Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria
Sign In / Sign Up
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria
3312 S Elm Pl, Broken Arrow, OK 74011, USAUnavailable
Featured Items
#1 Most liked
New York Cheese
$16.99
#3 Most liked
Manhattan Meat
$23.99
Liberty Supreme
$21.99
Bronx Chicken Alfredo Pie
$21.99
Stromboli
$12.99
#2 Most liked
Calzone
$10.99
Garlic Knots (3)
$5.99
Cheese Knots (3)
$6.99
Staten Island White
$21.99
Manicotti
$13.49
Cannoli
$6.99
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken & Bacon
$13.49
Cheesecake Calzone
$8.99
New York Cheesecake
$6.99
Brooklyn Prosciutto
$23.99
12" Manhattan Meat Slice
$8.99
Caesar Salad
$6.99
House Salad
$5.99
East Coast Veggie
$21.99
6" 1 Topping Kids New York Pizza & Kids Drink
$8.99
Full Menu
closedMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
New York Cheese
#1 Most liked
Jimmy's famous pizza sauce and New York premium cheese blend.
$16.99•97% (93)
Calzone
#2 Most liked
Jimmy's famous hand tossed dough filled with fresh mozzarella cheese, garlic and ricotta, folded, baked and served with a side of marinara sauce.
$10.99•100% (23)
Manhattan Meat
#3 Most liked
Fresh mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, meatball, Canadian bacon, Italian sausage and bacon.
$23.99•95% (22)
Liberty Supreme
Pepperoni, meatball, red onions, green peppers, mushrooms and black olives.
$21.99•100% (21)
Garlic Knots (3)
Prepared with fresh garlic oil, baked to golden brown and sprinkled with Jimmy's special blend of spices (served with side of marinara sauce).
$5.99•100% (13)
Cheese Knots (3)
Garlic knots topped with Jimmy's New York premium mozzarella cheese blend (served with side of marinara sauce).
$6.99•54% (11)
Stromboli
Jimmy's famous hand tossed dough filled with Genoa salami, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mozzarella, folded, baked and served with a side marinara sauce.
$12.99•100% (17)
Cannoli
Italian pastry shell filled with a creamy sweet filling and sprinkled with powdered sugar. Choose from: classic or chocolate dipped shell.
$6.99•75% (12)
Bronx Chicken Alfredo Pie
Garlic alfredo sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh chicken and bacon.
$21.99•91% (12)
Cheesecake Calzone
Yes, you did read that correctly. Jimmy's pastry dough filled with creamy New York cheesecake, spices and baked to perfection. You have to try it!
$8.99•100% (6)
Extras
Ranch-2oz
Jimmy's signature ranch, pairs perfectly with any pizza!
$1.50
Alfredo Sauce-2oz
Enjoy a side of creamy garlic alfredo!
$1.50
Marinara Sauce-2oz
Jimmy's own marinara recipe! Handmade from scratch daily
$1.50
BBQ Sauce-2oz
Sweet BBQ
$1.50
Buffalo Sauce-2oz
Spicy Buffalo
$1.50
Garlic Oil Sauce-2oz
Garlic infused olive oil
$1.50
By the Slice
Authentic, new York pizza slice made with fresh ingredients sourced daily. All slices come from our standard 24" pizza pie.
12" Manhattan Meat Slice
Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, Italian sausage, bacon, and meatball.
$8.99
Classic Pies
If a slice isn't enough for you, try one of our pizza pies that come in either regular (14") or large (16") sizes.
Liberty Supreme
Pepperoni, meatball, red onions, green peppers, mushrooms and black olives.
$21.99•100% (21)
New York Cheese
#1 Most liked
Jimmy's famous pizza sauce and New York premium cheese blend.
$16.99•97% (93)
East Coast Veggie
Spinach, red onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, fresh tomatoes.
$21.99
Five Boroughs Pizza Pies
Not in the mood for a classic pie? We can also do any of the following.
Manhattan Meat
#3 Most liked
Fresh mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, meatball, Canadian bacon, Italian sausage and bacon.
$23.99•95% (22)
Brooklyn Prosciutto
Garlic oil sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh asiago cheese, thinly sliced prosciutto (italian ham), cherry tomatoes, and fresh basil.
$23.99
Staten Island White
Garlic oil sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, sliced tomatoes, fresh ricotta cheese and minced garlic.
$21.99
Bronx Chicken Alfredo Pie
Garlic alfredo sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh chicken and bacon.
$21.99•91% (12)
Jimmys Specialties
We can make you a custom pizza or you can try one of our specialties.
Calzone
#2 Most liked
Jimmy's famous hand tossed dough filled with fresh mozzarella cheese, garlic and ricotta, folded, baked and served with a side of marinara sauce.
$10.99•100% (23)
Stromboli
Jimmy's famous hand tossed dough filled with Genoa salami, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mozzarella, folded, baked and served with a side marinara sauce.
$12.99•100% (17)
New York Appetizers
Start your meal with one of our delicious appetizers.
Garlic Knots (3)
Prepared with fresh garlic oil, baked to golden brown and sprinkled with Jimmy's special blend of spices (served with side of marinara sauce).
$5.99•100% (13)
Cheese Knots (3)
Garlic knots topped with Jimmy's New York premium mozzarella cheese blend (served with side of marinara sauce).
$6.99•54% (11)
Extra Ranch, Marinara or Alfredo
$1.50•93% (15)
Hot Pasta
Craving something other than pizza? Try one of our delicious pasta dishes. Made with the finest ingredients and Jimmy's famous marinara sauce. All of our pastas comes with one garlic knot.
Manicotti
Pasta tubes stuffed with seasoned ricotta and cheese, topped with Jimmy's New York cheese blend and marinara sauce.
$13.49•100% (7)
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken & Bacon
Fettuccine pasta, with garlic chicken and bacon topped with alfredo sauce.
$13.49•100% (7)
Special Diet
Healthy alternatives.
Keto Bowl
Fresh mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, meat balls, fresh chicken, black olives, minced garlic, and pizza sauce.
$10.99
Gluten Free / Cauliflower Pizza - Cheese Only
Gluten free. 10" pizza with your choice of gluten free toppings for a fee each. Gluten free toppings: bacon, chicken, spinach, green peppers, red onions, jalapeños, mushrooms, black olives, fresh tomatoes, anchovies, feta cheese, garlic and ricotta.
$16.99
Hot Hero Sandwiches
If you rather have a sandwich, select from served one of our satisfying 8" hot heroes. All sandwiches with classic chips.
Meatball Parmesan
Homemade meatballs covered in Jimmy's marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, sprinkled with fresh parmesan cheese.
$12.99
Italian Combo
Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, drizzled with olive oil, vinegar, salt and pepper.
$12.99
Salads
Here at Jimmy's, all of our salads are prepared fresh daily. Choice of Dressings: Ranch, Italian, Vinaigrette or Caesar. **Add grilled chicken to any salad for a fee**
House Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce, spring mix, cherry tomatoes, red onions, shredded carrots and seasoned croutons.
$5.99
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, fresh shredded parmesan, pecorino Romano and seasoned croutons.
$6.99•100% (6)
Greek Feta
Romaine lettuce, spring mix, cherry tomatoes, red onions, black olives, feta cheese and seasoned croutons.
$7.99
Kids Menu
Cheese Ravioli & Kids Drink
Mini cheese-filled ravioli. Includes Capri Sun.
$8.99
6" 1 Topping Kids New York Pizza & Kids Drink
6" New York-style pizza with choice of one topping from an assortment including meats, vegetables, or extra cheese. Served with Capri Sun.
$8.99
Fettuccine Alfredo w/ Chicken & Bacon & Kids Drink
Fettuccine pasta, with garlic chicken and bacon topped with alfredo sauce.
$8.99
Desserts
End your perfect meal with a delicious treat.
New York Cheesecake
Served by the slice. Choose from: plain, cherry topping or Ghirardelli chocolate topping.
$6.99
Cannoli
Italian pastry shell filled with a creamy sweet filling and sprinkled with powdered sugar. Choose from: classic or chocolate dipped shell.
$6.99•75% (12)
Mini Cannoli (Classic Shell)
Mini cannoli featuring a classic shell, filled with a traditional sweet ricotta cream, often complemented by chocolate chips.
$3.99
Cheesecake Calzone
Yes, you did read that correctly. Jimmy's pastry dough filled with creamy New York cheesecake, spices and baked to perfection. You have to try it!
$8.99•100% (6)
Drinks
We have many drinks to choose from.
Bottled Beverages
Availability varies.
$3.29•87% (8)
Bottled Water
Pure and refreshing bottled water.
$3.25
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash