e.g. enter on Main St, it’s the 4th door on the right

e.g. ring the bell after dropoff, leave next to the porch, call upon arrival, etc.

Get delivery or takeout from New York Plate at 5808 Melton Road in Gary. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!

New York Plate 5808 Melton Road - Order Pickup and Delivery

You'll need to go to New York Plate to pick up this order: 5808 Melton Road

This is a Pickup order

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

New York Plate (Gyro & Chicken)

The Manhattan Plate (Steak, Chicken & Gyro)

flamin hot cheese sticks nacho cheese flamin hot dust

flamin hot cheese stcks

Lettuce, tomatoes, nacho cheese,  hot peppers, sour cream on Doritos. Your choice of meat.

The new yorkers nacho Beef, Chicken, Steak or Gyro

Pizza Puff

The Brooklyn Plate (Steak & Chicken)

Lettuce, tomatoes, nacho cheese,, hot peppers, New York sauce. Your choice of meat.

new yorkers fries Beef, Chicken, Steak or Gyro

Tomato, lettuce, onions, tzatziki sauce with fries and two pita bread.

Gyro Platter

Cheese Sticks (6)

Philly Steak

Popular Items

Chicken Philly

Comes with onion,Cheese,Green pepper,Lettuce,Tomatoes,Mayo

Buffalo Chicken Philly

Comes with Onions,Cheese,Green peppers,Lettuce,Tomatoes, Mayo and teriyaki sauce

Chicken Teriyaki Philly

Brooklyn Philly

Bronx Phily

Onions, green peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, tzatziki sauce.

Gyro Philly

Ketchup, mustard, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, tzatziki sauce.

Gyro Cheese Burger

Double Cheeseburger

Mozzarella cheese, hot peppers. Dip or dry.

Italian Beef

Gyro, chicken, rice, New York sauce, onions, green pepper, lettuce, tomatoes.

New York Combo Wrap

Chicken lettuce, onions, green pepper, tomatoes, New York sauce.

Chicken Wrap

Catfish fillet, tartar sauce, lettuce, cheese, tomatoes.

Fish Sandwich

Chicken Sandwich

Gyro Sandwich

Comes with onions,cheese,Green peppers,Lettuce,Tomatoes,mayo

MONSTER PHILLY STEAK  W/Fries

COMES WITH ONIONS,CHEESE,GREEN PEEPERS,LETTUCE,MAYO

MONSTER PHILLY CHICKEN W/FRIES

manhattan philly

MONSTER PHILLY MIX ( STEAK& CHICKEN) W/FRIES

Sandwiches

3 Pcs. wings

4 Pcs. wings

6 Pcs. wings

10 Pcs. wings

20 Pcs.wings

30 Pcs.wings

40 Pcs. wings

50 Pcs.wings

20 pc mix  W/Fries (Legs/Thighs/wings)

Chicken Wings

Falafel

Okra

Mushrooms

Fries

Tenders

Onion Rings

Chicken Nuggets

Nacho Cheese Fries

Appetizers

Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese, jalapeños pepper, dressing.

Greek Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers and dressing.

House Salad

Salads

6 Pcs. half wings

10 Pcs.  half wings

12 Pcs half wings

25 Pcs. half wings

Buffalo Wings

The Bronx Plate (Steak & Gyro)

The Queens Plate (Chiken)

The Empire Plate (Gyro)

The Liberty Plate (Steak)

The Long Island Plate (Fried Shrimp)

The Coney Island Plate (Fried Catfish)

Rice, pita bread, lettuce, tomato, New York sauce.

Falafel Plate

RICE, ONOINS, GREEN PEPPERS, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, PITA

GRILLED SHRIMP PLATE 

GRILLED TILAPIA PLATE 

Plates

Pick any two items: three wings, one catfish fillet, one tilapia, two perch, eight regular shrimps.

Chicken & Fish Combo

Combo

Ocean Perch

Catfish Fillet

Tilapia Fillet

Shrimp

Jumbo Shrimp

Fish & Chips

Popcorn Shrimp

Seafood

The New Yorker Fries

The New Yorker Nachos

Cake Squares

Cheesecake

Butter Cookies

taffy grapes

Desserts

Bottle Soda

Bottle of Water

Can Soda

Drinks

burritos, wings, and cheese sticks coated in flamin hots. all flamin hot items comes with cheese fries and flamin hots

flamin hot double cheese burger

flamin hot mac & cheese bites 

flamin hots steak and gyro lettuce tomatoes mozz cheese black olives new York sauce

flamin hot steak and gyro burrito

grilled chicken flamin hot mozz cheese lettuce tomatoes ny sauce black olives

flamin hot chicken burrito

flamin hot wings

flamin hot menu

10PC  LEG/TH W/ FRIES

20PC LEG/TH W/FRIES

6PC LEG/TH W/FRIES

LEG & THIGH

All Day

Full Menu

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

This store is temporarily closed

Great flavor, more than enough food, just wish it was sliced just a little thinner

I ordered New Yorkers fries with chicken, and I received a huge pile of processed cheese, hot soggy lettuce, and 4 tomatoes, on a handful of fries. Very overpriced and just doesn't taste, look, or smell good. This place is usually good, but this time I wasted my money. 

flamin hot cheeto cheese sticks aren't hot at all and taste like regular cheese sticks imo.... they taste good dipped in the cheese sauce though just not what i imagined... the gyro is AMAZING one of the best i've had in a minute! definitely ordering my gyros from here always now. they also follow special instructions well! 

it's been a while since I've ordered here , but I ordered the liberty plate and added shrimp. The shrimp was tough and the steak was a little more spicy than I remembered,  my son had the Manhattan and couldn't eat it because it was smothered in New York sauce,  Just not worth the money I spent $45 for food that will end up in the trash 😑

horrible fish was fried too hard also ordered cat fish but was given a cheaper fish that tastes similar to catfish and that's Swai fish it was disgusting..We were given this fish and not told of the switch as if we would not know the difference..disrespectful..My perch was hard as a brick and it was more breading then meat. Needless to say my wife and I did not enjoy our meal and we threw most of it in the trash..

New York Plate

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

Popular Items

Sandwiches

Chicken Wings

Appetizers

Salads

Buffalo Wings

Plates

Combo

Seafood

The New Yorker Fries

The New Yorker Nachos

Desserts

Drinks

flamin hot menu

LEG & THIGH

New York Plate (Melton Road) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery