00
Pubfare - Burgers
Tavern Burger
8 Oz sirloin, cheddar, dark horse special sauce, English muffin.
$18.00
Prime Steakhouse Burger
10 Oz USDA grade a prime, steak seasoning, fried onions, horseradish sauce, pretzel bun.
$19.00
Bulleit Burger
8 Oz sirloin, candied bacon, pickled peppers, jack cheese, bulleit bbq sauce, pretzel bun.
$19.00
The Juicy Lucy
10 Oz sirloin, stuffed with cheddar, pepper jack and American cheese, pretzel bun.
$18.00
Bull Burger
8oz Sirloin, Cheddar, Fried Egg
$19.00
Bacon Blue Cheese Stuffed Burger
10 Oz sirloin, stuffed with bacon and blue cheese crumbles, topped with sautéed mushrooms, pretzel bun.
$20.00
French Onion Soup Burger
8 Oz sirloin, melted swiss, caramelized onions, pretzel bun.
$18.00
Sweet Potato Black Bean Burger
Vegetarian. Homemade patty (Sweet potato, black beans and rice), avocado, red onion, lettuce, tomato pretzel bun.
$17.00
Sonoma Burger
8oz Sirloin Topped With Fried Tortilla Chips, Bacon, Jalapeno, Salsa Verde, Mexican Street Corn
$19.00
B.Y.O. Smash
Build Your Own Smash Burger, Starts at 1 3oz Pattie, L/T/O
$14.00
Mac and Cheese Burger Burger
8 oz Sirloin, Topped with Baked Mac and Cheese
$20.00
Pubfare - Tacos
Short Rib Tacos
Avocado, cheddar, pico de gallo.
$19.00
Fish Tacos
Local fresh catch, avocado spread, pico de gallo.
$17.00
Shrimp Tacos
Firecracker shrimp, avocado spread, pico de gallo.
$19.00
Spicy Steak Tacos
Hot. Marinated steak, cilantro aioli, sour cream, avocado, pico de gallo.
$21.00
Birria Tacos
Crispy Corn Torilla, Cilantro, Lime, Melted Mozzarella, Jalapenos, White Onion, Consome Birria
$20.00
Taco Trio
One Steak, One Chicken, One Shrimp, Sour Cream, Avocado, Pico De Gallo, Lettuce
$20.00
Pubfare - Hearty Meals
Fish & Chips
Fried cod fillets, fresh cut fries.
$18.00
Shepherd's Pie
Ground beef, carrots, onions, green peas, topped with mashed potato crust.
$19.00
Chicken Pot Pie
Carrots, Onions, Roasted Chicken, Green Peas, Pie Crust
$18.00
Pubfare - Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan, Caesar dressing.
$17.00
California Wrap
Blackened grilled chicken, iceberg lettuce, tomato, avocado, bacon, cheddar, peppercorn parmesan dressing.
$18.00
Hummus Wrap
Vegetarian. Sautéed spinach, peppers and onions, avocado, tomato, spinach wrap, Home-Made Hummus, Choice of Protein if wanted!
$15.00
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Traditional style or buffalo sauce, blue cheese.
$17.00
BBQ Cowboy Wrap
Choice Short Rib or Fried Chicken, BBQ Sauce, Cheddar Cheese, Onion Rings, Side Cheese Sauce
$19.00
Chopped Cheese Wrap
Tender Beef, Melted American, LTO, Delicious Dark Horse Sauce, Warm Tortilla
$21.00
Kids Menu
Smaller serving sizes of select small bites, includes fresh cut fries or tater tots
Chicken Tenders
Vegetarian. Served with Honey mustard.
$10.00
Mozz Stix
House marinara.
$10.00
Pizza Rolls
Pepperoni, cheese.
$10.00
Kids Grilled Cheese
White bread, American cheese.
$10.00
Kids Cheese Burger
5 Oz sirloin, American cheese.
$10.00
Sides
Fresh Cut Fries
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Tater Tots
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Sweet Potato Fries
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Onion Rings
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Cajun Fries
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Cajun Tots
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Pickles
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Pickled Vegetables
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Mexican Corn
Served with fresh cut fries.
$7.00
Beverages
Juice
Cranberry, lemonade, orange, or pineapple juices available.
$4.00
Fountain
Choice of Club Soda, Coca Cola, Diet Coke, Ginger Ale, or Sprite.
$2.00
Tea
A soothing blend of selected leaves for a calming sipping experience.
$2.00
Coffee
Freshly brewed, aromatic blend to kick-start your day.
$2.00
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash