Mill Creek Tavern (Bayville Ave) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Mill Creek Tavern
275 Bayville Ave, Bayville NY 11709-1708, United StatesOpens 4:30 PM
Order for later
Featured Items
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
$36.00
Skirt Steak
$47.00
Prime Angus Burger
$23.00
Chicken Schnitzel
$31.00
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
$18.00
Sauerbraten Short Ribs
$37.00
Steak Sandwich
$30.00
Cheeseburger Sliders
$18.00
NY Strip Steak
$53.00
Potato & Cheese Pierogies
$16.00
Iceberg Wedge
$18.00
Filet Mignon
$57.00
Chicken Wings
$19.00
Rigatoni Ala Vodka
$27.00
Roasted Half Chicken
$35.00
Oreo Mousse Pie
$12.00
Angel Hair & Chicken
$28.00
Linguini Bolagnese
$29.00
Chili Pop Shrimp
$20.00
Chicken Parmesan
$31.00
French Onion Soup
$14.00
Shepards Pie
$27.00
Fried Chicken Sandwich
$23.00
Three Cheese Ravioli
$28.00
Mac & Cheese
$11.00
Full Menu
4:30 pm - 8:10 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
Gorgonzola, spinach, porcini mushroom-sage cream sauce
$36.00
Prime Angus Burger
GRILLED 10oz PRIME ANGUS BURGER
$23.00
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
Vermont cheddar, bleu cheese, scallions, hot sauce
$18.00
Chicken Schnitzel
Mushroom gravy, Choice of Side
$31.00
Cheeseburger Sliders
Bacon, cheddar, potato buns
$18.00
Potato & Cheese Pierogies
Bacon brown butter, chive sour cream
$16.00
Skirt Steak
Choice of Side
$47.00
Sauerbraten Short Ribs
Mustard herb späetzle, braised red cabbage
$37.00
Iceberg Wedge
Applewood smoked bacon, red onion, chopped tomatoes, bleu cheese dressing
$18.00
Steak Sandwich
Toasted garlic roll, mushrooms, sautéed onions, melted mozzarella, horseradish mayo
$30.00
Starters
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
Vermont cheddar, bleu cheese, scallions, hot sauce
$18.00
Burrata Mozzarella
Creamy mozzarella, balsamic reduction, basil infused olive oil, grape tomatoes
$20.00
Cheeseburger Sliders
Bacon, cheddar, potato buns
$18.00
Chicken Wings
Hot sauce, bleu cheese dressing, celery
$19.00
Chili Pop Shrimp
Baby shrimp, sweet Thai chili sauce
$20.00
French Onion Soup
Caramelized onions in a rich broth, topped with melted cheese and a sprinkle of herbs.
$14.00
Kung Pao Cauliflower
crispy cauliflower, Kung Pao sauce, scallions
$18.00
Little Neck Clams Oreganata
Roasted garlic, white wine, olive oil, parmesan bread crumbs
$17.00
Lobster Bisque
Rich and creamy lobster bisque with tender lobster pieces and a hint of herbs.
$15.00
Potato & Cheese Pierogies
Bacon brown butter, chive sour cream
$16.00
Potato Skins
Crisp potato skins typically topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, green onions, and a side of sour cream.
$19.00
Roasted Brussel Sprouts
maple brown butter, smoked bacon,
crispy onions
$18.00
Spinach Fondue
Tri-color tortilla chips
$18.00
Tuna Poke
Ahi tuna, mango salsa, spicy mayo, crispy wonton
$22.00
Tuscan Calamari
Fried calamari, marinara, lemon, horseradish aioli
$20.00
Tavern Mussel Pots
Mussel Fra Diavlo
Spicy pomodoro
$21.00
Mussel Provencale
Tomatoes, garlic, onions, white wine, butter
$21.00
Mussel Casino
Shallots, garlic, red peppers, bacon, white wine
$21.00
Salads
Tavern Market Salad
Baby greens, garden vegetables, choice of dressing
$17.00
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan crouton
$17.00
Iceberg Wedge
Applewood smoked bacon, red onion, chopped tomatoes, bleu cheese dressing
$18.00
Country Salad
Baby field greens, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, Maytag bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
$17.00
Mediterranean Salad
cucumber, red onions, Kalamata olives, feta, baby greens, grape tomatoes, garbanzo beans, Greek vinaigrette (Vegan - without cheese)
$18.00
Handhelds
Prime Angus Burger
GRILLED 10oz PRIME ANGUS BURGER
$23.00
Plant Based Beyond Burger
Plant-based patty, choice of fries, sweet fries, house salad, Caesar salad, or no side.
$21.00
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Lettuce, tomato, special sauce
$23.00
Grilled Chicken Club
Apple wood smoked bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo
$23.00
Steak Sandwich
Toasted garlic roll, mushrooms, sautéed onions, melted mozzarella, horseradish mayo
$30.00
Grilled Shrimp BLT Wrap
(grilled or blackened) shaved cabbage, mango salsa, avocado, cilantro lime crema
$25.00
Grilled Fish Tacos
avocado, pico de gallo, lettuce, corn tortilla
$22.00
Blackened Fish Tacos
avocado, pico de gallo, lettuce, corn tortilla
$22.00
House Specialities
Chicken & Granny Smith Apples
Roasted sweet potatoes, candied walnuts, Hudson Valley cider riesling sauce
$32.00
Chicken Scarpariello
bone-in or boneless, Italian sausage, hot cherry peppers, lemon, white wine, garlic, rosemary, roasted potatoes
$33.00
Roasted Half Chicken
sauteed spinach, mashed potatoes, natural chicken jus GF
$35.00
Sauteed Chicken
Diced Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, toasted pine nuts, lemon scampi olive oil, parmesan roasted potatoes
$32.00
Chicken Cordon Blue
Stuffed chicken breast with ham and Swiss cheese, typically complemented by a light sauce, offering a classic take on this house specialty.
$33.00
Pork Chop
pancetta, broccoli rabe, cherry peppers, roasted potatoes, pan jus
$39.00
Eggplant & Ravioli Vodka
Ravioli filled with eggplant, typically served in a rich vodka tomato sauce.
$28.00
Sole Oreganata
Jumbo shrimp, mussels, tomatoes, sautéed spinach, roasted garlic-lemon-olive oil, angel hair
$35.00
Sauerbraten Short Ribs
Mustard herb späetzle, braised red cabbage
$37.00
Meatloaf
crispy onions, country gravy, sautéed vegetables, mashed potatoes
$28.00
Shepards Pie
ground beef, carrots, peas, fresh herb jus, mashed potato crust
$27.00
Cedar Plank Roasted Norwegian Salmon
Cedar Plank Roasted Norwegian Salmon, maple roasted Brussels sprouts, stone mustard sauce
$37.00
Steaks / Chops
Skirt Steak
Choice of Side
$47.00
NY Strip Steak
Choice of Side
$53.00
Filet Mignon
Choice of Side
$57.00
Pork Chop
Choice of Side
$39.00
Mains
Chicken Francaise
Chicken francaise served with choice of side—variety from spinach, broccoli, potatoes, risotto, pasta, mixed or roasted vegetables, and more. Some premium options like truffle fries or loaded potato.
$31.00
Chicken Parmesan
Choice of Side
$31.00
Chicken Schnitzel
Mushroom gravy, Choice of Side
$31.00
Grilled Jumbo Shrimp
Choice of Side
$35.00
Blackened Jumbo Shrimp
Choice of Side
$35.00
Jumbo Shrimp Francaise
Choice of Side
$35.00
Jumbo Shrimp Oreganata
Jumbo shrimp with oregano and a choice of one side. Sides include various vegetables, potatoes, pasta, or salad options.
$35.00
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi
Choice of Side
$35.00
Jumbo Shrimp Piccata
Jumbo shrimp with capers and lemon butter sauce. Choose from various sides including spinach, broccoli, potatoes, and more.
$35.00
Sole Francaise
Choice of Side
$31.00
Sole Oregnata
Choice of Side
$31.00
Eggplant Parmesan
EGGPLANT PARMESAN Basil pomodoro, Choice of Side
$27.00
Blackened Norwegian Salmon
Choice of Side
$37.00
Grilled Norwegian Salmon
Choice of Side
$37.00
Sesame Crusted Tuna
Choice of Side
$34.00
Grilled Chicken
Choice of Side
$31.00
Blackened Chicken
Choice of Side
$31.00
Noodles
Angel Hair & Chicken
Spinach, diced tomatoes, basil, fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic white wine
$28.00
Homemade Mac & Cheese
Cheddar cheese, American cheese, fresh cream
$23.00
Linguine Clam Sauce
Whole littleneck & fresh chopped clams, red or white
$30.00
Linguine Seafood
Jumbo shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, white wine- garlic- olive oil or fra diavlo
$36.00
Linguini & Meatballs
Homemade meatballs, pomodoro, parmesan
$27.00
Linguini Bolagnese
Tender linguini topped with a rich meat sauce, diced tomatoes, and a sprinkle of fresh parsley and grated cheese.
$29.00
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
Gorgonzola, spinach, porcini mushroom-sage cream sauce
$36.00
Rigatoni Ala Vodka
Pomodoro, fresh cream, vodka, parmesan, crushed red pepper
$27.00
Rigatoni Sausage
cannelini beans, cherry peppers, white wine, roasted garlic, olive oil
$28.00
Three Cheese Ravioli
Melted mozzarella, basil pomodoro
$28.00
Zucchini Linguini Shrimp
Roasted tomato-white wine-garlic broth
$35.00
Zucchini Linguini
(VEGAN) Roasted tomato-white wine-garlic broth
$23.00
Dessert
NY Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecake slice with a graham cracker crust, garnished with whipped cream and a mint leaf, drizzled with a berry sauce.
$12.00
Oreo Mousse Pie
Rich chocolate mousse layered with Oreo crumbs, topped with whipped cream and drizzled with chocolate sauce.
$12.00
Tiramisu
lady fingers, espresso,
mascarpone, cocoa
$12.00
Sides
Creamed Spinach
Velvety spinach blended into a rich, creamy sauce. Perfect comfort side.
$11.00
Sautéed Spinach
Sautéed green goodness, perfect for health-conscious diners seeking a flavorful leafy greens option.
$11.00
Steamed Spinach
Steamed spinach typically includes tender, fresh spinach leaves lightly steamed for a simple and nutritious side dish.
$11.00
Burnt Broccoli
Charred broccoli typically includes garlic and a hint of lemon for a smoky, robust flavor.
$11.00
Sautéed Broccoli
Sautéed Broccoli bursting with healthy nutrients and vibrant flavors.
$11.00
Steamed Broccoli
Freshly Steamed Broccoli: Perfectly Tender and Bursting with Natural Flavors
$11.00
Spaetzle
Fresh egg noodles sautéed in browned butter, typically includes onions and cheese.
$11.00
Sautéed Veg
Typically includes zucchini, squash, carrots, onions, bell peppers, and green beans, sautéed in olive oil.
$11.00
Steamed Veg
A medley of seasonal vegetables, lightly steamed until tender.
$11.00
Roasted Brussel Sprouts
Golden-roasted Brussels sprouts, perfectly seasoned and bursting with flavor.
$11.00
Braised Red Cabbage
Cooked with cloves, juniper berries, coriander, apple juice, red wine vinegar, cinnamon, onions, sugar, bay leaves, and butter.
$11.00
Fries
Crispy golden potato strips, perfectly seasoned and fried to a mouthwatering perfection.
$11.00
Sweet Potato Fries
Crispy and flavorful fries made from sweet potatoes, a delightful twist on a classic favorite.
$11.00
Grilled Sweet Potatos
Grilled sweet potatoes typically include a hint of smokiness from the grill, complemented by a touch of sweetness.
$11.00
Truffel Fries
French fries tossed with truffle oil, parmesan cheese, and parsley.
$13.00
Onion Rings
Crispy golden-fried onion rings, perfectly seasoned for a savory crunch.
$11.00
Potato Croquette
Golden, crispy potato croquettes, typically filled with creamy mashed potatoes and lightly breaded before frying.
$11.00
Mac & Cheese
Creamy, classic macaroni in a rich, velvety cheese sauce.
$11.00
Mashed Potato
Silky-smooth whipped potatoes with a touch of butter and seasoning.
$11.00
Baked Potato
Perfectly baked, fluffy potato with a crisp skin
$11.00
Loaded baked potato
Baked potato loaded with butter, sour cream, chopped bacon, and shredded cheddar cheese, garnished with chopped chives.
$12.00
Roasted Potato
Roasted potato with olive oil, garlic, and fresh herbs.
$11.00
Side Pasta
Choice of Angel Hair, Penne, Rigatoni, or Linguini. Select from Pomodoro, Butter, Scampi, Vodka, Franchisse, Cream Sauce, Plain, or Garlic & Oil sauces.
$11.00
Shrimp Risotto
Creole seasoned shrimp over sweet-pea and white wine risotto.
$16.00
Risotto
Creamy risotto typically includes parmesan, mushrooms, roasted red peppers, and spinach.
$11.00
Grilled Sweet Potato
Grilled sweet potatoes typically seasoned with hints of cinnamon and brown sugar, offering a balance of natural sweetness and subtle savory notes.
$11.00
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash