Make My Cake (413 West 125th Street) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Make My Cake (413 West 125th Street)
Sign In / Sign Up

Make My Cake

413 W 125th St, New York NY 10027-4201, United States
Loading
Online ordering hours: 11:00 AM - 7:10 PM
Opens 11:00 AM
Order for later
Full Menu
11:00 am - 7:10 pm

Most Ordered

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Double Chocolate Slice

Chocolate cake with chocolate frosting and filling.
$8.00

Red Velvet Cupcake

Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting.
$5.50

Buttercream Cupcake

Butter cake with buttercream frosting.
$4.50

Lemon Slice

Butter cake with lemon frosting and lemon filling.
$8.00

Chocolate Layer Slice

Butter cake with chocolate filling & frosting.
$8.00

Buttercream Slice

Butter cake with buttercream frosting and filling.
$7.50

Lemon Butter Cupcake

Butter cake with lemon frosting.
$5.50

Coconut Pineapple Slice

Butter cake with coconut frosting and pineapple filling.
$8.00

Chocolate Cupcake

Chocolate cupcake with buttercream frosting.
$5.50

Chocolate Butter Cupcake

Butter cake with chocolate frosting.
$4.50

Cupcakes

Strawberry Cupcake

Butter cake strawberry frosting.
$4.50

Red Velvet Cupcake

Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting.
$5.50

Lemon Butter Cupcake

Butter cake with lemon frosting.
$5.50

Double Chocolate Cupcake

Chocolate cake with chocolate frosting.
$5.50

Chocolate Butter Cupcake

Butter cake with chocolate frosting.
$4.50

Buttercream Cupcake

Butter cake with buttercream frosting.
$4.50

Chocolate Cupcake

Chocolate cupcake with buttercream frosting.
$5.50

Cakes Slices

Buttercream Slice

Butter cake with buttercream frosting and filling.
$7.50

Chocolate Layer Slice

Butter cake with chocolate filling & frosting.
$8.00

Strawberry Slice

Butter cake with strawberry filling & frosting.
$8.00

Coconut Pineapple Slice

Butter cake with coconut frosting and pineapple filling.
$8.00

Lemon Slice

Butter cake with lemon frosting and lemon filling.
$8.00

Double Chocolate Slice

Chocolate cake with chocolate frosting and filling.
$8.00

German Chocolate Slice

Chocolate cake with coconut caramel pecan frosting and filling.
$8.00

Red Velvet Slice

Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting and filling.
$8.00

Plain Cheesecake

$8.00

Sweet Potato Cheesecake

$8.00

Red Velvet Cheesecake

$8.00

Carrot Slice

Carrot cake with cream cheese frosting & filling. Nuts and raisins in both frosting and filling.
$8.00

Pies

Apple Pie

$9.00

Sweet Potato Pie

$9.00

Other Desserts

Bread Pudding

This item contains raisins.
$7.00

Peach Cobbler

$9.00

Apple Loaf

Apple cake with caramel drizzle.
$35.00

Cake Jars

Red Velvet Cake Jar

White chocolate mousse with layers of red velvet cake and white chocolate and caramel morsels.
$12.00

Chocolate Cake Jar

Chocolate mousse layered with chocolate moist cake and chocolate morsels.
$12.00

Butter Cake Jar

8 oz jar filled with moist butter cake layered with Oreo cookie, buttercream frosting and funfetti sprinkles.
$12.00
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy PolicyNY Sanitary Grade DB
© 2026 DoorDash
Checking if the site connection is secured...