Papa j’s pizza (Shanley St) Near Me - Pickup and Delivery
Papa j’s pizza (Shanley St)
Sign In / Sign Up
Papa j’s pizza
395 Shanley St, Buffalo, NY 14206, USA25 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
Eggrolls
$16.99
Chicken Wings - Single (10 Pieces)
$14.99
Chicken Finger dinner - Single (5 Pieces)
$14.99
Steak Hoagie - 12'' Hoagie
$18.49
Cheese Pizza - Small 13"
$17.99
Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Slice
$3.99
Pizza Logs - 5 Pieces
$9.99
Fish Fry - Dinner
$16.99
Fried Dough
$9.99
Chicken Wings - Double (20 Pieces)
$28.99
Loaded Fries
$14.99
Steak Pizza - Personal 9"
$13.99
Chicken Finger Pizza - Personal 9"
$13.99
Turkey Club Sub - Whole 12"
$14.99
Garlic Bread with Cheese
$9.99
Small Cheese Pizza & Single Wings - Coupon
$28.99
Fried Cauliflower
$8.99
White Pizza - Large 17"
$29.99
White Pizza - Small 13"
$21.99
Shrimp with Fries - 8 Pieces
$13.99
Taco Pizza - Personal 9"
$13.99
Chicken Finger Pizza - Large 17"
$29.99
Meat Lovers Pizza - Personal 9"
$13.99
Chicken Wings - Triple (30 Pieces)
$43.99
Meat Lovers Pizza - Large 17"
$29.99
Full Menu
4:00 pm - 3:00 amMost Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Eggrolls
Comes with hoagie sauce, parmesan and parsley.
$16.99
Chicken Wings - Single (10 Pieces)
Served with celery & blue cheese.
$14.99
Chicken Finger dinner - Single (5 Pieces)
Comes with 4-6 Chicken Fingers. Served with celery and blue cheese, a side of fries.
$14.99
Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Slice
Savory tomato sauce, melted mozzarella, and spicy pepperoni on a thin, crispy crust.
$3.99
Steak Hoagie - 12'' Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, sub cheese, and are homemade steak sauce!
$18.49
Cheese Pizza - Small 13"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$17.99
Pizza Logs - 5 Pieces
Come with marinara sauce.
$9.99
Fries - Large
Comes with ketchup.
$4.99
Cheese Pizza - Personal 9"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$11.99
Cheese Pizza - Large 17"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$23.99
Appetizers
Pizza Logs - 5 Pieces
Come with marinara sauce.
$9.99
Jalapeno Poppers - 5 Pieces
Comes with ranch.
$7.99
Mozzarella Sticks - 5 Pieces
Come with marinara sauce.
$7.99
Tater Tots
Comes with ketchup.
$4.99
Fries - Large
Comes with ketchup.
$4.99
Onion Rings - Large
Comes with ketchup.
$5.49
Big boy box
3 Pizza logs, 3 Jalapeno poppers, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 fingers, fries, 1 Beef taco. Comes with ketchup, ranch, two marinara sauces, and taco lettuce, tomato, cheese, taco sauce.
$19.99
Cajun Fries
Comes with ketchup.
$5.99
Fried Cauliflower
Comes with ranch.
$8.99
Taco In A Box
Comes with doritos, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and taco sauce.
$16.99
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Comes with marinara sauce.
$9.99
Eggroll Flight
1 each: chicken, steak, and seafood. With a hoagie sauce and seafood sauce.
$17.99
Eggrolls
Comes with hoagie sauce, parmesan and parsley.
$16.99
Loaded Fries
Comes with cheese, sour cream, and chipotle ranch.
$14.99
Steak Hoagie Fries
Cheese, onions, banana peppers, steak meat, hoagie sauce.
$15.99
Loaded Tots
Comes with cheese, sour cream, and chipotle ranch.
$14.99
chicken hoagie fries
comes with onions, banana peppers, cheese, hoagie sauce
$14.99
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wings - Single (10 Pieces)
Served with celery & blue cheese.
$14.99
Chicken Wings - Double (20 Pieces)
Served with celery & blue cheese.
$28.99
Chicken Wings - Triple (30 Pieces)
Served with celery & blue cheese.
$43.99
Chicken Wings - Bucket (50 Pieces)
Served with celery & blue cheese.
$64.99
Chicken Wings From The Pit - Single (10 Pieces)
Served with celery and blue cheese.
$16.99
Chicken Wings From The Pit - Double (20 Pieces)
Served with celery and blue cheese.
$30.99
Chicken Wings From The Pit - Triple (30 Pieces)
Served with celery and blue cheese.
$45.99
Chicken Wings From The Pit - Bucket (50 Pieces)
Served with celery and blue cheese.
$66.99
Country Style Fried Chicken Wings - 10 Pieces
Served with celery and blue cheese. Available in lemon pepper, Cajun, and Honey Cajun.
$16.99
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Finger dinner - Single (5 Pieces)
Comes with 4-6 Chicken Fingers. Served with celery and blue cheese, a side of fries.
$14.99
Chicken Finger dinner - Double (10 Pieces)
Comes with 4-6 Chicken Fingers. Served with celery and blue cheese, a side of fries.
$24.99
Pizza
Cheese Pizza - Personal 9"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$11.99
Cheese Pizza - Small 13"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$17.99
Cheese Pizza - Large 17"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$23.99
Cheese Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$41.99
Pizza By The Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice - Slice
A slice of cheese pizza featuring a golden crust topped with rich tomato sauce and melted cheese.
$3.49
Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Slice
Savory tomato sauce, melted mozzarella, and spicy pepperoni on a thin, crispy crust.
$3.99
Cold Subs
Ham Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$8.99
Ham Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$13.99
Turkey Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$8.99
Turkey Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$13.99
Salami Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$8.99
Salami Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$12.99
Cappicola Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$8.99
Cappicola Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$12.99
BLT Sub - Half 6''
comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$8.99
BLT Sub - Whole 12"
comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$13.99
Cheese Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$7.99
Cheese Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$10.99
Assorted Sub - Half 6''
comes with Ham, turkey, salami, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$8.99
Assorted Sub - Whole 12"
comes with Ham, turkey, salami, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$14.99
Roast Beef Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$8.99
Roast Beef Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$12.99
Tuna Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$7.99
Tuna Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$12.99
Turkey Club Sub - Half 6''
comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce,tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$8.99
Turkey Club Sub - Whole 12"
comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce,tomatoes, cheese, and onions
$14.99
Hot Subs
Stinger Sub - Half 6''
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.
$9.99
Stinger Sub - Whole 12"
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.
$18.99
Steak Sub - Half 6''
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.
$9.90
Steak Sub - Whole 12"
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.
$16.99
Royal Sub - Half 6''
Italian sausage & capicola. Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.
$8.99
Royal Sub - Whole 12"
Italian sausage & capicola. Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese prepared with oil and mayonnaise, on a toasted 12-inch Costanzo's roll.
$14.99
Chicken Finger Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and cheese
$8.99
Chicken Finger Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and cheese
$14.99
Meatball Bomber Sub - Half 6''
Comes with pizza sauce and cheese.
$8.99
Meatball Bomber Sub - Whole 12"
Comes with pizza sauce and cheese.
$13.99
Pizza Sub - Half 6''
Comes with mozzarella, pizza sauce, pepperoni.
$8.99
Pizza Sub - Whole 12"
Comes with mozzarella, pizza sauce, pepperoni.
$13.99
Cheeseburger Sub - Half 6''
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, ketchup and mustard
$8.99
Cheeseburger Sub - Whole 12"
comes with mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, ketchup and mustard
$14.99
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub - Half 6''
comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes,onions,cheese,ketchup, and mustard
$9.49
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub - Whole 12"
comes with bacon, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomatoes,onions,cheese,ketchup, and mustard
$15.99
Italian Sausage Sub - Half 6''
$8.99
Italian Sausage Sub - Whole 12"
$13.99
Chicken Parmesan Sub - Half 6''
comes with pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese
$8.99
Chicken Parmesan Sub - Whole 12"
comes with pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese
$14.99
Hoagie Subs
Chop Chicken Hoagie - 8'' Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, sub cheese, and are homemade steak sauce!
$13.99
Chop Chicken Hoagie - 12''Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, sub cheese, and are homemade steak sauce!
$16.99
Chop Turkey Hoagie - 8'' Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, lettuce, sub cheese, and are homemade steak sauce!
$11.99
Chop Turkey Hoagie - 12''Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, lettuce, sub cheese, and are homemade steak sauce!
$14.99
Chop Burger Hoagie - 8'' Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, sub cheese, ketchup, mustard, and are homemade steak sauce!
$12.99
Chop Burger Hoagie - 12''Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, sub cheese, ketchup, mustard, and are homemade steak sauce!
$15.99
Steak Hoagie - 8" Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, sub cheese, and are homemade steak sauce!
$14.99
Steak Hoagie - 12'' Hoagie
Comes on a Costanzo roll with mayo, oil, chopped onions, chopped banana peppers, sub cheese, and are homemade steak sauce!
$18.49
Specials
Small Cheese Pizza & Single Wings - Coupon
Cheese pizza paired with a single order of wings. Wing flavors range from tangy to spicy and sweet options.
$28.99
Large Cheese Pizza & Double Wings - Coupon
Large Cheese Pizza & Double Wings (20 pieces)
$48.99
Large Cheese Pizza & Bucket of Wings - Coupon
Large Cheese Pizza & Bucket of Wings (50 pieces)
$76.99
Sheet Cheese Pizza & Bucket of Wings - Coupon
Sheet Cheese Pizza & Bucket of Wings (50 pieces)
$86.99
1 Slice, 3 Chicken Fingers & 1 Egg Roll - Coupon
comes with slice of cheese pepperoni pizza ,chicken eggroll and 3 chicken fingers.
$13.99
Cold Sub Of The Month - Coupon
Ask about our sub of the Week!
$9.99
Hot Sub Of The Month - Coupon
Ask about our sub of the Week!
$10.99
Wing Wednesday Pick Up Only Specials
Wings Special - 10 Pieces
Served with celery and blue cheese. Limit is 2 orders or up to 20 wings// not available for delivery
$10.00
Wings Special - 20 Pieces
Served with celery and blue cheese. Limit is 2 orders or up to 20 wings// not available for delivery
$20.00
Specialty Pizza
White Pizza - Personal 9"
Olive oil, ricotta cheese, fresh garlic, and tomatoes on a personal-sized crust.
$13.99
White Pizza - Small 13"
Creamy ricotta, spinach, and artichoke hearts on a small 13" pizza crust.
$21.99
White Pizza - Large 17"
A large 17-inch pizza topped with creamy white sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a blend of Italian herbs.
$29.99
White Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Olive oil, garlic, ricotta cheese, and sliced tomatoes on a large sheet pizza, typically featuring a blend of cheeses and herbs.
$45.99
Taco Pizza - Personal 9"
Ground beef, shredded lettuce, and cheese atop a personal-sized pizza crust, blending classic taco flavors with Italian pizza style.
$13.99
Taco Pizza - Small 13"
Taco pizza features seasoned ground beef, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and onions, capturing the essence of a classic taco on a small 13" pizza crust.
$21.99
Taco Pizza - Large 17"
Seasoned ground beef, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, and taco sauce on a large pizza crust.
$29.99
Taco Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Taco meat, salsa, onions, cheddar cheese, black olives, lettuce, and tomatoes on an 18" x 26" sheet pizza.
$45.99
Hawaiian Pizza - Personal 9"
Ham, pineapple, and cheese on a personal 9" pizza crust, typically with tomato sauce and bacon.
$13.99
Hawaiian Pizza - Small 13"
Ham, pineapple, and bacon on a small specialty pizza, typically topped with pizza sauce and cheese.
$21.99
Hawaiian Pizza - Large 17"
Hand-tossed pizza topped with ham, pineapple, bacon, and cheese on a traditional red sauce base.
$29.99
Hawaiian Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Ham, pineapple, and a blend of cheeses on a traditional pizza base, crafted on a sheet measuring 18" x 26".
$45.99
Chicken Finger Pizza - Personal 9"
Tender chicken fingers atop melted cheese and tomato sauce on a personal-sized pizza crust.
$13.99
Chicken Finger Pizza - Small 13"
Breaded chicken fingers on a cheese blend with a blue cheese base and a hint of spice.
$21.99
Chicken Finger Pizza - Large 17"
Breaded chicken fingers on a large pizza crust, typically complemented by a blend of cheeses.
$29.99
Chicken Finger Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Breaded chicken fingers, pizza sauce, and a cheese blend on a large 18" x 26" sheet pizza, offering a unique twist on classic chicken pizza.
$45.99
Steak Pizza - Personal 9"
Tender steak pieces topped with melted cheese on a 9-inch pizza crust.
$13.99
Steak Pizza - Small 13"
Sliced steak, tomato sauce, and cheese on a 13" pizza, typically featuring green peppers, mushrooms, and onions.
$21.99
Steak Pizza - Large 17"
Shaved steak, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and cheese on a classic pizza base.
$29.99
Steak Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Ribeye steak, onions, mushrooms, and green peppers on a sheet pizza, typically complemented by a blend of cheeses and a savory sauce.
$45.99
Breakfast Pizza - Personal 9"
Scrambled eggs, sausage, bacon, and a blend of cheeses on a personal-sized pizza crust.
$13.99
Breakfast Pizza - Small 13"
Scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, and a blend of cheeses typically adorn this small breakfast pizza.
$21.99
Breakfast Pizza - Large 17"
Savory pizza topped with crispy bacon, sausage, and scrambled eggs on a large 17" crust.
$29.99
Breakfast Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Scrambled eggs, bacon, ham, sausage, and a blend of cheeses on a sheet pizza.
$45.99
Veggie Pizza - Personal 9"
Vegan cheese optional.
$12.99
Veggie Pizza - Small 13"
Vegan cheese optional.
$20.99
Veggie Pizza - Large 17"
Vegan cheese optional.
$28.99
Veggie Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Vegan cheese optional.
$44.99
Meat Lovers Pizza - Personal 9"
Pepperoni, sausage, and ham.
$13.99
Meat Lovers Pizza - Small 13"
Pepperoni, sausage, and ham.
$21.99
Meat Lovers Pizza - Large 17"
Pepperoni, sausage, and ham.
$29.99
Meat Lovers Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Pepperoni, sausage, and ham.
$45.99
Chicken & Broccoli Pizza - Personal 9"
Grilled chicken and broccoli on a personal-sized crust, typically topped with alfredo sauce and cheese.
$13.99
Chicken & Broccoli Pizza - Small 13"
Grilled chicken, broccoli, cheese, and alfredo sauce on a small 13" pizza crust.
$21.99
Chicken & Broccoli Pizza - Large 17"
Grilled chicken and broccoli on a large pizza, typically featuring a creamy alfredo sauce and melted cheese.
$29.99
Chicken & Broccoli Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
Broccoli, grilled chicken, and a blend of cheeses on an 18" x 26" sheet pizza, typically featuring alfredo or white sauce.
$45.99
Stinger Pizza - Personal 9"
White pizza with steak, cheese, and medium chicken fingers on a personal 9" crust.
$13.99
Stinger Pizza - Small 13"
White pizza topped with steak, cheese, and medium chicken fingers on a small 13" crust.
$21.99
Stinger Pizza - Large 17"
White pizza with steak, cheese, and medium chicken fingers.
$29.99
Stinger Pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
White pizza topped with steak, cheese, and medium-spiced chicken fingers, served on a large 18" x 26" sheet.
$45.99
steak hoagie pizza - Personal 9"
topped with steak, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and are homemade hoagie sauce
$13.99
steak hoagie pizza - Small 13"
topped with steak, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and are homemade hoagie sauce
$21.99
steak hoagie pizza - Large 17"
topped with steak, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and are homemade hoagie sauce
$29.99
steak hoagie pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
topped with steak, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and are homemade hoagie sauce
$45.99
chicken hoagie pizza - Personal 9"
topped with chicken, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and are homemade hoagie sauce
$13.99
chicken hoagie pizza - Small 13"
topped with chicken, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and are homemade hoagie sauce
$21.99
chicken hoagie pizza - Large 17"
topped with chicken, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and are homemade hoagie sauce
$29.99
chicken hoagie pizza - Sheet 18" x 26"
topped with chicken, onions, cheese, banana peppers, and are homemade hoagie sauce
$45.99
Salads
Dinner Salad - Large
Lettuce, tomato, onions, croutons.
$9.99
Caesar Chicken Salad - Salads
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons, and caesar dressing.
$14.99
Taco Salad - Salads
Comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and taco sauce.
$13.99
Antipasto Salad - Salads
Lettuce, tomato, onions, crotons, cheese, ham, turkey, salami, green & black olives, pepperoni.
$17.99
Tacos
Beef Taco
comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce
$6.99
Chicken Taco
comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce
$6.99
Steak Taco
comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce
$7.99
Chicken Finger Taco
comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and taco sauce
$7.99
Fish Taco
comes with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, taco sauce, and tartar sauce
$8.99
Sandwhiches
Hamburger - XX-Large
Comes with lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, mustard, ketchup, and a pickle on the side, and a side of fries.
$13.99
Cheeseburger - XX-Large
Comes with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, mustard, ketchup, and a pickle on the side, and side of fries.
$14.99
Fried Bologna Sandwich - Sandwich
Comes mayo, fried onions, side of fries.
$12.99
Charbroiled Chicken Breast - Regular
Lettuce, tomato, and mayo, side of fries
$13.99
Roast Beef on Weck - Sandwich
Includes horseradish, side of fries.
$12.99
Fish Fry Everyday
Fish Fry - Dinner
Fried fish entree, typically featuring crispy beer-battered fillets accompanied by tartar sauce, coleslaw, and french fries.
$16.99
Shrimp Dinner - 10 Pieces
Breaded and fried shrimp, served with french fries, coleslaw, and cocktail sauce.
$15.99
1/2 Fish & 1/2 Shrimp - Dinner
Fried fish and shrimp, typically served with french fries, coleslaw, and tartar sauce.
$17.99
Fish Sandwich - Sandwich
Comes with mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and a side of tartar sauce and hot sauce, plus fries.
$13.99
Shrimp with Fries - 8 Pieces
comes with 8 jumbo shrimp, fries and cocktail sauce
$13.99
Desserts
Chocolate Cake
Decadent chocolate delight, lavished with rich frosting and served with a dollop of indulgence.
$5.50
Carrot Cake
Classic moist cake made with fresh carrots, rich cream cheese frosting, and a hint of spice.
$5.50
Fried Dough
Comes with powdered sugar.
$9.99
Powered byDoorDash Commerce Platform
© 2026 DoorDash