e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from Nelly's Italian Cafe at 5441 Main Street in Spring Hill. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

Nelly's Italian Cafe 5441 Main Street - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to Nelly's Italian Cafe to pick up this order: 5441 Main Street

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Plain cheese. Add toppings to make it your own !

Large 16inch 

Plain Cheese . Add toppings to make it your own!

X-Large 18in

Bread Twisted in knots and smothered in Fresh Garlic ,Olive oil and Italian seasoning . Order a Half or Full order. 

Sauce is not included. Please add on if you would like a cup of sauce.

Garlic Knots 

Layers of pasta, flavorful beef, creamy ricotta, melty mozzarella. Rich, satisfying, and comforting. Customize with meatball or  salad. Served with garlic bread.

Lasagna

NY Cheesecake

Nonna's famous Giant meatballs are made by hand daily, and we can barely make enough for the demand. (limited quantity). One meatball is huge!

Spaghetti & Meatballs

Italian Classic ! Lady fingers dipped in espresso, topped with Mascarpone cheese and topped with cocoa. Heavenly ! 

Tiramisu

A favorite Italian dessert!  Our traditional shell dipped in chocolate stuffed with Sweet Ricotta cheese and chocolate chips. 

Chocolate-Dipped Cannoli

Cheese Slice 

A favorite Italian dessert!  Our traditional shell stuffed with Sweet Ricotta cheese and chocolate chips. 

Traditional Cannoli

Popular Items

All made on homemade bread. Add a house salad for an additional charge.

Irresistible homemade meatballs with gooey mozzarella and zesty marinara on fresh bread. Perfect for dipping. 

Meatball Sub

Hearty Italian sausage with green peppers, onions, and melted mozzarella on homemade bread. Served with a side of savory marinara. 

Italian Sausage Sub

Crispy breaded Chicken Parmesan with flavorful marinara & mozzarella in a house-made roll. Satisfying. Hearty, juicy & flavorful!

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Savory eggplant parmesan stuffed in homemade bread, served with marinara. Hearty, flavorful, comforting.

Eggplant Parmesan Sub

Fresh mozzarella, fresh Basil, and tomato on a homemade roll, drizzled with house sweet balsamic. Juicy, flavorful, and aromatic.

The Caprese Sub

Ham, salami, cheese, lettuce, tomato, olives, & house balsamic.

The Italian Sub

Sandwiches

Choose from a variety of our Specialty Pies !

White Pie. Olive oil base , fresh garlic , Ricotta , Mozzarella and Romano Cheese. Add toppings to make it your own!

XL Bianca 

Hearty XL pizza piled with pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, and extra cheese. 

XL Carne 

Feeds up to 8 people. Two layers of crust stuffed with extra cheese , pepperoni , beef,  ham and Sausage . One of our best sellers!

XL Double Crust Meatlover 

Feeds up to 8 people. Two layers of crust stuffed with extra cheese , pepperoni , beef,  ham, Sausage ,green & black olives, mushrooms, green peppers  &  onions. 

XL Double Crust Supreme 

The works! Pepperoni, beef,ham,sausage, green & black olives, onions,mushrooms, peppers and extra cheese. 

You may add additional toppings for the price per extra topping.

XL Supreme 

XL-18in Specialty Pizzas 

Parmesan encrusted bread. Choose from a 10 inch full pie or a half pie. Full Pie comes with 2 sauces and a half pie comes with 1. 

Garlic Bread 

Nonna's famous Giant Meatballs! One is the size of a softball.

Single Meatball 

Appetizers 

Spring mix topped with  Giardinera (pickled veggies), Ham, Salami, Cheese, tomatoes, green & black olives. 

Antipasto Salad 

Spring Mix topped with Shredded Parm & Black olives . Caesar dressing on side .

Caesar Salad

Fresh Mozzarella , Fresh Basil & Roma Tomato Slices. Topped with Olive oil, Oregano & Salt. Sweet Balsamic included on the side. 

Caprese 

Spring Mix lettuce topped with Green & Black olives, Tomatoes, & Pepperoncini . 

House Salad 

Salads 

Huge Slice! One slice  is a meal. One Marinara cup included.

Double Crust Meatlover Slice 

Pepperoni Slice 

Pizza by the Slice 

All served with garlic bread. Add a house salad or side of spaghetti for an additional charge.

Baked penne noodles in marinara, topped with Mozzarella and Romano cheese. Choose to add a juicy meatball. Enhance your meal with a side house salad or extra marinara sauce.

Baked Ziti

Thinly sliced and fried eggplant layered with mozzarella, parmesan, & marinara.  This item does not automatically come with Spaghetti. However you can add it for only $2.50.

Eggplant Parmigiana

Crispy chicken stuffed with mozzarella and Romano, topped with tangy marinara on a bed of spaghetti. Served with garlic bread. Add a meatball or side options like house salad or extra spaghetti. 

Chicken Parmigiana

Classic spaghetti in homemade marinara sauce. Pair with a side of garlic bread. Enhance with a juicy meatball. Add a house salad or extra marinara sauce on the side.

Spaghetti Marinara

Hearty Italian sausage with tangy  marinara tossed with spaghetti. Served with homemade garlic bread. Pair with a side salad or extra meatball. Mangia!

Spaghetti & Italian Sausage

Pasta's

A Stromboli is a pizza dough turnover filled with various toppings and Mozzarella cheese.  Also known as a pizza roll. All served with Marinara.

Pepperoni Roll

Meatlover Roll

Pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, green & black olives, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, & extra cheese.

Supreme Roll

Chicken Parm Roll 

Spinach Ricotta  Roll

Stromboli's

New !! Chocolate Mousse Cake 

Desserts

Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil & Kalamata Olives.

XL Margarita

Personal size Gluten Free Crust! 10 inch. Perfect meal for one. 

Gluten Free Crust! 

Create your own Pizza 

Fresh Mozzarella , Fresh Basil & Kalamata Olives.

LG Margarita 

LG Bianca 

All meat includes Pepperoni , Sausage, Beef, Ham and Extra cheese.

LG Carne 

Feeds up to 6 people. Two layers of crust stuffed with extra cheese , pepperoni , beef,  ham and Sausage . One of our best sellers!

LG Double Crust Meatlover 

Feeds up to 6 people. The works! Two layers of crust stuffed with extra cheese , pepperoni , beef,  ham, Sausage ,green & black olives, mushrooms, green peppers  &  onions. 

LG Double Crust Supreme 

LG Supreme

LG-16in Specialty Pizzas 

All Day

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

Introducing Store Rewards

16 " pepperoni  pizza was very delicious , fast delivery , good temperature. Nellys always good Italian food! 

Pizza arrived hot, delicious and perfect. The cannolis are to die for. Absolutely love Nelly's NY style pizza and I hate to move and leave them behind. Worth every penny. Our family will definitely be visiting and getting Nelly's on each visit! 

There pizza is the best around, and so is the <<taggedItemId=405046749>>lasagna<</taggedItemId>>.

There pizza is the best around, and so is the lasagna.

X-Large / Large can't go wrong! Toppings always fresh! 
Their pasta is super good too! 
They're always good about extra comments on orders!

Sauce is so flavorful!  I love the <<taggedItemId=405046748>>eggplant parmigiana<</taggedItemId>>!!  Pizza is NY style!!! 

Sauce is so flavorful!  I love the eggplant parmigiana!!  Pizza is NY style!!! 

Nelly's Italian Cafe

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

Sandwiches

XL-18in Specialty Pizzas

Appetizers

Salads

Pizza by the Slice

Pasta's

Stromboli's

Desserts

Create your own Pizza

LG-16in Specialty Pizzas

Nelly's Italian Cafe (Spring Hill) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery