Mary's Mountain Cookies - Old Town Ft. Collins Near Me - Pickup and Delivery

Mary's Mountain Cookies - Old Town Ft. Collins
Sign In / Sign Up

Mary's Mountain Cookies

123 North College Avenue, Fort Collins, CO
Loading
Online ordering hours: 10:00 AM - 9:40 PM
9 min
ready for pickup

Featured Items

#2 Most liked
S'more
$4.50
#1 Most liked
Salted Caramel
$4.50
Best Sellers Box (12)
$49.00
Best Sellers Box (24)
$69.00
Standard Cookie & Brownie Box (24)
$64.00
Gluten Free Dreams Box - 12
$49.00
Large Party Tray
$69.00
12-Inch Big Cookie
$27.00
Standard Cookie & Brownie Box (12)
$42.00
Individually Bagged Cookies (12)
$59.00
Small Party Tray
$45.00
Black beanie
$27.00
Salt Mine
$4.50
Snickerdoodle
$3.95
Chocolate Chip
$3.95
Chocolate Chip Dough Tub
$18.00
Oatmeal Creme Pie
$5.25
Frosted Sugar
$4.50
Almond Glazed Sugar
$4.50
Gluten-Free Vanilla Avalanche
$5.50
Edible Brownie Batter Dough Cup
$5.25
Molasses
$4.50
Turtle
$4.50
Wookie Cookie
$7.00
Brownie with Powdered Sugar
$4.75
Full Menu
10:00 am - 9:40 pm

Most Ordered

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Salted Caramel

Sugar cookie with caramel bits, house-made caramel drizzle, sprinkled with cinnamon & sugar. Customer favorite!
$4.50•26
#1 Most liked

S'more

Our best-selling chocolate chip cookie topped with marshmallows, a Hershey's chocolate bar, and graham cracker.
$4.50•24
#2 Most liked

Vanilla Avalanche

Chocolate chip cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
$5.25•19
#3 Most liked

Chocolate Chip

Our signature classic, loaded with chocolate chips
$3.95•10

Snickerdoodle

Sugar cookie with crunchy edges and a soft center, rolled in cinnamon & sugar.
$3.95•15

Salt Mine

Snickerdoodle base with caramel bits, caramel glaze, dark chocolate drizzle, and sea salt.
$4.50•16

Dirty Panda

Fudge Fantasy cookie dipped in white chocolate and topped with Oreo cookies
$4.50•9

Frosted Sugar

Sugar shortbread cookie with buttercream frosting *Please note cookie shape and frosting color vary.
$4.50

Turtle

Pecans, caramel, caramel bits & chocolate chips.
$4.50•12

M&M

A nostalgic favorite and kids love them!
$3.95•9

Cookies - 1/4 Pounder

Chocolate Chip

Our signature classic, loaded with chocolate chips
$3.95•10

Snickerdoodle

Sugar cookie with crunchy edges and a soft center, rolled in cinnamon & sugar.
$3.95•15

Peanut Butter

Smooth & creamy.
$3.95

M&M

A nostalgic favorite and kids love them!
$3.95•9

Oatmeal Raisin

Soft and chewy with a hint of cinnamon.
$3.95•8

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

Soft and chewy oatmeal cookie with chocolate chips.
$3.95•8

Almond Glazed Sugar

Sugar shortbread cookie topped with almond glaze *Please note cookie shape and color varies.
$4.50•7

Salted Caramel

Sugar cookie with caramel bits, house-made caramel drizzle, sprinkled with cinnamon & sugar. Customer favorite!
$4.50•26
#1 Most liked

Turtle

Pecans, caramel, caramel bits & chocolate chips.
$4.50•12

S'more

Our best-selling chocolate chip cookie topped with marshmallows, a Hershey's chocolate bar, and graham cracker.
$4.50•24
#2 Most liked

Brownie with Powdered Sugar

Rich, chewy & fudgy, topped with powdered sugar.
$4.75•9

Snoopy

Chocolate chip cookie dipped in milk chocolate.
$4.50

Frosted Sugar

Sugar shortbread cookie with buttercream frosting *Please note cookie shape and frosting color vary.
$4.50

Salt Mine

Snickerdoodle base with caramel bits, caramel glaze, dark chocolate drizzle, and sea salt.
$4.50•16

Dirty Panda

Fudge Fantasy cookie dipped in white chocolate and topped with Oreo cookies
$4.50•9

Rotating Flavors

COWW

Craisins, oats, white chocolate, and walnuts.
$4.50•7

Chocolate Frosted Brownie

Our famous brownie with chocolate buttercream frosting and sprinkles.
$4.75•13

Chai Cookie

Sugar cookie topped with chai glaze that has a hint of pumpkin pie spice for extra yumminess
$4.60•6

Molasses

A soft gingersnap cookie rolled in raw sugar. Perfect blend of cinnamon, ginger & cloves!
$4.50•8

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip

Customer Favorite! Soft like a muffin.
$4.60

Dark Side of the Moon

Peanut butter cookie dipped in Dark Chocolate
$4.50

Sandwich Cookies

Vanilla Avalanche

Chocolate chip cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
$5.25•19
#3 Most liked

Chocolate Avalanche

Chocolate chip cookies with chocolate buttercream frosting in the middle.
$5.25

White Out

Snickerdoodle cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
$5.25

Mary'O

Fudge fantasy cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
$5.25

M&M Daydreamer

M&M cookies with buttercream frosting in the middle.
$5.25•9

Cookie Dough Delight

Edible chocolate chip cookie dough between chocolate chip cookies.
$5.25

Wookie Cookie

Our masterpiece! Chocolate chip cookie on top, fudge fantasy cookie on bottom with edible chocolate chip cookie dough in the middle and dipped in milk chocolate and white chocolate.
$7.00

Darth Vader

Fudge fantasy cookies with chocolate buttercream frosting in the middle.
$5.25

Chewbacca

Fudge fantasy cookies with peanut butter frosting in the middle.
$5.25

Oatmeal Creme Pie

Oatmeal raisin cookies with buttercream frosting
$5.25•6

The Ewok

Two, 2oz chocolate chip cookies with edible cookie dough in the middle, dipped in milk chocolate and white chocolate
$7.00

Gluten Free, Keto and Vegan

Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip

Soft, chewy and delicious! Gluten-free. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
$4.75

Gluten-Free M&M

Yummy! Gluten-free. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
$4.75

Gluten-Free Snickerdoodle

Traditional gluten-free sugar cookie topped with a cinnamon sugar mix. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
$4.75

Gluten-Free Salted Caramel

Traditional sugar cookie topped with caramel balls and drizzled with salted caramel glaze. Gluten-free. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
$4.75

Gluten-Free Vanilla Avalanche

Buttercream frosting between 2 chocolate chip cookies. Gluten-free. *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
$5.50

Vegan, Gluten-Free & Soy-Free Chocolate Chip

*we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
$4.75

Keto, Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie

Low in sugar and carbs, soft like a muffin! *we take special precautions in the baking process but cannot guarantee that there isn't any cross contamination due to being a facility that processes wheat flour.
$4.75

Edible Dough Cups & Take-and-Bake Dough Tubs

Edible Chocolate Chip Dough Cup

Chocolate chip cookie dough made without eggs
$5.25

Edible Just Dough Cup

Chocolate chip dough minus the chocolate chips!
$5.25

Edible Brownie Batter Dough Cup

Chocolate chip cookie dough with brownie batter mixed in. Brownie batter contains egg whites.
$5.25

Edible M&M Dough Cup

Cookie dough with M&M's
$5.25

M&M Dough Tub

3 lb M&M cookie dough to bake. Makes 48 (1 oz) cookies.
$18.00

Rollout Dough Tub

3 lb of our shortbread sugar cookie dough to bake. Makes 48 (1 oz) cookies.
$18.00

Chocolate Chip Dough Tub

3 lb tub of our classic chocolate chip dough to bake. Makes 48 (1 oz) cookies.
$18.00

Gifts & Special Orders

12-Inch Big Cookie

Chocolate chip cookie with frosted message. Please specify what you would like written on the cookie. *We don't use colored frosting but can add your choice of M&M's and sprinkles.
$27.00

Small Party Tray

*If you're wanting to order 2 trays or more, please call the shop at 970-482-5655 to place order. 50 - 1 oz. assorted cookies. Need a personal message attached? Write your message in the special instructions section. *No customized options with this tray. *no substitutions
$45.00

Large Party Tray

*If you're wanting to order 2 trays or more, please call the shop at 970-482-5655 to place order. 100 - 1 oz. assorted cookies. Need a personal message attached? Write your message in the special instructions section. *No substitutions on cookie flavors. *no substitutions
$69.00

Standard Cookie & Brownie Box (12)

12 - 1/4 lb. cookies: 2 chocolate chip, 2 snickerdoodle, 2 oatmeal raisin, 2 M&M, 2 brownie & 2 vanilla avalanche. Need a personal message attached? Write your message in the Special Instructions section.
$42.00

Standard Cookie & Brownie Box (24)

24 - 1/4 lb. cookies: 4 chocolate chip, 4 snickerdoodle, 4 oatmeal raisin, 4 M&M, 4 brownie & 4 vanilla avalanche. Need a personal message attached? Write your message in the Special Instructions section.
$64.00

Gluten Free Dreams Box - 12

3 gluten free vanilla avalanche, 3 gluten free salted caramel, 3 gluten free chocolate chip and 3 gluten free snickerdoodle.
$49.00

Best Sellers Box (12)

12-1/4 lb. cookies: 2 s'more, 2 salted caramel, 2 almond glazed sugar, 2 turtle, 2 brownie, 2 vanilla avalanche.
$49.00

Best Sellers Box (24)

24-1/4 lb. cookies: 4 s'more, 4 salted caramel, 4 almond glazed sugar, 4 turtle, 4 brownie, 4 vanilla avalanche.
$69.00

Individually Bagged Cookies (12)

12-1/4 lb. individually bagged and sealed cookies. Need a personal message attached? Write your message in the special instructions section.
$59.00

Add Your Message Gift Box (24)

24 - 1/4 lb. individually bagged and sealed cookies! Write your message in the special instruction box. This is the ultimate cookie lover's dream gift.
$79.00

Baked Daily T-shirt

Unisex, 100% cotton. Available sizes: XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL. *Choose your size using the size selector* Front: small logo on the upper left side. Back: Baked Daily, Fort Collins CO.
$29.00

Grey Beanie

Baked daily on front, mary's mountain cookie logo on back.
$27.00

Nalgene Water Bottle

Wide mouth - 32 oz.
$27.00

Black beanie

A cozy black beanie featuring a circular "Baked" logo patch in red and white.
$27.00

Beverages

Pint of Milk

Farmer's all-natural 2% milk (pint).
$3.00

Chocolate Milk

Nesquik - 8 oz.
$3.00

Red Bull

8.4 oz can.
$3.00

Sugar-Free Red Bull

8.4 oz can.
$3.00

Arrowhead Water

Pure, refreshing water sourced from Arrowhead Springs.
$3.00

Coconut Water

11.1 oz.
$3.00

Coke

12 oz can.
$2.00

Diet Coke

12 oz can.
$2.00

Sprite

12 oz can.
$2.00

Dr Pepper

12 oz can.
$2.00

Diet Dr Pepper

Crisp, Sugar-Free Dr. Pepper with a Unique Blend of 23 Flavors
$2.00
Accessibility StatementTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
© 2026 DoorDash