Main Street Ice Cream Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Main Street Ice Cream
Sign In / Sign Up

Main Street Ice Cream

35 Main Street, Hamburg, NY
Loading
Online ordering hours: 12:00 PM - 8:15 PM
Opens 12:00 PM
Order for later

Featured Items

#1 Most liked
Peanut Butter Supreme Sundae
$9.75
#2 Most liked
Fudge Brownie Sundae
$9.75
#3 Most liked
Buttery Blast Sundae
$9.75
8" Ice Cream Cake
$38.00
Ice Cream Cake Sundae
$9.75
Chocolate Whirlwind
$8.25
Turtle Sundae
$9.75
Vanilla Whirlwind
$8.25
Peanut Butter Pie
$24.00
Twist Whirlwind
$8.25
Nutty Buddy Sundae
$9.75
Chocolate Lover's Pie
$24.00
Chocolate Milkshake
$8.25
Chocolate Lovers Sundae
$9.75
Fudgy Peanut Bars
$4.75
Ice Cream Cake Pie
$24.00
S'mores Sundae
$9.75
Mexican Sundae
$9.75
Cookie Monster
$6.25+
Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich
$6.00
Gluten Free Brownie Sundae
$9.75
Dirt & Worm Sundae
$9.75
Oreo Cloud
$6.25+
Almond Joyful Sundae
$9.75
Main Street All Nighter
$6.25+
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 8:15 pm

Most Ordered

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Peanut Butter Supreme Sundae

Vanilla custard, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, reeses pieces and whipped cream. NO Substitutions
$9.75β€’115
#1 Most liked

Fudge Brownie Sundae

Vanilla custard, moist brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. No substitutions
$9.75β€’41
#2 Most liked

Buttery Blast Sundae

Vanilla custard, butterscotch sauce, crushed butterfinger, whip cream, and a cherry. No Substitutions
$9.75β€’39
#3 Most liked

Vanilla Whirlwind

Vanilla custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)
$8.25β€’32

Buddy's Dog Treat

Vanilla custard with a Milk bone. For the friend that's always there for you!
$3.75β€’27

Turtle Sundae

Vanilla custard, hot fudge, caramel, pecans, whipped cream, and a cherry. No Substitutions
$9.75β€’32

Chocolate Whirlwind

Chocolate custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)
$8.25β€’31

Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich

Vanilla custard sandwiched between two homemade chocolate chip cookies
$6.00β€’17

Chocolate Lovers Sundae

Chocolate custard, chocolate syrup, oreo pieces, chocolate sprinkles and whipped cream. No substitutions
$9.75β€’9

Twist Whirlwind

Chocolate/Vanilla twist custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)
$8.25β€’17

To Go-Go'S

Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

Vanilla custard sandwiched between two chocolate wafers
$3.75β€’14

Fudgy Peanut Bars

Layers of vanilla custard, peanuts and fudge covered in chocolate on a stick.
$4.75β€’6

Buddy's Dog Treat

Vanilla custard with a Milk bone. For the friend that's always there for you!
$3.75β€’27

Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich

Vanilla custard sandwiched between two homemade chocolate chip cookies
$6.00β€’17

Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwich

Chocolate custard sandwiched between two chocolate wafers
$3.75

Cotton Candy Ice Cream Bar

Vanilla custard mixed with cotton candy sprinkles dipped in blue raspberry, rolled in cotton candy sprinkles on a stick
$5.25β€’6

Oreo Explosion Bar

Vanilla custard mixed with Oreos, dipped in chocolate and rolled in chocolate crunch on a stick
$5.25

Peanut Butter Explosion Bar

Vanilla custard mixed with peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, reeses pieces, dipped in chocolate and rolled in peanut crunch on a stick
$5.25β€’6

Premium Sundaes

Turtle Sundae

Vanilla custard, hot fudge, caramel, pecans, whipped cream, and a cherry. No Substitutions
$9.75β€’32

Peanut Butter Supreme Sundae

Vanilla custard, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, reeses pieces and whipped cream. NO Substitutions
$9.75β€’115
#1 Most liked

Chocolate Lovers Sundae

Chocolate custard, chocolate syrup, oreo pieces, chocolate sprinkles and whipped cream. No substitutions
$9.75β€’9

Almond Joyful Sundae

Vanilla custard, chocolate sauce, coconut, almonds, whip cream, and a cherry. NO substitutions
$9.75

Buttery Blast Sundae

Vanilla custard, butterscotch sauce, crushed butterfinger, whip cream, and a cherry. No Substitutions
$9.75β€’39
#3 Most liked

Tropical Hurricane Sundae

Vanilla custard, pineapple, coconut, banana, pecans, whip cream, and a cherry. No substitutions
$9.75β€’11

Nutty Buddy Sundae

Vanilla custard, hot fudge, pieces of sugar cone, peanuts, whip cream, and a cherry. No substitutions
$9.75β€’14

Fudge Brownie Sundae

Vanilla custard, moist brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. No substitutions
$9.75β€’41
#2 Most liked

Chunky Monkey Sundae

Vanilla soft serve, fresh banana chunks, chocolate syrup, walnuts, whip cream and a cherry. No substitutions
$9.75

S'mores Sundae

Vanilla custard, hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, graham cracker, whipped cream and a cherry. No Substitutions
$9.75β€’5

Premium Sundae of the Week: Lucky Leprechaun Sundae

Handcrafted mint chip ice cream and fudge sauce topped with vanilla custard, mint sauce, whipped cream and mint/chocolate sprinkles
$9.75

Gluten Free Brownie Sundae

Vanilla custard, gluten free brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream
$9.75

Ice Cream Cake Sundae

Chocolate and vanilla custard, hot fudge, chocolate crunch, whipped cream and rainbow sprinkles
$9.75β€’6

Dirt & Worm Sundae

Vanilla soft serve, chocolate crunch "dirt", hot fudge "mud", gummy worms and whipped cream
$9.75

Mexican Sundae

Vanilla soft serve, chocolate sauce, Spanish peanuts, whipped cream and a cherry
$9.75

Ice Cream & Soft Serve

Vanilla Custard Soft Serve

Our soft serve vanilla flavored ice cream to enjoy at home
$6.25+

Chocolate Custard Soft Serve

Enjoy our chocolate flavored custard at home
$6.25+

Chocolate and Vanilla Twist Custard

Enjoy our chocolate and vanilla twist custard at home
$6.25+

Black Raspberry Soft Serve Yogurt

Enjoy our creamy soft serve yogurt at home
$6.25+

Red Raspberry Soft Serve Sherbet

Enjoy our soft serve red raspberry sherbet at home
$6.25+

Two Berry Twist Soft Serve

Enjoy Main Street Ice Cream's Two Berry Twist. A combination of our Black Raspberry yogurt and our Red Raspberry Sherbet twisted together
$6.25+

Brownie Mudslide

Brownie batter ice cream, brownie chunks and fudge swirls
$6.25+β€’6

Chocolate

$6.25+

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Chocolate peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter swirls
$6.25+β€’8

Coconut

Coconut flavored ice cream, shredded coconut and dark chocolate flakes
$6.25+

Coffee

You're so bold coffee ice cream
$6.25+

Cookie Monster

Blue moon ice cream with chunks of oreo, chocolate chip cookies, and cookie dough pieces
$6.25+β€’11

Cookie dough

Cookie dough flavored ice cream with cookie dough chunks and chocolate flakes
$6.25+

Cotton Candy

Cotton candy ice cream, swirls of cotton candy flavor and cotton candy sprinkles
$6.25+

Maple Walnut

Maple ice cream with walnut pieces
$6.25+

Mint Chip

Mint ice cream and chocolate flakes
$6.25+

Oreo Cloud

Oreo ice cream mixed with Oreo chunks
$6.25+

Peanut Butter Paradise

Vanilla ice cream, peanut butter and caramel swirls, peanut butter cups and reese's pieces
$6.25+

Strawberry

Strawberry ice cream with strawberries mixed throughout
$6.25+

Vanilla

$6.25+

Main Street All Nighter

Homemade coffee ice cream with cookie dough, chopped Oreo pieces, and creamy chocolate swirls.
$6.25+

Items of the Week

Flavor of the Week: Banana Pudding

Homemade banana pudding ice cream, fresh banana chunks, vanilla wafer cookies and marshmallow swirls
$6.25+

Flavor of the Week: Egg Nog

Creamy egg nog dessert. Available in 2 scoop dish or pint size for sharing (feeds 3-4).
$6.25+

Flavor of the Week: Frosty's Magic

Frosty's Magic: Other beverages option. Available in a pint serving 3-4 or a 2-scoop dish.
$6.25+

Flavor of the Week: Spumoni

Homemade chocolate, cherry and pistachio ice cream swirled together with black cherries and pistachios - A holiday tradition
$6.25+

Flavor of the week: Pumpkin

Pumpkin ice cream with whipped cream frosting swirls
$6.25+

Item of the Week: Pumpkin Molasses Ice Cream Sandwich

Homemade molasses cookie with homemade pumpkin ice cream
$7.00

Item of the Week: Vanilla Molasses Ice Cream Sandwich

Homemade molasses cookie with vanilla custard
$7.00

Flavor of the week: Pistachio

Handcrafted pistachio ice cream with pieces of pistachio nuts
$6.25+

Flavor of the week: Gingerbread Man

Handcrafted gingerbread ice cream with pieces of homemade gingerbread cookies
$6.25+

Ice Cream Cakes

8" Ice Cream Cake

Feeds 8-10 people. Layer of vanilla custard, chocolate cake crunch and fudge, layer of chocolate custard, whipped cream frosting and rainbow sprinkles
$38.00

Ice Cream Pies

Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie

Thin layer of vanilla custard topped with homemade pumpkin ice cream and whipped cream frosting
$24.00

Black Raspberry Yogurt Pie

Vanilla custard layered with low fat black raspberry yogurt topped with whipped cream frosting
$24.00

Chocolate Lover's Pie

Chocolate custard layered with fudge and chocolate crunch topped with more fudge, oreo cookie pieces, whipped cream frosting and chocolate sprinkles
$24.00

Ice Cream Cake Pie

Chocolate and vanilla custard layered with fudge and chocolate crunch topped with whipped cream frosting and rainbow sprinkles
$24.00

Oreo Pie

Vanilla custard with chunks of oreo cookies topped with whipped cream frosting, fudge and oreo cookies
$24.00

Peanut Butter Pie

Peanut butter custard layered with fudge and peanut butter sauce topped with more fudge, peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, Reese's Pieces, and whipped cream frosting
$24.00

Turtle Pie

Vanilla custard layered with caramel and fudge topped with more caramel, fudge, pecans and whipped cream frosting
$24.00

Vegan Pints

Cherry Dolewhip

A vegan frozen dessert with a cherry base, typically crafted with coconut milk for a creamy texture.
$10.75

Chocolate Oat Milk

Rich chocolate dessert made with creamy oat milk, offering a smooth and indulgent vegan treat.
$10.75

Vanilla Oat Milk

$10.75

Whirlwinds

Chocolate Whirlwind

Chocolate custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)
$8.25β€’31

Twist Whirlwind

Chocolate/Vanilla twist custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)
$8.25β€’17

Vanilla Whirlwind

Vanilla custard mixed with your choice of up to three candies. (First candy included in price)
$8.25β€’32

Milkshakes

Banana Milkshake

$8.25

Cherry Milkshake

$8.25

Chocolate Milkshake

$8.25β€’6

Mint Milkshake

$8.25

Raspberry Milkshake

$8.25

Strawberry Milkshake

$8.25

Vanilla Milkshake

$8.25β€’7

Strawberry Banana Milkshake

$8.25
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
Β© 2026 DoorDash
Main Street Ice Cream 35 Main Street – Order pickup and delivery