Mythical Pizza Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Sign In / Sign Up
Mythical Pizza
1855 Valley Rd, Berkeley Springs, WV 25411, USA15 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
Daddy Bigfoot - 14" Custom Pizza
$15.00
#2 Most liked
Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Standard Pepperoni Pizza)
$15.00
Stand By Meat (Mothman's Fav - Meat Pizza)
$15.00
#3 Most liked
Cheesy Garlic Bread
$10.00+
Alabama White THANG
$15.00
Lil' Mothman - 10" Custom Pizza
$10.00
Gluten-Friendly - 10" Cauliflower Crust Pizza
$18.00
Balsamic S.T.R.I.P.E.S.
$15.00
QUADZILLA - King of Pepperoni
$15.00
A Nightmare on Braxie Street
$15.00
Baby Nessie's Personal Salad
$9.00
Paranormal Pretzels (3 Dippable Sticks)
$5.00
*NEW* Attack of the 50' Meatball
$15.00
Mothman's Pepperoni Roll
$8.00
Stuffed Stromboli
$15.50
The Flight of the SQUONKS
$19.50
Mama Nessie's Family Salad
$14.00
Flatwoods Foldover - 14" Calzone Pizza
$19.00
Mothman Tiramisu
$7.50
#1 Most liked
Forbidden Focaccia Pizza (10" x 6")
$18.00
Large Cheesy Garlic Bread
$6.00
2 Liter Pepsi
$4.75
Baby Squonk - 5" Custom Pizza
$6.00
The Cryptid Club PARTY PACK (50 Wings)
$45.00
Alfredo vs. Predator (AVP)
$15.00
Full Menu
11:15 am - 8:10 pmMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Standard Pepperoni Pizza)
#2 Most liked
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni
$15.00•95% (42)
Cheesy Garlic Bread
#3 Most liked
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, sasquatch seasoning
$10.00+•90% (42)
Daddy Bigfoot - 14" Custom Pizza
Enjoy your pizza exactly the way you want it! Select your sauce, cheeses, toppings, edges and finishes!
$15.00
Stand By Meat (Mothman's Fav - Meat Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, diced ham
$15.00•100% (22)
Lil' Mothman - 10" Custom Pizza
A smaller, personalized version of your favorite pizza! Enjoy a 7" pizza fully customized for you!
$10.00
Paranormal Pretzels (3 Dippable Sticks)
house dough prepped into three dippable sticks, coated with a garlic butter and coarse sea salt, served w/ mucho queso
$5.00
Baby Nessie's Personal Salad
Our Arcadian lettuce blend is your base for this personal size salad, custom made for you with the toppings you crave!
$9.00
Alabama White THANG
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, cherry tomatoes, chopped basil (after bake: sasquatch seasoning and sea salt)
$15.00
BATSQUATCH Wings (10 Wings)
10 Bone-In or Boneless Wings, tossed in your choice of sauce!
$12.50•88% (18)
Mozzarella Monster (Standard Cheese Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella
$15.00•91% (34)
Garlic Bread Lovers Monday
Large Garlic Bread [No Cheese]
garlic oil, chopped garlic, sasquatch seasoning
$6.00
Large Cheesy Garlic Bread
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, sasquatch seasoning
$6.00
Large Cheesesteak Garlic Bread
garlic oil, chopped garlic, cheddar, steak, green pepper, red onion, sasquatch seasoning
$8.00
Large Mothman's Spicy Bread
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, pepperoni, red pepper flakes
$8.00
Build Your Own Pizza Pie & Salads
Daddy Bigfoot - 14" Custom Pizza
Enjoy your pizza exactly the way you want it! Select your sauce, cheeses, toppings, edges and finishes!
$15.00
Lil' Mothman - 10" Custom Pizza
A smaller, personalized version of your favorite pizza! Enjoy a 7" pizza fully customized for you!
$10.00
Baby Squonk - 5" Custom Pizza
Enjoy a 5" personal mini pizza, fully customized for your taste! A great option for picky and small eaters.
$6.00•100% (22)
Flatwoods Foldover - 14" Calzone Pizza
Half-Pizza, Half-Calzone! Pick your toppings of a normal pizza on one side, and a filled calzone on the other.
$19.00
Grafton Monster - 10" DEEP DISH Pizza
Legendary 10" DEEP DISH pizza is full of cheese & toppings, covered in marinara and Parmesan cheese!
$22.00
9" Pizza BOWL (KETO Friendly)
Load up with out the carbs! Choose your sauces, cheese, proteins and veggies for an out-of-this-world meal!
$10.00
KETO-Friendly - 10" Fattyhead KETO Pizza
Made with mozzarella, cream cheese, eggs and almond flour. This KETO friendly crust is only 6g net carbs per crust!
$19.00
Gluten-Friendly - 10" Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Our gluten-friendly cauliflower crust has an incredible punch of flavor!
$18.00
Drizzled Calzone
Calzone with Mozzarella, Ricotta, your choice of meats & veggies, baked golden and drizzled your way.
$14.75+
Stuffed Stromboli
Stromboli with marinara, cheese, your choice of meats & veggies. Served with a dipper.
$15.50
Forbidden Focaccia Pizza (10" x 6")
#1 Most liked
Thick, pillowy herb focaccia brushed with garlic oil and baked to perfection. Build it your way with your favorite toppings, then sliced into 4 massive squares.
$18.00•95% (42)
The Flight of the SQUONKS
A flight of three 5" Baby Squonk pizzas of our Signature Pies! Special requests to remove toppings, no substitutions.
$19.50
Mama Nessie's Family Salad
Our Arcadian lettuce blend is your base for this gigantic salad, custom made to your appetite!
$14.00•90% (21)
Baby Nessie's Personal Salad
Our Arcadian lettuce blend is your base for this personal size salad, custom made for you with the toppings you crave!
$9.00
Signature Pies
Mozzarella Monster (Standard Cheese Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella
$15.00•91% (34)
Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Standard Pepperoni Pizza)
#2 Most liked
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni
$15.00•95% (42)
Stand By Meat (Mothman's Fav - Meat Pizza)
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, diced ham
$15.00•100% (22)
Alabama White THANG
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, cherry tomatoes, chopped basil (after bake: sasquatch seasoning and sea salt)
$15.00
Alfredo vs. Predator (AVP)
alfredo, mozzarella, smoked turkey burnt ends, green peppers, corn, jalapeño peppers (after bake: barbecue drizzle)
$15.00
*NEW* Attack of the 50' Meatball
marinara, mozzrella, romano cheese meatballs, banana peppers, fire roasted red peppers, chopped basil
$15.00
Balsamic S.T.R.I.P.E.S.
marinara, mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, diced tomatoes (after bake: fresh spinach and balsamic glaze)
$15.00
*NEW* Big Trouble in Hot Chicken
nashville hot, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, red onions, fire roasted red peppers, dill pickles (after bake: ranch drizzle)
$15.00
Close Encounters (Of The Veggie Kind)
alfredo, mozzarella, diced tomatoes, green peppers, marinated mushrooms, red onions, chopped basil, garlic roasted brussels sprouts (after bake: basil pesto sprinkle)
$15.00
E.T. The Extra-Toppings Supreme
marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, diced ham, marinated mushrooms, red onions, green peppers, black olives
$15.00•93% (15)
Flatwood Bueller's Day Off
marinara, mozzarella, diced ham, pineapple, jalapeño peppers
$15.00
*NEW* The Great Pretzel Escape
garlic oil, cheddar, sausage, jalapeños, red onion on pretzel style salt & garlic edge, served w/ nacho cheese dipper
$15.00
*NEW* The Karate Cryptid
teriyaki, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, pineapple, green peppers
$15.00
A Krampus Story
garlic oil, mozzarella, ricotta, steak, green peppers, red onions, marinated mushrooms, sasquatch seasoning
$15.00
A Nightmare on Braxie Street
alfredo, mozzarella, cheddar, ricotta, bacon, chicken (after bake: fresh spinach & honey sriracha drizzle)
$15.00•100% (19)
Pastanormal Activity
alfredo, mozzarella, cheddar, penne pasta, chicken, bacon, smoked turkey burnt ends (after bake: barbecue drizzle)
$15.00
POULTRYGEIST
buffalo, cheddar, chicken, banana peppers, jalapeño peppers (after bake: ranch drizzle)
$15.00•90% (11)
QUADZILLA - King of Pepperoni
marinara, full-coverage pepperoni (after bake: mike’s hot honey drizzle & red pepper flakes)
$15.00•95% (21)
The Princess Brine
alfredo, mozzarella, smoked turkey burnt ends, green peppers, corn, jalapeño peppers (after bake: barbecue drizzle)
$15.00
*NEW* Raiders of the Lost Sauce
traditional tomato pie: marinara, chopped basil, sprinkled with parmesan cheese
$15.00
The TURKINATOR
sweet chili, cheddar, smoked turkey burnt ends, red onions (after bake: fresh spinach, buffalo drizzle)
$15.00
Smokey and the Bigfoot
barbecue, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, bacon, green peppers, corn (after bake: barbecue drizzle)
$15.00
Sprout-Man and the Masters of the Pizzeria
garlic oil, mozzarella, bacon, feta, red onions, garlic roasted brussels sprouts (after bake: balsamic glaze)
$15.00
Uncle Beak
ranch, mozzarella, chicken, bacon, red onion (after bake: fresh spinach, ranch drizzle)
$15.00
Penne Pasta Bowls
Build Your Own Kraken's Noodles
Build your own Kraken’s Noodles with your choice of sauces, cheeses, meats, and veggies!
$8.00+
Beast of Busco Bowl
marinara, mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni, green peppers
$8.00+
Mothman's Mushroom Bowl
basil pesto, mozzarella, sausage, marinated mushrooms, cherry tomatoes
$8.00+
Jersey Devil Fury Bowl
buffalo, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, jalapeno peppers
$8.00+
Ozark Howler Bowl
garlic parmesan, mozzarella, cheddar, ricotta, smoked burnt turkey ends
$8.00+
The Red-Eyed INFERNO Bowl
nashville hot, cheddar, chicken, red onions, banana peppers and finished with mike's hot honey
$8.00+
Braxie's Meatball Bowl
marinara, mozzarella, romano cheese meatballs
$8.00+
Enter The Mothman Bowl
teriyaki, mozzarella, chicken, pineapple, green peppers
$8.00+
Batsquatch Wings
BATSQUATCH Wings (10 Wings)
10 Bone-In or Boneless Wings, tossed in your choice of sauce!
$12.50•88% (18)
BATSQUATCH Jumbo Pack (30 Wings)
30 Bone-In or Boneless Wings, split into 3 flavors of 10, tossed in your favorite sauces.
$30.00
The Cryptid Club PARTY PACK (50 Wings)
two sets of 25 wings each with two 4oz dippers
bone-in or boneless together in a large box
naked or finished in any of our sauce options
$45.00
Big(Foot) Breads
Garlic Bread [No Cheese]
garlic oil, chopped garlic, sasquatch seasoning
$9.00+
Cheesy Garlic Bread
#3 Most liked
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, sasquatch seasoning
$10.00+•90% (42)
Cheesesteak Garlic Bread
garlic oil, chopped garlic, cheddar, steak, green pepper, red onion, sasquatch seasoning
$12.00+
Mothman's Spicy Bread
garlic oil, chopped garlic, mozzarella, pepperoni, red pepper flakes
$11.00+•81% (11)
Feta-n-Pesto Folded Bread
pesto, feta, mozzarella w. garlic oil drizzle
$7.00
Jalapeño-n-Cheese Folded Bread
alfredo, mozzarella, jalapeños w. honey sriracha drizzle
$7.00
Buffalo-n-Bleu Folded Bread
buffalo, mozzarella, bleu cheese w. buffalo drizzle
$7.00
Tomato-n-Balsamic Folded Bread
chopped garlic, mozzarella, diced tomato w. balsamic glaze
$7.00
Cryptid Rolls
Hodag Monster Roll
mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, diced ham
$8.00•77% (9)
Thunderbird Roll
cheddar, chicken, bacon
$8.00•85% (7)
Mythical Meatball Roll
mozzarella and romano cheese meatballs
$8.00
Mothman's Pepperoni Roll
mozzarella and pepperoni
$8.00
Veggie Man's Vegan Roll
vegan cheese, diced tomato, green pepper, red onion, black olives
$9.00
Paranormal Pretzels
Paranormal Pretzels (3 Dippable Sticks)
house dough prepped into three dippable sticks, coated with a garlic butter and coarse sea salt, served w/ mucho queso
$5.00
Drinks
20oz LIFEWTR
LIFEWTR premium bottled water, pH balanced with electrolytes for taste.
$3.00
Juice Box
Apple Juice with no added sugar and 100% daily vitamin C.
$1.50
Alani Cherry Slush
Tastes like a chilled cherry slushie with a rush of retro sweetness!
$4.00
Alani Sherbet Swirl
A sweet swirl of raspberry, orange and lime sherbet.
$4.00
Alani Breezeberry
Tart blue raspberries sprinkled with a sweet citrus frost.
$4.00
2 Liter Pepsi
Pepsi-Cola, the bold, refreshing cola.
$4.75
2 Liter Pepsi Zero
Pepsi Zero Sugar is here—bold, refreshing, zero calories, and full of flavor!
$4.75
2 Liter Mug Root Beer
Mug’s creamy vanilla and spiced sweetness enjoyed for over 65 years.
$4.75
2 Liter Schweppes Ginger Ale
Bold, crisp, and bubbly ginger ale—perfectly refreshing.
$4.75
Cryptid Club Sodas
Squonk Tears Club Soda
Crisp, fizzy club soda, perfect on its own or as a mixer.
$3.75
Chupacabra Black Cherry Soda
Bold black cherry soda that sinks its flavor fangs into your taste buds.
$3.75•81% (11)
Cryptid Cola
The fan-favorite, limited edition, and legendary refreshment is back!
$3.75
Hodag Orange Creamsicle Crush
A frosty burst of orange and creamy vanilla for a legendary sip!
$3.75
Point Pleasant Perk Espresso+Sugar
A bubbly blast of espresso and sugar to keep you buzzing like Mothman at midnight!
$3.75
Cheat River Lemon-Lime
A crisp mix of lemon, lime, and a hint of orange—pure refreshment!
$3.75
Mothman's West Virginia SCREAM SODA (Cream Soda)
Made with the finest vanilla for the ultimate cream soda!
$3.75•81% (11)
SQUONK (Raspberry Lime Rickey Soda)
A refreshing twist on raspberry-lime rickey—sparkling raspberry limeade!
$3.75
Perilous Pineapple
Our sweet tropical pineapple soda is made with real pineapple!
$3.75
Grafton Monster Groovy Grape Soda
This provides a bold, fruity grape flavor. A fan favorite!
$3.75
Bigfoot Brew Birch Beer
A sharp yet smooth blend of sweet birch and wintergreen mint.
$3.75•100% (8)
Regulär Wolpertinger Weuzelbier (Root Beer)
Our award-winning root beer has hints of vanilla, anise and honey.
$3.75
Diät Wolpertinger Weuzelbier (Diet Root Beer)
Our diet version of our award-winning root beer has hints of vanilla, anise and honey.
$3.75
Sasquatch Sarsaparilla
Made with sassafras root extract and provides hints of licorice, caramel, vanilla and wintergreen.
$3.75
Flatwoods FANTAsie (Orange)
With just the right amount of sweet and tangy, our Flatwoods FANTAsie is the perfect soda for you.
$3.75
Mixed Case of Cryptid Club Soda (24 Pack)
A 24-pack of Cryptid Club Sodas, hand-mixed by staff. *Cases are random; special requests not guaranteed.
$75.00
Desserts
*LIMITED TIME* Dubai-Style Chocolate Torte
Rich chocolate ganache, crunchy pistachio, delicate kataifi, and a chocolate graham crust in one unforgettable slice.
$7.99
1/4 lb. S'more MONSTER Cookie
Our giant 1/4 lb. cookies, baked fresh with Mini Kisses, dark chocolate, marshmallows, and grahams.
$3.50
*NEW* 1/4 lb. Lemon Blueberry MONSTER Cookie
A large cookie with tangy lemon flavor, bursting with sweet blueberries and sprinkled with sugar.
$3.50
2/$6 Lemon Blueberry MONSTER Cookies
Grab TWO of these delicious Lemon Blueberry Cookies!
$6.00•100% (8)
MONSTER BOX - 9 Assorted Monster Cookies
NINE Assorted MONSTER Cookies ready to share!
$25.00
*NEW* Braxie's Raspberry Donut Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecake with a graham cracker crust, topped with raspberry layer and crumbly streusel.
$7.50
*NEW* White Chocolate Blueberry Cobbler Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecake with swirls of blueberry and white chocolate, topped with chocolate curls and blueberries on a graham cracker crust.
$7.50
*NEW* Wendigo's Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Pie (Gluten-Friendly)
A rich chocolate crust topped with creamy peanut butter filling, adorned with Reese's peanut butter cups and drizzles of chocolate and peanut butter.
$7.50
*NEW* Mama Bigfoot's Lemon Meringue Pie
Rich lemon custard topped with a layer of fluffy meringue on a buttery crust.
$7.50
Mothman Tiramisu
Tiramisu with layers of mascarpone, espresso-soaked ladyfingers, a hint of liqueur, and a cocoa dusting.
$7.50•100% (8)
New York Style Cheesecake
Classic New York cheesecake with soft cheese, eggs, sugar, and a light graham crust.
$4.50
Hand-Filled Cannoli
MADE TO ORDER! Our cannolis are out of this world!
$4.75•87% (16)
8" Chocolate CHUNK Cookie
Our 8" Round FRESHLY BAKED Chocolate Chunk Cookie is a delicious treat that can be enjoyed by kids and adults alike!
$7.50
Dippers
14oz Bottle of Mythical Pizza's Honey Sriracha
Our sweet honey meets sriracha heat with red chili peppers. Perfect for any dish!
$13.99
12oz Bottle of Mike's Hot Honey
Mike's Hot Honey—the original honey infused with chilies, perfect for drizzling on your favorites.
$13.99
Mike's Hot Honey Dipper
Made with 100% pure honey, real chili peppers, and tangy vinegar!
$2.50
TOSTITOS Nacho Cheese Dipper
TOSTITOS Nacho Cheese Cup is delicious, tangy Nacho Cheese Dip ready to upgrade your favorite pizza, wings or pasta!
$2.00
Grandioso Garlic Sauce Dipper
This garlic sauce provides a creamy, savory taste that is a must-have addition for your pizza!
$1.00
Sweet Chili Dipper
A bold sauce with red chili peppers and garlic for a sweet, tart, mildly spicy kick.
$1.00
Garlic Parmesan Dipper
This flavor-packed sauce is made with parmesan cheese, garlic, vinegar, and salt for a rich, savory taste.
$1.00
4oz Ranch Dipper
This creamy and thick ranch dip is the ideal dipper for your favorite pizza!
$2.00
4oz Bleu Cheese Dipper
A creamy bleu cheese dip typically made with mayonnaise, buttermilk, and seasonings, ideal for pairing with various appetizers.
$2.00
*NEW* Dipper of Teriyaki
Teriyaki dipper features a sweet and salty sauce, typically made with soy sauce, sugar, and mirin, offering a delightful accompaniment for your pizza.
$1.00
*NEW* Dipper of Nashville HOT
Nashville hot sauce with a hint of spice, paired with crispy elements and typically accompanied by a creamy ranch drizzle.
$1.00
Dipper of Mythical Pizza's Honey Sriracha
Made with classic sriracha heat, red chili peppers, and honey sweetness, it's the perfect dipper for pizza!
$1.00
Dipper of Balsamic Glaze
This acidic, velvety liquid is a delicious add-on for any pizza or salad!
$1.00
Dipper of Bigfoot Barbecue Sauce
This deliciously thick and tangy-sweet barbecue adds a level of smokiness to any pizza!
$1.00
Dipper of Buffalo
Grab a side of the rich, buttery flavor of Buffalo! The heat is mild – but the flavor is anything but.
$1.00
Dipper of Marinara
Our Vegan-Friendly Classic Marinara is ready to be your dipper of choice!
$1.00
Dipper of Pesto
Our nut-free basil pesto is the ultimate flavor dipper!
$1.00
Parmesan Packet
Parmesan Cheese delivers just the right amount of savory, sharp flavor to pizzas, pasta dishes, salads and more!
$0.15
Crushed Red Pepper Packet
Crushed Pepper Packets provides those who like to add "zest" to their meals with a spicy solution!
$0.15•85% (7)
Salad Dressings
Raspberry Vinagrette - Fat Free
This is a light bodied dressing, deep maroon red in color with red bell pepper visible throughout.
$1.50
Creamy Caesar
Rich and creamy flavor with pleasant anchovy, garlic and Romano cheese notes.
$1.50
Golden Italian
Robust flavor with garlic, onion and tangy lemon notes, a truly authentic Italian flavored dressing.
$1.50
Balsamic Vinaigrette
Made from balsamic vinegar, this dressing makes an excellent complement to olive oil.
$1.50
Country French (Fat Free)
A smooth moderate bodied dressing accentuated by a fruity tomato notes in a tangy vinegar and spice background.
$1.50
Thousand Island
A creamy classic with just the right amount of pickle relish and spice.
$1.50
Ranch
With a taste that's cool and tangy, ranch dressing blends the familiar flavors of garlic, onion, and spices.
$1.50
Honey Mustard
Sweetened with honey and packed with a unique blend of mustard and spices.
$1.50
Blue Cheese
A full bodied spoonable dressing with visible blue cheese chunks.
$1.50
Utensils & Napkins
Cutlery (Knife & Fork) w/ Napkin and Salt/Pepper
$0.08
Plates
$0.08
Extra Napkins
Napkins for convenient cleanup during your meal.
$0.03
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash