Mikes Pasta and Sandwich Shoppe Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Mikes Pasta and Sandwich Shoppe
Sign In / Sign Up
Mikes Pasta and Sandwich
95 Harrison Street, Nutley, NJ
Online ordering hours: ClosedUnavailable
Featured Items
Caesar & Co.
$68.00
Mike's Fried Eggplant
$17.00
The Nutley
$19.00
Italian Standard
$18.00
Vodka Sauce
$18.00
Caesar & Co.
$18.00
Classic
$19.00
Love A Parm
$19.00
O.G.
$17.00
Marinara
$13.00
Morty Royale
$18.00
Mac Salad
$6.00
Truffle Mac
$9.00
Creste di Gallo
$7.00
Pasta Dealer Tote
$25.00
Mushroom Ragu
$8.00
Mafaldine
$7.00
Spaghetti
$7.00
Orecchiette
$7.00
Full Menu
closedMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Mike's Fried Eggplant
Yes, that one. Beef tallow fried eggplant with Ricotta, Arugula, and our infamous Tomato Jam dressed with Olive oil + Vinegar on a Seeded Ciabatta roll.
$17.00
The Nutley
with Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers,
Olive oil + Balsamic on a Demi Baguette
$19.00
Caesar & Co.
Baby Kale dressed in house made Caesar dressing with Mozzarella and Pecorino on a Focaccia style long roll.
$18.00
O.G.
with Provolone, Arugula, Roasted Peppers, Olive Oil + Balsamic on a Demi Baguette.
$17.00
Love A Parm
Topped with melted Mozzarella and Marinara sawwce, with Pecorino and basil puree on a Demi Baguette.
$19.00
Italian Standard
Ham, Salami and Provolone with Cherry Peppers, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Sicilian Oregano, Oil + Vinegar on a Demi Baguette.
$18.00
Mac Salad
Our house made pasta with carrot, onion, celery and mayo. Served by the half lb.
$6.00
Classic
Prosciutto, Mozzarella, and Arugula dressed with Balsamic and Olive oil on a Demi Baguette
$19.00
Truffle Mac
House made pasta, black truffle, mushrooms, scallions, mayo and Parmigiano. Served by the half lb.
$9.00
Calabrian Vodka
Spicy Nduja, Vodka sawwce with melted Smoked Mozzarella and finished with a Basil puree on a Demi Baguette.
$21.00
Mike's Specials
Our Weekly Specials, here until they're not.
Eggplant Parm
Mike's Classic beef tallow fried eggplant, dripping in our perfect house made Mozzarella, Marinara and basil puree on a Balthazar baguette.
$17.00
The Cutlets
This is our Chicken Cutlet sandwich lineup. All cutlets are fried in beef tallow. You're gonna love them. All of our sandwiches made with bread from the renowned Balthazar Bakery.
O.G.
with Provolone, Arugula, Roasted Peppers, Olive Oil + Balsamic on a Demi Baguette.
$17.00
The Nutley
with Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers,
Olive oil + Balsamic on a Demi Baguette
$19.00
Caesar & Co.
Baby Kale dressed in house made Caesar dressing with Mozzarella and Pecorino on a Focaccia style long roll.
$18.00
Calabrian Vodka
Spicy Nduja, Vodka sawwce with melted Smoked Mozzarella and finished with a Basil puree on a Demi Baguette.
$21.00
Love A Parm
Topped with melted Mozzarella and Marinara sawwce, with Pecorino and basil puree on a Demi Baguette.
$19.00
The Hitters
Just a collection of a few awesome sandwiches. All of our sandwiches made with bread from the renowned Balthazar Bakery.
Italian Standard
Ham, Salami and Provolone with Cherry Peppers, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Sicilian Oregano, Oil + Vinegar on a Demi Baguette.
$18.00
Smokey Grilled Cheese
Provolone and Smoked Mozzarella with Spicy Calabrian Chili and Sundried Peppers all goo'd up a Focaccia style long roll
$16.00
Morty Royale
Mortadella, Provolone, Pickled Onions and Baby Kale dressed in a dreamy Truffle Dijonnaise on a Focaccia style long roll.
$18.00
Mike's Fried Eggplant
Yes, that one. Beef tallow fried eggplant with Ricotta, Arugula, and our infamous Tomato Jam dressed with Olive oil + Vinegar on a Seeded Ciabatta roll.
$17.00
Classic
Prosciutto, Mozzarella, and Arugula dressed with Balsamic and Olive oil on a Demi Baguette
$19.00
Sides
Mac Salad
Our house made pasta with carrot, onion, celery and mayo. Served by the half lb.
$6.00
Truffle Mac
House made pasta, black truffle, mushrooms, scallions, mayo and Parmigiano. Served by the half lb.
$9.00
Garlic Bread
A gorgeous 10" Balthazar baguette, house made garlic butter, drizzled in olive oil, topped with pecorino romano and some good spices. Arrives Frozen! Cooking instructions come with. She hits.
$4.00
DIRTY Maui Onion Potato Chips
DIRTY Maui Onion flavored thick cut kettle chips
$3.00
DIRTY Salt + Vinegar Chips
DIRTY Salt + Vinegar flavored thick cut kettle chips
$3.00
DIRTY Jalapeno Heat Chips
DIRTY Jalapeno Heat flavored thick cut kettle chips
$3.00
San Carlo Potato Chips
Crisp and thinly sliced potato chips, lightly salted for a simple, savory crunch.
$3.00
Housemade Pasta
We offer bronze dye extruded Semolina Pasta and frozen handrolled pasta for you to cook and enjoy at home.
Mafaldine
Fresh, House made Pasta packed by the 1/2 lb. Made with responsibly grown Semolina and Spring Water. You've probably had our pasta in your favorite restaurant.
$7.00
Creste di Gallo
Fresh, House made Pasta packed by the 1/2 lb. Made with responsibly grown Semolina and Spring Water. You've probably had our pasta in your favorite restaurant.
$7.00
Spaghetti
Fresh, House made Pasta packed by the 1/2 lb. Made with responsibly grown Semolina and Spring Water. You've probably had our pasta in your favorite restaurant.
$7.00
Orecchiette
Fresh, House made Pasta packed by the 1/2 lb. Made with responsibly grown Semolina and Spring Water. You've probably had our pasta in your favorite restaurant.
$7.00
Sandwich Boxes
Your box comes with 4 sandwiches cut into 4. All sandwiches served on Balthazar Bread and all sauces / dressings are on the side. Perfect for Game Day, to order for parties, or just a nice gift to yourself.
O.G.
Beef tallow fried Chicken Cutlets, Provolone, Roasted Peppers and Arugula, Balsamic and Olive Oil on the side. Served on Demi Baguettes
$60.00
The Nutley
Beef tallow fried Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Prosciutto and Mozzarella, with Balsamic and Olive Oil on the side. Served on a Demi Baguette
$68.00
Caesar & Co.
Beef tallow fried Breaded Chicken Cutlet with fresh Mozzarella and Baby Kale dressed in our house made Caesar topped with Pecorino. Served on a Demi Baguette
$68.00
Fried Eggplant
Beef tallow fried eggplant with Ricotta, Arugula, and our infamous Tomato Jam. Olive oil + Vinegar on the side. Served on a Demi Baguette
$61.00
Classic
Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Arugula and Sundried Peppers with a side of Balsamic and Olive. Served on a Demi Baguette
$78.00
Italian Standard
Ham, Salami and Provolone with Cherry Peppers, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Sicilian Oregano. Oil + Vinegar on the side. Served on a Demi Baguette
$60.00
Sauces
Sauces made in house, sold fresh by the quart or pint
Marinara
1 qt of Mike's Marinara. Simmered tomatoes with garlic, onions, basil and olive oil. *Tip: 1 qt per lb of pasta, feeds up to 4 people.
$13.00
Mushroom Ragu
1 pint of Mike's Mushroom Ragu. Shitake mushrooms cooked down with tomatoes, vegetables and white wine. *Tip: 1 qt per lb of pasta, feeds up to 4 people.
$8.00
Vodka Sauce
1 qt of Mike's Vodka Sawwce. Tomato, Prosciutto, Onion, Garlic, Olive Oil, White Wine, Vodka, Basil and Salt. *Tip: 1 qt per lb of pasta, feeds up to 4 people.
$18.00
Drinks
All your favorite Italian sodas + beverages
Water
20oz bottle of water
$3.00
Sparkling Water
San Benedetto Sparking Water
$3.00
Aranciata San Pellegrino
Orange flavored Italian sparkling water
$3.00
Aranciata Rossa San Pellegrino
Blood Orange Italian sparkling soda
$3.00
Limonata San Pellegrino
Lemon flavored Italian sparkling soda
$3.00
Pompelmo San Pellegrino
Grapefruit flavored Italian sparkling soda
$3.00
Blood Orange Polara
Blood Orange Polara Italian sparkling soda
$3.00
Chinotto Polara
Chinotto flavored Italian soda
$3.00
Lemon Polara
Lemon flavored Italian sparkling soda
$3.00
Mole Cola
Classic Italian Cola
$3.00
Official Merch
Whatever we wanna sell. Support Your Local Pasta Dealer.
Pasta Dealer Tote
Farmers Market Szn is calling. Your go to tote for the goods. We got you.
SUPPORT YOUR LOCAL PASTA DEALER
Over the shoulder grocery tote. 10oz, 100% cotton twill.
Dimensions: 15"h x 13.5"w x 7.25"d
$25.00
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash