Freshy Fresh Bagels- Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Freshy Fresh Bagels-
Sign In / Sign Up
Freshy Fresh Bagels
Freshy Fresh Bagels, 917 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967, USAOpens 5:00 AM
Order for later
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
The Breakfast Special
$9.25
Bakers Dozen Bagels
$14.50
The Hungry Man Special
$12.50
Banana/Strawberry Nutella French Toast
$14.95
Classic Pancakes
$11.99
The Real Egg White Special
$9.35
1/2 Dozen Bagels
$8.50
Classic French Toast
$12.35
#2 Most liked
Bagel with Cream Cheese
$3.35
Strawberry Cheese Cake French Toast
$14.95
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
$12.25
1/2 LB Plain Cream Cheese
$5.50
Oreo French Toast
$14.95
1/2 LB Flavored Cream Cheese
$6.50
Western Omelette
$10.50
#3 Most liked
Side of Homefries
$4.99
Chicken Wrap
$12.99
Bagel with lox & Cream Cheese
$9.30
Big A
$12.99
Bagel Melt
$4.15
Godfather
$12.99
Saggio
$12.99
Tropicana Juice
$3.25
Bagel with Cream Cheese & Jelly
$4.75
Muffin
$3.85
Full Menu
5:00 am - 11:40 amMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
The Breakfast Special
2 Eggs cooked to your liking with a meat & cheese of your choice & a choice of a 10oz coffee or Tropicana orange juice
$9.25•96% (871)
#1 Most liked
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel of your choice with your choice of cream cheese
$3.35•91% (324)
#2 Most liked
Side of Homefries
A side of fresh grilled & seasoned Homefries
$4.99•92% (169)
#3 Most liked
The Hungry Man Special
Three eggs cooked to your perfection with two meats of your choice, fresh cheese, home fries on/off a hero. And a choice of a 10oz coffee and/or Tropicana orange juice
$12.50•89% (147)
1/2 LB Plain Cream Cheese
1/2 LB of our fresh cream cheese
$5.50•93% (80)
Bakers Dozen Bagels
Baker's Dozen comes with 12 bagels & an extra bagel for free, with your choice of bagel flavor! *NOTE* usually around closing we will run out of specific bagel flavors(Blueberry, Spinach, ETC.), we always try to keep it as up to stock as possible. Still, in the event we do not have the specific bagel you request we will replace it with the closest matching bagel or replace it with a plain bagel. You can also put in the "Special Notes" any bagels you would like, in case we do not have a specific kind. Thank you for understanding!
$14.50•92% (107)
Nesquick
Your choice of flavor nesquick
$3.10•94% (39)
1/2 Dozen Bagels
6 Bagels of your choice
$8.50•93% (118)
1/2 LB Flavored Cream Cheese
1/2 LB of our fresh flavored cream cheese of your choice
$6.50•96% (64)
Muffin
Your choice of flavored muffin
$3.85•95% (60)
Signature Sandwiches
All deli sandwiches come with a side salad of your choice and pickle.
Palma
Ovengold turkey, bacon, Swiss cheese or cheese of your choice & russian dressing on a roll.
$12.99
Rock Duke
Chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, red onions, roasted peppers & your choice of dressing on a roll.
$12.99
Big A
Pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut & mustard or thousand island on grilled rye.
$12.99•95% (23)
Saggio
Grilled deluxe roast beef, your choice of cheese, marinated mushroom & mayo, or your choice of dressing on toasted roll.
$12.99
Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing.
$12.99•88% (18)
Godfather
Cappy ham, salami, pepperoni, provolon cheese, roasted red peppers, red onions, lettuce, tomato, on a roll.
$12.99
Star & Stripes
Deluxe ham, American cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo, or dressing of your choice on a roll.
$12.99•90% (10)
Best Friend
Deluxe roast beef, choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo, or dressing of your choice on a roll.
$12.99
Bagels
Old-Fashioned Boiled & Baked Bagels Made Fresh Everyday!
Bakers Dozen Bagels
Baker's Dozen comes with 12 bagels & an extra bagel for free, with your choice of bagel flavor! *NOTE* usually around closing we will run out of specific bagel flavors(Blueberry, Spinach, ETC.), we always try to keep it as up to stock as possible. Still, in the event we do not have the specific bagel you request we will replace it with the closest matching bagel or replace it with a plain bagel. You can also put in the "Special Notes" any bagels you would like, in case we do not have a specific kind. Thank you for understanding!
$14.50•92% (107)
1/2 Dozen Bagels
6 Bagels of your choice
$8.50•93% (118)
Bagel
Choose a bagel with nothing on it from our selection of bagels
$1.35•96% (119)
Bagel with Butter
Your choice of a bagel with our finest butter
$2.65•88% (154)
Bagel with Butter & Jelly
Your choice of bagel with butter & your choice of jelly
$3.70•90% (10)
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel of your choice with your choice of cream cheese
$3.35•91% (324)
#2 Most liked
Bagel with lox & Cream Cheese
Bagel of your choice with lox & cream cheese
$9.30•82% (29)
Bagel with Lox Spread
Your choice of bagel with lox spread
$5.75
Bagel with Cream Cheese & Jelly
Your choice of bagel & cream cheese with strawberry or grape jelly
$4.75•92% (26)
Bagel with Jelly
Bagel of your choice with strawberry or grape jelly
$2.25
Bagel with Peanut Butter & Jelly
Bagel of your choice with peanut butter & strawberry or grape jelly
$4.35
Bagel Melt
Bagel of your choice with melted cheese of your choice
$4.15•86% (29)
Breakfast Specials
Hungry for some breakfast? We got you covered! All fresh hot ingredients for your enjoyment! We have so much to try & satisfy everyone! So much more new menu items coming soon! *These menu items can be cooked to order. Consuming raw or under cooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shelled eggs may increase your risk of food born illness*
The Breakfast Special
2 Eggs cooked to your liking with a meat & cheese of your choice & a choice of a 10oz coffee or Tropicana orange juice
$9.25•96% (871)
#1 Most liked
The Hungry Man Special
Three eggs cooked to your perfection with two meats of your choice, fresh cheese, home fries on/off a hero. And a choice of a 10oz coffee and/or Tropicana orange juice
$12.50•89% (147)
The Real Egg White Special
3 Real egg whites with a choice of meat & cheese of your choice & a choice of a 10oz coffee or Tropicana orange juice
$9.35•93% (76)
Western Omelette
6 real egg whites or 3 whole eggs W/ peppers, onions, ham, & mushrooms served in a platter W/ a side of toast & a choice of a 10oz coffee or Tropicana orange juice
$10.50•88% (26)
Cream Cheese & Butter
Add The Perfect Cream Cheese for Your Perfect Bagels
1/2 LB Plain Cream Cheese
1/2 LB of our fresh cream cheese
$5.50•93% (80)
1/4 lb. Plain Cream Cheese
1/4 LB of our fresh cream cheese
$3.35
1/2 LB Flavored Cream Cheese
1/2 LB of our fresh flavored cream cheese of your choice
$6.50•96% (64)
1/4 lb. Flavored Cream Cheese
1/4 LB of our fresh flavored cream cheese of your choice
$4.10
1/2 Butter
1/2LB of our fresh butter.
$4.85
1/2 lb. Lox Spread
1/2 LB of our fresh lox spread
$7.90
1/4 lb. Lox Spread
1/4 LB of our fresh lox spread
$5.30
Specialty French Toast
Super tasty & mouth watering Specialty French Toast. All toppings, including the fresh brioche bread, are fresh & homemade recipes! So good you'll be coming back for more!
Banana/Strawberry Nutella French Toast
Fresh Challah Bread in our Specialty Batter W/ Fresh Bananas, a Dollop of Nutella & a Coat of Powdered Sugar
$14.95
Classic French Toast
Our Classic Freshy Fresh Style French Toast in our Specialty Batter W/ a Generous Dusting of Powdered Sugar & Optional Side of Meat
$12.35•89% (38)
Oreo French Toast
Fresh Challah Bread in our Specialty Batter W/ Oreo Frosting, Crushed Oreos, & Whipped Cream.
$14.95
Strawberry Cheese Cake French Toast
Fresh Challah Bread in our Specialty Batter w/ Sweet Cream Cheese, & Fresh Strawberries
$14.95•94% (17)
Specialty Pancakes
Super tasty & mouth watering Specialty Pancakes. All toppings are fresh & homemade recipes! So good you'll be coming back for more!
Banana/Strawberry Nutella Pancakes
Our Classic Freshy Freshy Style Pancakes Layered W/ Fresh Bananas & Nutella
$12.95
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Our classic Freshy Fresh style chocolate chip pancakes W/ butter & a side of meat
$12.25•84% (19)
Classic Pancakes
Our Classic Freshy Freshy Style Pancakes Served W/ Butter & Optional Side of Meat
$11.99•88% (26)
Oreo Pancakes
Pancakes with Crushed Oreos
$13.25
Sides
Want a side to go with your breakfast? We got you covered right here!
Side of Bacon
A side of fresh grilled bacon
$2.15•97% (80)
Side of Ham
A side of fresh grilled ham
$2.15
Side of Homefries
A side of fresh grilled & seasoned Homefries
$4.99•92% (169)
#3 Most liked
Side of Sausage
A side of fresh grilled sausage patty
$2.15•94% (19)
Side of Turkey
A side of fresh grilled Turkey
$2.15
Side of Turkey Bacon
A side of fresh grilled Turkey Bacon
$2.15•100% (9)
Beverages
All of our available drinks in the store
Coffee
Freshly brewed coffee, available in small or large sizes.
$2.30•93% (83)
Hot Chocolate
Rich hot chocolate available in small or large sizes.
$2.55•94% (19)
Monster
Your choice of Green or Blue Monster
$2.99•95% (20)
Nesquick
Your choice of flavor nesquick
$3.10•94% (39)
Simply Juice
Your choice of Simply Juice
$3.25•100% (13)
Snapple (16oz)
Your choice of flavor of the 16 oz Snapple bottles
$2.85•95% (24)
Tropicana Juice
Your choice of Tropicana Juice
$3.25•97% (36)
Red Bull
Choice between a large or small red bull
$3.10
Desserts & Snacks
Looking for something sweet? Or just something to snack on? Check out our fresh desserts and snacks and looking for something you are craving!
Cakes
Your choice of flavor from our fresh cakes
$3.85•94% (38)
Cookies
Your choice of one of our cookie flavors
$3.85•100% (7)
Grilled Buttered Muffin
Your choice of a Muffin flavor grilled with butter
$4.25•94% (56)
Loaf Cake
Your choice from our loaf cakes
$3.85•100% (15)
Muffin
Your choice of flavored muffin
$3.85•95% (60)
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash